Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

28th July 1910

Cumberland Miners' Demonstration At Egremont

Address By Mr. Keir Hardie, M.P.

The annual demonstration and sports organised by the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners and Kindred Trades Association was held on Monday, in the Co-operative Field, known as Malcolm Bars, Egremont. Throughout the previous day rain fell incessantly and notwithstanding that there was a downpour in the early part of the morning of the much looked for day, the climatic condition by noon improved. "Old Sol" began to peep from the now fast departing clouds, but unfortunately he did not smile on the proceedings the whole of the afternoon, and frequent showers somewhat marred the demonstrations in the way of sport, but, the attendance was little affected inasmuch as the rain did not fall until after the time arranged for the start. The gathering would number upwards of 2,500, and these thronged to the town in all descriptions of vehicles, which had conveyed them from all parts of West Cumberland.

Officials — President, Mr. Edward Thompson, Handicap officials; Handicapper, Robert Long; official starter, Wm. Jackson; referees, Dr. Braithwaite; judges, Joseph Glover and James Southward; marksmen, R. Mills, James Pickthall, Wm. Woodend, Edward Watson, and R. Newall; telegraphists, Albert Todd and Richard Rooney, competitors tent, John Hodgson and Francis Rule, bellman, John Higham. Hound Trail — Starters and judge, Dr. Braithwaite; catchers, Jos. Moore, Geo. Pickering, William Fluskey, James Carroll, George Gordon, George Woodburn; trailers (managers, J. Kitchin and Jos. Milburn), J. Greaves and William Millburn; stewards, Dr. Calderwood, Mr. Edward Atter, and Mr. J. J. Thompson. Puppy Trail, Trailers, Morris Haile and Jos. Cowan. Wrestling officials, referee, John Milburn; judges, R. M. Leach and J. Simpson; weighers in, Luke Cowan and Robert James, snap pitching: Referee, John Dixon, committee, Jos. McGuire and William Hetherington. Gatekeepers, David Tidyman, Mark Daniels, Mossop Rothery, and J. Hornsby. Dancing competition; Judges, John Kelly and Isaac Messenger; committee, Richard Rooney, James Pickthall, and James Carroll. Field stewards; All members of the committee; treasurer, Noble Dawson, Sykes House, Bigrigg; secretary, T. Gavan-Duffy, Alva House, Moor Row.

At 12.15 p.m., the members of the Association headed by the Egremont Town's Prize Band, and followed by their general secretary (Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy), Mr. John Hanlon (the Whitehaven miners' agent) and others marched to the number of 500 along the streets. The members had their beautiful banner, which was borne by two stalwart members. At the tail of the procession was the Cleator Moor Brass Band, who played inspiring marches en-route the walk. On arrival at the sports field, a public meeting was held. The chair was occupied by Mr. Lancaster Todd, of Maryport (secretary Cumberland Labour Party Federation), who was supported by Mr. J. K. Hardie, M.P., and Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy (general secretary).

After a brief speech by the Chairman, the following resolution was moved by Mr. J. McCusker, and seconded by Mr. Mitchelle. This mass meeting, representing the iron ore workers of West Cumberland, desires to express its deep and profound sympathy with the relatives of the men who are entombed in Wellington Pit and we affirm the belief that the State ownership and control of all the mines can alone diminish the number of mining accidents. We call upon all men employed in the iron ore mines to join our Association as the only bona fide trade union representing the iron ore miners and kindred trades in this district, and as being the only means of securing absolute unity of action. We reiterate our adherence to the principle of Independent Labour Representation upon all public bodies, and we express our gratitude to the Labour Party in Parliament for the splendid services which they by their ceaseless vigilance and untiring seal have rendered to the workmen throughout our land. We further affirm that no final solution of the problems of poverty and unemployment can be found except in the establishment of a co-operative commonwealth owing and controlling the necessities of life.

Mr. Keir Hardie said he had just been reminded that it was some 24 or 25 years since last he spoke at a demonstration of the iron ore miners of this district. As the Chairman had said, in those days the principles with which he was associated were neither so well known nor so well understood as they are now. But there was one principle which then as now he held to be

Essential To Their Progress

and the improvement of their condition, and that was that everyone connected with the iron ore mines in whatever capacity and whether below ground or on the pit top, should be a loyal member of his trades-union. (Hear, hear.) They might take this for granted; that without trades union organisation their condition would go from bad to worse. It is none too good as it is, but it would be infinitely worse that it is but for the strength of their trades union organisation, and the stronger they made their union the better it would be for them. (Hear, hear.) The resolution which they had just heard read began with an expression of sympathy with the relatives of the men who were lying entombed within a few miles from where they were met; and perhaps they would pardon him if for a few minutes he made reference to

The Wellington Pit Disaster.

He wanted to do it for two reasons — first of all to put right a misrepresentation of himself circulated by one of their local Liberal newspapers; and secondly to try if possible to get the facts as far as they are known so placed before the country that public opinion may be educated so as to have the law amended to prevent such accidents occurring in the future. (Hear, hear.) He was speaking to a body of practical working miners. He himself worked for his bread for 14 years in the coal pits of Scotland. They and he, therefore, knew what they were talking about when they spoke of mines; and he said in the most emphatic way he could and knowing the responsibility attached to what he said, that out of every 100

Accidents Which Occurred

in a mine, 75 could easily be prevented. (Hear, hear.) Remember that 1,100 men and boys, on the average are killed in the mines of this country every year. Every day 3½ or four lifeless bodies are carried into their homes — men who went out in the morning full of the strength and the joy of life, carried home dead in the evening. And surely if means can be devised to stop all that sacrifice of human life and all the suffering and sorrow which it brings in its train, no matter what the cost, those means must be taken. (Hear, hear.) But it was not only that 1,100 lives are lost, but 100,000 when are maimed and injured every year. ("Shame.") Suppose this country were at war; suppose they read of some great battle in which 1,100 men had been killed and 100,000 wounded — how the heart of the nation would be touched to the core and how our sympathy would go out to the relatives of those who had been left behind. And yet that awful toll of life and limb is going on every year in the mines of our country; and it is only when some great disaster takes place that the public hears of it at all, or that the matter is brought to their attention. He had said that he referred to this question now for two reasons — first, a personal one. It would be within their recollection that when

The Decision To Wall Up

Wellington mine was come to he was speaking at a meeting in South Wales; and he then stated that in his opinion the probability was that most of the men in behind the fire were alive — ("So they were.") — at the time the decision was come to. (Hear, hear.) He made that statement. He stood by that statement. (Hear, hear, and applause.) Might he call to their notice one or two facts bearing upon this aspect of the case. The mine here was walled up a week after the accident. In the Braydon Colliery of Somersetshire in 1903 eleven colliers were saved after they had been closed in for five days. In the Cherry Colliery of Illinois, America, 22 colliers were rescued after being enclosed for nine days. In the Courier Colliery at Trent, four years ago, where the men had been walled up also, remember, 13 men were saved alive after they had been entombed for 19 days, and one man was brought out alive after 25 days. In Scotland there is a case well-known, an old colliery near to where his home was, where a man was rescued alive after being 23 days entombed in the mine. If, therefore, these men in these cases could live all those days after the disaster, all the probabilities were that the same thing was true at Wellington when the mine was closed up there. ("True.") Well, now, what happened? He made that statement. He did not place any blame on the authorities for closing up the mine. He expressed no opinion upon that at this stage. But the Home Secretary thought fit to interpret his speech in is own way, and had charged him with making a cruel and infamous assertion. He challenged the Home Secretary on the floor of the House of Commons with regard to his statement, whereupon Mr. Churchill withdrew his statement — (hear, hear,) — and expressed his regret for making it. (Applause.) Very well; but what happened? He came now to

"The Whitehaven News"

a Liberal paper (a laugh) — for the 23rd June, 1910. Commenting upon what happened in the House of Commons, the editor wrote; "Mr. Keir Hardie spoke hastily and he apologised lamely, and as it seems to us not quite frankly." The point is this, men, that it was the Home Secretary who apologised. (Hear, hear.) But this Liberal paper tries to make you believe that I had apologised for a statement I never made. (A voice; "Shame.") I mention that not for any personal reasons, remember. I am too well used to that kind of thing for it to affect me. I have got to the position where neither Liberal nor Tory can hurt me or do me any harm. (Applause.) But, I mention it now that you may see how Liberal papers, which are always your friends at election times, try to misrepresent the men who are standing up for you when you require to be stood for. (Hear, hear.) Now I pass from that.

A Voice: Why didn't you mention the thing at the time, not after?

Mr. Keir Hardie: At what time?

The Voice: At the time of the Whitehaven disaster.

Mr. Keir Hardie: I did mention it at the time.

Another voice: Whey he did mention it; oppen th' lugs.

Mr. Keir Hardie: I was afraid you Cumberland men would not understand my Scotch accent. [To the interrupter:] Now behave yourself; don't make an ass of yourself. I mentioned the thing the day after it happened. How much sooner could I have mentioned it? Why did not your Liberal and Tory members in the House of Commons mention it, when you send them to represent you. If I had been a Cumberland member I should have been on the spot the night after it happened to find out the facts for myself and stand by my men in their hour of need. I am going down to Whitehaven a few days from now to go into the whole of the facts, so as to search the whole thing to the bottom, as far as it can be done now. But that is not the point. I join with you in expressing my

Sympathies With The Relatives

who are left to mourn, and I want to express my appreciation of the heroism of the men who risked their own lives in trying to reach those who were entombed. On occasions like this the very best side of our human nature is brought out. The miners' agent, Mr. Hanlon, the colliery manager, the colliers in the pit all of them took their lives in their hands to try if they could not reach the men who were beyond the fire. We are often told that self-interest is the only spur that will move humanity; that it is only when you offer men rewards that they will be inspired to do anything. He had always disputed that. He said that underlying the love of gain there is a deeper love — the

Love Of Human Kind.

(Hear, hear.) And when these great colliery disasters took place the men who go to the rescue could not be tempted by any pay to take the risks they do; it is because they love their fellows and want to try to rescue them that they risk their own lives in making the attempt. And so he wanted to pay his token of respect to the men who on this, as on every such occasion, came forward to take the risk. A collier's life is one of being daily and hourly in the presence of danger, and he has a courage and a heroism which no field of battle ever equalled in any part of the world. (Applause.)

Lord Lonsdale And The Whitehaven Colliery.

And now they might be interested in knowing something about Wellington Pit, and the reasons why it came to be worked as it is being worked. In the days of Charles II, the Lonsdale's got a grant of all the land between the high water and low water at Whitehaven. About the middle of last century the mines were being worked under the sea. In 1859 it was discovered that the Earl of Lonsdale had got beyond low water mark and was working Crown minerals without paying any royalties. When a poor woman during a strike picks up a few pieces of coal for her fire, she gets a month's imprisonment to teach her how heinous an offence it is to steal coal. But here was the Earl of Lonsdale stealing coal belonging to the Crown. (Applause.) See what happened. The Commissioners of Woods and Forests agreed to say nothing about the past and offered to lease this part of the coalfield at half the royalty rents which other people were paying. In 1850 a lease was given to the Earl of Lonsdale for 31 years, at a rent of £1 a year, and a royalty of 2d a ton on large coal, 1d a ton on small coal, and 1½d a ton for ironstone, fire-clay, and other minerals. That went on for twenty years, during which the Earl of Lonsdale paid to the Crown £1,688 11s 2d a year. In 1863 his Lordship offered to buy out the Crown rights offering £10,000 for ten miles of coal. The Commissioners of Woods and Forests said, "Thank you, but we will wait till your offer grows" (Laughter.) In 1871 Lord Lonsdale doubled his offer and offered £25,000; and the Commissioners of Woods and Forests said, "You are getting on, but we will still wait till it grows a bit." And in 1880 Lord Lonsdale agreed to pay £50,000 for the minerals, and the Crown then gave him a new lease for 43 years, slightly increasing the royalty rates and giving him the option of buying out the Crown's rights if he were so-minded. (A voice: "Shame on the Crown.") The result was that in 1881 Lord Lonsdale bought ten miles out from St. Bees Head, from the Crown, for a total sum of £50,000, about one-fifth of its real value. That is how patriotism serves the State when occasion arises. That then is how the mines came to be worked as they are. And now he wanted to call attention to a very important matter bearing upon the question.

Previous Fires And Escape Roads.

In 1863 there was a fire in the same coalfield. There was another fire in the same coalfield a few years later; and when in 1880 the Earl of Lonsdale leased his collieries to the Whitehaven Coal Company, his engineers and their engineers agreed upon a method of working the coal so that when fire broke out in any district it might be easily isolated and the men rescued from the other parts of the mines. A few years after that agreement was come to, it was modified to some extent, although to what extent he had not yet been able to find out. The point I am leading to men, is this, and you will see the importance of it: It was shown there was risk of fire in those collieries. There had been a fire 37 years before, and special precautions had been adopted for the safety of the men. Knowing there was that risk, why were there not proper outlets for the men when the fire took place? (Hear, hear.) There are two pits well within a mile of Wellington Pit — the William Pit on the one side, the old Croft Pit on the other. Why, I ask, were there no escape roads from the workings of the Wellington Pit to these adjacent pits? Why did not the men travel them then. [A voice: Here's a man who got out of Wellington Pit. He will tell you whether there is any road out.] That is all right now. I will go into the details when I come down to Whitehaven. My point for the moment is this — that if there had been proper escape roads from No. 6, No. 5, and No. 3 districts, to these other pits, the men would have escaped and these lives would not have been sacrificed. The point of my argument is, men, that it was because it was going to cost money to have these roads made that the risk was, taken, and as a consequence you have these men lying dead and their widows and orphans mourning.

The Remedy.

What is the remedy for the state of things? At the present time a colliery manager and the officials under him are in a most anomalous position. A manager is literally between the devil and the deep sea. On the one side he has the directors of the colliery pressing him to get dividends, to keep down the working costs; on the other side there is the Inspector of Mines pressing him to see the safety of the men. The inspector comes very occasionally; the directors are always there. The inspector cannot sack the managers, the directors can. And so it is but natural that the influence of the directors should court for more than the influence of the inspector. Some means must be devised whereby the man who is responsible for the safety of the miners should not be in the employment for the colliery owners who have power to sack him. (Hear, hear.) The men who is responsible for safety should be a different person from the man who is responsible for dividends. (Hear, hear.) And if that reform could be brought about it would work and immediate change in the condition of our mines. The resolution spoke about the nationalisation of mines. That is the only final solution, for so long as our mines are worked for profit, whatever reforms may be brought about profit will always count far more than safety. Make them national property and put upon the House of Commons the responsibility of every life lost in the pit. (Hear, hear.) A coal pit might almost be as safe as a Royal palace if only as much money was spent on the safety of the one as is spent on the safety of the other. There are great difficulties in getting a few thousands a year for more inspectors. Last Friday the House of Commons agreed that £20,000 a year should be spent on looking after the drains in the Royal palaces. They voted £50,000 more for putting the house of the Queen Mother in order — £30,000 for one woman's house; and they could not spend £5,000 to look after the lives of colliers.

A Royal person may be a very important person, although it struck him that when the day of judgement comes, we have all to stand there before the great white throne, with all the trappings of royalty torn off as well as the duds of the colliers. We will all appear very much alike there. (Applause.) He said, then nationalise the mines; but before you nationalise the mines you will require to nationalise the House of Commons. (Hear, hear.)

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward      
Braithwaite, —, Dr.      
Calderwood, —, Dr.      
Carroll, James      
Churchill, Winston Leonard Spencer    Home Secretary  
Cowan, Joseph      
Cowan, Luke      
Daniels, Mark      
Dawson, Noble      
Dixon, John      
Fluskey, William      
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas      Whos Who Page
Glover, Joseph      
Gordon, George      
Greaves, J.      
Haile, Morris      
Hanlon, John      
Hardie, James Keir    M.P.  Whos Who Page
Hetherington, William      
Higham, John      
Hodgson, John      
Hornsby, J.      
Jackson, William      
James, Robert      
Kelly, John      
Kitchin, J.      
Leach, R. M.      
Long, Robert      
McCusker, J.      
McGuire, Joseph      
Messenger, Isaac      
Milburn, John      
Milburn, Joseph      
Millburn, William      
Mills, R.      
Mitchelle, —      
Moore, Joseph      
Newall, R.      
Pickering, George      
Pickthall, James      
Rooney, Richard      
Rothery, Mossop      
Rule, Francis      
Simpson, J.      
Southward, James      
Thompson, Edward      
Thompson, J. J.      
Tidyman, David      
Todd, Albert      
Todd, Lancaster      
Watson, Edward      
Woodburn, George      
Woodend, William      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print