Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd September 1908

Colliers Charged With Contravention Of Special Rules At Lowca

Miner's Jaw Broken In A Fight

At the Whitehaven Police-court, on Thursday, before J. Dickinson (chairman) and W. Hastwell (the mayor), Esq., Joseph Holliday (20), collier, Senhouse-street, Whitehaven, and David Findlay (19), collier, 7, Concrete Cottages, Lowca, were charged with contravening the special rules made under the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1887, by striking workmen in No. 9 Pit, Lowca, on August 11, 1908.

Findlay was also charged by Holliday with assault at the same time and place.

Mr. W. H. Chapman appeared on behalf of the prosecutors the Harrington Iron and Coal Company, while Mr. E. Atter defended on behalf of Holliday, and Mr. G. A. L. Skerry appeared for Findlay.

In the opening proceedings Mr. Chapman said the offence alleged was a breach of special rules 135 of the colliery, which ran "no workman shall strike another or throw stones, coal, or other missiles about a mine." Continuing, the speaker said he held that the Bench had nothing to do in a case like this with provocation, if such existed. It was necessary to preserve discipline in a coal mine. There was no feeling on the part of the prosecutors, who simply wished to have their rules adhered to for the safety of the men who worked underground.

Isaac Armstrong, shiftsman, 21, Newhouses, Lowca, produced the special rules of the pit. On the 12th inst., he was on duty at No. 9 pit at a quarter past three in the afternoon, and as the coal was coming up badly he went to the "flat sheets," where he found the defendants quarrelling about their tubs on the haulage road. Each claimed the right of precedence, and Findlay shoved Holliday's tub back. Witness slewed Holliday's tub out first, so as to get on with the work. About ten minutes later witness went back to a siding where he saw the defendants lying in holds on a full tub. He parted the men and told them there was going to be none of that done there.

Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: Witness had been connected with the pit about twelve years. There was a tub for each workman and when they were filled they had to go to a siding to get empty tubs. The first man there had the option of securing the first empty tub. On the occasion in question he believed Findlay got there first. Findlay took the first tub off the siding. When witness separated the combatants he did not notice if Holliday was bleeding. The latter did not make any complaint to him, and about two hours afterwards witness heard that Holliday's jaw was broken.

Cross-examined by Mr. Skerry: Witness was going to put Findlay's tub on the road first, because he thought he had the right to be first. Holliday pushed a full tub back and jammed Findlay against the "pack," putting his lamp out. When witness saw the defendants on the tubs they were "coddling" one another (Laughter.) but he did not see any blows struck.

Thomas Coates, 3, Newhouses, Lowca, said he was a trailer at No. 9 Pit. Witness was standing with an empty tub when Holliday came down and was followed by Findlay, who called him a ****. The former said "If you call me that again I will knock you through the tubs." Findlay repeated the epithet, and the defendants commenced to fight. Both were struck more then once — perhaps half a dozen times each added witness. Holliday finally got his opponent on top of the tubs and held him there until the previous witness came and parted them.

Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: He was not more friendly with one defendant than he was with "t' other." He did not hear Holliday say "I will hold you until someone comes to see what you have done to me," but he did hear the defendant remark that he would make Findlay pay for what he had done.

By Mr. Skerry: He did not hear Findlay complain about Holliday having crushed him against the "pack" with the tub. A few days previously the latter had attempted to get witness's turn with a tub, and on the day in question was trying to get Burn's turn when Findlay came and called him a ****. After the fight witness noticed that Findlay's mouth was bleeding.

At this point Mr. Skerry said so far as the contravention of the rules went, he was prepared to admit that his client struck Holliday, but he held that it was more in self-defence than anything else, and that the other man was the aggressor.

Mr. Atter said that his client held he did not strike a blow.

Robert Burns, Sea View, Lowca, who is also a trailer at the pit said that Holliday was claiming witness's tub, when the other defendant, Findlay came down and called Holliday a ****. Witness went on to give similar evidence to Coates.

Answering Mr. Atter, witness stated he bore Holliday no ill will. He did not notice Bragg during the time the fight was in progress, although a man might be on the siding and yet be out of sight.

After this period the Court, adjourned for luncheon.

On resuming Andrew Miller, certificated manager of the Harrington Iron and Coal Company's pits, was called, and deposed this was a very important rule to contravene. On august 14 he saw Findlay underground and asked if the charge made against him was true. Findlay acknowledged that he fought with Holliday underground, and said he was not going to allow the latter to strike him and shove him against the "pack."

Questioned by Mr. Atter, witness said he had not an opportunity to question Holliday, as the latter lived in Whitehaven, and had not been to the pit since the alleged fight. Witness heard the following day that Holliday's jaw was broken. It was reported to witness that Holliday had gone to the under-manager's house and stated that Findlay had struck him and broken his jaw, and that he had not struck Findlay, but simply held him until someone came to his assistance.

Mr. Atter said he could hardly see how this rule was requisite, or really carried any remedy. There is a remedy if one is struck, and the ordinary remedy is to take out a summons. He differed with Mr. Chapman's opinion "that no provocation can be taken into account, if a blow is struck." He (Mr. Atter) held that provocation was certainly to be taken into account.

Joseph Holliday stated that he had worked for the Harrington Iron and Coal Company over six years and had been acquainted with Findlay over four months. On August 14 witness got to the siding first, but Findlay claimed his turn and they "chocked" on the flat sheets. Armstrong came and slewed witness's tub out first. When witness was returning for another tub the other defendant called him a ****, and he replied that he had better not call him that again. With that Findlay struck him and broke his jaw, and his lamp was knocked out. Witness was stunned, and when he came round he seized Findlay round the body, and told him he would hold him there until someone came. It could not be possible that he sustained his injury through falling. Witness did not strike Findlay at any time, but told him he would make him pay for it. He got up the pit at half-past four and reported the occurrence to the under-manager. Witness was attended by Dr. Muriel, and had been unable to either work or take any solid food since. The doctor told him it would be a month or six weeks before he could take the bandages off his jaw.

Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: Witness was not in a pugnacious frame of mind that day. He had a fratch with Burns, as the latter wanted to take his turn. He could not tell why Findlay struck him, as he had no provocation. Witness did not threaten to knock Findlay through the tub if he called him a **** again. When he said he was stunned he meant he was dazed, but not unconscious.

James Bragg, of Parton, said he was working alongside the defendants, when he heard Findlay call Holliday a ****, and afterwards saw him strike him (Holliday) twice on the jaw. Witness would be nearer to the defendants than Coates and Burns, who would perhaps be three yards further off the men than him. When Holliday recovered he threw his arms round Findlay, and said he would hold him until somebody came. Holliday never struck Findlay.

Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: If Coates and Burns said they were nearer to the defendants than witness they were telling lies.

Giving evidence on his own behalf Findlay said that as he was going to get out with his tub Holliday came up and asked who he followed, and witness said "You follow me" Holliday attempted to get out first, and they both met on the "flat sheets." Holliday jammed witness against the "pack." Armstrong came up and asked who was first, and Holliday claimed that first turn. Witness spoke to Holliday about it, and called him a ****, and the latter said if he called him that again he would knock him through the tubs. Witness repeated the epithet and Holliday struck him in the ribs, and consequently he struck back in self-defence. Holliday then put him on the tubs and said he would hold him there until someone came. Witness resumed work after they had been separated by Armstrong, and half an hour later he heard that Holliday had come up the pit.

Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: While witness was struggling with Holliday he received several blows, some on the body and one on the mouth. He admitted striking Holliday, but he did not hit him on the jaw.

Findlay was fined 20s for a breach of the rules and 20s for assaulting Holliday, while the charge against Holliday was dismissed.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Armstrong, Isaac    Shiftsman  
Atter, E.    Solicitor  
Bragg, James    Miner  
Burns, Robert    Trailer  
Chapman, W. H.    Solicitor  
Coates, Thomas    Trailer  
Dickinson, J.    Magistrate  
Findlay, David   19 Collier  
Hastwell, J.    Magistrate  
Holliday, Joseph   20 Collier  
Millar, Andrew    Colliery Manager  Whos Who Page
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Solicitor  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Harrington Colliery  Harrington Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print