|
13th August 1908 Important Whitehaven Mining QuestionBrown And Others V. Whitehaven Colliery Company£100 was claimed from the Whitehaven Colliery Company, as damages for alleged breach of contract. The plaintiffs were Wm. Bowne, Court 29, Church-street; James Swailes, 8, Charles-street; Wm. Quirk, 4, Cross Green, High Harras; Henry Baker, Union Buildings, Scotch-street; James Wallace, 13, Railway-terrace, Newtown; Wm. Stephenson, 8, Quay-street; James Quayle, 16, Peter-street; Peter Chambers, 7, Charles-street; and James Chambers, 4, Bell's Place, New Lowther-street, all miners, of Whitehaven. The particulars of claim set forth that plaintiffs were from March 26th to May 16th inclusive, working for the defendant Company at William Pit, Whitehaven, under a continuing contract for driving No. 1 dip bord on the terms of payment for their work after the rate of 4s 2d per yard and percentage. The defendant Company paid the complainants after the agreed rate up to the 16th of May, on or as from which date the defendant Company, it was alleged, wrongfully terminated the contact or refused to allow plaintiffs to continue performance of their part at the agreed rate. The plaintiffs, therefore, claimed as damages for breach of contract the sum of £100. Mr. Byrne, Manchester (instructed by Messrs. Lightfoot & Lightfoot, Maryport) was counsel for the plaintiffs; and Mr. Proctor, Liverpool, (instructed by Mr. W. H. Chapman, Whitehaven) was counsel for the defendants. Mr. Proctor raised a question as to the jurisdiction at the Court. There was in existence in Cumberland a Board of Conciliation for the purpose of settling disputes between employers and employed in connection with the coal trade; and he submitted that this case was entirely a matter for that Board, and that the jurisdiction of the County Court was therefore ousted. Mr. Byrne said there was nothing in his friend's objection. The Conciliation Board was for the purpose of dealing with general and not individual disputes like the tone in question. His Honour found that he had jurisdiction; but offered to adjourn the case to enable him to be set right on that point, if he was wrong, by the Superior Court. Mr. Proctor said he would prefer that the case should go on. Mr. Byrne then proceeded to state the case. The plaintiffs sent in their tender for working. There were three shifts, three men for each. Their written tender was accepted verbally, and work was commenced and proceeded until the 16th May. Particulars were handed in to His Honour showing the earning of the men as so working. Mr. Proctor said he had no copy of this information and knew nothing about it. Mr. Byrne said the document would, of course, be subject to proof. The men earned during the seven weeks they worked £124 15s 3d, which was at the rate of £2 0s 2d per man per week, or 9s 7¾d per shift per man. Under the general rules of the pit the men employed were entitled to give or take 14 days notice; and all working places were to be cavilled or balloted for every three months, with the exception of narrow or winding places. The particular work plaintiffs were engaged upon was at a narrow or winding place, and the rule was that all such places should be considered permanent cavil. The contention of the men was that a permanent cavil should last the full contract time of three months. On the other hand, if it was the contract could not be broken either by the plaintiffs or the masters without at least 14 days' notice. Mr. Proctor said he did not claim the right to terminate the contract at once. Mr. Byrne said that made the case much shorter. His friend admitted that 14 day notice must be given on either side. Now then, what happened? Seven of the thirteen weeks had expired when water, which had caused some difficulty, began to go down, and the work became easier. On the 12th May, Mr. Turner, the manager, asked the men what they would do the rest of the work for. One of the men said, "Oh, we have got a contract; we are not going to alter it." They had some conversation on the matter, and the result was that a meeting was arranged between themselves on the 16th May. They continued at work in the meantime. On the 15th May, a under-manager, named Rothery, came to them and said, "You are to start work next Monday at 2s 4d per yard and percentage. His Honour: 2s 4d! Mr. Byrne: 2s 4d as against 4s 2d. He did not think Mr. Rothery himself meant 2s 4d; he thought what Rothery really meant was 3s 6d; but it was 2s 4d he said. This showed that at that time the defendants were wanting to get out of this contract and claimed to break it without 14 days notice. At the meeting on the 16th May, Baker, Quayle, and Wallace, one from each of the three shifts, met Mr. Turner. Mr. Rothery, and Mr. McKenzie, who were acting for the defendants. The substance of what took place was this. Mr. Turner said what they wanted was a reduction in the price, Baker said, "Well, you won't get that"; and Baker added, "Now, before going any further, hadn't you better give us 14 day's notice." Mr. Turner said, "Have you ever given us notice when you wanted a price changed?" There he no doubt referred to the occasion on which, instead of the work becoming easier, the work became harder, and the men appealed for a rise. Mr. Turner said that now that the water was being got rid of the defendants could break the contract, Baker said, "The contract is not for water; the contract is for yardage." "Then," says Turner, "it does not matter. I am not going to pay you the price you have got, and I won't give you a day's notice." Baker said, "Suppose we come on Monday, will we be on a reduction?" and Turner said, "Yes." That was the end of the interview, and the men did not return to work on the Monday. Suppose that account of what took place was correct, he submitted that there was a clear breach of contract by the defendants in not giving 14 days' notice. The men were anxious not to lose their job, and they at once reported the matter to their agent, Mr. Hanlon. He wrote to Mr. Turner on the 21st May, asking him to receive a deputation in reference to this company of men, who were, he said, idle because Mr. Turner had reduced the contract price without legal notice. Mr. Turner replied in writing that the men had left the pit without notice, and that any grievance they had was imaginary. They came and told him themselves, when he asked for a reduction, that they would not work any more, and he had not made any reduction in the meantime. Their conduct he could not be, in any way, responsible for, he added. An interview was fixed for the following Saturday. At that interview, Mr. Smallwood, one of the men's delegates, went with three men. Smallwood asked, "Will you give the men another job, or if not will you let them continue their contract" at the old price, of course. Turner refused either of these courses. He again said the men left of their own accord, and then as the water had gone down he was entitled to review the price. Nothing further occurred until the 25th, when the men again approached the masters. There were then present Mr. Smallwood, Mr. Hanlon, Mr. James, and Mr. Turner. Mr. James admitted that the contract could only be determined by 14 days' notice, but he said that the 14 days' notice have been given on the 12th, when Turner first mentioned the question of reduction. That was not sound, on the face of it, because between the 12th and the 16th May, there were only four days, and not fourteen. Nothing came of that interview. Again on the 2nd June the men sought to have the matter set right; and Mr. Hanlon, the agent for the Whitehaven miners, and Mr. Andrew Sharpe, J.P., general agent of the West Cumberland Coalminers' Association, and Mr. James and Mr. Turner. Mr. James had to leave before they had proceeded far. Mr. Turner proposed that the men should return to work on the following Thursday, the 4th of June, on the original terms of the contract; that they should work upon these terms till the end of the week, but that after that they should accept 3s 6d, instead of 4s 2d; and if they did not take that, then in the alternative they could take ordinary work at he mines as ordinary men. There what Mr. Turner wanted was still to break the contract and put the men off without compensation. Mr. Sharpe and Mr. Hanlon reported this to the men, who refused to accept these proposals. That refusal was communicated to Mr. Turner by Mr. Hanlon and Mr. Smallwood, and Mr. Turner then said, if those things were refused, not only would he not give better terms, but he would never let one of them work again. A man named Quirk, thinking it was hopeless at William Pit, went and got employment at Ladysmith Pit, on the 13th of June. On the 18th he was summarily dismissed, for what reason he could only conjecture. If he proved these facts, Mr. Byrne concluded, there was a clear breach of contract, and the men were entitled to the maximum they could have earned in the fortnight. The nine men might have worked 96 shifts, and with improved conditions, as compared with the conditions under which they had actually averaged 9s 7¾d per shift per man, they would have had a higher average per shift. Henry Baker, said he was one of the plaintiffs, and was present at the interview with Mr. Turner on the 16th. Mr. Rothery, Mr. Hanlon and Mr. McKenzie were present. It was in Mr. Rothery's office. Mr. Turner spoke first. He said, "It is very seldom you fellows come to give anything away." Witness replied that they could do with something added. Mr. Turner said well he wanted a reduction. Witness replied that he could not have it. Mr. Turner began talking to Quayle; and witness interrupted to say that before he went further he had better give them 14 days' notice. Mr. Turner asked, "Whenever have you given me notice when you wanted anything?" Witness was stopped by the under-manager from saying any more. John Rothery said, "One at a time." Mr. Turner said that as soon as he got clear of the water he could breach the contract. Witness said there was no water mentioned in the contract; the contract was by yardage, not by water. Mr. Turner said, "It does not matter. I am not going to pay you the price and I won't give you a day's notice." There upon Quayle asked him for another place, so that we would not be lying idle. His answer was, "No." Quayle then asked, "If we come to work on Monday morning will we be under a reduction?" His answer was "Yes." They all there and then refused a reduction. Witness was then quite willing to go on with the contract at the old prices. They were all willing; it was a fairly good contract. They let Turner know that they were anxious and willing to go at the old prices. Since the 16th May they had not been able to get any work at the Whitehaven Colliery. On the 23rd of May there was another interview. Mr. Smallwood, one of the Union delegates, was there; Wm. Brown, Quayle, and witness one from each company again. They saw Mr. Turner, and Mr. Rothery afterwards came in, Mr. Smallwood was spokesman. Mr. Smallwood asked for a re-instatement of the men. That was refused. He asked that they might go on with their own contract, and that was refused. Turner said they did not ask for another place in the pit. Yes, they said they did. Mr. Turner said they could soon settle that; that John Rothery was in at the time, and he called Rothery. Rothery said yes that they did, that Quayle asked for another place and Baker for 14 days' notice. Mr. Turner said they left themselves. Witness was not present at any later interview. Cross-examined by Mr. Proctor: They signed rules when they were first employed. Every three months they balloted for places, and outside of that there were places that were tendered for, and in regard to these there was the question of these months but simply of fourteen days' notice. A special price was given for more difficult work, and it was let and not cavilled for. It was not on account of the water, but because every 30 yards they went they gained another working. They left the working behind them, and were getting into more comfort. The working was 4 yards wide, which was the usual width. Mr. Proctor suggested that water was the only difficulty. Witness replied that it was not, and that the reason why it was contracted for was because they were gaining places. He submitted that if difficulties had increased the men would have asked that the price should be reviewed. On the 16th May, they resolved that they would not have any reduction. Mr. Turner asked them for an offer and they would not give him one. Mr. Turner had not suggest that if the place had got worse they would have asked for more, and having got better he was entitled to a reduction. Mr. Turner told them that if they started again it would be at a reduction. He put it right off. Witness knew that their place was not filled for six weeks. They knew that they were entitled to 14 days' notice on the contract. They did not again present themselves for work. They reported the case to Mr. Hanlon. Mr. Turner did not tell them that they had left work without notice, and that they had broken the rules of the Conciliation Board. If he had started them they could have taken it to the Conciliation Board, but not when they were standing idle. Witness did not think, Mr. Turner wanted them to go to the Conciliation Board himself or he would have started them. The number of shifts it was possible to work, in a week was 48, for the nine men. On a cavil the average that witness had earned would be from 9s to 10s a day. On this contract they made an average of 9s 7¼d. If they had got cavil work its an average of 9s to 10s a day, they would have been as well off as on contract. Mr. Turner told them that they could have places in the pit, but that was if they would let his case drop. (Applause in Court, which His Honour deprecated.) Re-examined: Supposing the conditions and been getting harder and they wanted to revise the price, the men would have given 14 days' notice. They would not have considered themselves justified in putting on their coats and walking away. The employers kept a week's pay in hand so that the employers could always recoup themselves for at least one week if the men stopped work. It was never suggested by anybody that they could go back to their work at the contract price of 4s 2d. His Honour here asked what was the point in dispute. Mr. Proctor said what the defendants said was that they did not discuss the men; that they expected the men would come to work, to be paid at the old rate for the fortnight's notice to which they were entitled. Mr. Byrne said that was reducing the matter to very small compass. This was the first that he had heard of such a suggestion. Wm. Brown deposed that he was at the interview on the 12th. Mr. Turner said, "Now, Monsey (laughter) I want you to give me a loss price for this place, as it's getting clear of water, and getting into a better stool of coal." Witness told him he could not give him a price; and Mr. Turner said, "Tell your marrow, and to come and see me on Saturday." Witness told his marrow, and saw Rothery on the 15th May. Rothery came into the working and said, "You will be aware that this place starts at 2s 4d on Monday." Witness said, "We had better all see him." "Oh," he said, "you need not lose a shift, one will do." So they did not lose a shift. Witness was there at the interview on the 23rd, with Smallwood and Baker. What Baker had said about the interview was correct. Turner never told them that they could go on at the 4s 2d rate on the following Monday morning. Witness heard Quayle say that they had asked for another place, and Mr. Turner denied it and brought the under-manager in, and the under-manager confirmed Quayle that he did ask for another place. Cross-examined: They understood that Mr. Turner was stopping them there and then on the old rate, but from the 12th to the 16th they were paid at the old rate. On the 16th Mr. Turner reckoned that they had broken the rules of the Conciliation Board, and left without notice. James Swailes, another of the men, corroborated the evidence of Brown, more particularly in reference to what Rothery said about them starting on Monday at 2s 4d. Wm. Quirk was called, but at this point there was a decision as to an adjournment, seeing that it would be impossible to finish the case that day. It was agreed that work should be available for the men in the meantime, pending the finish of the case, without prejudice on either side. His Honour said the issue was very much narrowed, and he hoped that he men working in the meantime there would be an effort made to settle the case. There had been mutual misunderstanding. The men thought that the employers claimed to get out of a contract without notice. The employer said he never intended anything of the kind. That being so, it seemed to him that there ought to be a settlement. Mr. Proctor said that His Honour having made that statement he thought if time permitted they might come to a settlement at once. His Honour: By all means. Come into my room. That is better than an adjournment. On returning to the Court, after a short absence in conference with counsel. His Honour said: I am very glad that a acceded to the suggestion made that we should consider this matter in my private room. I have heard a good deal of the bottom of this dispute, and I think I understand it. I don't desire to say any thing with regard to the unfortunate misunderstanding which has arisen, because there is every disposition both on the part of those who spoke for the workmen and those who spoke for the masters, to come to an amicable and friendly arrangement. How that is to be arrived at has been left to me; and I think that although complete compensation cannot be given something should be done; and I have come to the conclusion that if I say that each of the men who have unfortunately suffered, in consequence of a misunderstanding for this everybody is very sorry now that each man should received £2 as compensation, and that the balance of the sum which I am going to name should go for costs; and that there will be no more disagreement between the men and the masters in this matter, but that the men shall go back to their work, as they could not have done before, and I hope they will forget all that has happened. Therefore every man will get his £2 and the balance of £60 will go for costs. You understand in all cases of this court costs are a very heavy thing. (Applause). It is settled in the terms that £60 shall be paid, and each man shall receive £2 compensation. (Applause.)
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||