Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th January 1908

The Explosion At William Pit, Whitehaven

The Resumed Inquiry

The resumed inquest on the unfortunate men who were killed in the gas explosion at William Pit on November 26th was held on Tuesday in the police-court, Whitehaven. The names of the deceased are: Wm. Vincent Fitzsimons, Jos. Kennedy, Alfred Burns, Wm. Hanlon, and James Rowe.

The inquiry was conducted by Mr. E. Atter, coroner for West Cumberland, and a jury of whom Mr. R. Wilson was foreman.

Mr. L. T. Helder represented the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and these were also present: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines; Mr. H. A. Abbott, Assistant Inspector; Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Metalliferous Mines; Mr. T. P. Martin, representing the Coalowner's Association; Mr. A. Sharp; Mr. J. Hanlon, Mr. T. Cape (of the Cumberland Miners Union); Mr. T. Milburn, working on behalf of the relatives of the deceased; Mr. R. Smillie, Lanarkshire Miners; and Mr. H. Roughlay, Lancashire Miners, representing the Miners Federation of Great Britain.

At the outset the Coroner said he had received notice that Mr. Smillie had been appointed to represent the men.

John Graham, deputy was re-called, and in answer to Mr. Smillie said he started work in the pits at the age of 14. He had been fireman about 13 months, and had worked at timbering at the coal face, but never as a hewer. He had not any personal or practical experience in boring or shot firing. He was acquainted with the Mines Regulation Act so far as his duties were concerned. He was aware that under general rule 4 a competent person appointed as fireman must make examination with a locked safety lamp before the men went in. His duty was to see that no person passed the lamp station until he had made an examination. The men stopped at the bottom of the drift, with the exception of the shot firer, until he had been in and made an examination. He considered that he carried out the provisions of the Miners Act. He thought the shot firer was a likely person to go with him. He would not say that the taking of the shot firer with him was a breach of the Act. The shot firer was competent person to go with him.

Mr. Helder said the question as to whether there was a breach of the Act was for hereafter.

Replying to further question by Mr. Smillie, witness said if he had found gas he would have entered it in the report book. He was in the habit of starting the fan before going to the face of the drift. It was the duty of the overman if he found gas to clear out all workmen before he expelled it, and he would have done so had he found any gas.

Mr. Smillie said if the witness used the fan to drive gas out before going into the place he could not ascertain whether it existed or not.

By Mr. Helder: The shot-firer was an authorised official. Burns was shot-firer on this occasion.

In answer to Mr. Milburn, Graham said that in the report book on October 11 he reported gas. When he took the shot-firer in then went up to the face.

Wilson Graham, foreman, was also re-called, and replying to the Inspector of Mines said he passed the end of the drift at 1.25 on the day of the accident, and he then thought there had been a runaway. He was in the cabin when a cloud of gas went by and the chargeman said he thought there had been a fall.

John Rothery gave evidence as to the time the deceased men had been in the employ of the Company.

John Graham, deputy overman, stated that he was down the pit at three o'clock in the afternoon on November 25. On leaving the pit at half-past ten the previous night all was right.

By the Inspector: He was deputy for the Lowca district. He was in the drift at half-past ten at night, and the shot-firer and two men were in. He did not find any gas at the face. He did not examine further back for gas.

By Mr. Milburn: When he left the drift on Monday night there was the refuse from the last shot, which was left for the incoming men to clear up.

Thomas Moore, drifter, who appeared with a bandaged head, said he went to work in the drift at six o'clock on the morning of the 25th November. He was working in the face and Kennedy was with him. He was at the bottom of the drift when the accident occurred, and he remembered nothing afterwards until he reached the pit top. He was hurt on the forehead and on both legs, and was eight or ten days in the infirmary. He was still suffering from the extent of his injuries.

By a juryman (Mr. Kerr): He saw the holes properly stemmed.

By the Inspector: He was burned on his finger but not on his face. He did not see any flame. The first he heard of a runaway was when Cowan told him, but he felt no difference in the air owing to the runaway. On going to the bottom of the drift he found half-a-dozen tubs laden with metal were overturned. The mouth of the drift was not blocked by the tubs. Witness was able to get past. They were working at the tubs about a quarter of an hour before the explosion occurred. He heard three reports while at the bottom of the drift, and immediately after the last report came the explosion. He saw gas showing when Burns examined the place, and when he spoke to Burns the latter replied there was a little gas. Witness helped to stem the holes. He put the clay in all the nine holes. He put no small coal in the holes, and could not account for it being found there after the accident. They put from eighteen inches to two feet of stemming in the holes. He was employed by Rowland Williams the contractor. The door at the bottom of the drift opened after the second report and did not close again. Witness went to try and shut it, but could not, as it was jammed. The door would perhaps remain open between five and ten minutes. He could not say what the effect of the door being open would be.

By Mr. Milburn: There would be six or seven of them trying to separate the tubs, which were piled on top of one another. The ventilator pipe was all right, as the tubs were all on the opposite side. He could not say what the doorway was jammed with. As far as he was told Kennedy was found through the doorway. Only three were left in the face while others were ordered out to attend to the tubs. They were not ordered out for safety. He was aware there was an accident in this same drift on Midsummer's Day owing to gas and fumes. The fan would be working at a distance of from 60 to 70 yards from the face. The air piping would be carried to within eight or ten feet of the face. He remembered the fan being changed because it was not giving sufficient air. When witness got to the face on the 26th the lamps burned all right. He often helped Burns to fire the shots. As to the system of drilling the holes were drilled wedge shape. On this occasion some of the holes were drilled straight in.

By Mr. Smillie: In drifting the drift they crossed some faults in one of which was seam of coal. This gave off gas nearly the whole of the time they worked it. They followed the deputy up from 80 to 90 yards to the face. Sometimes the chargeman went in with him. Seven of the holes were bored in a little coal seam and the corner or side holes were bored straight in. He had been told there was blown-out shot, but in his opinion all the holes were properly stemmed. There was a great hurry to get this place through, and he had known the shot-firer refuse to fire shots on account of gas. On June 24 witness was carried out of the place unconscious owing to being "gassed." At that time the fan was in. The archway at the foot of the drift was not very large and if the tubs were up to the top he thought it might check the air a little. He thought it would have been safer under the circumstances to have stopped shot firing after the tubs were upset. He did not know that the drift could have been driven without shot firing. His lamp had gone out many a time on account of gas. It would be natural that a deputy would also find gas in the same place. Witness never found gas at the face of the working after the fan was put in. He thought it would have been safer after the accident to the tubs to have stopped the shot firing and withdrawn the men.

By Mr. Milburn: The entry on Midsummer Day that the main end of No. 6 drift was fenced off on account of gas would refer to this drift.

In reply to Mr. Helder, witness stated he had worked in William Pit six or seven years, and had followed the pits about 15 years. Referring to the accident on Midsummer's Day he did not mean there was an explosion. Some of them were overcome by the fumes of the explosive. He did not know if a different kind of explosive was now used. When he found gas on his lamp he did not report it. He did not know there was a rule that anybody finding anything dangerous must cease work and report it.

By the Inspector: He remembered a fall at the dilly top, but it was not a very large one, though it took more than one shift to clear it away.

By the Coroner: The accident on Midsummer's Day was the only one that had happened to him in the seven years. Shot-firers named John Henney and Alf. Burns had both refused to fire shots to witness's knowledge. He had no opinion whatever as to the cause of the explosion.

William Cannon, 25, Irish Street, Whitehaven, said he had worked for the Colliery Company for about three years. On November 25 the deceased were all working along with witness. He had to assist with the runaway tubs and at the time of the explosion was working at the bottom of the drift. Close by were Moore, Kirkpatrick, Cowan, Evans, Moore, and Kennedy. Witness was badly cut about the head and his left leg and knee were very bad yet. He was not burned but rendered unconscious.

Replying to the Inspector, witness said he was at the face when the runaway occurred. He knew nothing about it until Cowan came up and told him. The shots were then ready for firing. On the last occasion when witness saw Burns the latter stated he was going to re-charge one of the shot holes. At that time witness was in a manhole and he had left the face as the holes were all charged. He heard one report previous to that, and it would probably be the firing of the flanking holes. When witness was working at the face on November 26 he did not see any gas. Runaway tubs was not a common occurrence, and witness only remembered it happening once previously. Directly the fan started the deputy and the shot firer usually went in, and when the deputy gave the word that all was clear the other men entered the drift.

By Mr. Milburn: He did not know if they wanted the drift through by Christmas. He did no know if it was uncommon thing to put seven shots in a thin seam of coal. He understood that the accident in June was due to fumes from the explosive used. Nobody attributed it to gas within his knowledge.

By Mr. Smillie: He did not know that the injuries to Moore and himself caused in June were due to insufficient ventilation. When they went to work they did not always wait at the foot of the drift, but sometimes went in to the manhole. They were never told it was against the law for them to be there. The deputy reported to them at that point that all was clear. He (witness) had gone in to work the fan. The fan man always went in with the deputy to work the fan and he was not an official. He had been one of the drifters all the time, and was told sometimes there was a little gas. Witness had seen it on a lamp. He thought the deputy once reported the presence of gas. He had never done any stemming himself, and did not take any notice how much stemming was put in these holes.

In answer to the Inspector, witness said when Burns told him that a shot "had not got" there were also present a young man named Kirkpatrick and Fitzsimons (Deceased).

Rowland Williams, contractor, Bransty, said he had contracted for the last 14 years, and was down the pit every day superintending the work. On November 26th he was in No. 5 drift, and on the previous day was in No. 6 drift some time in the morning. He had seen it better than on that occasion, although the pipes were disconnected from the fan. The men however, put it right in a few minutes. There was a little accumulation of gas in the face by the time the pipes were put right. Witness did not detect the gas himself, for when he got to the face it was clear. He was aware it was a place that gave off gas, and they had made all possible provision for the safety of the men. He had no control over the sot-firer, who was not in his employ. In his time he had seen hundreds of shot-firers, but never saw a more cautious man in his 40 years' experience than Alf. Burns. The men in the dilly had to do all they could, but were not to work under undue pressure or take any risks at all.

Replying to the Inspector Mr. Williams said he did not think the disconnecting of pipes would often occur. Practically all he had to find was the labour. The shot-firer, the fan man, and the dilly man were employed by the Company. The fan man was supposed to change at the fan, and as far as witness knew this was carried out. The Company had to provide him with sufficient ventilation, and witness had to complain once or twice on account of ventilation, although the Company generally did their best. It was however a difficult place to ventilate. In his opinion there was plenty of air to ventilate this drift if everything was right. Witness had told the under-manager sometimes that they could do with more air, and the latter had always done his best. The time the canvas galley was put in the working, witness was off work. He thought Burns was cautious because he fully examined every little corner and one day he would not fire because he thought there was a little gas about 60 yards from the face. Witness did not wish the shots to be fired if there was the least possible risk. His opinion of the explosion was that the runaway tubs had caused a current of air that had driven gas from somewhere into the drift, where it had entered a crevice, and from there reached the face and had been ignited by a shot. Witness thought if one of the shots "had not got" it would be one of the flanking holes, and if that blew out the flame would strike the side of the drift.

By Mr. Helder: There was no more than the usual amount of gas in this drift considering the circumstances. Whenever he spoke of the ventilation to the officials they always gave the matter their prompt attention. Since they changed the kind of explosive used he was not aware of any more men affected by the fumes.

By Mr. Milburn: There were two little seams there, and they therefore expected gas. He could not say when it was that Burns refused to fire the shots, but it would be some months ago. He never looked into the report book to see what was reported, but left all that to the officials, who were responsible for the place. There was a seven inch vein of coal and underneath it a foot of clay. They bored eighteen inches, right into the clay, and did this because it would cause less confusion.

By Mr. Smillie: Witness employed his own men, although the overman or manager could object to any men they liked. He took his men according to the work they were required for. He was of the opinion that a blown-out shot had been stemmed, although the best of men could overlook a thing like that. Blown-out shots were not common. It was quite true he only expressed his opinion from what he saw afterwards. He had never seen flame from "Saxonite." He had driven many drifts through solid stone, and the ground of this drift was solid. He had seen a brick wall put up the centre of a drift to ensure that good ventilation, but it was quite possible that had a brick wall been put in No. 6 drift it would not have made the ventilation much better. He did not know whether one of the fan men was only a lad, but there were two or three men, who had been told to relieve the fan men now and again. The ventilation in this drift was fairly good in comparison with some. Witness had never paid any attention to the screen in the drift, because there were men who had to see to it. He had seen gas himself many a time.

At this point the proceedings were adjourned for an hour.

Upon resuming, James Smallwood was called, and stated that he lived at Whitehaven, and was a coalminer. He was also a delegate for William Pit. He had been in the habit of visiting William Pit on the workmen's account. Witness did not keep a special book, but he was bound by the Act to make a report before he left the Colliery. On the occasions he was in the pits he made reports.

By the Inspector: he was in the drift on the morning of the accident somewhere near half-past ten. They visited No. 5 and No. 6 drifts, and the reason he visited No. 6 drift was to see how far it had advanced. The men were not in at the time, but were getting their "bait." He saw the under manager examining for gas, but he (witness) did not see the result of his examination. In their report they recorded the watering of the main roads to keep down the dust. They believed it dangerous, as he had been led to believe the dust might explode. He recognised the fact that if the flame had reached the coal dust there might have been a loss of over 100 lives.

By Mr. Helder: He did not examine the place as he was not there for that purpose. He had never had any difficulty with the employers, who would always carry out any reasonable request.

By Mr. Smillie: There were two different places for the report book. In case of No. 6 drift the lamp station is at the bottom of the drift. In his last report in December he stated there were places that had not been fenced in, in which were fire damp. He did not know if as a result of that the inspector for the district had made an examination. It was quite by accident he was down the mine on the day of the explosion on other business. He had heard complaints about the ventilation of this drift, and he thought a brick wall as suggested would ensure quite adequate ventilation. He knew that the Company changed the explosive when they became aware of the deadly nature of the fumes. It was the duty of the deputy under the law to make sure if there is any gas in the workings. He thought a blown-out shot had something to do with the accident, as it might set in motion any gas lurking in crevices. After the accident he was down the mine, but never saw any broken lamps or anything. He thought the "caution" notices that had been recently erected carried out the provisions of the Act of Parliament.

By the Coroner: He never made a report that he did not consider the ventilation sufficient. He however, thought it was not sufficient for the comfort of the men, although he never reported it. He did not think the ventilation was so insufficient as to be dangerous.

Replying to Mr. Milburn, witness said he was accompanied round by Wilson Graham.

John Rothery, under manager, was again called, and said he descended the pit about quarter past eight on Nov. 25. He was in the drift about a quarter to ten, and all seemed right. He heard about a quarter past two of the explosion, and when about three quarters of a mile from the pit mouth he heard what was wrong. He met all the injured men on the way out, and remained in the pit until about ten o'clock at night when the bodies had not been found. At six o'clock the following morning he again descended the mine, and was close at hand when the bodies were found. Hanlon, Burns, and Rowe were the first three he saw. He thought from every standpoint he could view it from that the concussion from the first shots caused some rents or fissures in the roof, and the extraordinary atmospheric conditions prevailing at that time caused gas to come from the top or eighteen inch seam. At the same time they must take into consideration the runaway tubs, which might reverse the air current. He was afraid if the blown-out shot had been insufficiently stemmed it was somebody's fault.

By the Inspector: This drift was really going into virgin ground, and they naturally expected a little gas. As far as he could remember, the natural ventilation in this drift was only about 500 cubic feet a minute, or about a hundred and twentieth portion of the current down the main road. He suspected there was a little gas at the face, and gave orders for the fan to be turned before anybody entered. He did not think General Rule 1 was carried out in this particular drift on Sundays when the fan was standing. They could only divert a portion of the air current into Number 5 drift, as there were two large districts beyond depending upon it for ventilation. He was not aware that some of the drifters went beyond the foot of the drift before the deputy had concluded his examination. His view, after hearing the evidence, was that they only entered a manhole 20 yards from the foot of the drift, and they would be preceded to the point by the deputy. There must have been flame from the face of the drift to within 120 yards of the foot, as a sleeper was found on fire at that point. He could not account for all the air pipes being flattened.

In answer to Mr. Milburn, witness said the runaway tubs partially blocking up the entrance to the drift would increase the danger, if there was any. He believed that Graham set the men to work to remove the tubs.

By Mr. Smillie: The fall of the barometer on that morning was an addition to any danger that might be caused by the runaway tubs. Had witness known of the fall of the barometer at the time he would have taken additional precautions? He believed it was right that a fan-man or driftsman should accompany a deputy into a drift. He did not believe it any breach for a deputy to take company.

Mr. Smillie said that the law held that a deputy must make an examination, and a workman must not go beyond a certain point until then.

Witness said he had always thought he was justified in sending someone with the deputy for company.

By the Coroner: He did not think it was right now.

By Mr. Smillie: If men accompanied the deputy into the drift as far as the second manhole — within 100 yards of the face - they would be causing a breach of the rules. He would be astonished if it was proved that the workmen passed the lamp stations before the deputy had concluded his examination. Any gas given off in the drift would have been rendered harmless had the air current been three times as strong. In view of what had taken place he thought a brick wall would have been desirable. The contractors were paid by the yard but he was certain this place was not being hurried through too quickly. He was aware their deputies must be competent persons, and as he knew the men personally he could easily tell their competency. John Graham was a very young deputy, and had had no experience as a shot firer, but witness considered him a practical and fairly intelligent person. He considered all the deputies were thoroughly competent persons, and expected they were carrying out the conditions of the Act. Had he been aware they were not he would have attended to the matter. On October 28 his attention was called to gas being in the drift, but he positively denied giving instructions to anybody not to report gas if they found it. He believed it was reported in the books that shot-firers had refused to fire shots, and if this was on account of gas that ought also to have been put in the book. He knew that if the workmen put in their reports that they apprehended danger, a copy must be sent to the Inspector of Mines.

By the Inspector: When the deputy took a companion it was to work the fan before they went in.

Samuel Turner, manager of the Colliery Company, said he had occupied that position for the last nine years. He attended at the pit every day, Sundays included. He had just come up the pit at the time of the explosion, and immediately went down again. He was in No. 6 drift that morning about twenty minutes to ten when everything seemed all right. He did not consider the work was being unduly pushed forward. He had confidence in all the men, and thought they were capable of carrying out their duties. When witness arrived on the scene they had found Kennedy and Fitzsimons. There was no the least trace of burning. The other three bodies were found on Wednesday night, and from their position Burns appeared to have apprehended danger before his death. His conclusion of the explosion was that it was easy accounted for if the door was open, although that was news to him. Gas would have gathered. The runaway tubs were also an important factor, as the reversion of the air current would have brought out all the gas in the crevices above, and then when the air settled back to the usual course it would carry the gas before it, and the men in the drift would be caught like rats in a trap. The fall of the barometer on that day was somewhat unusual, and there was nothing like it during the whole of 1905. If a shot was properly stemmed it could not blow out. He put great importance on the duties of a shot-firer, and he had full confidence in those holding the position.

By the Foreman: Burns would be left to his own discretion, as was only natural.

By the Inspector: He knew that runaway tubs could reverse the air from his own experience. He was surprised when he heard one of the shots "had not got." That meant the charge had gone of without dislodging the metal, and of course the hole would then have to be charged again. He knew that ventilation had to be constantly produced and considered on Sundays that the ventilation of the pit was sufficient to keep the drift clear. It had been proved that there was natural ventilation in this place. He was not aware of the men passing the lamp stations. There were notice boards that had been erected, and these were renewed from time to time.

By Mr. Helder: A brick wall had been erected in a district in which there was an explosion even greater that this.

The manager said these men have never reported danger.

By M. Helder: Anything required for the safety of the men was carried out irrespective of cost.

By Mr. Milburn: He could not reason why Graham, the deputy, knowing the danger from the falling barometer did not call the men out.

In answer to Mr. Smillie, the witness said he was satisfied the officials were competent, and he also believed them to be careful. If the men entered the drift with the deputy and proceeded to the second manhole before he had made his examination it would be a breach of the regulations. If a companion went beyond a lamp station with a deputy that was also wrong. He admitted a considerable number of the notices had been renewed within the last five weeks. He thought there was sufficient ventilation in the drift, although he did not think it would go on in the future as it did before the explosion. They expected getting the drift through by Christmas, but at the distance they had to get through he did not think they were being unduly hurried.

By the Coroner: He thought the last accident was in 1904, when a lad was killed, but there had been no other gas explosion except this one in November since he became manager. No suggestions had been made by the inspector since the accident as to how something might be done to remedy matters.

John Hanlon, miner's agent, said he agreed generally with the evidence given by Mr. Smallwood.

John Kirkpatrick, driftsman, said he began working in No. 6 drift about seven o'clock on the morning of November 26. He was not a practical man, and although he had heard there was an accumulation of gas he could not say whether it was so or not. He went down to help with the runaway tubs, and after he had heard three shots fired he knew nothing more until the wall stopped him. (Laughter.) His elbow suffered a compound fracture, being completely splintered. From what he could judge Burns was a careful man.

By the Inspector: When he was in the manhole near the face after they finished boring there were others present, but only two of them were now alive - Cannon and witness. The others were Burns, Hanlon, and Rowe. He saw Burns make up another shot after he had stated a shot "had not got." Witness was perfectly sure he was burned on various parts of his body. He could not account for the other men not being burned.

By Mr. Smillie: John Graham was almost invariably their deputy. He had never been in No. 6 drift on Sunday night, although he generally worked on that day. He never troubled about ascertaining whether there was gas or not, but left that to somebody else. He had only been in the pit eight months.

Richard Walker Moore, mining engineer, said he had been acquainted with William Pit for the last 33 years. He was in No. 6 drift some two months before the accident, when they had crossed the fault and got the 18 inch seam of coal. He thought the ventilation was quite sufficient for what was being done, as they were merely making this drift to improve the haulage road. William Pit was a very old one, and shortly after commencing there were some very disastrous explosions. The last one was in 1882. Witness was one of a search party, and saw the first three bodies being brought out. He thought the gas emerged from a seam in the roof of the drift, and had been wafted out of the drift, and had been wafted out of the "rafting" and had crept up, to the face. Some of it might only be about three inches in depth, and had easily escaped the attention of Burns. The explosion would be due to one of the shots, either through it being insufficiently stemmed or not stemmed at all. He thought the accident was one of those things that could not be foreseen.

By the Inspector: He did not interfere in all the details of the working of the colliery. He was not responsible for the working of the pit, and could only go by what he saw.

By Mr. Smillie: He had been a mine manager himself for 14 years. The 18 inch seam had not been worked in any part of the colliery. His duty was mainly to see that the colliery was worked safely, and should he notice anything likely to endanger it he would certainly interfere. He had known considerable amounts of gas being given off from small seams, but this 18 inch seam did not give off much gas. The use of iron air pipes were quite customary in collieries, and he did not think anything could have been done to prevent the loss of these lives. He thought it would have been wiser to have withdrawn the men on November 25th after the tubs had run away and the barometer had fallen, but it was easy to be wise after the event. He was not prepared to suggest anything that would prevent an accident of this kind happening in the future.

Mr. Atkinson gave evidence. He arrived in Whitehaven on November 25th and went down the pit about 11.30 at night. He found them engaged about half-way up the drift. When they got the three bodies witness left the pit. On a subsequent occasion he examined the face of the drift, and found that a shot had apparently blown out. He did not attribute the explosion to the coal dust at all. The explosion came from a charge of "Saxonite" coming into contact with fire damp. If it was proposed to continue that drift he thought better ventilation should be obtained. Previous to the explosion there was barely sufficient ventilation, and he did not think there was a large enough margin. He considered the position of the fan in the drift at the week-ends was a breach of General Rule 1.

By Mr. Smillie: He thought if the workmen reported gas being given off a copy of that should be sent to him (the Inspector). If the deputy was be accompanied by someone else when he was making his examination it was a breach of the regulations. If he were the manager he would not work this drift in the same manner as it had been worked. A set of runaway tubs did not often signify much in a pit, but on this occasion it was of rather more importance. The deputy should have gone in and made his report on an examination before he used the fan, as it drove out the gas and they therefore could not find any and report it in the book.

The Corner, in summing up, said he did not purpose detaining them long as regards the observations he had to make. Regarding the accident the Colliery Company had given them every facility that could be given, and helped the jury and himself to appreciate the evidence given at the inquiry. The professional gentlemen present had enabled them to have the hearing of all concerned, and they had had an exhaustive inquiry. The case for their consideration was when and how these poor deceased men came by their deaths. There can be no question in our minds that what was the cause of death was an explosion of gas. As regarded the witnesses if they were of the same opinion as himself, the evidence of one and all had been given in a highly satisfactory manner. He thought there was the one desire on the part of all who had been called to give the true facts of the case. A great deal of evidence had been given to them, and he did not say wrongly, as regarded alleged breaches of the bye-laws in the regulations. On that, if they considered they were breaches, they were not to adjudicate or take any notice whatever. The only question was, had there been neglect and fault on the part of those persons who had the management and control of that colliery, and if there had been, it must be - before they could condemn such persons — such culpable neglect that they should be held responsible for this loss. There did not appear to be any such breach on the part of any-one. He suggested the evidence was clear end distinct: that the accident was due to an explosion of gas. He totally failed to see, from the manager downwards, that there had been any culpable neglect on the part of anyone.

The jury retired, and returned in 30 minutes. The Foreman said their verdict was "The jury are of opinion that these five men lost their lives by an explosion, but how the explosion occurred there is not sufficient evidence to show, and they are also of opinion that there was not sufficient ventilation in No. 6 drift."

The Coroner suggested that "gas" be put in to show the nature of the explosion.

A juryman suggested "fire damp," but there apparently being some difference of opinion on this point the jury again retired, and were absent almost half an hour.

On their return the Foreman read the amended verdict, which was as follows: "The jury are of opinion that the five men lost their lives in No. 6 drift, William Pit, by an explosion of gas, but how it occurred there is not sufficient evidence to show; and they are also of opinion that there was not sufficient ventilations."

The Foreman added that he wished the Coroner to thank the Colliery Company for their kindness in allowing them to go down the mine and for the plans submitted.

The Coroner, on behalf of the jury and himself, expressed appreciation of the Colliery Company's action.

Mr. Smillie thanked the Corner, court officials, and the jury on behalf of Mr. Roughlay, Mr. Sharp, and himself for the kindness extended to them.

The coroner said he very much appreciated their kind remarks, and he was sure they were duly appreciated by the jury.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abbott, Henry Arnold    H.M. Assistant Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Burns, Alfred   26 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Cannon, William    Miner  
Cape, Tom      Whos Who Page
Fitzsimmons, William Vincent   22 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Graham, John    Deputy  
Graham, Wilson    Foreman  
Hanlon, J.      
Hanlon, William   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Helder, L. T.    Solicitor  
Kennedy, Joseph   22 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Kerr, —    Juror  
Kirkpatrick, John    Driftsman  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Martin, Thomas Pattinson      Whos Who Page
Milburn, T.      
Moore, Richard Walker    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Moore, Thomas    Driftsman  
Rothery, John    Under Manager  
Roughlay, H.      
Rowe, James   24 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sharp, Andrew      
Smallwood, James    Miners' Delegate  
Smillie, Robert      Whos Who Page
Turner, Samuel    Manager  Whos Who Page
Williams, Rowland    Contractor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Nov 1907  The Colliery Explosion at Whitehaven (The Times)
18 Nov 1907  Latest News, The Whitehaven Colliery Explosion (The Times)
27 Nov 1907  Colliery Explosion at Whitehaven (The Times)
28 Nov 1907  The Colliery Explosion at Whitehaven (The Times)
28 Nov 1907  Gas Explosion In William Pit, Whitehaven, Five Men Killed And Seven Injured (Whitehaven News)
28 Nov 1907  The Whitehaven Colliery Explosion, Latest News (The Times)
28 Nov 1907  Colliery Disaster At Whitehaven, Explosion In William Pit, Five Men Killed And Seven Injured (Cumberland Pacquet)
05 Dec 1907  The Gas Explosion At William Pit, Whitehaven, The Inquest (Whitehaven News)
09 Jan 1908  The Explosion At William Pit, Whitehaven, The Resumed Inquiry (Whitehaven News)
23 Jul 1908  Whitehaven Colliery Explosion, Mine Inspector's Report (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Whitehaven, William Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Report Page  Text of the official report into the incident

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print