|
5th November 1908 The Prosecution Of Workmen By Whitehaven Colliery CompanyThe Cases WithdrawnAt the Whitehaven Police-court on Monday, before R. Jefferson (in the chair), W. H. Watson, and H. Kitchin Esqs., the hearing was resumed of the charge against John Winter Wilson, wagon weighman, George Street, and Thomas Mitchell, locomotive driver, Queen Street, Whitehaven, "that between July 13, 1907 and July 6, 1908, they did unlawfully conspire, combine, confederate, and agree to feloniously steal diverse sums of money, amounting to £7 6s 10d, from the Whitehaven Colliery Company," and Wilson and Wm., Fleeton locomotive driver, West Strand, Whitehaven, were also charged with conspiring to steal diverse sums of money amounting to £4 7s 7d, from the Whitehaven Colliery Company, between April 13, 1907 and April 13, 1908. Mr. W. H. Chapman prosecuted on behalf of the Colliery; Mr. E. Atter appeared for Mitchell and Fleeton; and Mr. G. A. Skerry for Wilson. When the case was opened against Wilson and Mitchell on Monday week evidence was given by Andrew Blair, weighman at Wellington Pit, and Alexander Dunlop, shipper for the Colliery Co., at Whitehaven Harbour, as to the system of time-keeping and the payment of wages to the employees. Dunlop also making a statement with regard to alleged wrongful entries in the shipping time-book in the handwriting of Wilson and a man named William Morgan, who had since died. Before any evidence was given Mr. Chairman said his witnesses would be at the Colliery Office when required, as they objected to remaining in the room set apart for witnesses. It was a fearful ordeal and like the Black Hole of Calcutta if they had to remain in it any length of time. (Laughter.) He did not suppose there would be any objections so long as they were out of Court. The Clerk said the object of having witnesses in the room attached to the Court was so that information would not be conveyed. Mr. Chapman: Well, they have had nearly a week to convey the information. Neither Mr. Atter nor Mr. Skerry raised any objection to the witnesses being allowed to remain at the Colliery Office when asked by the Clerk. Being cross-examined by Mr. Skerry, the witness Dunlop said he swore that all the handwriting he had, spoken to in his examination in chief are Wilson's handwriting was Wilson's. Mr. Skerry asked witness to look at an entry for September 30 opposite Mitchell's name? Witness said he was not prepared to swear that it was in Wilson's handwriting. The cross-examination continuing, witness said he could not swear to an entry on November 2 as being in Wilson's handwriting, because his eyes were bad and he could not see well. He swore that an entry on November 9 was in Wilson's handwriting as far as he knew, but he believed the entry on the 16th November was in Morgan's writing. The entry on December 7 was in Wilson's handwriting as far as he knew. The Clerk: You have already sworn in chief that they are, you know. Witness replying to Mr. Skerry, said he could not really swear to any of the entries being in Wilson's writing as his eyesight was very bad. Mr. Watson: Are they worse than last Monday? Witness: Yes, I have been to Liverpool about them. Being further cross-examined; witness said the names of the locomotive men had been put in the books after he had signed them. At this point Mr. Chapman rose and said; I am only doing my duty in view of the contradictory evidence given by this witness in asking to withdraw the charge? The Clerk: Does it apply to the other case? Mr. Chapman: They are all one. Fleeton as well. The Chairman: Then we understand the case is closed? Mr. Chapman: Of course it rests with you to some extent. The Clerk: Well, there is not evidence at present to justify the magistrates in convicting. The prisoners were discharged. Mr. Atter: As regards the prisoners, nothing has been said in their defence, and I would have been rather better pleased if my friend had said something when withdrawing the charges as regards the reflections. Mr. Chapman: That is quite impossible Mr. Atter. I am the victim of circumstance. Mr. Atter: We are the victims of circumstances also, and I am quite sure had the charge not been withdrawn we could have satisfied the Bench, and the charge would not have been sustained.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||