|
31st March 1910 The Mining Fatality At WoodendThe InquestThe inquiry into the death of Lawrence Byrne whose death resulted in consequence of injuries received at the Woodend Mines, took place at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, on Thursday afternoon, before Mr. E. Atter (coroner) and a jury, of which Mr. Robert Wilson was chosen foreman. There were present: Mr. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. J. Hope Brown, who appeared for the Company; and Mr. J. Flynn, Cleator Moor, who appeared for the relatives of the decease. Mr. Sherwen put in a plan showing where the accident happened. The first witness called was Lawrence Byrne (son of the deceased), who said he lived at 56, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, and was in the employ of the Workington Iron and Steel Company, at their Moss Bay Mines at Woodend. He said deceased was a married man and had worked at the mines about twelve years. Witness had not been working with him, but had worked on the same shift. The last time he saw deceased was at six o'clock on Monday morning, and he was then in good health. He was going to his work at that time. Witness's first knowledge of the accident was when he heard deceased shouting to a man named Carson, who called for the ambulance. He then found his father. The last time he saw him alive was on Wednesday. His father told him he did not know how the accident happened. Deceased made no other statement. Witness did not know how the accident happened. The Foreman: What kind of explosives were they using? — Gelatine dynamite. Witness considered it safe. The Coroner: Who supplies the dynamite the workmen of the Company? — The Company. Replying to a question by the Coroner witness said he did not know whether his father had fired shots. John Kiveney, 17, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, mines labourer, said he had worked at Moss Bay Mines at Woodend, about three or four months. He was working along with the deceased on Monday morning last and also with Murphy. Deceased and the latter were boring holes. They bored four holes. Three shots were fired. The reports went off, one after another, but the fourth one did not go off. When the fourth shot did not go off they stood away off for 25 minutes, at a distance of 80 yards from the place. Murphy went back to the place for a minute and witness followed him. Murphy went back to see if the "snuff" had fallen away from the hole. He left deceased sitting at the same place. When Murphy go to the hole, he said "There is a hole miss-fired." Byrne had made the hole; it was one of the three he had made that did not go off. Byrne went to put another charge in the hole. Witness thought it was the first charge that went off, as the second one had not been lighted. He (witness) was not touched, but Murphy who was nearer, was knocked down. He did not see deceased. The Coroner: Was any iron or steel piercer used? — No one used any. The Coroner: Does anyone superintend this shot firing? — No. Each man does his own. Answering the Coroner, witness said he had often seen miss-fire. In reply to the Inspector, witness said he had an idea how the charge was made. The explosive was brought into the mine in tins. A packet in a tin contained forty cartridges. Each man used them at his own discretion. Four holes were lighted. Murphy lit two as also did Byrne. Witness walked out to a place of safety. He heard three shots go off. Twenty minutes was the time they stood out when there was a miss-fire. He had seen a pricker used for scraping out holes. When working with a spade it was only used to clear away the face of the hole. They thought two shots had gone off together. He was quite certain they stood off more than twenty minutes. Byrne had the charge on him in his belt. Byrne made no remark about the shot. Mr. Brown: You said you waited for twenty minutes; is that the rule in the pit? — Yes. Mr. Flynn: When you have had a miss-fire, have you ever found anything wrong with the fuse? — No, except that they said the fuse was not up to much. Mr. Flynn: Murphy said nothing about the fuse; you were all in the dark when the explosion occurred? — Yes. What length of fuse was there out of the holes? — Three length. He could not remember whether the hole had split or not. Deceased had not touched the holes when the explosion took place. John Hillon, Flosh Cottage, Cleator Moor, deputy-overman, at Moss Bay Mine, said he knew the deceased. He last saw him down the mine about eleven o'clock on Monday. Murphy was working with him. He was in No. 20 Company at the time of the accident. His first knowledge of anything wrong was when he heard from a labourer that two men were lamed. He went to the place. When he got to where Murphy and Byrne were he found both on the top of the level. Byrne was suffering from face injuries, but Murphy did not seem to be much hurt. He made inquiries, and Murphy said that it was a miss-shot that had gone off. Deceased could not give any reason as to how it had occurred. Both men were at once attended to. He did not see deceased after the accident. He only heard him speak when he said he did not know what had happened. As a deputy-overman he thought the shot hole hung fire and then went off when they got near it. The men made their own charges from material with which they were supplied. He had had complaints about the fuses. The last report he got was a week last Monday from a man named Glover, who told him they had a miss hole, in No. 8 Company. He got Glover's cap that came out of the hole and they exploded. Deceased and Murphy had the same caps and fuse that had been complained of. These fuses had been called in, because they were considered dangerous. He did not find any defects. When there is a miss fire they are ordered to stop out. They had no special rules. He (witness) would have gone back in twenty minutes. After igniting, it all depended on the length of the fuse. He thought an 18 inch fuse would take about a couple of minutes. After twenty minutes he would not expect any danger. Mr. Kitchin had given orders for the fuses to be called in. The Foreman: You think they are dangerous when these things do not go off? — Yes. Mr. Leck: What is the general practice as regards to stemming holes, what tools are they requested to use? — A swab stick. What are the explosives? — Blasting gelatine. Do you know what charge was in the hole? — Not correctly. After inserting their cartridges they use this wooden rod? — Yes. What is the stuff they use for stemming? — Soft sill, a sort of clay. Have you any prickers in the pit? — No. They were not necessary. Have you had any other complaints with reference to the fuses, except those mentioned? — No. Have you had any complaints about the fuse being too thick? — No. Have you tried any yourself? — Yes. It fits very nice. They require very little pressure. A smaller fuse takes more pressure. Deceased was carrying out the general practice of the mine. Was there any other method? — He did not know of another. Witness continuing, said he had known deceased about ten years. He was a very careful workman. There were about forty ambulance men at their pit. Mr. Leck: That is a very good proportion. Mr. Brown: How long have you been using this particular kind of fuse? — Witness: About twelve months. The first complaint you had was last Tuesday week? — No. That was the first complaint within the last fortnight. What complaint had you had before? — On Wednesday, a man had told him about a miss-fire. Mr. Flynn: Do you keep a record of miss-fires? — Witness: Yes. Were you using the same fuses before the flooding? — Yes. With reference to the fuse, is it wrapped with rubber? — Yes. It is Swansea fuse. Are there any instructions in the mine that all miss-fires should be reported? — I had told them to report them. How many times have you had complaints about defective fuse? — About twenty. You have had these fuses about twelve months. It is five months since, the flood. How many reports had you before the flood? — Witness did not know anybody had complained. Mr. Flynn remarked that with regard to stemming, he thought the whole of the regulations had been carried out. Mr. Atter (to witness): Have you had any other accident like this? — They had had an accident before 12 or 13 years ago. The Coroner: There is a danger and risk about miss-fires. Would it not be better in your opinion than an experience man should be the person to inspect fuses? — Witness: Yes. It would be better to do that. Answering Mr. Flynn, witness said black fuse was the best to use. Mr. Kitchin said he had been general manager of the Moss Bay Mines for two years. He spoke of deceased as a careful, reliable, and steady man. In his opinion the cause of the accident was miss-fire, and there was no fault attached to anyone. He called the fuses in because he thought they were defective. He had tested them, but could not find anything. The detonator which had exploded under ordinary conditions, exploded under the black fuse. He had substituted another fuse, which was used in another mine, and where they had had no complaints. He thought it would be safer then the other. The Coroner: A man being out twenty minutes would be justified in going to see the cause? Witness: I put no blame on the men for having done so. Witness saw Byrne at the Infirmary and he said he had always lacked upon the side of being too careful, and that the younger men went into the place, and consequently he went in. They took the wooden rammer with them to see how far it was to the level so that they could insert an additional fuse. He had not inserted the fuse. Byrne was perfectly conscious when he made the statement. Answering Mr. Lavery, witness said if they used an electric battery they would have explosions. It was 25 years since he had had an accident before. Something had been said about the detonator: he would like one tried. A detonator was handed to Mr. Leck, who fitted it to a piece of fuse, and it was found to be a good fit. Mr. Leck: How long have you been using black fuse? — Witness: About twelve months. The fuse they were now using was from a Swansea firm. Mr. Leck: In this particular case to what explosive do you attribute the accident? — The fault was on both sides: the fuse must have hung fire; in this particular case it must have been the fuse. Replying to Mr. Leck, witness said the man who charged the hole should carry out his own duties. He should report a miss-fire, so as to prevent another. He thought the minimum should be 20 minutes. In reply to Mr. Atter, witness said a man would lose by stopping out, and it was an inducement to him to go back. Dr. Middleton, house surgeon at the Infirmary, stated that deceased was brought in at 2.15 p.m., on Monday. He was suffering from injuries about the face, compound fracture of the skull, and destruction of both eye-balls. It was an exceedingly serious case. He was conscious and in good spirits. Death took place on Wednesday at 3.25 p.m. Deceased said it had been a dynamite explosion and blamed no one. In summing up the Coroner expressed pleasure at the way in which the evidence had been given. There was no blame attached to anyone — the deceased, the man Murphy, or any of the workmen. There was no questions, but what this was a pure accident. The jury returned a verdict of "Death from misadventure," the Foreman adding that in case of miss-firing the men should stop out another ten minutes; twenty minutes seemed too short. Mr. Leck: In the new Home Office Quarry Rules they had made it thirty minutes. Expressions of regret were given by Mr. Brown and Mr. Leck, the latter adding that he had personally known the deceased for nearly 25 years. His character was in every way above approach. Mr. Atter said it would be pleasing to the relatives of the deceased to hear these expressions of good feeling for deceased, and Mr. Flynn also expressed his feeling of regret.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||