|
27th March 1908 The Fatal Accident At Brayton PitAn Absent WitnessOn Tuesday afternoon Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, held the adjourned inquest at the Reading Room, Aspatria, into the circumstances attending the death of Alexander Sewell, 32 years of age, living at 73, Harriston, Aspatria, who was killed on the morning of the 3rd March by a fall of stone at No.4 Pit Brayton Domain Colliery. Mr. Cephaus Bouch was foreman of the jury. Mr. Nicholson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, was present, and Mr. G. H. Askew, manager, represented the Colliery Company. John Reed, Waverley Yard, deputy for the Brayton Domain Colliery, said he had had that job for four years. He was at the pit at six o'clock on Tuesday of last week. He saw Sewell when he went. Sewell was a shiftsman, and was working with witness. They started about a quarter to seven to clear away some stones. At a quarter to nine a stone from the roof fell on Sewell, pinning him down. Witness and Christopher Harker tried to remove the stone, but failed. Sewell only spoke once, saying "Be sharp." When they found they could not remove the stone they called for assistance, and about twelve men came, and eased the stone with props until they got Sewell out. It would be half an hour before they got him out, and he was then quite dead. Witness examined the working place that morning, and it seemed all safe. The stone gave a crack, and fell immediately after. Witness thought the stone had fallen through the "bumping" of the roof. By the Inspector: The stone fell about 30 or 40 yards from where the hewer was working at the face. He had plenty of timber near if he had wanted it. Witness was at the place 20 minutes before Sewell came, and considered it safe. The place had been "jumped" a little while they were working. Christopher Harker was next called, but it was stated that he was not present. Mr. Askew said he gave instructions that morning that the witness had to attend the inquest. He did not know that Harker was not working, and would not therefore be told. The Coroner was informed that Harker lived at Blennerhasset, and was not at the opening of the inquest last week. The Coroner said he generally relied on witnesses coming and saying the inconvenience of summonses, and he generally had the greatest assistance by mineowners and those under them. Evidently Mr. Askew had done what he thought necessary. Harker ought to have been present, for with every respect to Reed, who had given his evidence in a satisfactory manner. Harker should have been present either to corroborate that evidence, or to give his own account. Thos. Hillary, under manager, living at 55, Park Road, said he saw Harker last on the morning of the accident. He had not worked since then. Witness understood he had a sprained wrist, but expected him to be present at this inquest. On the morning of the 3rd inst, witness was about 260 yards from the place of the accident when a youth came along and said a stone had fallen on top of Sewell. Witness immediately went with others to the place, and found a large stone on Sewell, who seemed to be dead. The stone, which weighed about 15 cwt., was removed as soon as possible. Witness was on his round at the time he was told of the accident. He thought the stone must have been worse than Sewell and his mate regarded it to be. They might have been in a hurry when they examined it. By the Inspector: There was friction round where the stone fell which had caused a cut in the roof. The Coroner, in summing up, said he did not know whether they required additional evidence. Probably if they had had Harker they might have had more. But there seemed some explanation why he was not present, as he seemed to have met with an accident. He (the coroner) saw no reason to doubt Reed's statement, which was corroborated later by Hillary. There was no doubt Sewell came by his death by the fall of stone. The question was, was anybody to blame. Hillary very candidly expressed his opinion. He thought there had been some error of judgement on the part of Sewell and Reed. If Reed was careless or at all negligent about it, there was this very strong fact - he himself ran every bit the same risk as did Sewell. Therefore it was not a matter of being careless of the safety of others. If they found that it was an accidental fall of stone, which he thought it was, it would be hardly fair to Sewell, who thought not the deputy, was a sort of under authority, who had also taken part in the investigation of the place - or to Reed if they found that the fall of stone was caused by reason of any neglect or default on the part of those two men, unless their opinion differed from what he suggested the evidence was. There was no criminal neglect, and unless they thought there was greater blame than he thought he suggested that a verdict of "accidentally killed" should be returned. The jury consulted together, and the Foreman announced that 12 of the 13 jurymen were in favour of a verdict in accordance with the Coroner's suggestion. The Coroner said he could accept the verdict of twelve men, and he would record their verdict as "accidentally killed." The thirteenth juryman - 14 were sworn at the opening of the inquest, but one was absent through illness - was in favour of adjourning the inquest until the evidence of Harker was obtained. Mr. Askew said he was sorry that Harker was not present. Had had known he would have sent the trap for him.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||