|
6th January 1910 Fatality In An Egremont MineMiners Shocking DeathOn Thursday morning last a shocking and somewhat singular accident which unfortunately had a fatal termination occurred at one of the mines owned by the Millom and Askam Iron Co., known as Ullbank, situate at Egremont. The victim was a married man named Arthur Richards, aged 54 years, who resided with his wife and family of two daughters and one son at 1, John Street, Moor Row. The unfortunate miner met his death under most distressing circumstances, as from the particulars ascertained it appears that the deceased was following his employment at the bottom of the pit, and was in the act of wheeling a bogie along a stage in Ullbank Pit, when by some means or other, at present unexplainable, the staging collapsed, and deceased was precipitated to the ground below, a distance of about fifteen feet. With the collapsing of the staging, it is surmised that the pit props which supported the roof were slackened, and immediately the stage gave way so also did a portion of the roof and the debris of metal, stone, & etc, fell and completely buried the deceased. The affair was soon brought to the notice of the manager, and without delay the work of removing the earth commenced, and in a few minutes the deceased was extricated from beneath the debris, but all was in vain as life was extinct. The affair cast a gloom over the employees, as all held deceased in high esteem for he was a most courteous and good workman. Deceased was Cornishman by birth, but for some years he resided at Dalton-in-Furness, and came to West Cumberland six years ago. He was a very active member of the Primitive Methodist Church, serving as a local preacher in that denomination, being well-known for his most efficient services in that capacity throughout the district. Inquest The inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of the above was opened on Friday afternoon at the Reading Room, Moor Row, conducted by Mr. W. T. Highet, deputy coroner to Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury over whom Mr. James Mitchell acted as foreman. Mr. A. Lawrence, solicitor, Millom, represented the Millom and Askam Iron Company, and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy appeared on behalf of the relatives. After formal evidence of identification had been given by Arthur Wilfrid Richards, the inquiry was adjourned until Tuesday. Mr. Gavan Duffy said he wanted to know whether the managers of the Company would allow them to inspect the staging where the accident took place. Mr. Lawrence replied that he did not think there would be an objection on the part of the managers. The Deputy Coroner said Mr. Duffy would have to make an application to them, as it was out of his jurisdiction to say. The Funeral The remains of the deceased were interred at Egremont cemetery on Sunday last. The body was taken to the Primitive Methodist Church, where an impressive funeral service was conducted by the Rev. W. Bowe, of Whitehaven, assisted by the Rev. F. Stoddard, of Cleator Moor. Mr. Bowe delivered a brief and effective appreciation of the deceased's character and service, especially in connection with that place of worship, and expressive of the deepest sympathy of all with the widow and family. On leaving the church the cortege proceeded to Egremont, being headed by the officials of the Iron Ore and Kindred Trades Association, represented by Mr. T. Gavan Duffy and other gentlemen. The members of this Association also forwarded a beautiful wreath and glass shade. At Egremont the Rev. W. Bowe also officiated. There was a very large attendance of sympathisers. The mourning coaches and hearse were supplied by Mr. Jas. Mitchell, of Egremont. The services at the Primitive Methodist Church, Moor Row, on Sunday morning and evening, were of a sympathetic character, the preacher planned for the day, Mr. J. Jenkinson, Whitehaven, making special reference at the morning service to Mr. Richard's life and character, and their great regret as a church at his sudden death. Deceased had been a local preacher for 33 years, and was never known to have missed an appointment. The Adjourned Inquest The adjourned inquiry touching the death of the above was conducted by Mr. W. T. Highet. The Millom and Askam Iron Co, owners of Ullbank Mine, were represented by Mr. T. Lawrence, of Millom; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy appeared on behalf of the relatives; and Messers. W. E. Walker and R. Hartley, mining engineers, and Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines, were also in attendance. At the outset, Mr. Lawrence said on behalf of the Company he desired to express his deepest sympathy with the relatives in their loss through the unfortunate accident. Mr. Richard Hartley, mining engineer, produced the plan and section of the working in the pit, previous to the accident, and after the accident, which he pointed out. The first witness called was Joseph Greaves, manager at Ullbank Mine, and who resides at Gillbank, Egremont. He stated that he was acquainted with the deceased, and knew him very well. He was a very capable workman, and a man of great experience. On Thursday, the 30th December, he received information that something had happened in the mine about quarter to eleven, and witness entered the pit at once and helped to get him out. The man was employed at the time of the accident getting ore, and taking it along a staging into a hurry. A man named Luke Murphy was engaged with him. When witness went down the mine he discovered that the staging had collapsed, and the deceased had fallen with the staging, and the bogie he was wheeling. A considerable quantity of debris also fell on to the deceased. When witness arrived on the scene Richards was buried beneath the timber and the debris. The bogie deceased was pushing would contain about 8½ cwts. of ore. The debris was removed in about fifteen minutes and deceased was recovered, but life was extinct. Witness noticed deceased had a scalp wound, and he got hold of his head and rocked it about, and he concluded that the man's neck was broken, and he felt his pulse, but his heart was not beating. The miners commenced work at seven o'clock, but witness had not been down the pit that morning, and he had never inspected the staging that morning, and he had never received a report about the stage that morning. As far as witness knew the stage was in good order the previous day, and nothing had moved, as he could see as would cause any suspicion on his part that the stage would fall. The stage had been repaired on several occasions, and he (witness) thought the deceased would do some repairing to it the week previous to the accident. There had been a fall of earth the previous afternoon. The fall may have thrown some ore down, causing the timber to crack, and practically that was the cause of the collapse. The fall would throw a greater strain on the cross-trees. Another theory witness had was that the fall on the previous day a great amount of weight was put on the timber, and the wood would not be sufficient to support the weight, with the result that it gave way. He had inspected the timber since and did not find anything out of the ordinary. Mr. Leck: The last time he saw that particular place was about half-past one the previous day. He was going to inspect the working half an hour after the accident. There was an inspection of the working every day. Witness had assistants who inspected. Their names were Henry Burns and Wm Ainsworth. Neither of these men attended to the stage on the date in question, as they were at work. The longitudes were resting on limestone, and the sets were composed of limestone. The straights were larch head trees. These run on an average to a size of six feet. One theory of his was that a slice of ore may have fallen off one side, and smashed the timber. The wood was broken about 18 inches from the end. He had examined the wood and found it to be in good condition. Witness had a conversation with the deceased on the previous day about the working. Deceased told witness they had blasted and knocked a fork out, and he asked Greaves if they should fill up with ore. Witness said certainly if he thought they were safe. They could fill it up providing they were safe. At the time of the accident a man named Luke Murphy was working with Richards on the same gangway. He examined the tree when it was brought up the pit, and it was sound, with the exception that it was broken. New headtrees had been put in. The men themselves repaired the stage. Legs would have been of no advantage, if they were right up against the ground, but if they had been 18 inches from the place where it broke it would have helped to support it. The miners had access to get wood for repairing in any part of the yard. It was the regular custom for men to take their own timber down in the working. The Coroner: You have been talking about using legs or forks. When do you use legs and in what way? What leads you to decide whether to use them? Witness: The nature of the hitches they had to find whether they were fit or not to support the roof, and then they used legs. If they had a solid foundation they need they hitches. Witness had never had a fatal accident at the mine during the eight years he had been at Ullbank. And had been a foreman for eleven years. By Mr. Leck :— He never had a fatal accident under his supervision. Answering Mr. Duffy :— Witness said the gantry was put up perhaps five years ago, and it was last repaired a week previous to the accident by the deceased. He (witness) inspected it after it was done. Mr. Duffy: Are you sure about that? Witness: Yes Mr. Lawrence: He has answered it. Mr. Duffy: Because I have an allegation that Mr. Greaves has not been near the placed for a month. Answering further, witness said he did inspect the staging after it was repaired a week previous. He had never had any complaint about the wood used for the gantry being rotten, from the deceased. Mr. Walker asked to be excused for interrupting, but he did not think the word rotten had been used. That was the first time the word had been mentioned. Mr. Duffy asked how it came about that the place where the accident occurred was omitted being inspected on this particular day? Witness replied that he hadn't time to make an inspection, as there had only been a 3½ hours' shift. Luke Murphy, miner, living at 26 South-street, Egremont, said he was employed at Ullbank Mine. On the 30th December he was engaged working with the deceased, filling metal into hurries. Twelve bogies of metal were taken over the staging on the morning of the accident, and there was about ten cwt. in a load. He did not inspect the staging that morning, but his mate (deceased) did. Richards said it was all right. When the deceased was bringing the 13th load over the staging, witness was on another part of the stage, and deceased was in front of him, and when crossing with the bogie everything collapsed. He could not say what had happened to the deceased, but he heard him moaning down below. The bogie fell with the deceased, also a quantity of debris & c. Witness assisted to extricate the deceased. By Mr. Leck: Witness had taken eight of twelve bogies across the stage. When the smash came and the deceased fell, his light did not go out. Witness alighted from the stage by means of a ladder. In his opinion the weight of the fall the previous day, which might have fallen on to the wood, was the cause of the staging collapsing. Witness thought the stage was quite safe. Witness had a very narrow escape himself. Mr. Leck asked what was the position of the cross-bar and the headtree? Mr. Greaves said he might tell them that it was resting right over the head-tree. Answering further questions put to him by Mr. Duffy, Murphy said he was sure deceased had no conversation with the manager about going to work in that place. The repairers were all the miners. He was quite certain that the timber on the gantry on that morning was sound and good. Mr. Duffy: The theory of yours about timber coincides with the theory of Mr. Greaves. Have you talked the matter over with Mr. Greaves? Murphy: No. Never say him? No. Jas. Henry Harvey, miner, of 12, Bookwell, Egremont, also gave evidence, and stated that he had worked across the stage scores of times during the past month. The wood was as sound as a bell. It was seasoned, as good as larch. The Deputy Coroner, in his summing up, said they had heard evidence, which had been given exceedingly well and impartial, and the questions put to the witnesses by Mr. Leck no doubt had assisted them a great deal. Well, as they knew, accidents would happen, and happen very often in spite of the care and precaution taken, and probably they would agree that this was one of those unfortunate cases. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||