Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

6th February 1908

Cumberland Assizes

Tuesday, February 4

The Cumberland Winter Assizes were opened at the Courts, Carlisle, on Tuesday.

Mr. Justice Pickford took his seat in the Crown Court at eleven a.m.

The Iron Ore Miners' Dispute.

This was a civil action in which William Senogles and two others sued as one of the trustees of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' and Kindred Trades Association, and the defendant is Mr. James Flynn, Trades Union agent, who was formerly sole agent and secretary of the Association.

The plaintiffs sought to recover their books and other property that the defendant retained in his possession; and defendant counter-claimed for damages, declaring that he was still the general secretary of the Union, and seeking for an injunction to prevent the plaintiffs restricting him in the execution of his duty.

Mr. L. Sanderson, K.C., and Mr. Jos. Sharpe, instructed by Messrs. Howson, Dickinson, & Nanson, appeared for the plaintiff; and Mr. Langdon, K.C., and Mr. T. Mansfield, instructed by Mr. E. Atter, were for the defendant.

Mr. Sanderson, in stating the case to the jury, said the plaintiffs, Senogles, Sanderson, and Corkhill, were trustees of a Trades Union called the Cumberland Iron ore Miners' and Kindred Trades Association; and the defendant is Mr. James Flynn, who up to the 12th July of last year was general Secretary of this Trades Union. The Trades Union consists of iron ore miners, with five branches at Egremont, Cleator Moor, Moor Row, Frizington, and Kirkland. Each includes several mines. Under the Trades Union Act, the whole of the property of the Trades Union is vested in the trustees. They are the people who are responsible for its safe keeping; and the rules provide that they shall continue in office during the pleasure of the Association. It had been the custom to re-elect them; but he submitted that once elected they remained trustees until death, resignation, or until the pleasure of the Association was expressed otherwise. The trustees were required by the rules to zealously guard the interests of the Association, and see that no money is paid contrary to the rule. The supreme government of the Association was vested in the Council, which was made up of representatives sent for each lodge, together with the President, Secretary, Treasurer, and Trustees. Council meetings were to be held in January and July each year, the January meeting to be the annual for the election of officers. The general secretary was required to notify the different lodges of all meetings, by circular, seven days before such meeting, together with a list of the business to be transacted. "A special meeting of the Council shall be called by the general secretary if required." No question was to be entertained by the Council which had not been previously laid before the members, except questions or cases which might be considered urgent, which might be dealt with after the regular business had been disposed of. Then the general secretary (that was the defendant in this case) had to be elected by a majority of the members of the Association; his duties were defined; it was provided that his wages should be fixed by a majority or the members generally and paid fort-nightly; "he shall be under the control of the general Council, and shall obey their direction"; and that he should give and receive three months' notice before leaving the service of the Association. Now what was the position? He thought the jury when they had heard the facts would come to the conclusion that there never had been a more unmeritorious and unworthy defence than had been set up in this case. The plaintiff Association said that the defendant was dismissed on the 12th July last year; and that in spite of that he had retained a sum of money belonging to the Society, and books belonging to the Society, and went on holding himself out and acting as the general secretary of the Society. The defendant says he has not been dismissed, and he is relying upon certain technicalities, or to put it in another way he says the proper procedure has not been adopted by the plaintiffs or the Council or Association, and that he is still their secretary although a ballot has been taken and all the members who had a right to vote, as to whether he should be discharged or not; although there was a majority of seven to one in favour of his been discharged; although out of some 2,400 members, 2,100 odd were now paying members of the Association, and the defendant had only a paltry 200 or something like that who were his supporters; although it was a plain as a pikestaff that this Association would have none of him, he had brought the plaintiffs there and put this Association to the expense of this trial, simply because he said the proper procedure had not been taken to dismiss him, and then he thought the jury would be even more surprised at the course which had been taken by the defendant and his advisers in this case. The defendant formerly himself an iron ore miner, became a member of the County Council. His election expenses, and, he believed, also his travelling expenses, were paid out of the Association's funds. He became also a member of the District Council, of the Board of Guardians, and a Justice of the Peace. The result was not an uncommon one, that the defendant had, to use a colloquial expression, become too big for his boots, and the result was paid far more attention to his duties of J.P., County Councillor, and so on, than he did to the Society of which he was general secretary. So long ago as 1905, different branches had passed resolutions that he should be called upon to retire, as he was not attending to his duties in the way he ought to do.

Mr. Langdon said none of these resolutions had been given to the defence. The whole point here was the construction of these rules.

Mr. Sanderson said he did not agree to that.

The learned Judge: I understood the question is whether he has been properly dismissed?

Mr. Sanderson said that was one question. They said he had been properly dismissed in accordance with the rules; but they said secondly that his conduct was of such a nature that the very existence of the Society was endangered.

The learned Judge: Does that empower you to dismiss in any other way than provided by the rules?

Mr. Sanderson: Yes, we submit it does.

The learned Judge: What is the relevancy of the resolution passed by these lodges? It is questioning whether he has mis-behaved himself, you must prove that the resolution does not prove it.

Mr. Sanderson said he ought to show that there was such dissatisfaction with the defendant that it became necessary to get rid of him, for the safety of the Association had an inherent right to do so.

The Learned Judge: That may be; but how are theses resolutions evidence? I think you are only fighting a shadow; you can prove it in some other way.

Mr. Sanderson said if the resolution was not sent to defendant at that time, as he believed it was, he knew all about it. But he would not say anything more about what took place before the crucial time 1907. He was now drawing the attention of the jury to certain facts which he would submit to them at the proper time were evidence of such misconduct, or such conduct, as to endanger the very existence of the Society, so that it became necessary to get rid of him somehow or other, especially as his own acts, the things he had himself done, had prevented to a large extent these rules being carried out. He would give then an instance. One of his defence was that he could not have been dismissed except at a special general meeting of the Council, and he said there was no such meeting held, and then he went on to say that if there was such a meeting held, it was not called by the general secretary. That was himself; and so far from the Society being able to call a special meeting, it was impossible, because he had said he would not call a meeting of the Council obey the Council, or the defence. In May, 1907, the annual meeting that ought to have been held in January had not been called by the defendant. Pressure had been put upon him to call a meeting, but he had not done so. There was a good reason for it; because he knew that when the next meeting of the Council was called there were certain things that would have to be faced. To begin with, he had not produced to the Council the three last balance-sheets, which was a very serious matter indeed. The defendant knew that a resolution had been passed by one of the pits in 1907 calling upon him to resign, and there were other things which he knew he would have to face at the meeting of the Council. What did he do? Without the slightest authority and without the knowledge for a very long time of the members of the Council, he proceeded to get together another Council. He went round to the pits and persuaded some of the men to appoint a Council in another way. Up to that time the Council had been appointed by lodges, each lodge sending so many men to the Council. Mr. Flynn proposed a new plan altogether, entirely off his own belt. He suggested that each pit should send a member to the Council, and that for the future the Council should be elected in that way and not has it had been in the past. He sent out a circular asking the various pits to take a ballot whether they were in favour of each pit sending a delegate to represent it on the Council; and he stated that he did so on a resolution of the Cleator Moor and Frizington lodges. That was the proposal that he made on his own account; it was absolutely untrue that a resolution had been sent in by Cleator Moor and Frizington lodges. The evidence would show that at some of Mr. Flynn's meetings he told the men this was authorised by the Council; at all events he never told them that it was done without the authority of the Council and against the wish of some of the members of the Council to whose ears that proposal had come, as it was contrary to the rules and had never been brought before the Council. Well, having got as he thought the means of getting a new Council together, Mr. Flynn then called a meeting of the old Council, or as counsel said he should call it, the real Council. That meeting, the first held in the year, was held on the 7th June. It ought to have been annual meeting, and the election of officers and so on ought to have been provided for. Instead of that there was only on the notice of the meeting "Notice of resolution from the mines and other business." The meeting was held and the 18 members were present. The Council knew by this time what Mr. Flynn had done with regard to the formation of this other Council, and they refused to receive resolutions from the pits because they said they ought not to be sent from the pits but from the lodges, and further they said there was a much more serious question than that to be discussed and that was Mr. Flynn's own conduct. At that meeting a resolution was brought from the Ullcoats mine, which was in the Egremont lodge, and which was by far the largest mine in the Union. Of course the Council having refused the other resolution from the pits could not accept that one; but Mr. Flynn was given notice that the resolution of this large body of men was that he should be dismissed. This was a very important matter. The Council had heard that this man had without their knowledge for a long time, always without their consent, to a certain extent by mis-representation of the real facts, had obtained from the men at the different mines — some of them, not all of them, because some of them had objected to it at once and would have nothing to do with it — resolutions in favour of each pit sending its own representative to the Council. There was a Council already; Mr. Flynn proceeded to bring another Council into existence. He would not give way, and therefore there were two Councils — one elected in accordance with the rules, the other brought into existence by Mr. Flynn. He actually went so far as to summon four of those new representatives to the proper Council meeting of the 7th June; three of them went out of the room when they were objected to, but the other insisted on staying and stayed during the whole of the meeting. Mr. Thomas Burns was in the chair at that meeting and it was agreed to adjourn till the 14th June, as the matter was not one they could deal with at once. Mr. Flynn when he left that meeting said he would not send out notice for the 14th June. At all events he did not do so. Mr. Burns received a letter from Mr. Flynn stating that he was not going to attend on the 14th, as the new Council had come into existence, and there was not the slightest reason why he should attend "the" Council, as counsel called it. Counsel drew the jury's attention to this, as he claimed that this was almost sufficient for his case. Mr. Flynn refused to attend a meeting of the Council or to obey its directions. Counsel submitted that defendant ceased to be secretary then, on the 14th June. These were inexperienced men, merely iron-miners, who were endeavouring to do the best they could for their Society. What was to become of the Society, if they were going to have two Councils? It was going to be broken up at once; two sets of collectors, two treasurers, two set of trustees, two Councils, two everything, and the result would have been chaos. It was the duty, counsel said, and the right of the Council at that time simply and solely to get rid of the man, and one would not at all have been surprised had they passed a resolution dismissing him there and then. He suggested that Mr. Flynn dismissed himself. But these men showed considerable common sense and business capacity. No, they said, we will make it as right as we can. We cannot call a special meeting, but we will adjourn this meeting, originally called by the secretary, and adjourn it from time to time, and we will take the opinion of the members of the Society. Therefore on the 17th June it was resolved by the Council to call a meeting, and with that object posters were put up in different parts of the district, asking the members to attend a general meeting of the Society on the 22nd June. On the 22nd June that meeting was held at Cleator Moor in the Market Hall, and the place was full. Mr. Brereton, who had been elected president, was in the chair. Mr. Flynn was there, Mr. Senogles, one of the trustees, and one of the plaintiffs in this action, was there. Mr. Brereton got up and explained what the meeting was about, also Mr. Senogles, who read the resolution which by that time had been sent by the Egremont Lodge instead of by the Ullcoats mine, asking that Mr. Flynn should be discharged. It was a very rowdy meeting and the rowdiness was supported by Mr. Flynn and his friends; even Mr. Flynn himself interrupted some of the speakers. The result was that there was such confusion and chaos that finally Mr. Flynn and his supporters left the meeting followed by other members of the Association. Thereupon the Chairman said, and he submitted to the jury very wisely said, well it is quite impossible to form any opinion as to the feeling of the meeting, and we will have a ballot taken and see what is the feeling of the members about dismissing the secretary. He submitted that having regard to the means the Society had in its hands, that the Society proceeded to take the opinion of the members in the most careful way. They sent out a circular explaining all the circumstances and arranged for a ballot, by which the Council said they were quite willing to be bound what ever the result. The ballot was held on the 3rd July. The result was 769 in favour of dismissal, and only 163 in favour of keeping Mr. Flynn as secretary. This result of the ballot was brought up at a Council meeting on the 6th, when 17 members of the Council were present, and it was unanimously received in view of this ballot that Mr. Flynn should be dismissed. On the 12th July written notice was handed to Mr. Flynn and the sum of £39 in cash handed to him by the treasurer in lieu of three months' notice. Mr. Flynn read part of it and then threw it on the ground, saying it was only waste paper — that it was a notice sent to him by a Council which did not exist, and that he would not accept the £39 or the notice. If the defendant did not cease to be secretary on the 14th June when, he refused to obey the directions of the Council, he was certainly dismissed on the 12th July. But defendant would not recognise the ballot nor the Council. He continued to act as general secretary, and continued to have a certain amount of money collected at the various pits; he sent out collecting cards and books and held himself out as the general secretary of the Association and up to the present time he still maintained that he was still secretary of the Association. Plaintiff's Council then issued a writ in the names of the trustees and made an application to the learned judge for an interim injunction, and an interim injunction was granted restraining him from acting or holding himself out as general secretary.

The Learned Judge said the injunction was merely to prevent him interfering with the management of the Association, not to prevent him from saying that he was secretary. To have decided that he should be permitted to say he was general secretary would have been to have decided the action. It was merely to prevent injury to the affairs of the Association; it was not intended to decide anything, he thought.

Mr. Sanderson said the words of the injunction were that he was prevented from acting or purporting to act as secretary. After that the collecting books and cards were used by the defendant were altered and "Cumberland Iron Ore Miners" was made "Iron Ore Miners," "Cumberland" being left out. The plaintiffs said that was not abiding by the injunction, and applied to the Court that defendant should be committed for content. The learned judge did not see fit to do that, but he was told that he made a remark.

The Learned Judge: I don't think remarks made are very relevant. There are a great many remarks made. (Laughter.)

Mr. Sanderson: If your lordship says go I will not mention it. The learned council went on to say that defendants tried to get his "Iron Ore Miners Association" registered on the trades union register, but they would not register it because they said it was too like the one already existing. The name was changed to the "National Iron Ore Miner's Association." The defendant published what purported to be a balance sheet of the "National Association of Blastfurnacemen and Iron Ore Miners, Cumberland Iron Ore Branch." He continued going on as before, only under a different name. With regard to the books and the money which defendants had in his hands, the learned counsel said he could not understand what defence to this action there could possibly be. The property is vested in the trustees by Act of Parliament, and if the defendant was called upon to hand over the property he had absolutely no right to refuse whether he was secretary or not. He was asked to do so on the 12th July, and he was asked to do so by solicitor's letter on the 24th July last year, and he had never given the trustees the money which he had collected after he was dismissed. The affairs of the Society had improved enormously since the defendant was dismissed. Confidence had been renewed; and the miners knew where they were, and they had a Council in whom they could trust, and the subscriptions were coming in better than before.

Wm. Joseph Senogles, examined by Mr. Sharpe, said he was a member of the Cleator Moor Lodge and working at Ullcoats Pit.

Intervening in the examination of witness, His Lordship said he took it that the questions for the jury were — whether the Council which dismissed the secretary was properly constituted? and whether the meeting at which he was dismissed was properly convened?

Some argument followed on the rules, and the learned Judge observed that one good rule the Society had, which might be adopted in Parliament was that no-one should speak more than five minutes. (Laughter.) The question for the jury was whether the general meeting was properly summoned?

Mr. Sanderson: I understand that is the only point.

Mr. Langdon argued that the Secretary was only removable by a special general meeting.

His Lordship asked if that was not a question for the Judge.

Mr. Langdon: It is not a question for the jury.

His Lordship: What other question is there for the jury?

Mr. Sanderson: The misconduct of the defendant — whether he was guilty of such misconduct as would justify us in dismissing him.

His Lordship: That seems to be a question for the jury.

Witness said he was treasurer of the Ullcoats Lodge. He was a trustee of the Society. In 1905 he was elected a trustee of the Society, and re-elected in 1906 and 1907. There were between 26 and 30 pits in the Association and five lodges. At the end of each year an election of Councillor or delegate took place in the lodge; a representative was elected for each 100 members. In 1907 the Council was composed of 30 members. The ex-office members were Mr. Redmond, Mr. Sanderson, Mr. Cox, and Mr. Clark. In June, 1907, Mr. Cox resigned, and Mr. Corkhill was appointed in his place. As regards the annual meeting called by Mr. Flynn on the 1st June for the 7th June he verbally requested Mr. Flynn to call a meeting more than once from January to June, but he did not do so until the 1st June. Defendant said he would call the meeting, but did not do so until 1st June. In May witness became aware that Mr. Flynn was taking steps to form another Council. He received a copy of that resolution that representatives be sent from the pits instead of from the lodge. As a member of the Cleator Moor Lodge he remembered a discussion on that question, but not the resolution read. As the result of a circular issued a meeting took place at Ullcoats Mine, and a resolution was passed condemning the proposed new scheme. Witness was present at the meeting of the Council on the 7th June when four new Councillors were introduced. They said there were pit delegates, but objection was taken to their presence, and all went out but one. At the meeting on the 14th June the Chairman (Mr. T. Burns) read a letter from Mr. Flynn, which letter witness understood was retained by Chairman.

Here Thos. Burns was called, but he said he had not got the letter. He believed it had been burned with other old papers. The effect of the letter was that Mr. Flynn refused to act for the new Council, and they looked upon it as a dismissal.

Mr. Sanderson: A dismissal of himself?

His Lordship said there could not be a dismissal of a man by himself. He could resign or give up his position.

Mr. Langdon, interposing, said he was anxious to shorten the case if he could. He was prepared to say this. There was such a difference of opinion between Mr. Flynn and the Council that they would be justified in dismissing him in the proper way the law allowed, whatever that was.

His Lordship: That is as much as you can expect Mr. Sanderson. You do not admit anything improper, Mr. Langdon?

Mr. Langdon: I do not, my Lord.

His Lordship: You admit there was justification in his conduct in dismissing him if it could be done legally.

Mr. Sanderson said he was not at all sure that was sufficient for his purpose. Assuming they had not complied with the rules he was going to submit that the conduct of the defendant was such as to make it impossible for them to comply with the rules, and that under the circumstances it was absolutely necessary for the Council to take the steps they did.

His Lordship: That is a question of law?

Mr. Sanderson: I don't agree upon the misconduct.

His Lordship: It does not matter how great the misconduct was if there is a way properly providing for dismissal you must take that way however great the misconduct may be. His Lordship went on to point out that there might, however, be circumstances that rendered this impossible. The defendant might have picketed the place so that a general meeting could not be held.

Mr. Sanderson said he would submit that the question for the jury was — Was there such misconduct on the part of the defendant as would justify the Council in removing him without complying with the rule?

His Lordship: Isn't that a question for me — it is not of fact.

Examination of Senogles was then continued. Witness was of opinion that the effect of the letter was that Mr. Flynn was calling his own delegates together, and saw no use in calling the old delegates together. He was not present at the meeting. There were no keys, and witness went to an ironmonger's and got some skeleton keys, and opened the door. The meeting had been duly called, and witness thought they had a right to get into the room. At the meeting of the 7th June the Ullcoats resolution was brought up, up ruled out of order. That resolution was Mr. Flynn be given three months' notice. The understanding was that the meeting should be adjourned from time to time until the crisis was over. At the mass meeting the resolution of the Egremont Lodge came out. It was to the effect that the Association dispense with Mr. Flynn's services. As soon as the resolution was read Mr. Flynn left the meeting, which broke up in consequence. It was a very disorderly meeting. Mr. Flynn got a fair hearing, but afterwards when it was seen that Mr. Flynn's party was making a noise their members retaliated. After Mr. Flynn left witness told the meeting there would be a ballot.

After the luncheon the examination of witness was resumed. Witness was present at the meeting of the 6th July. Including officials there would be 18 or 19 present. A resolution was passed which dismissed the Secretary in the terms of the ballot. A small committee of the Council was appointed to meet Mr. Flynn. The committee consisted of Mr. Brereton, Mr. Sanderson, and witness. The first-named tendered Mr. Flynn £39, which he refused to take. He read part of the resolution, and then threw it down, saying he wanted nothing to do with that.

Cross-examined by Mr. Langdon: The largest membership was about 2,400. At that time there were about 2,000, and out of these about 900 members took part in the ballot. There were resolutions from the Cleator and Frizington members that representation should be by pits instead of lodges. It was not the case that the whole dispute between Mr. Flynn and the Council had its origin in this question of the representation of the outside pits. The Council would have been able to consider it, but they did not. His opinion was that pit representation would lead to delegates putting pit interests before those of the general union. If the Cleator Moor Lodge had instructed him to vote for that he would have done it independent of his personal opinion. Mr. Flynn forfeited his confidence when he misled the Council in September, 1905. No personal motives had influenced him against Mr. Flynn, but he said he would do his best to have him removed in accordance with the resolutions. In 1907 Mr. Flynn received a testimonial, but the Association contributed a very small amount. The ballot against Mr. Flynn was taken in the lodge rooms. If they wanted to get the opinion of all the members they took it at the pit head. The ballot for the next secretary was taken at the pit heads. They did that because Mr. Flynn's supporters had criticised having it at the lodges.

Re-examined by Mr. Sanderson: Mr. Duffy had a majority of 1,000. The figures were 1,644 for Mr. Duffy; 108 against. Mr. John Burns was the only one he had heard suggest pit instead of lodge representation. He had a seconder on one occasion. In September defendant lost witness's confidence because of a statement respecting £100 lying in a bank at Workington, which had been the subject of debate between Mr. Sharp and Mr. King. Witness found that statement to be incorrect.

By the Judge: The meeting broke up when Mr. Flynn went out because his supporters rose in various parts of the hall and went out, breaking up the meeting. The Council did not call another meeting because considering the high feeling displayed at that meeting they thought another meeting would mean nothing else than a riot. When on the platform Mr. Flynn told witness that if he was going to bring up personal matters he (Mr. Flynn) would leave the room, but witness replied that it was a personal question and must be dealt with.

John Redmond, school attendance officer and a friend of the defendant for some time, said up to October, 1907, he was treasurer of the Union. He first heard of the proposal to change the representation from the lodges to the pits in the early part of 1907. Witness told him it was not workable, and that it ought to go before the Council. Mr. Flynn said that he thought it would be the best way, and that it would be either that way or nothing for him. Witness suggested that it would be a violation of the constitution. Witness said he thought it would be disastrous to trade unionism in the district. Mr. Flynn pooh-poohed the idea, and said a fortnight's organising would put matters right. He spoke at the mass meeting, which ended in a fiasco. There was no order, only disorder and chaos. Both parties were on the platform, and there was high feeling. The feeling got worked up. It was Saturday night. That might have something to do with it. (Laughter.) It was considered that the ballot was taken in a fair and honourable way. In trade unionism they want a good deal on points of honour.

By the Judge: It was considered that the ballot would be unquestioned, and no questions of litigation arise.

By Mr. Sanderson: He did not think another meeting in the same place would be as orderly as the first had been. (Laughter.)

Cross-examined by Mr. Langdon: He could not say whether there was a lodge at Whitehaven or not. The Council organised the ballot. The papers were supposed to be distributed at the mines. On the 14th June Mr. Burns was appointed secretary pro tem. Mr. Burns was not present.

He ought to have kept a book saying to which lodges he had sent the ballot papers. It would be an awkward thing if Mr. Burns had forgotten to send the ballot papers to one of the lodges. They were all a bit excited. Senogles spoke in favour of the resolution he had read. Mr. Flynn admitted the truth of what witness had said as to mismanagement of the affairs of the Association, and said "We all err, I don't pretend to be perfect." Witness had been saying that it was a critical time for the Association, and they wanted to put the matter fairly to the members. Mr. Flynn's agreement with what witness had said, that it was a critical time, that there was friction between the secretary and the Council, and the question was which of them was to have it. If the resolution went against the Council they would have resigned. It was thereupon that Mr. Senogles moved the resolution that Mr. Flynn be dismissed. He made some remarks after he read the resolution. Mr. Kelly, witness thought, next supported the resolution. Mr. Kelly's opinion was that Mr. Flynn had not been giving satisfactory service to the Council. Mr. Flynn was the only one who spoke from the platform on his own behalf. All the others on the platform were members of the Council. The disorder became so great that it was evident it was no use putting the resolution, and the resolution was not put. The meeting broke up. Mr. Brereton tried to prevail upon the audience to give a hearing, but the meeting broke up in disorder — several people on their feet each one wanting to speak at the same time, and none of them willing to give way to the others. There was a great deal of noise, but no real violence.

Then it comes to this, that the meeting broke up like a suffragette meeting, because they were all wanting to speak at once? I have never been to a suffragette meeting. (Laughter.)

By Mr. Sanderson: Mr. Burns was not here. He was in America, he supposed. The Whitehaven lodge would have somewhere about 30 members in 1907.

Peter Kelly said he was the secretary of the Egremont lodge, and produced the minute book. The Egremont lodge, with 968 members, was the largest in the Society. Witness had been a member of the Society for about nine years, and during that time had known Mr. Flynn. Witness being asked what was his opinion of Mr. Flynn's general conduct, the question was objected to, and was not pressed. Witness said he had sent several letters to Mr. Flynn requesting him to call a meeting of the Council. No meeting was called prior to the 7th June. He was present at the Ullcoats meeting. He read the circular on pit representation to the men. They were against it, and they passed a resolution that Mr. Flynn be dismissed. The Egremont Lodge ultimately adopted that resolution. The Ullcoats resolution came before the meeting of the 7th June, and was ruled out of order. The notices respecting the Conciliation Board were posted at the pit heads without the authority of the Council. He could not remember whether Mr. Flynn's signature was printed on them or not. He was present at the general meeting, and spoke. He spoke of the confusion that prevailed in the Union owing to not getting returns, and also of three balance-sheets that had not been adopted by the Council and had got out to the members. These balance-sheets were for the quarter ending December, 1906 the annual balance-sheet for the quarter ending March, 1907. He was one of the officers appointed to look after the ballot on the 3rd July. He was present at Egremont all the time except when he went for lunch. It was a Co-Operative Society's ballot-box and the secretary of the Society came and locked it. Every voter's name was checked. Mr. Doyle sealed the box at the close and it was subsequently taken to Frizington. They did not consider it wise to hold another general meeting. They were afraid there might be some disturbance.

Mr. Langdon: Up to June, 1907, can you point to any resolution of the Council censuring Mr. Flynn? On June 28, 1906, there was a resolution of the Frizington Lodge that Mr. Flynn be dismissed. Mr. Flynn excused himself, and promised to do better, so it was not put to the meeting. About July, 1905, the same resolution was proposed, but the chairman, Mr. Dobie, ruled it out of order. Personally he did not wish to get rid of Mr. Flynn, and had talked to him. As regards the difference in the number of votes in the Flynn and Duffy ballots, when the first were held in the lodge rooms some of the Egremont men had to travel to Cleator Moor to vote, and some of the Cleator Moor to go to Egremont, and they would not do it.

Mr. Langdon: Some of the men were disfranchised.

His Lordship: I don't know about being disfranchised; they did not vote.

Cross-examined continued: Those who kicked up a row at the mass meeting were drunk. Some of each side were drunk, because, unfortunately, it was Saturday night. If it had been held on any other night they would not have got so many members there.

Mr. Langdon: Better have all the members there than have half the members drunk.

By his Lordship: If they had got a meeting where the men were not drunk they could have got a decision on the question from the meeting.

Cross-examination continued: There had been disturbances at previous meetings. They had had meetings concerning strikes.

Mr. Langdon: If would have been an unpleasant thing to have taken a vote at that meeting if the Council had been defeated? There were some men in who were not members.

Mr. Langdon said it would be an invalid meeting.

His Lordship: It does not follow that it is an invalid meeting because some men got there who should not have been.

By Mr. Langdon: That was one of the reasons why the vote was not taken.

The main reason? — One of the reasons.

Mr. Sanderson: There was never a general meeting of the members of the Society before? — Never.

By Mr. Sanderson: It is not wholly due to some of the men being drunk, but owing to some personal matter relating to Mr. Flynn that the meeting ended so unsatisfactory. They thought the wisest course would be to take a ballot of the members' lodges.

By his Lordship: They could have got a decision from the meeting, but they thought it more satisfactory to submit the question to a ballot.

Mr. Sanderson: Why not hold another meeting? — The inconvenience of members getting to the meeting and the state of feeling which existed.

Mr. Sanderson: You have been asked about these minutes not containing any censure on Mr. Flynn. I suppose Mr. Flynn kept them himself? — Yes.

Thomas Sanderson a member of the Union for 19 years, said he was a member of the Cleator Moor Lodge. He had been a Councillor for four years, and a trustee since 1905.

His Lordship: Mr. Sanderson, is it necessary to go into all this. The case rests on broad points?

Mr. Sanderson: Very well, my lord; I won't bother this witness any more.

John Hulley, treasurer of the Cleator Moor lodge, said that he and Messrs. John Fleming and Wm. Martin conducted the lodge ballot. He was there the whole of the day from eight o'clock in the morning until about seven. Some of them were there all day. Mr. Flynn was there during the day. When a man came in they asked him his name and when they found he was in the book they handed him a voting paper and ticked him off on the book.

His Lordship: You don't dispute Mr. Langdon that there was any unfairness after the votes were in the ballot boxes.

Mr. Langdon: Oh, no. We don't charge any unfairness.

Witness further examined said that at Cleator Moor 141 people voted.

Cross-examined: The stamp of the Quarrymen's Association stamped on the ballot papers was an old stamp. No quarrymen were allowed to vote.

By Mr. Sanderson: He thought Mr. Flynn had addressed meetings in that district before the ballot.

His Lordship: I may take it that that evidence applies to the other lodges.

Gabriel Thomas, a member of the Council for Moor Row ever since its commencement, said that in May last year in Cleator Moor he met Mr. Flynn, who told him of the new scheme of pit representation. Witness told him that it would be the ruin of the Association.

By Mr. Langdon: He did not think there were many illiterate miners in the district.

Wm. Edwards, formerly treasurer and now president of the Frizington Lodge, said he got a receipt from Mr. Grears for money paid to Mr. Flynn, the sum of £13 14s 6d being the sum taken to pay delegates.

By His Lordship asked what was the breach of the rules.

Mr. Sanderson said he supposed the suggestion was that Mr. Flynn intercepted money that should have gone to the general treasurer.

Peter Marshall, member of the Egremont Miners' Union, said he remembered James Hogg, an agent for Mr. Flynn, coming to the pit collecting money for Flynn in 1907.

Mr. Langdon admitted that Mr. Flynn had continued to act as secretary and collected money.

Noble Dawson said he had been Councillor for the Egremont lodge since 1905. The defendant spoke to him about the proposed change from pit to lodge representation about a month before June. Witness said it would have to go before the members. When Mr. Flynn came in June to speak at the pit at Bigrigg he said that the sanction for the new scheme had come from the Cleator Moor and Frizington lodges. Witness told him that it ought to have come before the Council. Mr. Flynn told him it had come before the Council, and it was put to the meeting and carried. Witness objected to the resolution being put as he did not think it was legal as it did not comply with the rules. Witness was proposed as secretary of the proposed pit lodge but he declined to act. The whole of the members of this lodge, the Egremont lodge, were in favour of the Council.

Wm. Kearns, a member of the Frizington Lodge, and working at Margaret Pit, said that in November, 1907, he saw a notice posted at the pit in the name of the Cumberland Miners' Association.

His Lordship: If Mr. Flynn was properly dismissed you are entitled to an injunction; it not properly dismissed what has this got to do with it? Evidently these gentlemen think the jury are going to try which of these gentlemen are right, but we have no power to do anything of the kind.

Henry Crellin, auditor of the Society, said he could not tell how many members were paying at the present time. He could not tell from the last audited balance-sheet.

Before adjourning, His Lordship again referred to the points to be submitted to the jury.

Mr. Sanderson submitted that but for defendant's conduct a decision would have been arrived at by general meeting.

His Lordship: I have great doubt as to whether there is any evidence of prevention on the part of the defendant.

Mr. Langdon submitted there was no evidence.

His Lordship: I have great doubt whether there is any evidence, but I will leave it to the jury.

Mr. Langdon said he was prepared to put his client in the box. The defendant differed from the Council as to the proper pit representations, and did take up that attitude. Whether right or wrong was for the judge to rule. His brief was not prepared for a case of that kind. But he was prepared to put his client in the box, and he wished to know the case he had to meet when the court reopened.

His Lordship: Mr. Sanderson says he so conducted this agitation that he raised such an amount of ill feeling that they could not have this meeting and decide it.

Mr. Langdon: I don't think it necessary to call evidence on this point.

His Lordship: The other question I was going to ask the jury was whether the way in which the ballot was taken was a fair way and arrived at the opinion of the members.

Mr. Langdon: On that point we can give no evidence at all.

His Lordship: You don't think the defendant's evidence necessary.

Mr. Langdon: Unless there is something definite against him I don't want to put him in the box for the whole case to be re-opened.

His Lordship said he had the greatest doubts as to whether there was any evidence of prevention by the defendant. With regard to other matters. The ballot with a poll 920 under one system did seem unsatisfactory compared to one with a poll of 1,700 under another system, and he did not know what view the jury might take of that. But supposed the defence succeeded, and the case was technically dismissed, and then supposed the Society called another meeting to-morrow?

Mr. Langdon: That us what I felt when I suggested a ballot at the outset.

His Lordship: And suppose the plaintiffs succeed and are technically right there may be difficulties and troubles to say nothing of appeals, therefore it is worth while to consider if a poll satisfactory to both of you, that would express without a doubt the will of the Association, would not that be the most satisfactory ending? Perhaps you will consider it, because both of you have got difficulties to consider.

Mr. Sanderson: We are very much obliged for your Lordship's suggestion. If we let it stand over until to-morrow morning, perhaps your Lordship will give us some assistance?

His Lordship: I don't think it is an unreasonable suggestion. It there is any chance of it being done the sooner it is done the better.

The Court adjourned at five o'clock.

Second Day's Proceedings

Mr. Justice Pickford took his seat on Wednesday at 10.30.

At the outset Mr. Langdon asked for one minute in which to consult the other side.

After an absence of about 55 minutes Mr. Sanderson, returning into Court at 11.25, said : I am sorry we have kept your Lordship so long, but I hope it will be disposed of in another minute or two.

His Lordship: I don't mind if it comes to something.

Mr. Mansfield then entered the Court, and said his learned friend would be in in a minute.

His Lordship: Very well, Mr. Mansfield, you are coming in by degrees.

Mr. Mansfield: It has been very hard work.

Mr. Langdon now entered the Court, and after a short consultation with Mr. Sanderson and Mr. Flynn,

Mr. Sanderson: Now, my Lord, I am glad to say there is an end of this matter at last. My learned friend, Mr. Langdon, and I have agreed, with the consent of the parties — I think that accounts for the time we have been discussing it, my friend and I could have settled it sooner. There will be judgement for the plaintiffs in accordance with the terms of the statement of claim; and as an account is part of the claim it will be necessary to have an account taken, and my learned friend and I have agreed to have it taken by solicitors; that, if it is necessary, that we should apply to your Lordship to grant an injunction that the defendant will return the property which he now holds belonging to the plaintiffs. My Lord, with regard to the drawing up of the order with regard to the account, we have agreed that the form of the order shall be drawn up by my learned friends, Mr. Mansfield and Mr. Sharpe, the juniors in the case. My Lord, each party will pay its own costs, and there is only one other thing for me to say and that is if, during the case, I have inadvertently made any suggestions against Mr. Flynn I entirely and unreservedly withdraw them.

His Lordship: I did not understand, and I do not think the jury understood, there was any imputation on his character.

Mr. Sanderson I only want to make it clear.

Mr. Langdon: My Lord, may I just add a word. Mr. Sanderson apologised for the length of time we took, but obviously it was not my case nor Mr. Sanderson's case, but a case in which feelings are very much concerned, and in spite of Mr. Sanderson's tactful conduct of the case, there have been allegations and imputations of an indefinite kind, but as he stands, however, now his character is untouched. Mr. Flynn has been advised, and he thought that, in the interests of the men — and he was largely concerned with their interests — that the matter should end. He has his Association and they have their Association, and in the interests of trade unionism he thought it best that the matter should end.

His Lordship: I think it is an extremely satisfactory settlement. I have not the least idea what the jury would have decided, and although I don't say what I would have decided, but I have some ideas. But whatever the jury decided it would not put an end to this dispute, which obviously is a matter of very great importance to the Association, and to the miners who are not members of the Association. I think it is very much more satisfactory to the parties to come to an amicable agreement, and I am sure that any time occupied has not been wasted. It is very much better they should come to an agreement among themselves than that they should have got a decision that would have been no decision whatever, as it would only have decided the immediate dispute. I don't think that in the pleadings there are any suggestions against Mr. Flynn's moral character or against his character at all. I don't think there appeared to be any suggestion as to his character in the case as it was tried. There seemed to be no grounds of anything against his character. It seems perfectly untouched by anything that has gone on here. I hope it will be an end, not of the difference of opinion, but the difference of feeling among the members of the Association and the miners generally.

Mr. Sanderson: Will your Lordship give judgement in the terms agreed upon, and leave to apply.

His Lordship: Yes.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, E.      
Burns, Thomas      
Crellin, Henry      
Dawson, Noble      
Dickinson, —      
Edwards, William      
Flynn, James      
Grears, —      
Howson, —      
Hulley, John      
Kearns, William      
Kelly, Peter      
Langdon, —      
Mansfield, T.      
Marshall, Peter      
Nanson, —      
Pickford, Justice      
Sanderson, L.      
Sanderson, Thomas      
Sharpe, Joseph      
Thomas, Gabriel      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print