14th December 1908
Law Report
House of Lords
(Before the Lord Chancellor, the Earl of Halsbury, Lord Macnaghten, Lord James of Hereford, and Lord Dunedin.)
Dyson v. Forster and Others — The Same v. Seed and Others — The Same v. Quinn and Others — The Same v. Morgan and Others.
Colliery — Compensation for Subsidence — Covenant.
Their Lordships delivered judgement this week in these consolidated appeals from orders of the Court of Appeal (the Master of the Rolls and Lords Justices Moulton and Farwell), dated January 23, 1908, which affirmed a decision of Mr. Justice Ridley dated
June 28, 1907, by which damages were awarded to the several respondents. The Elvet Colliery Company were the defendants in the action, and the hearing in the Court of Appeal is reported 24 The Times Law Reports, 205 ; L.R. (1908), 1 K.B., 629 ; 77
L.J., K.B., 521. The plaintiffs' claim in the several actions was for an injunction or compensation for subsidence in the circumstances stated in Lord Macnaghten's judgement. Their Lordships reserved judgement on June 29 last.
Mr. Tindal Atkinson, K.C., and Mr. J. A. Compston appeared for the appellants in the appeals ; Mr. Scott Fox, K.C., and Mr. Simey were for the respondents in the first appeal ; and Mr. Manisty, K.C., and Mr. Meynell for the other respondents.
The appeal was dismissed.
The Lord Chancellor. — I have had the advantage of reading in print the judgement of my noble and learned friend Lord Macnaghten, and have nothing to add.
Lord Macnaghten. — In 1871 the predecessors in title of the Ecclesiastical Commissioners for England conveyed to one Forster in fee simple certain lands in the county of Durham, reserving all mines with power to work the minerals from below, making
reasonable compensation for such damage as might be occasioned to the surface. In 1887 the Ecclesiastical Commissioners demised to one Crawford seams of coal and other minerals under the lands conveyed to Forster, and under adjoining lands. The lease
contained a covenant on the part of the lessee expressed to be made with the "owner or owners, occupier or occupiers for the time being" of the surface to pay compensation for all damage occasioned by the lessee in working the mines or seams of
coal thereby dismissed. In 1896 Crawford's lease was assigned to a company called the Elvet Colliery Company (Limited), which is now in liquidation. It is admitted that the mines have been worked so as to occasion damage to the surface of the lands
conveyed to Forster. This action has been brought to recover compensation. The plaintiffs are devisees of Forster and his successors in title. The substantial defendants are the legal personal representatives of Crawford, who died in November, 1900. The
defence is twofold. In the first place the defendants say that Forster's assigns cannot take advantage of the covenant because the surface owners were not parties to the indenture in which the covenant is contained. Secondly, they say that the covenant
does not run with the land and that, therefore, Forster's assigns could not have had the benefit of the covenant even if Forster himself had been named a party to the indenture. The Court of Appeal rejected both defences. In my opinion they were right.
The first objection is, I think, answered by section 5 of 8 and 9 Victoria, Chap. 106. That section enacts that a stranger may take the benefit of a covenant respecting any tenements and hereditaments, although the taker be not named a party to the
indenture. The Court of Appeal held that the provision only applied to covenants running with the land. They held, however, that this covenant did run with the land, and so was within the section. Whether the section must be confined to covenants running
with the land may, perhaps, be doubted. The point, however, is not, I think, material in the present case, because I agree with the court of Appeal in thinking that the covenant in question is one which runs with the land. The question is, Does this
covenant affect the nature, quality, or value of the land, or is it a covenant simply collateral ? It is not, I think, simply collateral, for one reason which is sometimes proposed as a test for the purpose of determining whether a covenant runs with the
land or not. It is beneficial to the surface owner and beneficial to no one else [see "Vyvyan v. Arthur" (1 B. and C., per Best, J., 417)]. I think it affects the nature and also the value of the land. I think it affects the nature of the land
because it tends to prevent disturbance of the surface, and so it tends to preserve the natural state and condition of the land. A person who has agreed to pay compensation to his neighbour for injuriously affecting his land is more likely to be careful
to avoid mischief than one who is not answerable for the consequences of his act. I also think that the covenant affects the value of the land in respect of which it was given. Suppose the land being properly drained were to be let for agricultural
purposes, a tenant, I should suppose, would be more likely to take it and would probably give more for it if he were assured that compensation would be payable in the event of the drainage system being dislocated by subsidence. Similar considerations
would apply if the land were to be let for building purposes. I am, therefore, of opinion that the decision of the Court of Appeal should be upheld, and the appeal dismissed with costs. The same question is involved in other cases which were set down
with the case of "Dyson v. Forster," and the same result must follow.
The Lord Chancellor said that Lord Halsbury and Lord James concurred with the judgement ; and Lord Dunedin briefly expressed his agreement.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atkinson, Tindall | | K.C. | |
| Compston, J. A. | | Solicitor | |
| Dunedin, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Dyson, — | | | |
| Farwell, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Fox, Scott | | K.C. | |
| Halsbury, Earl of | | Justice | |
| James, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Macnaughten, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Mainsty, — | | K.C. | |
| Meynell, — | | Solicitor | |
| Morgan, — | | | |
| Moulton, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Quinn, — | | | |
| Ridley, — | | Justice | |
| Seed, — | | | |
| Simey, — | | Solicitor | |