Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

30th June 1910

Local Miners' Associations

Action For Libel

Flynn v. Duffy

At the Carlisle Assizes on Monday was commenced the trial of this action before a common jury, in which the plaintiff was James Flynn, Crossfield Road, Cleator Moor, secretary of the National Iron Ore Miners' Association, and the defendant was Thomas Gavin Duffy, Moor Row, miners agent. The action was brought by the plaintiff to recover damages for alleged libel. Mr. Eustace Hills (instructed by Messrs. Chapman and Baxter, Whitehaven) was counsel for the plaintiff; Mr. Langdon, K.C., and Dr. Atkinson (instructed by Messrs. Cobbett, Wheeler and Cobbett, Manchester) were counsel for the defendant.

Mr. Hills, in opening the case for the plaintiff, said the plaintiff asked for damages for a series of libels on him published by the defendant. The defendant, by his defence set up two defences. First, the defendant said he did not print or publish the libels; and, secondly, that those libels were true. Owning to certain questions which there had been power to put to him the jury would not be troubled with the first of those defences because defendant now admitted that he printed and published the libels, complained of, so that the only issue before them, he thought he might say, was whether or not the charges which were made by the articles complained of against the plaintiff were true. There would be no question when he came to read them to the jury that the charges were serious and grave; and when he had opened this case and called his evidence, he would ask then to say that they were not true, but were untrue, and that the plaintiff was entitled to their verdict. Before coming to the libel it was necessary that he should give a short outline to show how the dispute arose. In 1907 the plaintiff had been for came twelve years secretary to an Association called the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners and Kindred Trades Associates, which he proposed for the sake of shortness, to call the Cumberland Association. In 1907 there was a matter in dispute between the plaintiff and the trustees of this Cumberland Association. Generally speaking the dispute was as for the representation of the different mines. Some mines were represented by many representatives; some either not at all or by few. The result was that an action was started, and in February 1903, it was settled at these Assizes, each party paying their own costs, and the plaintiff if then ceased to act as secretary to the Cumberland Association. A large number of miners thought the plaintiff had not been well treated, and gave him their allegiance, and as a consequence a fresh Association, called the National Iron Ore Miners' Association — which he would call for shortness the National Association was started. When the new Association was started more than 600 members joined, a fact which he asked them to bear in mind, because one of the allegiances was that this was a bogus Association, and had practically no members. The defendant was appointed secretary to the Cumberland Association on the plaintiff ceasing to hold the office. There was a considerable friction between the two Associations, and the members of one Association came to the conclusion that they would not work with members of the other, and a strike was the result. The strike occurred at the beginning of 1908, and the now Association had to find money to relieve its members. The position was this: Here was the plaintiff, who had started this new Association, and in the early days of the life of this Association it was meet with the fact that it had to find funds to relieve these men on strike, the actual funds required being 15s a week for a man, and 1s a week for every child. The plaintiff not unnaturally felt that though undoubtedly not directly responsible for this strike, still that indirectly he could not but feel himself to a certain extent responsible, because the strike was the result of the 600 or 800 men who had given him their trust and followed him from the old Association. At this time the plaintiff was also treasurer of the Cumberland and Lancashire Miners' Federation, which he proposed to call the County Federation. From this federation the plaintiff borrowed £254 odd, and applied it to the relief of the men on strike — the members of the Association. If not the most serious charges in this action was that the plaintiff stole that money, that he robbed the County Federation — he was using the words of the libel itself. The defendant in 1908 started a paper called the Cumberland Miner and almost immediately after the first issue in September 1908 an article appeared in it virulently attacking the plaintiff, and making in fact the charges practical with the charges upon which he was basing his action today. The headlines of the articles were: Flynn registers a bogus Association. An empty shop registered as the office. Extraordinary hoax played on the Registrar County Federation found robbed. Sensational revelations, Flynn fired out. Resignation insisted on. Defendants £251. Miners demand Flynn's arrest." That was all in headlines. Then followed the article which contained these sentences :—

"Sensation follows sensation so rapidly in connection with Flynn's various claims and scheming that nothing but his arrest is needed to bring the whole of this sordid and disgraceful affair to a fitting climax. There can and will be no hushing up. The hard earned money of the blastfurnacemen, coalminers, and steelworkers, which they paid into the County Federation for productive and defensive purposes, has gone and Flynn has stolen it. We have had evidence of this in our possession for some time, and although we forced the pace we preferred to have facts officially confirmed before giving them to our readers."

"There could be little doubt that Flynn had grossly deceived them by having two bank books, one for the purpose of showing to the delegates, and the real one which he kept back."

The serious effect of allegations seemed to have funded four leads. The first was that the plaintiff robbed the Federation funds and stole £254; second the allegation that there could be little doubt that Flynn had grossly deceived them by having two bank books, one to show to the delegates and the real one which he kept himself. The third of the most serious of the charges seemed to be the words that began the article; "Flynn fired. Resignation insisted on." "Miners demanded Flynn's arrest." This was alleged to have been made at a meeting of the County Federation on September 22nd 1908; but he would produce the minutes and witnesses who attended that meeting, and when they had heard exactly what happened he would ask the jury to say that that was not a true account of what passed. The fourth and last allegation were in the headlines: "Flynn registers a bogus Association," "Empty shop registered as an office." "Extraordinary hoax played upon the Registrar." The offices of the Association were registered at 22, High-street, Cleator Moor. High-street, it was perfectly true, contained an empty shop, but it also contained the registered offices of the Association. The suggestion that the Association was not a genuine Association was answered by the fact that it had 600 or 800 members. After dealing next with some of the correspondence between the parties he called

The plaintiff, who stated that the defendant first came to West Cumberland in 1907. Witness was then secretary of the Federation. In 1907 there was a dispute between witness and the trustees of the Cumberland Association due to a change in the working of the Association. A change was made because the Conciliation Board was then established one representative from each mine being chosen to meet the employers. The registered office was 22, High-street, Cleator Moor, which was the same place as had been used for 11 or 12 years before. There was an empty shop there for a time. Fresh offices were afterwards got at 10, High-street, Cleator Moor. At first there were 800 to 1,000 members in October, 1907. It was in no way a bogus Association. It was carried on as he had carried on the old Association since October, 1907, with the result that there had been continual friction. Under the title: the National Association provided money for men on strike. At that time he was treasurer of the Federation, which was a combination of union joined together. The National Association belonged to it, but not the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners. The Federation extended over Barrow and Ulverston. At that time, when the strike took place, being part of each, they used some of the Federation money to pay the men on strike, as they had done before. He naturally felt indirectly responsible for the men and wanted to pay them. The pay was 15s a week per man and 1s a week for each child. He applied about "251 of the County Federation funds for the relief of these men. He had that amount by cash at different times, and he gave it as a rule to Thomas Hogg, their treasurer on Saturdays to pay the men. Very rarely did witness see the money actually paid to the men out of work. In further examination witness answered a great number of questions relating to figures in his balance-sheets, which showed that the total loan of Federation money was "254 15s 4d.

Mr Hills: Is it true that you robbed the Federation of this £254?

Plaintiff: Certainly not. I took it to pay the men with and will pay it back.

Is it true that the miners demanded your arrest? — I never heard tell of it.

Were you ever fired out? No. — Nothing was done at the meeting at all.

Are you still secretary? — Yes, of the National Association.

Did you have two bank books? — Certainly not, not belonging to the Federation.

Is it true that the miners demanded your arrest? — I never heard of it until I saw it appearing in this paper, the "Cumberland Miner."

Cross-examined by Mr. Langdon: Do you keep books of account? — Yes.

Do you have collecting cards and collectors? — Yes.

Do you give receipts? — No. The collectors at each pit enter it on their books and bring their books in.

And to whom do they pay it? — To Mr. Hogg, the treasurer.

Does he put it in the bank? — We have no banking account. We never had one. We pay the money out to the members.

Who keeps the money? — Mr. Hogg.

Have you a register of members? — No.

How can you tell if a man is a member? — Only by the delegates books.

If money is paid to a member does the treasurer get a signature for it? — No.

Rather lax isn't it? — Well, I don't know. That's our system in the National.

Then the treasurer has nothing to show he had paid money? — He may have.

Was there a strike or a lock-out in the Gillfoot Mine? — Yes.

When? — In January or February 1908.

Have you anything to show that? — The treasurer's book would show it.

How long did it last? — About twelve months unfortunately for us because our men were sent home because they would not join the other Association.

How many men were there? — About 30.

Was there a strike at the Postlethwaite Mine? — Yes, about the same time, and it affected 32 men.

And one at Ullcoats? Yes. — That lasted a long time, and we had four men out for three months.

When was the Salter Hall strike? — It would be about the same time as the other. It lasted only about twelve days, and affected 12 or 15 men.

In 1908 you were personally in great straits for money? — Yes. I had a disastrous fire.

Where the County Court judgements out against you? — Yes.

And you have not satisfied them? — Some may have been paid.

The Learned Judge: But were they paid before August 1908?

Witness: No.

Mr. Langdon: And I think in October, 1908, you offered 10s in the £ in three months on a £3 debt?

Witness: No. — I offered 10s in the £ to all my creditors. It was not accepted in regard to the £3 debt, and that was paid in full.

Answering further questions plaintiff said that Mr. Hanlon; as a municipal candidate at Whitehaven, was entitled to Federation money if his candidature was approved by the Federation. Mr. Hanlon never applied to him for "10 1s 8d. He paid Mr. Hanlon £5 in connection with the demonstration not in connection with the election. The claim was £3 18s. It had reference to the spots at the demonstration. He did not give him the £8 18s all at once, because he had not got it. It was money to pay for the field for the demonstration.

Mr. Langdon: But did you not give Mr. Hanlon a cheque for £5 1s 8d on your own private account? — Yes.

And was it not dishonoured? — Yes.

Did you pay Mr. Hanlon's election expenses? — I can't remember doing so. He never asked me for it.

Did he not write to Mr. Sharp for his election expenses? — I could not say. Mr. Sharp kept those accounts.

But you were treasurer? — I was treasurer in name, but Mr. Sharp kept the accounts.

Does not the balance-sheet of January, 1908 show that there ought to have been £400 belonging to the Federation in the bank? — Yes.

And did not Mr. Hanlon want to know why he could not get a cheque for £5? — But that had nothing to do with the Federation money. The demonstration was a separate account.

The Learned Judge: Why was your cheque dishonoured?

Witness: I had spent the money in making payments.

In further cross examination witness admitted he used about £200 of Federation money without telling the Federation, although two grants of £30 each had been made. It was irregular but not dishonest. It was used to pay the men with. He knew of the United Whitehaven Lodges. He had no notice that they had passed a resolution that a warrant be issued for his arrest. He never knew what took place at the United Whitehaven meetings. He did not know what the Broughton colliers had done.

Mr. Langdon: In what bank was the £270 cash on account shown on the balance sheet of 1908?

Witness: It would be in the Joint Stock Bank.

And where would the £157 cash on deposit be?

In the York City Bank.

The cross-examination was continued after the luncheon adjournment. Plaintiff stated that he attended the audit of the Federation accounts for 1907-8. Mr. Sharp had prepared the balance-sheet which was placed before the auditors. Witness did not sign it. After it was printed he saw his name at the bottom of it. He had never prepared or signed a balance-sheet. His name was put at the bottom of the printed sheets without his authority. He read the balance-sheet and thought it was all right. He never bothered about the balance-sheets. The money was always right.

Mr. Langdon: Do you keep no books yourself? — Witness: None. Mr. Sharp kept the books and accounts.

Mr. Langdon: You ought to have banked all the Federation money?

Witness: Yes.

And did you? — No.

Where is the account of this £270 which you show was in the bank? — We paid it out in strike-pay. I have no account showing where it was.

The Learned Judge: The balance-sheet shows £270 in the bank, and there was only £17 there. Where was the difference?

Witness: The balance was in hand.

Mr. Langdon: How did you have it?

Witness: In notes and gold.

Mr. Langdon: You have been connected with these organisations for twelve years, and you have been in business on you own account as a cycle agent; you are a justice of the peace and a member of a District Council, and you know something about accounts?

Witness: Well, I know more about mining than accounts.

Mr. Langdon: During this period in 1908, your private affairs were hopeless?

Witness: Yes, they were.

Were they bad in 1907? — At there and 1907 they were.

Mr. Langdon: A little dangerous to have money in your hand when your balance sheet showed £280 in the bank when there was only £17. Have you spent any Federation money for your private affairs?

Witness: No.

Will you produce your York City and County Bank book? — Yes. Mr. Chapman has it.

There is a cheque here July 24th, 1908, of £100. What cheque is that? — That was a cheque from the insurance company for my fire.

Were there two fires? — Yes, but one was slight. Only a few papers were burnt.

On whom was this cheque drawn? — It was for £115. I paid it into my bank. I put the £100 in and took the balance of £16 in each.

Mr. Langdon: Now show me the account of the disbursements of the £270.

Witness put in a daybook which he said was written up very nearly every weekend.

Mr. Langdon: Show me in this book anything showing a loan of £270 from the Federation.

Witness: We just took the money. It is in different items.

Mr. Langdon: Well mark with a pencil the items which you say make up the loan.

Witness made some marks on the book and handed it back to the learned council.

Mr. Langdon: Now then, here is £50 entered as "loan by self" in February 1908. Why didn't you put the £220 in the bank?

Witness: Because we had to keep paying it out.

Mr. Langdon: But you did not know the strike was going to last so long. Where did you keep the £220?

Witness: In the house.

Mr. Langdon: What! £220 in the house belonging to the Federation without telling the Federation! Why didn't you put in this book "loan by Federation?"

Witness: Because we did not want our own members to know it.

The Learned Judge: I should think it is about as gross a misapprehension of your position as treasurer as could well be.

Witness, answering Mr. Langdon, said the expenditure account put in was made up in the office or in the lodge room. It was not all written at one time. It was all written with one kind of pen.

The Learned Judge having examined the books, told Mr. Langdon that, going through it roughly, it indicated that £278 had been paid for strikes and look-outs in the whole period.

In re-examination plaintiff stated that he had handed every penny of the £254 over for the benefit of the men on strike. He had appropriated none of the £270, which, except for the balance, was the same money as the £254, for his own use. His salary was £3 a week and expenses, or ought to have been, but this year he was £125 back. He had only received £96 wages and expenses and everything combined.

John Dodd, local manager at Carlisle for the Royal Insurance Company, deposed that plaintiff's premises were insured against fire. There was a fire at these premises in May, 1908, in respect which £116 was paid in July.

Andrew Sharp, Maryport secretary of the Cumberland and North Lancashire Federation of Workmen and of the Cumberland Miners Association, deposed that he was present at a meeting held in September, 1908, at which Mr. Walls presided. He produced the minutes of the meeting, showing that, a sub-committee was appointed to inquire into the "treasurer's business," and that the treasurer was suspended for the time being. He did not remember anyone suggesting that the Federation had been robbed. The Board did not treat the matter as a robbery, and no demand was made for Mr. Flynn's arrest. Witness did not say at the meeting that the plaintiff kept a bogus bank book. He had had an apology from the printer of the paper in respect of that statement. At a subsequent meeting it was found and admitted that Mr. Flynn owed the Board £254, but the matter was ordered to stand over until the next Board meeting.

Cross-examined: He was only the secretary, and therefore concerned only with the clerical work. Mr. Hanlon was a well-known member of the Whitehaven Lodge. The funds of the Federation were liable for the payment of his municipal election expenses. Mr. Hanlon sent witness a letter asking for those expenses. He expected that Mr. Flynn had paid them, but afterwards he heard from Mr. Hanlon that the cheque had been dishonoured. In consequence of that Mr. Hanlon demanded a full inquiry into the conduct of the treasurers, which led to the meeting of September 22nd. He was surprised that so small a sum as £5 was not forthcoming from the treasurer to pay Mr. Hanlon's election expenses with. In September, 1908, witness expected the money to be either in the bank or in Mr. Flynn's hands. He expected the auditors wanted to see the bank book for the current account, and that Mr. Flynn showed them a bank book. One of the auditors was a coal-miner and the other an ore-miner.

Patrick Walls, Moss-Bay, Workington, agent for the Blastfurnacemen, deposed that he was chairman of the meeting held on September 22nd. It was not the fact that at the meeting Flynn was "fired out." He did not hear Mr. Sharp make any statement about Flynn keeping two bank books. The question of the £254 was throughout treated as money that had been used wrongfully, but no one suggested robbery.

Cross-examined: They looked on it seriously when they got to know. Plaintiff was suspended and not reinstated.

James Dobie, Moor Row, engine driver, stated that he was present at the September meeting, when plaintiff was suspended for the time being as treasurer. At the sub-committee the using of the Federation funds in the way described was treated as an irregularity.

Cross-examined: He was one of the trustees. He signed the return placed before him by Mr. Flynn. He did not know it was inaccurate. He did not think Mr. Flynn would have led him astray.

Thomas Hogg, miner, Penzance-street, Moor Row, treasurer of the National Association, deposed that during 1908 a good many members of the Association were on strike, and some money had to be found to pay the strike pay with. Some of that money was refunded at the time. From time to time plaintiff handed him sums of money to pay strike pay with, but witness did not know where plaintiff got that money from. Witness has a book showing £50, received from plaintiff February 22nd, another £50 on February 20, and other sums on other dates. All of it was spent on the men locked out. £50 was received from plaintiff on March 7th, and £100 on March 28th.

Cross-examined: He was the paid treasurer of the Society. His pay was 8s a week. He lent the Society £10 on one occasion, but did not enter it in the books. He was prepared to lose it, he expected. He followed Mr. Flynn from the old Society to the new one.

This closed the plaintiff's case.

On the hearing being resumed on Tuesday morning.

Mr. Langdon, K.C., opened the case for the defence and said what had been made clear beyond all doubt was the way Mr. Flynn wilfully and intentionally deceived the Federation whose monies he had under his control to disburse accordingly to the will and direction of the Federation. As regards the foundation of the Society it was obvious there had been a dispute. As a result of that he was as they claimed, dismissed, as he, claimed not dismissed according to the forms that were necessary, and an action was brought in order to clear him out of the Society, and get back from him the property and books of the Society, which he claimed the right to possess. In the meanwhile he carried on, or claimed to carry on, the business under the name if the old Association, collected subscriptions, and dealt with members as though he himself were the old Association. He was injuncted from holding himself out as secretary. Here he as secretary of one of the largest Associations in the country was told he was no longer wanted. That was blow No.1. Blow No.2 was even worse, because it meant that he lost not merely his position and power and reputation, but he also lost these pounds, shillings and pence the money that would be paid to him as secretary to the Association. Mr. Flynn must give a bribe — he used the word deliberately — to the men, he was seeking to retain as adherents and supporters over and above the money he lawfully and properly might give. The benefit which by the rules the members might get out of the funds of the Society was limited to 10s a week in strike pay. But he gave 15s a week. The Learned Judge: £1 in some cases. — Mr. Langdon: Yes, £1. Continuing, he said Mr. Flynn shifted out of one Society and established another. Though only entitled to give 10s a week he dipped his hand into the pocket of the Federation and paid out to these men what he had no right to give them. For months he paid sick pay. He was also paying for superannuation and death allowances. He had not a justification for parting with a single penny for any one of these objects. Under such circumstances, was there not some justification for saying this was a bogus Association? True, it existed as an Association; it was registered after eight or ten months; it did some work in strikes, but it was too much to say that an Association of this kind which paid benefits that were illegal and had no funds out of when to pay these benefits; and got organisations on foot by illegal and corrupt payments, was a bogus Association. In the article that was printed they undoubtedly went too far on some matters, because, as it now turned out, the Association had offices, and after twelve months were registered. But he took £250 from the Federation without telling them because he knew, if he did tell them, he would not get the money. In his books there appeared an entry of a loan from the secretary of £100, and on the same date another entry showed that the secretary's salary for three months, £39, was paid. If that £100 belonging to this Federation had not been taken, from the Federation and paid to his Association, would he have got his £39? He took it out of one pocket, which he called the Federation bank, and put it into another, which he called the Association bank, and then transferred it to his waistcoat pocket, where he kept his salary. This money was taken from the Federation without the knowledge of the Federation in despite of it to pay in part the salary which was at that day his only means of livelihood.

The Learned Judge: Do you still attempt to justify the statement that he stole the money?

Mr. Langdon: I cannot prove that; therefore cannot justify that he put it into his own pocket. He took the money in the way I have described, and used it for his own purposes.

John Hanlon, Mark Lane, Whitehaven, general secretary of the Whitehaven Joint Lodges of the Cumberland Miners' Association, and a member of the Cumberland County Federation, said he was a candidate for the Whitehaven Town Council, and the Federation were to pay his expenses. The expenses due to him were £10 1s 8d, for himself and another candidate. He asked Mr. Flynn for the money, but he could not get it from him. He got £5 on account in July 1908. Afterwards he gave witness a cheque on his own account for £5 1s 8d. That cheque was dishonoured, and he wrote to Mr. Sharp asking that this be investigated. He had seen Federation balance-sheet showing £400 in hand. Witness was present at the meeting of September 22nd. Mr. Flynn said he had had hard trouble, and offered to show his bank books. Witness said he only wanted to know why he could not get his £5 1s 8d. Flynn then admitted it had all gone, and in reply to questions he said he did not know where. Witness said he had been instructed to press for an inquiry. Then it was moved that a sub-committee be appointed to inquire into the whole matter and report. It was also agreed to ask Mr. Flynn to resign, and to call a Board meeting to receive the report. Mr. Sharp said that at a meeting Flynn passed a bank book round which seemed to satisfy the members so he must have had two.

The Learned Judge: The minute book says that resolution to ask Mr. Flynn to resign was not carried.

The witness said there was some dispute about the words resign or be suspended; but Mr. Sharp said it was only a word, and it did not matter. Witness said it did matter. Mr. Flynn said the old society owed him £120, and some of the money had gone to the men. The Whitehaven miners passed a resolution to take local action, against Flynn, and Mr. Sharp was to attend to it. Some members spoke of arrest.

Cross-examined: He was not a friend of Mr. Duffy any more than anyone else. When he first met Mr. Duffy the latter was a friend of Mr. Flynn.

John Haslewood, steelworker, Darcy Street, Workington, gave evidence with regard to the meeting of 22nd September.

Henry Wharton, Great Broughton, secretary of the Buckhill Lodge, was about to give evidence as to the miners demanding Flynn's arrest, but the Learned Judge ruled the evidence out on the ground that it did not appear in the particulars.

John Fletcher, a member of the Executive of the National Association, said no register of members was kept, nor any record of the membership beyond the lodge book. In 1908 he heard Mr. Flynn say there were 600 members. He never looked into Mr. Flynn's books. Hogg never submitted his accounts to the Executive to witness's knowledge.

Answering the Learned Judge, witness said the Executive know practically nothing about the affairs of the Society. It was run by Flynn and Hogg.

Joseph Branthwaite, Frizington, also gave evidence.

Thomas Gavan Duffy, the defendant, admitted the authorship of the article. His Association gave and demanded receipts for every halfpenny. The article was written from information supplied by men he believed to be truthful. He wrote the article in 1908, and in correspondence of what happened at Salter Mine he republished it. The "Cumberland Miner" was now published without a printers name.

Mr. Hills: That is an offence. Why did you do it? — Because it is so easy to get at a printer.

Exactly: That was the reason the statute was passed. — A printer might possibly pay rather than fight no matter how justified he may be.

The Learned Judge: Do you know that is forbidden by statute? — I have learned since.

Have you put it on? — No, there has been no issue this year.

When did you learn that was an offence? — In October last.

Mr. Hills: Has the paper been published since? — There was an issue in December.

Is the paper dead? — No.

Is it about to die? — No, it shan't die.

The Learned Judge: Why did you not put the printer's name on the December issue? — I thought it was not necessary.

You know, the statute said it should be put on? — I thought it was not a vital matter.

Mr. Falls: Did it not occur to you that you could safely attack people if your paper appeared without a printer's name? — No, that is not so.

Your paper makes scurrilous attacks upon almost everybody from time to time? — No.

Does it not attack various people?

Mr. Hills: Since this action was started have you published an article about a gentleman engaged professionally in the action, containing the most scurrilous language possible? — I think the same gentleman used scurrilous language himself.

Have you talked about the gentleman as a professional muck-rake. — It was a local application.

Mr. Hills: Have you been persistently attacking Mr. Flynn since the proceedings commencement of the action? — No.

Have you caused handbills to be issued talking of "Flynn's alleged libel action against Duffy?" — Yes.

Have you said that "after nearly two years" threatening and shuffling the above action had been entered for trial, and will be tried at Carlisle on the 24th of this month. Mr. Gavan Duffy has refused to apologise and he goes to Carlisle to unmask the common enemy of the district? — Yes, that was published.

Do you know that is a great contempt of Court? — I am sorry if it is so; I did not think it was.

The Learned Judge: It is so; you have no right to go placarding a district with things about your action.

Mr. Hills: Do you then go on to say that you wanted funds and that a committee had been formed to get you funds to defend this action? — Yes.

Did you say a special appeal is made to the members of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Association? — Yes, we had a right to appeal to our own members.

Did you say, "It would be a lasting disgrace if the defence were limited by lack of funds?" — Yes.

Did you say "a collection will be taken next payday and urge everyone in the district to give what they could?" — Yes.

Have you put up any posters in prominent type put up outside the mines in order to draw men from plaintiffs union to your own? — No.

Have you put up any posters like this (holding up a poster of which the following is the text) :—

"Cumberland Iron Ore Kindred Trades Association — A mass meeting of all the members of the above Association (the only recognised trade union in this district) will be held on Friday first at two p.m. Business: To select a deputation to wait upon the Board of Directors in accordance with Mr. Burnyeat's letter to Mr. Gavan Duffy. Don't be bluffed or terrorised. A Conciliation Board is now promised to us. Flynn has had no deputation to the employers. His concessions are bogus like his union. Join with the men at Woodend, Pallaflatt, Parkhouse and Mowbray, in a united demand for fair wages and the repudiation of the Salter strike smashers."

Mr. Hill: Did you draw the circular up, it was altered by one of the members who put in that bit, would be a lasting disgrace to the district.

Mr Hills: Don't you know that some of these circulars were actually given to the delegates of the National Association. Not by me or on my behalf. I did not know it was done. Colonel Jackson was then shareholder of the Salter Mine. He did not consider that the paper contained a verbal attack on Colonel Jackson.

Mr. Hills: Colonel Jackson is a man of honour and probity. — I don't know the gentleman.

Was it because your people had been defeated at the Salter Mine that you attacked him? — As a shareholder and employer of labour he had a right to be criticised.

Do you call that article criticism? — Yes.

Do you tell the jury that the Association was a bogus one? — As a trade unionist, yes; it did no trade union work. At the outset there would be 160 members. Later they would be much less.

Do you say now it had no offices? — In twelve months they have shifted four times, and their chief offices is now a pigeon cote.

Do you say they issued no balance-sheet? — I do.

The Learned Judge: We have a balance-sheet put before us. It has been recently printed. — They were never seen in district before.

Mr. Hills: Do you mean that the County Federation was robbed? — After the evidence I believe that now more than ever. "Flynn fired out" was true if in a figurative sense. They were words which miners could understand. Speaking to the arrest, he considered it a fair statement.

Mr. Hill reading from the article: "There can and will be no hushing up. Flynn had stolen it."

Witness: He has admitted it.

The Learned Judge: That is not the question; you know it quite well.

Witness: In my opinion it is true; he has stolen it.

The Learned Judge: What do you mean by the word stolen? — Taking without the knowledge of the people who owned it.

Do you say he took it for himself? — Yes, my lord.

That is all, I want to know. Don't cavil about the meaning of the word.

Mr. Hills (continuing to read from the article): "There could be little doubt; Flynn grossly deceived them." That was a report conveyed to him on the authority of men he thoroughly believed.

The Learned Judge: You are asked if it was true. — I cannot say it is untrue.

Mr. Hills: I must ask for an answer. — I shall rely on the information given to me, and say it is true.

Counsel having addressed the jury, the Learned Judge, in summing up, said nobody could justify what Mr. Flynn did to pay the strike pay, but when a man says another had made himself liable to conviction he must prove it, or pay damages. Nobody could defend plaintiff or his conduct, but he had not stolen the money; it was taken to pay strike pay. On the question of damages they might take into consideration the conduct of both parties. They could consider whether he was really protecting the public in this article or had a personal feeling against the plaintiff. With regard to the plaintiff, a man who did what he did, and ought not to have done, did not come into Court with perfectly clean hands, and they might consider that.

The jury retired, and after 45 minutes' deliberation returned with a verdict for the plaintiff; damages, 1s.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —, Dr.      
Baxter, —    Solicitor  
Chapman, —    Solicitor  
Cobbett, —    Solicitor  
Dobie, James    Engine driver  
Dodd, John    Manager Insurance Co.  
Fletcher, John    National Assoc.  
Flynn, James    Union Secretary  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Hanlon, John    Union  
Haslewood, John    Steelworker  
Hills, Eustace    Barrister  
Hogg, Thomas    Miner  
Jackson, Colonel      
Langdon, —    K.C.  
Sharp, Andrew    Union Secretary  
Walls, Patrick    Union agent  
Wharton, Henry    Union Secretary  
Wheeler, —    Solicitor  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print