|
20th August 1908 Bigrigg Youth Shockingly MutilatedPractically Cut Into Pieces By Railway WagonsA shocking fatality occurred at the Moss Bay Iron Mines, Woodend, on Saturday forenoon, by means of which Isaac John McLean, 15 years of age, who resided with has stepfather, Robert McLean miner, 25, Springfield Road, Bigrigg, came by his death. Deceased and another lad were engaged in taking two wagons down an incline when by some means McLean got between the rails, one wheel passing over him. He was terrible injured, the right arm and leg being almost torn from the body, the left leg fractured and the left hip dislocated. Dr. Calderwood was speedily on the scene and ordered the removal of the unfortunate lad to the Whitehaven Infirmary, but when admitted to that institution McLean was found to be dead. The Inquest. The inquest was formally opened in the Whitehaven Infirmary on Saturday by Mr. E. Atter, coroner for West Cumberland. Mr. Isaac Cannell was chosen foreman of the inquiry. Robert McLean identified the body, and said that he was the deceased's stepfather. Deceased was 15 years of age last March. He worked at the Woodend Mines for the Moss Bay Company; in the same employ as witness. Witness worked in the bottom, while the lad was a surface hand. He accompanied his stepson from Woodend to the Infirmary on Saturday. The accident occurred between nine and ten o'clock on Saturday morning. The lad was attended by Dr. Calderwood, and it would be about one o'clock when they got to the infirmary. Deceased died on the road. The last time he spoke was when they were near Hensingham. The inquiry was adjourned to the Whitehaven Police Station until o'clock on Monday afternoon to allow of the attendance of the Inspector of Mines. On Monday the inquiry was resumed, when Mr. J. B. Atkinson, H. M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. J. B. Kitchin, manager of the Woodend Mines; and Mr. J. Flynn, miners agent, were amongst those present. Plans were produced previous to the taking of the evidence. James Wilson Dalzell, engineman at the Woodend Mines, said he had been acquainted with the deceased over twelve months. He acted as a guard for witness. On Saturday morning McLean commenced work at six o'clock and the accident happened about ten. Two wagons were coupled and had to be brought down an incline. Deceased was on the second waggon and a lad named Clementson on the first. They were on opposite sides owing to the position of the brakes. The waggons were only braked on one side, and were filled with ore. Deceased was on an old waggon, and witness believed it went over his leg. Witness could not say if the brake had been tested recently, but it appeared to be all right. The waggon came in empty on Friday, and was loaded on Saturday morning. He had never seen the brake worked, but he just went by its appearance. He looked at the brake after the accident. Witness was standing below the points waiting for the two waggons to come down, and he could not say what really happened as he did not see the accident happen. His attention was attracted by the shouts of McLean's companion, and he saw deceased lying on the ground. The lad was conscious. Witness turned deceased over on to his back, and noticed that one of his legs was broken. He was clear of the waggon wheels altogether. An arm and a thumb also appeared to be broken, and there was a lot of blood about. The line sloped down at this point. Mr. Kitchin explained that the incline was one foot in thirty. Witness, continuing, said he did not notice any blood on the waggon wheels, although he did not examine them closely. Immediately after seeing the injured youth he sent for Mr. Lowery, the clerk, and for Mr. Hillon. Assistance was rendered by Mr. Lowery, who he understood was an expert as regards ambulance work. The wounds were dressed, and Dr. Calderwood arrived after being telephoned for. The doctor would arrive before eleven o'clock. The lad was then despatched to the Infirmary. By the Coroner: The lad was riding on the brake on the same side as he was found lying. It was possible he could have slipped off. It was not usual for him to ride on the brake, and there were brake sticks for pinning the brakes down with. It was deceased's duty to have pinned the brake down with a brake stick. He could have done that by walking alongside, and the waggon was going at a very slow pace; barely moving. He did not think it would proceed more than six yards altogether. By the Foreman: It was against the regulations riding on the brake. Brake sticks were provided to pin the brakes down with. Replying to the Inspector, witness said he did not say anything to the deceased when he was sitting on the brake. He had seen McLean on the brake before and had warned him. There were brake sticks on the engine. Deceased was wearing clogs. There was a check rail near the point where the lad was lying, and they came to the conclusion that it had caught his foot and dragged him in. When he was sitting on the brake his feet would be hanging inside the rail. Witness did not hear anyone warn deceased to get off. Deceased's duties were those of an ordinary guard braking waggons, coupling and uncoupling, changing the points, &c. Witness noticed after the accident that the brake was pinned down. The brake was down when the lad got on to the waggon, but the pin may not have been in then. Examined by Mr. Flynn, Dalzell said he considered the boy was helping forward the work when he was doing this. The work in question should really have been done by two boys named Clementson and Dakin, but the latter was engaged in bringing down an empty waggon at the time. The Coroner: Was he doing the same work on Saturday as he had been doing before? Witness: Yes, sir, he was accustomed to pinning brakes down and stopping waggons. In your opinion was there danger in his riding on the brake? — Yes, there was. Danger to himself? — Yes, sir. Have you often seen him do it? — No, sir. When did you last see him and warn him? — I could not exactly say sir. It was not a common occurrence. Just some ides, please? How often had you warned him; once or more? — I had only warned him once and I think it was about two months ago. You have never seen him repeat it until this morning? — No sir. How long did you see him on the brake before the accident? — Just half a minute, and perhaps not that. Why did you not speak to him? — I was standing a bit off, sir, and as steam was blowing a bit strong I don't think he could have heard me if I had shouted. Henry Clementson, 69, Main Street, Egremont, stated that he was a waggon picker at the Woodend Mines. He had followed this employment for the last twelve months. Deceased often gave witness a "hand down" with the waggons if the other lad was not there. On the date in question he was on the first waggon and McLean on the second, and the latter said he was going to have a ride down on the brake. Witness replied that he had better not, but evidently deceased disregarded his advice. Witness and McLean were at opposite sides of the waggons, and when they had proceeded about half a dozen yards there was a shout, and he stopped the waggons. On going back he saw the deceased, who was lying clear of the wheels of the last waggon. Deceased was lying on the same side as the brake. Witness never rode on a brake himself, because it might "switch" up and "toss" him on the line. He had been told not to do it, as it was dangerous. Deceased was just giving him a hand in letting the waggons down, because the other lad was engaged elsewhere. McLean was doing wrong in sitting on the brake, and he should have had a brake stick. Witness released the brake of the first waggon and thus let them go. By the Coroner: Witness should think the accident happened though the brake giving a bit of a "switch," and throwing deceased between the rails. By the Foreman: Witness was not the first to reach deceased after the accident. Replying to the Inspector, Clementson said he was 16 last may. They were accustomed to having two lads for the waggons. Deceased was not a regular worker at this job. It was not often that deceased helped them down with the waggons. Mr. Flynn: Did you tell the lad not to ride on the waggon, or has this occurred to you since? Did you tell him before the accident? — Witness :— Yes, before the accident. I told him he had not to ride on the brake before we went down. Have you ever stood on the brake? — No. Always used a brake stick? — Yes, always used a brake stick. The cross-examination continuing, witness replied that the two waggons were coupled together. Deceased had his brake partly lifted up, in order that when witness released the brake of the first waggon they would commence to move. Witness did not actually see McLean sitting on the brake owing to being at the opposite side. While the waggons were running witness did not notice any shock, and he was walking alongside the first waggon pressing the brake down with his stick. The other boy used to ride on the brakes, but desisted when warned by witness, who had never-ridden on a brake himself. He had never previously had any bother in letting the waggons down. Robert Dakin, 3, Montreal Street, Cleator Moor, who is also waggon picker at the Woodend Mines, said he was 14 years of age, and had been employed at the mines about two months. Witness saw deceased sitting on the brake — he being about six yards away and told him to get off, but the lad wouldn't. The exact words he used were, "Get off, or you'll fall on the line." The waggons just moved slowly. When deceased got on the brake he was engaged in work which witness ought to have been doing. Witness was engaged in letting an empty waggon down at the time. He would bring an empty waggon down in two or three minutes. Deceased fell forward into the line, and one of the wheels went over a leg and an arm before witness pulled him out. He called to Dalzell, and Clementson stopped the waggons with his brake stick. McLean had not a brake stick, but witness had one in his hand. He offered his brake stick to the deceased, but the latter refused to take it. Witness did not notice any jerk sufficient to shake the lad off. By the Foreman: Clementson gave witness instructions that he had not to ride on the brake. Examined by the Inspector: While deceased was sitting on the brake one arm would be over the buffer, and his feet would be hanging underneath the waggon at a distance of about a foot from the ground. He could not say whether deceased's clog was produced, and found to he dented near the sole. Mr. Kitchin: Could you tell whether he fell inside; between the waggon wheels? — Witness Yes, sir, he did. Mr. Flynn suggested that it was an utter impossibility for the boy to fall in between the waggons, unless he was caught and drawn in. Witness agreed with Mr. Flynn's suggestion. Isaac Lowery, 4 Roper Street, Cleator Moor, clerk and storekeeper at the Woodend Mines, said he thought the deceased was a very intelligent lad. On Saturday morning after the accident, he was called for, and rendered what assistance he could. Deceased was then lying on the side foot way with his feet over the rails. Witness rendered first aid, and telephoned for the doctor, Mr. Kitchin, and an ambulance. The right arm and the right leg were nearly torn from the body, and the flesh was off the right thumb to the bone. The left leg was fractured, and the hip dislocated. Witness had attended ambulance classes, and used his knowledge as best he could. Answering the Coroner, witness said the doctor was satisfied with the bandaging, and sent the lad to the Infirmary as he was. Witness's opinion of the accident was that the deceased's clog caught the check rail; and pulled him off. By Mr. Flynn: The waggon had come down the reverse way, and the lever of the brake, was in front of the wheels. James Bateman Kitchin, manager of the Woodend Mines, gave the deceased lad a very good character. He was a promising young man. Witness was telephoned for after the accident, and in addition to himself, four ambulance men and the doctor were speedily at the place. He did not ask McLean any questions or hear him say anything. He did not think there was much blood on the waggon, but there was a good deal on the ground where the lad had fallen. It was against all regulations to ride on the brake, and also very dangerous. Witness was not aware it had been done, and never heard such a thing mentioned. From the position in which Dalzell saw deceased, witness felt positive that his clog caught on the check rail, which would drag him in, and the front wheel would be bound to go over him. McLean would know the danger as well as any person, and he thought the accident was due to want of thought. The Inspector: Don't you think it would be better if you had men to shift those waggons instead of boys? Witness: Well, in this case I think it would have been an advantage. Replying to questions put by Mr. Atkinson, witness said the total weight of a loaded waggon would be 15 tons. He was deceived with the age of the deceased lad, and thought he must be 17 or 18, as he was a big young fellow. The Coroner said there was no avoiding it that the poor lad was doing what he ought not to have done. The thought in all probability they would agree with Mr. Kitchin that the accident happened through want of thought. It was either that or want of appreciation, he not being fully aware of the danger in which he was placing himself. Everything possible was done after the accident that could have been done. The Foreman said the jury agreed it was a pure accident. They also wished it to be recorded that they thanked Mr. Lowery for the assistance rendered after the accident. On behalf of the employers and himself, Mr. Kitchin expressed sympathy to Mr. and Mrs. McLean at the death of the poor lad. The Coroner said he felt sure that he himself and also the jury, held the same opinion.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||