13th January 1909
Reviews Of Technical Books
Colliery Machinery*
This is the most ambitious and comprehensive compilation dealing with the mechanical engineering side of coal mining that has appeared since the publication, in the year 1882, of the late Mr. C. M. Percy‘s well-known work of the same name.
Although the latter treatise did undoubtedly awaken interest in the subject and contribute to a wider knowledge of colliery engineering plant, the author of the volumes under review is hardly warranted in stating in his introduction that "about the
time the late Mr. C. M. Percy first published his articles . . . in the Colliery Guardian, improvements began to be effected" as though it were for the first time. Improvements in the mechanical engineering of collieries began to be
effected long before the period named. It would be a mistake to suppose that invention and development had remained stagnant in respect to the equipment of collieries (when so brisk in other engineering industries), say from the great expansion in the
railway system in the early forties up to the date of issue of Percy's work in 1882.
In Volume I. of Mr. Futer‘s treatise boring, shaft sinking, headgears and heapsteads, winding, and the screening and washing of coal are discussed, whilst in Volume II. haulage, pumping, generation and transmission of power, coke ovens,
ventilating fans, coal cutters and conveyors are treated in greater or less detail ; all the subjects named in the two volumes being, of course, regarded chiefly from the point of view of the mechanical engineer, and nowadays to be an efficient mining
engineer one has also to be a good mechanical engineer.
The first chapter, that on boring, is largely devoted to a description of diamond drills, the only other vertical boring appliances discussed being Mather and Platt's and ordinary hand boring with rods. Now, although the diamond drill is one of the most
efficient of boring machines, it is to be regretted that some attention has not been directed to Continental practice, when the Raky, Fauck, and some other methods of boring have achieved such remarkable results, especially in Germany and Austria. Notice
should also have been taken of the American rope drill, the calyx drill, and boring with chilled steel shot, which methods have of late years been largely and successfully applied in the United Kingdom. The chapter would also have been of greater value
had it been supplemented with information relative to the price of boring plants and the rates and costs of boring through various strata with different plants, so that the engineer might be enabled to form some opinion as to the comparative value of the
respective appliances.
Turning to the operation of shaft sinking, the author is chiefly concerned with such items as temporary arrangements at the surface, sinking platforms, rock drills, and the extraction of the water. Somewhat undue prominence is given to Walker's patent
walling scaffold and sinking frame, the text being illustrated by as many as eleven figures representative of this appliance. The description of sinking pumps is distinctly the best part of the chapter, and might be studied with advantage by those
engaged in carrying out "wet" sinkings. Curiously enough, however, though electrically driven reciprocating pumps are mentioned under the head there does not appear to be any allusion to electric high lift centrifugal pumps, which have
performed such good work in some recent sinkings.
Those about to lay out the surface works of new or rearrange the heapsteads of old collieries should read Chapter IV. dealing with headgears. It is one of the best in the work. The various important questions which have to be discussed and weighed one
against the other before coming to a decision respecting the type to be adopted and dimensions of cages and general shaft equipment are well and clearly considered.
The author adheres to the old formula for determining the breaking strain — C²x1.4 — in tons for guide ropes (presumably of steel, though he does not say so), but do mining engineers and others really place much reliance in this formula
? The question of the breaking strain of steel ropes is one worthy of further investigation. On the same page the author says :— "As guide ropes have practically little or nothing to do, they may be loaded up to one-third of their breaking
strain, the load, of course, including the weight of the rope itself" — a statement which it would have been well to have supported with detailed information relating to actual cases. Guide ropes certainly are, in a sense, inactive, but are
subjected to considerable strains and much wear and tear.
It would have added to the interest of the author's remarks on headgear pulleys had he given us the benefit of his opinion relative to the merits of the cast as opposed to the built-up type. The former are difficult to obtain of large diameter, and the
latter are, it is stated, prone to shake loose owing to the vibration induced by the winding rope. The information given under "winding" is very good, and the author seems more at home with his subject when describing plants with which he has
had what appears to have been actual first-hand acquaintance. He has himself patented an ingenious speed controlling device possessing considerable merits, which is likely to be extensively used. Whilst giving this mood of praise it must be remarked that
the capping of ropes is inadequately treated. Considering the importance of the subject it would have been well if the several kinds of capels in use at collieries had been described, illustrated, and their relative merits compared.
In dealing with the subject of haulage several kinds of tubs are illustrated and described, but the largest type in use, the tram of the South Wales collieries, is omitted. No mention is made of self-acting curves for "endless rope" haulage, or
as to relative heights of inner and outer rails on curves in "main and tail" rope haulage, nor of the arrangement of sheaves at branch roads with endless rope.
The information relating to pumping is very full, and it might have been added "complete" but that the Reidler pump is worthy of more notice, marking, as it does, an epoch in the history of pumping appliances and in the use of compressed air.
Compressed air is and has for long been used to a far greater extent than the author appears to realize. He says on page 683 :— "Compressed air has long been used for the transmission of power, but it is only within recent years, with the
introduction of stage compressing, that the efficiency has been such as to warrant its adoption to any considerable extent. For many years 40 per cent. efficiency was regarded as the maximum that could be obtained, but with the introduction of
multi-stage compressors the efficiency has been raised until it approaches that of electricity, though it will probably never be equal to it." For two reasons compressed air will in all probability hold its own with electricity as a means of
transmitting power underground in collieries. The use of electricity in fiery (gassy) coal mines is accompanied by dangers due to sparking, and secondly, compressed air is easier to deal with. The present writer can recall, in the latter connexion, an
instance which occurred within the last decade where, at a non-fiery colliery, the general manager replaced electricity with compressed air for the purpose of driving coal-cutting machinery, as he found the latter so much easier to handle. For the same
reason also the great majority of percussion rock-drills are actuated by compressed air ; a really efficient percussive rock-drill — one easily handled, and which will withstand the rough usage that rock-drills are subjected to — has yet to
be constructed.
The chapter on ventilating fans is somewhat weak. The author says that "generally the question of measuring the air is a very controversial one," but the question is generally considered to have been removed from the controversial stage. He
adds, "The theory of the fan is very complex, and so far independent investigators have published results and designed formulae — which would be quite inapplicable to some other types, and without some standard regulations to be observed in
carrying out comparative tests upon fans no reliance can be placed upon results." But if Mr. Futers will refer to the £Transactions of the Institution of Civil Engineers," vol. lxvi., pp. 266-277, the "Bulletin de la
Société de l'Industrie minérale, vol. ix., 1880, pp.5-101, and the "Transactions of the Institution of Mining Engineers," vol. xxi., pp. 369-370, he will be able to satisfy his mind on the subject. He will then find that the
formula T=v² d
g is only applicable, as M. Murgue has shown, to ventilators the blades of which are radial, and that when the blades are inclined backwards the theoretical water gauge contains a negative expression, and is only equal to T=v² d -vv2 Cos ad.
where v2 is the relative velocity of the air upon
g g
the blade and a the inclination of the blade.
Hence the reason for certain ventilators being credited with abnormal efficiencies. If the author will apply to the construction of fans the formulae on which the design of the most approved modern high lift centrifugal pumps are based, he will probably
produce a ventilator superior to many of those at present in operation.
It has been deemed well to draw attention to the comparatively few errors contained in these volumes — errors of omission rather than of commission — because the work fulfils a distinct want in the mining world and is likely to be widely read
and consulted, constituting, as it does, a useful manual for the guidance of mining engineers in the selection of plant for colliery purposes. No doubt a second edition, which should be required before long, will rectify the omissions to which we have
directed our criticism.
The text is illustrated by 1,649 figures, many of which, if enlarged, could be used for working drawing, as accurate dimensions are given. In fact, so clear and useful are the illustrations in the majority of instances that it could be desired that they
had all been of equal merit, and that the occasional use of blocks, evidently drawn from trade catalogues, had been dispensed with. The author's English is not always above suspicion. The use of the expression "down over," in the chapter on
boring, used evidently in contradistinction to "up over," may be good Tyneside, but it is bad English.
* "The Mechanical Engineering of Collieries." By T. Campbell Futers. 10x7¼, vii.+783 pp. (The Colliery Guardian, Chichester Press, London.) Vol. i. 21s. Vol. ii. 10s. 6d.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Futers, T. Campbell | | | |
| Percy, C. M. | | | |