|
29th October 1908 Alleged Defrauding Of The Whitehaven Colliery CompanyFalsifying Pay ChequesJohn Winter Wilson (41), wagon weighman, 86a, George-street, Whitehaven, and Thomas Mitchell, (28), locomotive driver, Queen-street, Whitehaven, were charged with having on July 13th, 1907, unlawfully conspired, combined, confederated and agreed to feloniously steal divers sums of money amounting to £7 6s 10d from the Whitehaven Colliery Company. Mr. John Winter Wilson aforesaid and William Fleeton (40), locomotive driver, West Strand, Whitehaven, were charged with having conspired to steal divers sums of money amounting to £4 7s 7d from the Whitehaven Colliery Company, between the 13th April, 1907 and the 13th April 1908. Mr. Chambers appeared for the prosecution; Mr. Skerry (Workington) appeared for Wilson; and Mr. Atter appeared for Mitchell. The first charge was gone into separately from the other. Mr. Chapman said he would explain the system under which time is kept and payment is made. Each workman on going to his work has given to him by a clerk there for that purpose a numbered piece of wood called a board; and at the end of the day he hands back that board to the same clerk, with a record on it in chalk or pencil of the time worked by the man that day. From the board this record is transferred to the time-book, and then the time-book in due course goes to the Colliery Office and the time is put into a pay-book. As a rule that is done on the Monday, he believed. There having got the time into the pay-book, as pay-day approaches the pay due to each man is arrived at from the record of the time, and that is put opposite his time in the book. The entry was then complete as a guide as to what that man had to receive as the end of the week. Tickets are then made out from this pay-book, recording the men's name, wages, deductions made, and so on. That is filled up in the case of each man from the pay-book, and these are sent down to the pit clerks on Friday evening; and then as part of the same process bags are sent in which the wages of each man are ultimately put and which are endorsed with the amount due to each man. These ticket and bags go down to the pit on the Friday, and so the Friday these tickets are dealt out to each of the various men who are entitled to receive the amounts inscribed upon them; and on the Saturday the payment is made. A man hands in his ticket. It does not necessarily follow that he presents his own ticket; it is not uncommon for one man to present half a dozen; but at all events the tickets are presented and then the bag is handed over containing the man's or men's money. Since the Compensation Act came in the tickets are not kept by the Colliery Company, but are stamped with the stamp of the Company and handed back to the workmen to keep, in connection, of course, with the bag given to him with the amount inscribed upon it. Well, now, that is the general system. But at Wellington Pit there is another little pay system, which is separate from this general pay system, and is carried out in two books called shipping books. These books record the pay of only four men and a contractor. That is what they are for — for the purpose of recording the pay of two-horsemen at Wellington Pit, one brakesman, one labourer, and the contractor, the latter under the name of Dale and Company. The Bench would hear in evidence that the name in those books of any other person than those four men and Dale and Company must necessarily be wrongly there. During the period that would be proved, the entries in these books were made by two different persons. The warrant charges Mitchell and Wilson with conspiring, but the evidence would show that the conspiring was done with one other person, since dead, a man of the name of William Morgan. Wm. Morgan was in the same office, twelve hours in the twenty four, as Wilson; and he died in June last; so that up to June last these books were kept alternatively by Morgan and the accused Wilson. The evidence would be that on page after page covering the period from July, 1907 to June, 1908, they would have the handwriting of Wilson and Morgan proved, and the whole of that period was in the handwriting of the one or the other. At the bottom of the page there was the signature either of Alexander Dunlop, shipper, or of a man named Humphries who took Dunlop's place while Dunlop was in America in the back end of last year. Dunlop would tell the Bench that on no occasion when he signed the book was the name of the defendant Mitchell on the page at all. But in many cases there were blanks; and what the prosecution said, and what he thought they would succeed in proving, was that Wilson (who was the timekeeper for these four men and the Company) went to Dunlop and got his signature, he had put in the name of Mitchell for extra pay he was not entitled to, and that had been going on for twelve months, and that the money so obtained had been divided between the defendants Mitchell and Wilson. The Bench would have before them also the evidence of the clerk, who keeps the proper time-book, and they would have it proved to them that on these occasions two pay cheques were issued. It was the observation that in the case of this defendant Mitchell, two pay cheques had been issued that aroused suspicion and caused inquiry to be made. Then, it was found that there was something serious. Mr. Steele, the manager at Wellington Pit sent for Mitchell and the other defendant, Wilson, and with Wilson was his father, the engineer of Wellington Pit. These men came down to Mr. Steele's office, and Steele put these questions to them in the presence of Wilson, and Wilson, Mitchell, and Fleeton. Each man was interrogated separately, and each replied separately. The question put in each case was this; "Have you been in the habit of getting two pay-cheques?" Mitchell replied, "Yes. I cashed these on Saturday, and gave it all to Wilson, and he gave me some back." Mr. Steele said, "How much did you get?" Mitchell replied "Sometimes 2s and sometimes 4s." Steele then said, "What did you do when Wilson was no on the night shift?" Mitchell replied, "When Morgan was on the day shift he received the money from me and divided it," Steele pursued his inquiries and said, "How long has this been going on?" Has it been going on for six months? Mitchell said, "More than that." Steel then said, "Has it been going on for twelve months?" and Mitchell said, "More than that," Steele then said, "How long do you think it has been going on then?" and Mitchell replied, "As near as I can tell, about two years." Andrew Blair, 9, Mid-street, Whitehaven, weighman at Wellington Pit, said he was the time-keeper at the pit between April, 1907 and July, 1908. Each man, before going to work, was supplied with a board with a number on it, and during the period mentioned it was witness's duty to hand out the boards to the men. It was the general rule for each man to get his own board, but occasionally a man took his own and that of another man. Each man wrote his time on the board, and put it in a box behind the store-house door. The next morning the boards were taken out of the box, and the entries on the boards were written in a day time-book by the timekeeper. The day book was kept until the week end, and the entries were then copied into another similar book, which was afterwards signed by the manager and sent to the colliery office. The entries were then put into a pay book, and from the checks or pay tickets were made out and sent to the pit on a Friday morning. Each man's money was then put into a paper bag, and the bag's containing the money were sent to the pit on a Saturday morning when the money was paid out and the checks bearing the stamp of the Colliery Company, were handed back to each man. Up to June last a man named William Morgan was timekeeper and weighman for the shipping at the south side of the harbour. Morgan died about July, and witness was then appointed joint time-keeper and weighman with Wilson. For the ordinary time-keeping there was only one book kept, but for the south side shipping there were two books, these being used in alternative weeks, so that one book could be sent to the office in the meantime in order that the entries could be posted up from it. There were no boards used in connection with the shipping pay. The only persons receiving money for the shipping whose names should appear in the book were three brakesmen, a road cleaner, and sometimes a man with a spare horse, also Dale and Company who were the shippers. No locomotive men's names should appear in the shipping book. Alexander Dunlop, shipper, signed the shipping book weekly before it was sent to the office. In reply to Mr. Watson, Mr. Chapman said that Dunlop was responsible for the accuracy of the entries in the book. Witness produced four time-books dating from October 13th, 1905, to October 24th, 1908. The name of the defendants Mitchell was entered for the week ending Tuesday, July 13th, 1907. Mr. Atter objected to the production of the book on the ground that it was only a copy. In reply to the Bench, witness said the original book was in the store-house. A manager was then despatched for the original book. Witness said the entries were made weekly, and the pay was made from the book which had been produced. Mr. Chapman: So you see this is the important book. Witness, continuing, said he made the entry in the time-book produced. It was made from the rough time-book. The Court at this stage adjourned for lunch, pending the arrival of the original time-book. On resuming, the witness Blair produced the original time-book from which the entries had been copied and which contained entries from June, 1907, to July, 1908. They were all in witness's handwriting up to July, when witness was succeeded by William Copeland. All the entries were taken from the boards. On being referred to certain dates to see if there were entries by Mitchell, the witness was unable to find any until the week ending October 26th, 1907, and explained that the system of boards only came into vogue when Mr. Steel was appointed manager of the pit. On the 26th October there was an entry, "Thomas Mitchell, 6¼ days." On the Wednesday in the week, Thomas Mitchell was also entered for one day's time, and on the Monday in the week ending November 2nd there was an entry of 4¼ days for Mitchell. There was also a similar entry for the Wednesday in the same week. Witness spoke to further entries up to May 2nd this year. Some ten months ago witness noticed that some of the enginemen were getting two pay checks, and he had some conversations with Wilson. He asked him how it was that they double checks were coming to the pit, and Wilson said it was for running coal over to the dock, and this had to be charged against the shipping account. Witness accepted this explanation. Cross-examined by Mr. Skerry: All the entries in the books were made by witness from the boards. He would not say he had not made mistakes in taking entries from the boards, but he didn't think he had. Mitchell would be bound to work the days entered in the book. It was possible for a man to put on 2¼ days in twenty-four hours by working all night. There might be an entry in both pit book and the shipping book against the man for the same day. A locomotive man sometimes went to the pit in the morning, and was sent to the shipping place later in the day. He would get the board at the pit, and it was possible for Mitchell to have been entered in both the pit and the shipping book, though it should not have been done without witness's knowledge. He did not know that locomotive firemen had been regularly entered in the shipping book. He knew that Mitchell had been running coal over to the dock, and he had no reason to doubt this when Wilson gave it as a reason for the double checks. Cross-examined by Mr. Atter, he had known Wilson for eight or ten year, and Mitchell for six or seven years, while he had known Morgan for sixteen years. During that time he had never known anything against the character of the men, who had been in the constant employ of the Colliery Company. Wilson's father had been employed at the colliery for forty years, and was now head engineer. Witness had never complained to the Company about the check or pay system. He had about seventy boards to deal with daily, and there was no one to check his entries. Workmen had never complained to him about his making mistakes with the boards. Before the board system came in the men had brass checks. The locomotive men did not have the checks, and witness used to enter their time from seeing them at work. It was possible for one man to have two boards and out them into the box. He had checked the men in the pit with the boards almost daily, and had never found anything wrong. Anyone presenting another man's pay check could get a paper bag containing his money. Another man could also get another man's check at the pit on merely asking for it, and giving the man's name. There was no entry made of any such transaction, but it was frequently done. All the time-books for 1907 and 1908 were not in Court. The locomotive time-book was not there, though it contained some entries relating to Mitchell in August, September, and October, 1907. Alexander Dunlop, who signed the book, was still in the employ of the Company. There has been no change in the system since July. Witness had been doing the same kind of work as Morgan did. Witness remembered an occasion when Mitchell gave him a check and asked him to take it back. He told Mitchell he could not accept it, as it would get him and everyone else into trouble, and he must take it back to those who put the time in. Wilson's father, and Mr. Steel, the Manager were over witness, but he didn't mention the matter to either. This was about six months ago, and witness spoke to Morgan about it. What Mitchell said to him about the check was not in the nature of a complaint. The check referred to Dunlop's time-book, but witness did not say anything to Dunlop about it. Morgan told him there must have been a mistake somewhere, as it was for running coal to the dock. Witness had been mixed up for a long time, almost daily, with Mitchell, and he had no reason to doubt his honesty. Mr. Atter: Have you any reason to doubt his honesty now? Witness: No. Re-examined by Mr. Chapman: When a workman took out two boards, he took one for himself and one for another workman. Alexander Dunlop, North Waif House, Queen's Dock, Whitehaven, said he was shipper for the Whitehaven Colliery Company. The time-book for the shipping was kept in the weigh office at Wellington Pit. This book was made out daily by the weighman, and at the week-end witness examined it, and, if correct, signed it. He was in the habit of going through every name in the book for the purpose of seeing that the time put down was for men who were actually working. Locomotive men were entered in the shipping book until about three years ago. After that time a special locomotive book had been used, and no locomotive men ought to have been entered in the shipping book. The names of locomotive men appearing in that book had been wrongly entered after witness had signed it. Witness produced the shipping book containing entries of T. Mitchell in July, 1907. There were entries for Tuesday and Thursday in the week ending July 13th for Thomas Mitchell working half a day and one day respectively, and these should not have been in the book and were not there when witness signed it. There was another entry against Mitchell for one day's time on the Thursday in the week ending July 20th. This was in Wilson's handwriting, and the entry was not there when witness signed the book. For the Wednesday in the week ending July 27th there was another entry against Thomas Mitchell for one day's time, and this was in Wilson's handwriting. Again for the Friday in the week ending August 17th appeared an entry by Morgan for one day's work for Mitchell. Witness spoke as to other entries in the handwriting of Wilson and Morgan up to June, and said that none of the entries were made when he signed the books. Witness was absent for four weeks — when he went to America — and during that time the books were signed by George Humphreys. At this stage owing to the lateness of the hour, the Bench decided to adjourn the further hearing of the case. The Clerk (Mr. Helder) said if the case had to be thrashed out it would apparently take some days and the question as to the most suitable time of resuming the hearing was discussed, with the result that it was decided to adjourn the case until Monday. On the application of Mr. Atter and Mr. Skerry, the accused were allowed bail, each in £50 and two sureties of £25.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||