|
1st April 1909 Fatality To An Egremont MinerMan Crushed To DeathA shocking accident, which had a fatal termination, occurred on Monday evening at the Wyndham Mining Co's., Helder Pit, at Orgill, Egremont. The person who unfortunately lost his life was a man named George Coles, aged 36, single man, who resided with his married sister at 15, Smithfield, Egremont. The man was really employed as a sinker at the above mine, but it appears that proceeding the time of the accident he was employed doing some banking for another man, and consequently on that account he did not go down the pit when the other men went under. It was about 8.15 p.m. that the deceased got into a water vat, which is used in sinking operations and which was fixed beneath a skeleton cage. The warning was given for the engineman to lower with its passenger, but when the vat reached about 100 fathoms down the pit, without any warning, and some means or other unexplainable it got wedged. Just at this time when Coles was fastened in like a rat in a trap, and could do nothing in any way to escape, the skeleton cage descended. A few moments later a young man named William Sewell, who was engaged in looking after the pumps close to where the vat was wedged, heard a shout, and going to the place from where the sound came from, he found Coles lying with his back across the vat or bucket, with the skeleton cage resting on his chest. Sewell spoke to the man, but he received no reply, and he then gave the alarm for the cage to be raised. The deceased was extricated at the top, and Thomas Brocklebank, banker, asked him if the vat had got to swinging on him, and he replied, "I don't know, Tom." Dr. Braithwaite was immediately called, but despite the medical man's treatment, Coles expired about 11.30 p.m., after much suffering and agony. The deceased was a respectable man, being a good worker, and was highly esteemed by all his fellow workmates. The Inquest. The inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of the above person was conducted by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury, of which Mr. Ewart was foreman, at the Police Office, Egremont, on Wednesday afternoon. Those present included Mr. W. Leck, H.M.I. of Mines, Cleator Moor; Mr. J. B. Adair, engineer for the Wyndham Mining Co.; and Mr. Ormrod, from the offices of Messers. Brockbank, Helder, and Ormrod, who represented the firm. The first witness called, Joseph Jackson, of Smithfield, Egremont, gave evidence of identification. He said the deceased was a sinker at Helder Pit. He last saw him alive about 11.30 on Monday evening. Prior to that he saw him on the pit top, and he was then all right. He was just beginning to do some banking. Witness, when he saw the deceased, was going down the pit, with another man. Seven men were working with the men. Three went down at two o'clock, and others went down later. The deceased was last to go down. The first three went below on the kibble, and the next three on the vat. Witness did not know how deceased got down. He (witness) had no difficulty in getting down. The reason why they went down on the vat was because the kibble was under and the vat was on the top. They generally went down in a kibble. It was his suggestion that the kibble was kept down while the water was got out. He could not say whether the vat was a proper thing to go down in, but it had never stuck before. Witness and the majority of the other miners would rather go down in the kibble. He received his instruction from Mr. Kitchin, the manager. Six men were down the pit, and he knew his brother-in-law (deceased) was going to go down. The men below thought they heard something like bumping in the shaft, so they waited for the vat to go down for more water, but it did not come, and he asked one of the pumpsmen to look and see whether the vat was swinging in the shaft. Shortly afterwards an oily cap dropped down the pit, and someone said it was Coles's. He (witness) did not know anything had happened until the vat was sent down for them and two men along with him went up in it. Witness got to the top and the banker told him that a bad job had occurred, and later Jackson saw the deceased in the engine-house. He was being attended to by a doctor, and witness asked him what was up and he replied the skeleton had nipped him. The deceased told him he was hurt on the left side, but did not complain about his head. He was removed home, and although he was conscious all the time he died at 11.30 p.m., the same night. Deceased did not tell him how the accident happened. The men sometimes went down the shaft in the vat, but not always. They generally went down on the kibble. By Mr. Leck: Witness did not know how the accident happened, but he had been told. When the men were changing the shifts they rode in the kibble, but when the men were working they would take the first thing on the hook when they wanted to go down. He could not say that they had had instructions from the "gaffer" that they had to ride on the kibble. He did not think there was anything wrong in riding in the bucket in preference to the kibble. No officials had found fault with the men about riding in the vat. Mr. Kitchin had been manager there for three months, but neither the present manager or past managers had found fault with them for going down on the vat. When the accident happened the kibble was at the bottom. The men preferred riding on the kibble, but as a matter of fact they used the kibble for changing the shift, but any other time they used anything that was on the rope. A plan of the shaft was produced, and witness was questioned on it. When he (witness) went down in the vat he always kept as close as he could to the chain. Mr. J. B. Adair then described the plan and working of the shaft to the jury. He added that the skeleton cage was a frame used to guide the vat or kibble down the shaft. There was no projection into the shaft from the lodge. Probably the vat caught on the lodge and canted over, and immediately the vat stopped the skeleton cage would come down. The weight of the skeleton was 8¼ cwts. The rule was to go down on the kibble, but as far as he knew they had been riding on the vat. There was no rule that, but there were instructions. If the managers saw anything being carried out that was dangerous they would have had it stopped. The kibble was the recognised thing for conveying men down a sinking shaft. By Mr. Leck: The object of the skeleton cage was used to keep the vat from swinging, especially when it got a good way down. It would be possible for a similar accident to occur with the kibble, and if it caught, the occupant would be thrown down the shaft. Mr. Leck: The sole object of the skeleton was to keep the kibble in the centre of the shaft and prevent oscillation. Especially in deep pits he (Mr. Leck) always liked to see skeleton cages used, but some people did not like them. Tom Brocklebank, 8, Smithfield, banker at the pit, stated that when he went to the pit top about 7.0 p.m., he found that the gas had tailed them all round. He sent a man down to tell the men below to come up, but during the time they were coming up the gas had got all right. He got Coles to take his place banking while he took the water out of the gas pipes. When he (witness) had finished he released Coles, and just then a vat of water came up, and deceased said he would go down with it. Deceased got on the vat, and witness gave the engineman the signal to let the vat down. It would only take the vat a few minutes to go down, but probably in that time a man would get uneasy sitting in the vat. Witness had occasionally rode on the vat, but the men pleased themselves what they went down in. There was no danger on the vat if the occupant sat still, but if they moved about it would begin to swing. He was on the top of the pit when deceased was brought up, and he asked him if the vat had got to swinging. He replied "I don't know, Tom; its done me. I am lamed across here," putting his hand up to his breast. By Mr. Leck: Instructions were given against riding on the vat. That was when they began sinking the pit. John Tidyman, engineman, residing at 11, Bookwell, Egremont, deposed that on Monday evening he saw the deceased get on to the vat, and witness got a signal to let it down the pit. He let it down steadily, and when it had got about 100 fathoms down the engine began to get light and stopped. He lowered a little to make sure that he had the weight, but subsequently he drew it a little back again. He thought the skeleton had caught the vat or kibble. He had known the vat to catch before, but no one was on then. He drew the cage back again and he got the weight and then lowered, and he waited to receive a signal. He received the signal four, which meant lift slowly. He noticed when he drew the cage up there was a man lying in the vat. By Mr. Leck: Witness had known the kibble to catch when they had been drawing stuff, but they drew very much quicker that as if they were lowering men. William Sewell, living at North-road, Egremont, and who was employed on a Cameron pump at the shaft, said he was at the lodge at 8.30 on Monday night, when he heard a scream and he went to see what was to do, and he saw the vat was wedged in the shaft. Coles was lying across the bucker, and the skeleton cage was resting on his chest. Witness spoke to deceased two or three times, but he did not replay as he was unconscious. The man was drawn to the top, and witness went for a doctor. The bottom of the vat had caught on the side of the pump lodge, and the vat was jammed across the shaft. By Mr. Leck: There was no projection from the lodge. He was working at the pumps, and that accounted for his presence at this particular spot. Mr. Joseph Kitchin, manager of the Oregill Pit, said the only theory he could give of the cause of the accident was that the man had altered his position whilst in the vat, and that would cause it to tilt over. If the man got so away steady and kept in the position he did not see that there would be any danger. He had never known the vat to catch before, and if such had occurred he would have investigated the matter and prevented a repetition. Mr. Leck said when he went down the pit that morning their relative positions in the kibble never altered, and there was not the slightest oscillation. By Mr. Leck: Witness had never had any cause to stop the men from going down the shaft in the vat, as he had never seen any men riding in it. The Coroner, in summing up, said it had been the result of a pure accident, and the man had got crushed, and died from the result of being crushed. The method in this pit of taking men down was the method used in all other sinking pits with improvements. Mining was a dangerous occupation, and all miners run risks, and every man should be very careful and so not run risks. He thought they could not find that there was any negligence in this case. The jury returned a verdict that the deceased was accidentally killed, and they recommended that the men should not be allowed in future to ride on the vat. They should always ride on the kibble. Mr. Ormrod promised to convey this to the managers.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||