|
16th January 1908 Fatal Result Of Accident At Oatlands PitCoroner And The Manager's DutiesThe unfortunate man, David Thomas Ellison, of Barnghyll Cottages, Distington, who, on the 7th inst., fell from a gangway on the pit bank at Oatlands Colliery, and broke his back, died in Whitehaven Infirmary on Saturday night. An inquest was held at the Infirmary on Monday evening by Mr. E. Atter (coroner for West Cumberland) and a jury, of which Mr. R. Wilson was foremen. Mr. Wm. Leck (inspector of Metalliferous mines) was present, and Mr. H. Morrison (manager of Oatlands Pit) was also in attendance. Wm. John Ellison, engineman, Barnghyll Cottages, brother of the deceased, stated that the latter was 29 years of age, and was employed as pit headman and weighman at the Moresby Colliery Company's Oatlands Pit.. His brother had worked there for 14 or 15 years, and witness was also employed there, and had known the gangway at the pithead for 12 to 14 years. At this stage a plan of the bridge or gangway was put in by Mr. Wm. Graham, jun. Ellison, continuing his evidence, said the middle rail in the fencing on the side of the gangway was off, but was put on again shortly after the accident. The bridge had been under repairs. There were two sets of lines along the gangway, where the bogie got off the metals on the day in question. It was not an exceptional thing for tubs to get off the line, but he had never known any person to fall or slip in the way his brother did. Patrick Johnston (16), of 59, Pica, said he was employed at Oatlands, and his duty was to attend to the tubs. The tub referred to got off the road on the gangway about half-past twelve on the 7th. It was a full tub, and Ellison got a prop for the purpose of putting the tub back on the metals. While he was trying to do this the prop slipped, and Ellison fell through the opening where there was no rail. The Coroner: If the rail had been there how far would he have gone then, do you think? Witness: Well, I could not say. Have you known tubs to go off before? — Yes. Did they often do it? — Yes. Ellison sometimes helped to get them back. The rail had been put on again since the accident. Men were working at the gangway a few days before, and witness and Ellison did not know the rail was off. By Mr. Morrison: Mr. Miller looked after the place. The Coroner: And did he give orders for the rail to be put up afterwards? Witness: I don't know. Mr. Humphreys (a juror): Do you think there is enough protection at this place at present? Witness: Yes. By Mr. Gair (another juror): He could not say how long the rail had been off. Mr. Morrison: If you had known the rail was off would you have reported it? — No, sir. You would not do so? — Well, it was not any place to do that. By the Inspector: The rail was not knocked off in order to give Ellison more room to use the prop. George Miller, engineer at Oatlands Colliery, said he saw Ellison working on the gangway on the Tuesday, and trying to pit the tub on the rails again. He did not see him fall, but he went to him immediately after the accident. Ellison, who was quite conscious, then told him that as he was putting the tub on to the metals again, he slipped, and went right through the railings. The ground below the gangway was very hard that day. Ellison was taken into a little office, and a doctor was sent for. In the meantime witness examined the inured man as far as he could. Ellison complained of pains in his chest. By the Coroner: He did not know the rail was off until after the accident. He passed over the gangway that morning shortly after seven o'clock, but it was dark at that time. The man was lying along the gangway when witness saw it after the accident. He could not say whether Ellison could have knocked it off in falling. The rail was 13 or 14ft. long, and was fastened by nails to the posts. The same rail had been put up again. By the Foreman: If the ordinary rail had been there he might have broken it if he had hit it hard. The Foreman: I don't think it would have broken it. By Mr. Gair: Ellison did not blame anybody for the accident. In reply to another juror (Mr. M. Hexham) witness said the rail was nailed on from the inside. By the Inspector: The rail was broken at the end, but was quite whole at the point where Ellison fell off. The Inspector: So it seems pretty clear that the rail was not on when Ellison fell? Witness: No, I don't think it had been on. If it had it should have been strong enough to prevent the man from falling off the gangway. It was his (witness's) duty to see that all dangerous places were properly fenced off. Assuming that it had been properly fenced, according to your own judgement, would that have prevented the accident? Yes. - Well it was always considered a safe gang way. If that bridge had been properly fenced off, according to your own judgment, that would have prevented the accident? - Yes. Replying to further questions by the Inspector, witness said he last remembered seeing the rail about four working days before the accident — when the joiners were employed on the gangway going repairs. The joiners had been working there, on and off, for several weeks. The actual height of the bridge was 22ft. 9in. That was the distance Ellison would fall. He had known the gangway to have been working about 19 years, and no accident had occurred during that time. It was not a very regular thing for tubs to get off the metals at those points. Witness was across the gangway several times a day in the ordinary course of his duties. Ellison was using a sort of pole when trying to get the tub on to the metals again. He was an excellent servant, thoroughly steady and reliable, and well acquainted with his work. Henry Morrison, the manger, stated that he had been at Oatlands Colliery six months. He went over the place every day to see that all was safe and sound. He was there the day before the accident — between two and three o'clock in the afternoon. He did not then notice anything wrong with the railing. The first time he knew that anything was wrong was about an hour after the accident about a quarter to one. Asked if he went to the gangway and examined the railings, witness replied in the negative. The Coroner: Why didn't you go to the place as manager? Witness: When I got word of the accident I went to where the man was. I first went to his assistance. Ellison was in the weigh cabin, and witness stayed with him until the doctor came, about half-past one. What did you do after that? — I waited until the doctor made his inspection of the injured man and a trap arrived to take him to the Infirmary. What time do you think he was taken away in the trap? — About twenty minutes past two. How far were you then from the gangway where the accident happened? I was still at my pit cabin, 40 or 50 yards from the scene of the accident. What did you do after half-past two? — I gave instructions to the joiners to go and repair the gangway. Did you see it? — No. Why? Will you please tell me why you didn't go and see and inspect the gangway, as manager? — Well, for the reason I didn't know there was anything wrong with it at the time. Then how could you give orders for the joiners to repair the place? — A joiner came and reported it to me. Then you must have known something was wrong. Why, then, didn't you go and inspect it? — I have no other reasons than I have given. Can you give us no other reason? It is a serious accident that has happened, and you were told by the joiner that something was needed? — Because I was very anxious about the injured man. The man had gone to the Infirmary. Why didn't you go and see the place after he had gone? What time did you give the orders to the joiner? — About two o'clock. Is there any explanation or not why you didn't go and inspect this place? — The day shift deputies were coming up the pit at the time, and I went to meet them. That was more important than going to see about this other, was it? — I don't know. Do you not think you ought to have gone and inspected the place yourself, as manager? — Well, I sent the joiner to repair it. Do you think you should have gone or not? — No, answer. Did you hear the question I asked you? — Yes, sir. Well, I am waiting for an answer? Do you or do you not think you should have gone and inspected this place? You were only about 40 yards from it? — I don't think so. Why do you think you should not? — I sent a joiner to repair it, and I expected he would do so. Without seeing the place or inspecting it yourself? — Yes. And you have been manager for how long? — For six months. The Coroner: For six months. The Foreman (to the witness): I think there was a great amount of neglect on your part in not going to look at the place. Witness: It would not have saved the accident. The Coroner: No, it would have saved the accident. Is that all you think of it? Was it not your duty as manager to try to prevent another accident? For any attention on your part there might easily have been another accident. Witness: I sent a joiner, and expected it was done. The Coroner: Well, if you would do your own work, instead of sending someone else, you would better fulfil your duties. Mr. Gair: Did you know the rail was off the place? — Witness I didn't know. You are supposed to know? — It was off, then I would get word of it. The Coroner: Then you would not go and see it done. The Inspector asked witness if the rail had been up, would it have been sufficiently strong to have prevented Ellison from falling? Witness said it would depend on the force with which he would go against the rail. The Inspector: Have you some suspicion that the fence was not strong enough to keep a man from falling if he went against it? — Witness: No. Supposing the rail had been on, would it, in you opinion, have prevented the accident? — I think so. The Foreman: I quite believe it would. By the Inspector: He could not see from the cabin that there was any defect in the fence, and did not know there was any until the joiner reported it. The joiner said there was a rail off, and should he go and repair it. Witness told him to go and repair it, and make it safe. The Inspector: You thought that was sufficient? — Witness saw the place next morning. Miss Evans, matron at the infirmary, stated that Ellison, who was suffering from spinal injuries, died about ten minutes past eight on Saturday night. The Coroner, in summing up said, although they had no direct evidence, he thought the jury would come to the conclusion that the rail was off, and that probably through the rail being off. Ellison fell from the gangway. The question for the jury to consider was whether there was anyone to blame for neglect, if there was neglect through default of the rail not being on. Speaking for himself, he thought Miller, who was the responsible man, gave his evidence creditably and in a straightforward manner. He did not seem to shirk the responsibility which was upon him. He readily admitted to the inspector that the liability was upon him to see that any dangerous places were properly protected, and he also gave the opinion candidly that the rail was not on at the time of the accident. He could trust his evidence against that of Mr. Henry Morrison, and he must say that it was not within his recollection that unsatisfactory evidence had been given by a manager than had been given by Mr. Morrison. What was his statement? He was the manger, and the person to have the superintendence of the pit, and the one to whom the men trusted to have protection provided for them. In a measure he was right in waiting until the injured man was removed, but he (the Coroner) should have thought that most persons and especially most managers, whether of six months or more experience, would have gone and inspected the place themselves to see what had happened, and what was needed to be done. That however did not suit him, but he gave his order to a joiner, and although he himself was within a short distance of the place, he did not go. He (the Coroner) agreed with what the Foreman had said — that there was a very great amount of neglect on the part of Mr. Morrison. The Foreman said the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," and were of opinion the accident might have been prevented if the rail had been looked after, and put back in its place. The Coroner: You don't find that there was culpable neglect on the part of anyone? The Foreman: There was neglect. The Coroner: But not culpable neglect? Several Jurymen: No, no. The Foreman said the jury quite agreed with the remarks which the Coroner had made with regard to Mr. Morrison — that he did not look after the place as he should have done. The Coroner (addressing Mr. Morrison): You heard the observations I made to the jury, and also the remarks of the Foreman, that this place had not been properly looked after by you. I quite endorse what the jury have expressed. It expresses entirely my own opinion. Mr. Morrison said the reason he did not go to look at he place was because he was very much upset at the time owing to Ellison getting hurt, and knowing him so well. Moreover, he had to go to the telephone and arrange about Ellison's removal to the infirmary. The Coroner: But why did you not go after he was taken away? You had ample time then, seeing that it was only a short distance away. Mr. Morrison: That is all I can say about it. I thought the joiner would make the place safe. The Coroner: The suggestion is that you, as manager, should have gone to see the place where this accident happened.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||