|
12th May 1910 The Frizington Mine FatalityThe Adjourned InquestThe adjourned inquest into the circumstances relative to the death of the man named John Mossop, an iron ore miner, who resided at Trumpet terrace, Wath Brow, and who met with a fatal accident in the Fletcher High House Mine, Frizington, on Monday was conducted by Mr. E. Atter, coroner, at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, on Friday afternoon last, Mr. R. Wilson foreman of the jury. Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines was present, and Mr. O. F. Ormrod and Mr. W. W. Smith (engineer and manager) represented the Company, and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy secretary to the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners and Kindred Trades Association represented the relatives if the deceased. James Mulholland, miner, residing at 22, Mill-street, Frizington, said he was in the employ of the High House Company, and worked at No. 4 pit. Mossop had been working with him for five or six months. On Monday witness commenced work, at two o'clock in the afternoon. Patrick Styles and deceased started work at the same time. Whilst engaged in the pit some "stuff" came down about three o'clock and knocked deceased down. Witness was close to deceased at the time of the fall, but none of the "stuff" touched witness. Patrick Styles and witness lifted deceased up and took him into the "eye." There was not much "stuff "on deceased. Deceased spoke to witness saying he was getting a bit wet. He saw a lump of stone on the staging after the accident. The workmen, manager, and deputy all examined the roof, and the customary examination took place about two o'clock by a man named Lightfoot. There were some shots fired about one o'clock. The place was about fifteen feet high where they were working, and they looked with lights to see if anything had stirred. By the Inspector: There were no holes fired after witness and deceased started work. Some of the men told them to take notice going down as they had been firing. Witness was working on a staging and would be about fifteen feet from where they were standing to the timber. This was as sinking pit — they were opening an old mine out. It was intended to timber the place down — to put logs in up to the other timber. The last timber was put in the shaft a little over a week before, and nothing had fallen during that time so far as he knew. He remembered the shaft being worked about forty years since. The "stuff" which fell gave no warning. Witness had seen the overman examine the shaft. Every time they fired somebody looked at the place. Replying to Mr. Ormrod, witness said a good light was provided in the shaft. After firing they always proceeded to the "eye" of the shaft. He thought perhaps a piece of stone might have got wedged behind the wood, and it might have been worked down by the water. Patrick Styles, 62, Yeathouse road, Frizington, stated that he had been working at the pit since the shaft was re-started about eight months ago. Witness, Mulholland, and deceased, when down the shaft at two o'clock, and immediately commenced working on the staging. While they were making holes he found Mossop lying on the staging but he didn't hear anything fall, and he had no idea then what had caused Mossop to fall. He was standing partly with his back to deceased. Witness did not see an examination of the shaft made on Monday. The last time he saw it examined was on the previous Saturday. There was very little blood about the deceased after the accident. By Mr. Leck: The wound on the deceased's head did not look dangerous. The shaft was filled up to the "eye" before being re-opened. They took out the material and timbered as they went along. Where they thought the ground was bad they put timber in right away. Witness had never used in this county what was termed "the miner's hard hat." Originally the shaft was worked without any timber because the ground was good enough without. On Monday they were boring holes to make hitches to put a frame set in. They put a frame set in at every "eye." By the Foreman: If he (deceased) had been wearing a "miner's hard hat," he thought it would have saved is life. The Inspector: These hats used to be a regular thing for miners to wear, but they have been out of use for some time. The Foreman said as it was a dangerous job he thought it would be useful to have these hats in cases of that kind. Replying to Mr. Duffy, witness said there were no shots fired on the second shift. Asked if it was possible to put a piece of board across the shaft above workmen in the shaft to prevent anything from falling upon them, witness said he had never seen anything of the kind in mines where he had worked. Witness had always worked in the open. Mr. Duffy: If this was done do you think it would have prevented this lump from falling on this man? Witness: Yes. What objection would there be to some provision of that kind being made? — I don't see any objection. By the Coroner: He had never heard of any such arrangement as suggested by Mr. Duffy, and he did not think if could easily be done. Isaac A. Parker, overman at the pit, said he had held this position for about two months. Deceased was a steady reliable man. He saw him before going down the shaft and gave him and the other two men instructions to bore the holes for the hitches. On Monday he made a thorough inspection of the shaft and felt confident that all was right. When witness examined the deceased after the accident he found no sign of any injury about his arms and legs. He was unable to find any trace of a "fall" in the shaft. Witness spoke to deceased, who was conscious, when he got to him. He found a slight cut on the head when he got into the change house, but the man was then unable to tell him anything. The Foreman: Was there are likelihood of either of these men to have hit him with the hammer when they were working close together. Witness: I don't know. By the Coroner: This was his first knowledge of a fall having taken place. Replying to a juror (Mr. Cannell), witness said it was possible for a piece of wood to have fallen from about 18 feet above where the men were working. By Mr. Leck: If a piece of stone about the size of a man's hand fell he would not look upon that as a "fall of ground" which was generally referred to as a "fall". All the usual precautions were taken, the men being supplied with belts and ropes. They had the full ambulance equipment at the mine offices. By Mr. Ormrod: He did not find any rough stone on the staging in the shaft. There might have been bits about the size of an egg. By Mr. Duffy: He did not think it would be practicable to erect some staging over the workmen's head in a shaft like that. Wm. Lightfoot, contractor, of Wath Brow, said he had the contract for the work of sinking of High House shaft. Witness finished his work at two in the afternoon. They were making holes for the hitches, and deceased and the other two men were to follow them in that work. Three shots were fired about half-past one, and afterwards they examined the place to see that all was right. Mr. Parker frequently examined the shaft. Witness did all that, in his opinion, was necessary for the protection of the men working in the shaft. By a Juror: His version of the accident was that there must have been a piece of stone lodged behind the wood and that this had fallen. Lightfoot, replying to Mr. Leck said Mossop was on of the best of workmen. His opinion was that a piece of stone had been blown behind the timber, just above where the men were working. It was an extra wet shaft, and the water ultimately had dislodged the stone. He did not think anything came off the solid stone. By Mr. Duffy: He did his work under the control and superintendence of Mr. Parker. Dr. Middleton, house surgeon at the infirmary, deposed that the deceased was suffering on admission to the infirmary from a small scalp wound on the back of the top of the head, which might have been caused by a sharp or blunt instrument. He did not discover any other injuries. The wound it was evident, was not in itself sufficient to render the man unconscious. When the man was conveyed to the hospital he was in a very serious condition, and this was evident from the fact that the deceased was unconscious and vomiting, which showed that the brain had been injured. Answering the Coroner, the doctor said he had examined the stone, which was very heavy, and it was just about the size of a man's fist, and if it fell a distance of about twenty feet it might cause such an injury as deceased suffered from, and leave no more trace of the skull. The injury in itself that caused death was not due altogether to the wound, but death was due to compression of blood on the brain, caused by continual bleeding inside. The man never regained consciousness and died on Tuesday. Mr. W. Leck said at this mine it was a special kind of sinking, and almost unique in this district, inasmuch as it was not ordinary sinking, but they were sinking through material that had been filled in. Special precautions had been taken and the company had at all times been from the very beginning exceptionally anxious to carry out the work without accident and timber it right through. It was quite clear in the old days, where a shaft was sunk that the lower part of the shaft wasn't timbered at all. He thought the theory suggested by the last witness was as likely as any that a small piece of stone had lodged behind the timber and then dropped out. He did not think anything could have fallen down the shaft because there was a cover over it. There was nothing to complain of the Company. He might point out that he had examined the shaft recently and he was quite satisfied at the time with the precautions taken. Mr. Ormrod expressed how much his clients regretted the accident, especially when taken they, he was pleased to hear Mr. Leck say so perhaps more than ordinary precaution in providing belts and lamps for the work, and he understood the work was in its last stage of sinking and with all their precautions they felt it very much that such an accident should have occurred. Mr. Duffy brought to the notice of the Company that the man was not conveyed to the infirmary until six o'clock, which he said showed the need for a horse ambulance for the district. Mr. Parker said he had the deceased taken to the changing house about 5.30 and a doctor was called, and he was afterwards taken in a covered cab to the infirmary. If they had thought it better then he would have called the ambulance. Mr. Duffy said he felt sure that he (Mr. Parker) had done his best, but still it was quite necessary for an ambulance to be obtained, and not for a person suffering from compression of the brain to be taken in a cab. The Coroner, in his summing up, said it seemed to him that the evidence clearly showed there had been no neglect or default on the part of anyone. He commented upon the satisfactory manner in which James Mulholland had given his evidence. The jury returned a verdict "That deceased met his death by misadventure." The Coroner: And not specify the cause? The Foreman: That is so.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||