|
17th September 1908 The Lowca FatalityMr. Atter and a jury, of which Mr. I. Cannell was foreman, resumed an adjourned inquest, at the Police Station, Whitehaven, on Tuesday evening, touching the death of Peter Rogan, on whom a wall fell at No. 9, Micklam Pit, on Monday week, with fatal results. The inquest had been adjourned in the first instance from Monday week last until Wednesday week, for the attendance of the Factory Inspector, and then from Wednesday week until Tuesday last for the attendance and evidence of Patrick Rafferty, who had been injured as a result of the same accident. The Coroner thought that Mr. George Wm. Foster, the foreman who had charge of the work, blamed Rafferty for not having observed his instructions as to the way in which the work was to be done, and for having thus gone to the wrong side of the wall — the side on which the wall was bound to fall. In justice alike to Rafferty and Mr. Foster, the Coroner therefore adjourned the inquest. On Tuesday, Mr. Ormrod, solicitor, was present, representing the employers, and Mr. Seymour, the Inspector of Factories, was also present. Mr. Foster was re-called, and said, a quarter to nine would be the last time he would be close to the wall before the accident. By Mr. Ormrod: He gave instructions to Rafferty that he was to undercut the wall. Patrick Rafferty deposed that he was a labourer, and worked for the Harrington Iron and Coal Co., for ten or eleven weeks. Mr. Foster was supposed to be the gaffer. He was working at the taking down of the wall. Peter Rogan was working with him. Witness had worked at this job before on two occasions. Neither witness for Rogan had any experience at the work. Mr. Foster gave them the order to start. He told them they were to start pulling down the building. He did not tell them how they were to work, whether inside or outside. They worked as they had worked before, undermining the wall on the inside. It was Mr. Foster who gave them instructions on that previous occasion, and he told them to undermine it. Witness did not think that was the right way to do it. Witness would have taken the wall down from the top. Mr. Foster was standing not more than a couple of yards away, while they were working. The wall came down from the top and fell upon witness. Witness was inside the building. He would think the proper place to have been would have been outside; but they were not told whether they were to be inside or outside. Witness repeated that Mr. Foster never gave them any instructions whatsoever, except that they were to take the wall down from the bottom. He did not tell them it was dangerous. By the Foreman: Mr. Foster when he saw them working where they were, did not say anything to them or tell them they where, or where they should not be. By the Inspector: What he meant by "under-mining" was that they took some bricks out. They had a hammer and bar. They knocked down some of the brick-work. Witness thought it was safe enough. Mr. Foster was standing inside close to them for several minutes. Witness did not hear a crack or anything before he was caught by the falling wall. If witness had thought it was a dangerous thing to do he would have gone to Mr. Foster to tell him so. Rogan did not say anything to witness about it being dangerous; they just went on with their work. By Mr. Ormrod: He had only helped to demolish one other wall, and had no experience; but if he had been going to do it himself he would have done it from the top. Asked whether he would put his inexperienced opinion against that of an experienced man like Mr. Foster, witness did not reply. Mr. Ormrod further asked if witness thought it would have been best to do the work from the outside, why he acted in defiance of his own judgement, seeing that he said Mr. Foster gave him no instructions one way or another. Witness did not answer this question. Questioned again by the Inspector, witness said they took out about six courses of bricks, from the inside. By Mr. Ormrod: Hasn't Mr. Foster told you on previous occasions always to work from the outside? — No, never. H.M. Inspector of Factories said that he had viewed the place where the accident happened; and he found that the accident had happened on consequence of the difference in the lime. A portion of a side wall and of an adjacent gable wall were built to a height of seven feet with white lime, and a portion of 5ft. above had been built later with slag lime. The side wall was being brought down, and when the top of it came, it brought down also the solid top of the gable. He did not know that the men would have been safer on one side than on another. The best way would have been to have blown the thing down. The Coroner told the jury they had to consider whether anyone was to blame for this accident. On that they had the conflicting testimony of the foreman and of Rafferty. Rafferty and Rogan did not appear to have been experienced persons. He mentioned that because Mr. Foster said that the men were experienced. Rafferty was neither experienced at this work nor in giving evidence. Another workman was said to have seen the danger and to have shouted out that the gable end would be coming down. Mr. Foster was stated to have been there and yet he made no mention of any danger. Mr. Foster said he was not there for half an hour before the accident. The Coroner said there was no legal obligation on Mr. Foster to be there all the time, if he gave rightful orders. There was strong corroboration of the Inspector, who did not think the order given was a wrongful one. The Coroner said he himself saw no neglect, legally speaking, on the part of anyone; the only question he thought there might be was whether there was any want of attention or warning or caution on the part of anyone. The jury retired to consider their verdict, and returned with a verdict of accidental death, and that there had been neglect on the part of the foreman in not supervising the work, and not giving proper instructions to the men, this work being very dangerous. The Coroner asked whether they jury meant that there was any culpable neglect; whether the death was caused as a result of the neglect, or whether it was thoughtless neglect. The foreman said it was thoughtless neglect, not criminal neglect that the jury meant.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||