|
16th June 1910 The Wellington Pit DisasterCumberland Miners' AssociationWhitehaven Relief FundDissatisfaction With Administration. On Monday night a special meeting of the Executive Cumberland Miners' Association was held at the Coal Offices, Workington. Mr. A. Sharp presided, and all the members of the Executive were present. The Whitehaven disaster and the payment of Union men who had been thrown idle was first considered. The Chairman said great dissatisfaction had been expressed by the Miners' Association, and especially in Cumberland, with reference to the treatment of Union men by the Mayor of Whitehaven and his committee. Non-unionists, Mr. Sharp said, were paid out of the fund, but the Union men were not paid anything for the first week. This week they had been paid less than half of what the non-union men had received. Their Association was not compelled by rule to grant any support to the members thrown idle by the disaster, but owing to the distress prevailing the Association granted support equal to strike pay, and had paid up to the present £2,000, and both non-unionists and Union men belonging to other Associations had received pay from the Mayor's fund. In the course of the discussion that followed several of the committee expressed dissatisfaction at the way in which their fellow members of the Union had been treated. It was stated that the Mayor and his committee were holding a meeting that afternoon to consider relief matters. It was decided that, if as the results of the meeting the members of the Cumberland Miners' Association were not treated in the same way as non-unionists and the members of other trades unions, a meeting with the Mayor's Committee be requested to discuss the whole question. Rescue In Mines Mr. Churchill's Suggestions. A representative body of the Mining Association of Great Britain met at the Home Office on Wednesday to discuss the use of rescue apparatus in mines. Mr. Churchill stated that several foreign countries already legislated on the subject of rescue work in mines; and he knew perfectly well what praiseworthy efforts had been made by many members of the Mining Association of Great Britain to make an effective advance into the new field of scientific work. It was essential that they should have men who knew how to use a particular apparatus, and there could be no effective organisation of rescue work. The rescue brigade must be carefully selected, and he understood the St. John Ambulance were willing to assist and co-operate. The men ought to be selected from those engaged in each shift, so that all of them should not be underground at the same time. They should be divided into squads of five, who would be accustomed to work together. The number of men in the brigade should not be less than 5 per cent of the underground workers. The Home Office thought there ought to be a rescue station at every colliery, or within half an hours drive of a colliery, and at which there should be apparatus and trained men. He was anxious to make it clear that he was not pressing those proposals upon them in any sense of reproach at all but the thought the time had come when they had got to see that the apparatus and rescue provisions were brought into general use throughout the whole country. He thought legislation would probably be necessary, and he would be prepared to introduce legislation on the subject at a suitable opportunity. But he was anxious that they should go forward hand in hand, that the voluntary adoption of that apparatus should not be delayed a single day, and that the general opinion of coalowners all over the country should support any statutory measure which might be passed. The orders would not prescribe one type of apparatus, because it was desirable that experiments should be made and considerable latitude allowed for the present at any rate. Mr. T. Ratcliffe Ellis remarked that it was absolutely necessary that before the adoption of measures they should be very carefully considered to see how far they were really suitable for the purpose for which they were to be applied. The coalowners felt that before any rules were laid down more consideration would have to be given to the matter. There was not yet a perfect apparatus, and while some people preferred one type, other people preferred another. The manager of the mine must be responsible for the rescue work. His Association were entirely in agreement that there should be men trained in rescue work at each colliery, and that stations should be established. The Association intended to send the proposals which had been made to the colliery owners, and invite them to do what they could to carry out the recommendations of the Royal Commission. It was desirable that the progress should go on voluntarily rather than that any legislation should take place. Mr. Ellis then referred to a statement recently made by Mr. Keir Hardie, in reference to the Whitehaven colliery disaster, that "in his opinion as a miner he believed that the walls built up to put out the fire at the colliery while the victims were still alive." With regard to the appointment of inspectors, Mr. Ellis said that if the Home Office had to appoint a lower grade of inspector they asked that at any rate he should be qualified. Mr. Redmayne remarked that up to present, when colliery disasters had occurred, the rescue apparatus had had to be obtained from a considerable distance. Very often a district might be cut off by a danger zone, and in a safe place beyond that zone men had been known to live for more than a day, and in other cases he was convinced that if rescue apparatus had been immediately available many lives could have been saved. Mr. Churchill quite agreed that they were in the experimental stage at present, but he earnestly pressed upon them to inform him as soon as they possibly could as to what steps could be taken swiftly to obtain a wide extension of it. They did not want anything that would impose a heavy burden of a great deal of difficulty, but the whole subject had got to be pressed forward, and he hoped he might rely upon their effective co-operation in carrying it forward at once. With regard to the statement made by Mr. Keir Hardie that had been raised, he took that opportunity of saying that he greatly regretted that such a statement had been made by a public man. He thought it was a very cruel and a very disgraceful statement to make. He greatly regretted that a member of the House of Commons should have given utterance to such a cruel aspersion. Mr. Keir Hardie And The Whitehaven Disaster. Mr. Keir Hardie, seen on Thursday in reference to this, said: "Mr. Winston Churchill's statement is evidently based on a very much abbreviated report of what I said. His comment is characterised by righteousness which could only proceed from total ignorance of what I said and of the facts of the case. In the course of the speech to which Mr. Churchill takes exception I gave it as my opinion, based upon my practical experience as a miner, that at the time it was decided to wall up the mine the miners were in all probability still alive. I further stated that had the spirit of the Mines Regulation Act been carried out in connection with working of the mine the disaster would not have occurred. The fire which imprisoned the miners took place in what was known as the "bottle neck," and apparently this was the only means of egress from the workings. Beyond the "bottle neck," the workings branch off in five main levels, and it would have been an easy matter to have had a safety road laid from these to the pit shaft so that in the event of the main haulage road between the shaft and the "bottle neck" getting blocked up the other would have been available for the men to escape by. I suggested that these were matters which would require to be investigated, and it is this suggestion which the Home Secretary characterises as "cruel and disgraceful". The working miners of the country will have a very different opinion. I hope Mr. Churchill is not more concerned about shielding the mine-owner than he is about finding out the truth.
Mr. J. A. Grant, M.P. and the Sealing of the Pit. In the House of Commons on Monday. Mr. Churchill informed Mr. Grant (C) that the decision to close the intake-airway, by which the pit conflagration at Whitehaven was being fed with air, and which further carried the poisonous gases generated by the fire through all the workings of the mine, was made by the authorities of the mine, acting on the advice of Her Majesty's inspector of mines for the district. It was confirmed by the chief inspector of mines on his arrival at Whitehaven a few hours later, after a conference at which the which the managers of the mine, six inspectors of mines, and others were present, who unanimously advised that the stopping must be maintained. This decision was arrived at because it was clear that, in view of the extent and fierceness of the fire, any further attempt to penetrate the mine was useless; that it was impossible that any of the workmen in the workings could be alive, and that further operations were attended with imminent danger of another explosion, which could cost the lives of the would-be rescuers. Mr. Grant: May we take it from the answer that the rumour to which currency has been given, that the colliery owners sealed the mine in order to save their own property, is absolutely without foundation? Mr Churchill: The sealing of the intake-airway was done on the advice, and with the approval of His Majesty's inspector of mines. (Hear, hear.)
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||