|
3rd February 1910 Fatal Accident To A Egremont MinerThe InquestSomewhat sad were the circumstances relating to the death of a married man, named John Walker, of 37, South Street, Egremont, who was killed at Winscales Mine, owned by the Beckermet Mining Company, on Monday afternoon, as the result of a fall of roof in the pit. On Tuesday, the inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of the deceased man, was conducted by Mr. G. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury over whom Mr. James Mitchell acted as foreman, at the Police Station, Egremont. Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines attended, and Mr. J. Hope Brown appeared to represent the Mining Company, whilst Mr. T. Gavan Duffy represented the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners and Kindred Trades Association. Also present were Mr. J. Mitchell, secretary to the Mining Company, and Mr. G. Turner, Ponsonby Hall. The first witness was Curwen Walker, residing at 12, Old Bridge, Egremont, brother of the deceased, who gave evidence of identification. He added that the deceased was 29 years of age. Witness saw him alive on Monday about five minutes past six in the morning, when he was at the bottom of the shaft in the pit, and he (deceased) was then lighting a candle to go up the drift. Deceased had worked for the Company three or four years, but he had been a miner 14 years, and knew his work all right. Cross-examined by Mr. Leck; He (deceased) had not been a miner for 14 years, but he meant to say he had worked in a mine during that period. Elias Andrewartha, living at Low Mill, near Egremont, deposed he was a miner, and was employed at Winscales Pit, where he was engaged on Monday. He began work at six a.m., and was engaged with William Proctor and deceased. All were working in the fore breast, and the accident occurred about twenty minutes to one. Witness was boring a hole in the fore breast, Proctor was cutting a hitch for the head tree, and deceased was cutting it on the contrary end. About twenty minutes to one, when he was boring the hole, the first thing he heard was a crash in the wood. He looked around, and saw that John Walker was fast. (Here witness began to sob) Continuing, he said the deceased was fast under a lump of metal, which had fallen from the roof. Witness had previously seen this lump of metal in the roof, but it didn't look at any time likely to fall. They had tried it three or four times, but it would not fall, and it was tried about nine o'clock on the day of the accident, and this was done with the aid of a long bar. Witness could not say what caused the fall. Witness was boring from the roof, but that would not shake the lump at all, and he did not think Proctor, nor Walker would shake it, when cutting the head tree. The metal did not look dangerous, and they worked under it. The hitches were being cut for the head tree for the purpose of protecting the working from the lump. The metal fell about two or three feet from witness, but it touched Proctor's shoulder as it fell. He did not know whether it hurt him or not. The fall did not kill Walker instantly, but he never said anything to witness afterwards, who went to his aid immediately. The metal was not altogether on the top of him, and the heaviest part was off him altogether. He could not say what the weight of the metal would be, but it was quite heavy enough to kill deceased. When witness found out what had happened, he went for assistance and they obtained bars to ease the metal off his body, and eventually this was accomplished, but when got out the deceased was quite dead. Proctor and Walker were preparing to put some protecting wood over this lump, being told to do so by Mr. Hocking, and the work was necessary. Witness had seen the lump exposed (showing) on the Monday, but they did not attempt to get it down on the Friday as it was not bad then, but it had got worse. The miners sounded lumps with a hammer, and if it sounded hollow it came away. The metal in question did not sound in any way hollow on the Monday morning. By the Foreman: The sides of the working consisted of conglomerate, and they were getting the hitches for the conglomerate to put the head tree up. If it had been five or ten minutes later they would have had the head tree in. They were using every care. By Mr. Leck: Both Mr. Hocking and Mr. Booth were in the mine on the morning of the accident about 9.30. Whilst they were in the working there was no conversation about the roof as witness knew of. When they were in Proctor was working at the roof on the fore breast, but not at the lump that came down. They had been dressing down the piece of metal. If the work had gone on in the ordinary way, and no accident had happened, witness would have timbered it up. They, (the three men) were going on with that work, and in five or ten minutes they would have had the timber up, as it was all ready. There had been one hole fired that morning, by John Walker, to make a hitch. Deceased was working on the left hand side. The light side of the pit consisted of conglomerate, and the right side of a mixture of ore and stone. The working was about 12ft high, and was about the same in width. The head tree would be about 8ft from the working face, and it was a solid working, yet apparently they had timbered it. The men were making ready the head tree for the second shiftsmen to put in. Two shiftsmen were working in the mine, and there was a "gaffer" came in every shift. Cross-examined by Mr. Brown: They were going to timber the lump as was usual. They thought the roof was safe enough until they got a head tree. By Mr. Leck: There were no legs under the two last head trees on either side. The practice was that when they put a head tree in, they legged it also. By Mr. Duffy: They tested the roof with a hammer or bar, and Mr. Proctor used the bar. He did not think it likely that Proctor, in using the bar, might loosen the lump. There were two head trees without legs, but that was not because they were without timber, as they had plenty. Mr. Hocking was not only a practical man in the mine, but also a careful man. If they had got the head tree in the accident would have been averted. Mr. Dixon, mining engineer, submitted a plan of the mine, which he said was a correct one. Considering the nature of the working, he thought the timber had been carried forward enough at that time. Wm. Proctor, miner, residing at 10, Church Street, Egremont, employed at Winscales, stated that he commenced work at the pit at six o'clock, and came off at two o'clock. He was employed with deceased and Andrewartha. Witness and deceased were both on a staging cutting hitches for a head tree, and without warning the lump of ore came out of the roof and fell on Walker. It appears that the deceased had heard the crack in the roof, and had jumped from the stage to the ground, a distance of about 4ft., but whilst trying to escape the lump had caught him on the back. They only heard one crack. Witness did not see whether the fall knocked him off or whether he jumped off the stage. The metal when falling broke the stage down with its weight. He (witness) could not say whether part of the stage was underneath Walker or on top of him, as they could not see for the lump of ore which was lying on deceased, who was lying face downwards. They had sounded the roof and dressed it down, and it was satisfactory and safe to work under. They were cutting the hitches with the hammer and "moil," but witness did not think that that would tend to shake the roof, as both sides of the mine were solid. He could not account as to what caused the metal to fall. They were making the timber ready with the object of putting in to keep the place safe from anything that might fall from the roof. The deceased was killed instantly. By the Foreman: They were all satisfied that the place was quite safe, after dressing it down, for working in. The lump did not sound bad, but it was too big a piece of metal for anybody to sound. Cross-examined by Mr. Leck: Hocking had told them to get ready, and get the wood in as soon as they could. There was a "gaffer" visited the mine every shift for the purpose of inspection. When the accident happened they were not left in the dark. Witness had been in the place since the day of the accident, but soon after the fall they sounded the remaining roof of metal, and appeared then to be sound. Replying to Mr. Gavan Duffy, witness said there were two head trees without legs. That was simply because they could not get them in, but he did not think they were required, seeing the sides were all good. By Mr. Leck: The timber was packed up to the roof, as far as they could see. He was last working on a shift on Friday. Edward Hocking, underground manager at Winscales Pit, stated that on the morning of the accident he went down the mine into the working where Walker was killed. Andrewartha, Proctor and deceased were in the working, and they were dressing the roof. The roof did not look to bad, and when tested it sounded "drummy." Nothing could be done to avert the accident. There was nothing in the roof to show that it was likely to give way. He told the men to get the wood in as soon as they possible could. The roof required timbering, and those men worked there to carry out that work. By Mr. Leck: He repeated that nothing could be done to prevent the accident. Had he known at the time that the place was really as dangerous as it was when he saw it after the accident, he would have told the men to have blasted it down. But he did not think it was dangerous. They could not have blasted down the piece of bad roof without risk. There would have been some risk. It looked quite safe, and would stand until the men got the timber ready. He believed there were two head trees without legs. He was quite clear that a head tree had not broken. He could not give any reason for the fall except that it came from the conglomerate. The working was practically dry. He (witness) was in practice of going through the working in the morning, and other managers went through on the afternoon and night shift. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: He took exceptionally good care that there was plenty of timber. The place was sounded while witness was down, and he was perfectly satisfied that it was safe, and he would have worked there himself. The Coroner, summing up, said the circumstances of the accident were particularly clear, and he did not want to waste their time by summing up at any length, but in all of these occupations, and especially that of a miner, there was a large number of risks to be run. A lot of precautions had to be taken, but everything cannot be foreseen, and there were those risks to be run. The evidence pointed to the fact that no one could have foreseen that this piece of roof would have come down, and after hearing the evidence he thought there was no blame attached to any person. Under the circumstances they (the jury) should bring in a verdict that the man was accidentally killed by a fall of roof. There was no evidence of negligence. The jury agreed with the Coroner's suggestion as to their verdict. Mr. J. Hope Brown said, on behalf of the Company he represented, he expressed their extreme regret at this accident, and tendered their sympathy to the widow. Deceased, he said, was a good, faithful, and steady workman, and his loss was with great regret. The Coroner said this would be conveyed to the widow.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||