|
5th December 1907 The Gas Explosion At William Pit, WhitehavenThe InquestThe adjourned inquest on the deaths occasioned by the gas explosion in No. 6 drift of William Pit on Tuesday afternoon, November 26th, was resumed on Tuesday morning in the Magistrates' Court, Whitehaven, by Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland. The names of the killed are :— Wm. Vincent Fitzsimons, aged 22, Bransty, single; Joseph Kennedy, 22, Queen-street, single; Alf. Burns, Bransty, married; W. Hanlon, Charles-street, married; Jas. Rowe, George-street. Mr. Robert Wilson was foreman of the jury. Mr. L. T. Helder represented the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and there were present: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines; and Mr. H. A. Abbot, Assistant Inspector; Mr. Leck, Inspector of Metalliferous Mines; Mr. T. P. Martin (Coalowners Association), Mr. Sharp, J. P. C.C., Mr. J. Hanlon, and Mr. Cape (Miners' Union), Mr. Tom Milburn, Workington, appeared on behalf of the relatives of Rowe, Fitzsimons, Kennedy, and Hanlon, Mr. Smillie (Lanarkshire Miners) and Mr. H. Raughley (Lancashire Miners) was present on behalf of the Miners' Federation of Great Britain. Mr. Milburn said he was instructed, before any witnesses were called, to apply for the inquest to be adjourned. Some of the injured men were still in hospital and it would be necessary to have their evidence, and it would be better taken when they were in a better condition of health than at present. He thought it was only just to his friend, Mr. Helder, to make the application at the outset of the case before any witnesses were called and before the case was disclosed on the part of the employers. He made that suggestion as he thought it very desirable it should be acceded to because he did not think he was sufficiently instructed that day to cross-examine the witnesses, and he did not want to make the application later on when cross-examination had been gone into. Mr. Helder would perhaps agree to that. Mr. Helder: I have nothing to agree to; I am entirely in the hands of the Coroner. As I expressed at the opening inquest my clients will offer every facility that the true cause of death may be ascertained. I am entirely in the hands of the Coroner; I don't think it is a question for me to express an opinion on. The Coroner: I have decided to go on with the inquiry to-day. There are a great number of witnesses present and should it be thought requisite later on I will be prepared to consider the application, but at present I think the inquiry should be proceeded with. Mr. Milburn: Just as you please, sir. Robert Blair, mining engineer and assistant general manager for the Whitehaven Colliery Co., said he had been mining engineer for about nine years. He produced two plans of the working places where the explosion occurred. Witness explained the plans to the jury. Evan Evans, 78, Scotch-street, Whitehaven, said he was a driftsman, and had been working for the Whitehaven Colliery Co. for almost seven years. He was working at William Pit on November 25th. He was on the first shift and his fellow workmen were the five deceased men and the six who were injured. The injured men were Wm. Cannon, John Nelson, Wm. Cowan, Evan Evans, John Kirkpatrick, John Hanlon and Tom Moore. They started their work about ten minutes past seven in the morning. Witness was employed by Roland Williams, a contractor, and when they started they were clearing the rubbish away and preparing to fire shots. The first shot was fired about twenty-five minutes to two and nine holes were made for the firing. The debris had been caused by shot firing on the previous shift. There was no smell of gas when they entered, and all seemed safe by vision and proving by the lamps. He had known gas to be there when the ventilation was not working. On the Monday before the accident there was some gas in the working when the fan was being shifted higher up. No shots were fired then. There was a report of three shots about twenty minutes to two, and witness saw the holes drilled by four of the men for firing. All the holes were drilled together. Two holes were fired at first and one afterwards and then one. No gas was given off after the first shot. The fireman, Alf. Burns, tested the place with his lamp, but there were no signs of gas. About five or eight minutes later he heard another shot, and these would be fired by Burns. Before the third shot he could not be positive in saying there was no gas as he was not there. A minute or two after hearing the fourth shot witness was carried away about 40 yards. He was not quite unconscious as he could remember thinking he was wrapped up in canvas and trying to get himself free. He was fast at the time, and seemed as though canvas was wrapped right around him. He had a cut on his head and near the eye, while his body was covered with bruises. The Coroner: What was the canvas sensation - a choking sensation? — I did not feel really bad at the time, and I tried to help the other men. The Coroner: There would be really nothing on you at the time? — Yes; I was fast at the time. Witness, continuing, said that afterwards he helped in the work of rescue, and he could hear the men shouting. The lamps had all gone out, and they were in darkness, and he was trying to help in the dark. They were working with safety lamps. Witness could not smell anything. Cowan was not badly injured, and helped witness to shout for help. The other men were fast. In five or ten minutes lights appeared, two or three, and the men tried to clear the way to relieve the men. He could not see or speak to any of the men at the time who were in the working. The fireman of the night shift, James Bigrigg, told them the place was all right before they went in. He put his initials in the working also, but witness could not see whether they were there that day or not. The Foreman: Can you explain the real cause of the explosion? — I have been trying to consider and cannot possibly think of the cause, because I was saying to my friends that if I was the shot firer at the time I would have fired 100 shots as regarded the appearance of the place. Everything appeared to be so nice and I don't know how it has happened. It is all dark to me. Are all the holes charged at once? — They are charged at once and fired separately. A Juryman: How far apart were the holes? — Well, they would be at least from 15 to 18 inches apart. A Juryman: What was the reason of the gas on the previous Monday? — It was because of the shifting of the fan from one place to another. Did you shift the fan on account of gas? — No, we were extending it as we were going along with the drift. We were taking the fan up with us. That was your usual way? — That was out usual way. The place looked very healthy at the time we were in. By the Inspector: The other shift were not there when they got there. They would be riding in as the other rode out. There were six or seven men at the place, not including the shot firer. Witness was chargeman. There was a seam of coal about seven inches thick near the bottom in which they drilled seven holes, two near the top coroners. They were machine drilled. The shots in the top holes would be 4ft 6in. to 5ft. long, and the flanking holes would be fully six feet. The others would be five feet or five feet six inches for squaring off purposes in the coal seam. Six or seven Saxonite cartridges were put in the large holes. There would be six in the flanking holes. The shots were fired by a battery with a cable of 66 or 70 yards extending from the face to the battery. The holes were damp or cleggy as they called them. The holes were stemmed with clay which was kept half way down the drift and carried to the face in a bucket. They stemmed all the holes with clay? The Inspector: Are you sure? — Yes. Just look at this (handing witness a small paper bag): That was in one of the holes that was not fired. It is small coal. The Inspector: That is not clay. Witness: It might be possible after the concussion of the shot to crumple up like that. Continuing, witness said he did not stem the holes that morning. The shot-firer stemmed them. Two men might help him. Several of them were engaged in putting the explosives into the holes. The explosives were under the charge of Burns, who kept them locked up. They generally put from 9 inches to a foot of stemming into the holes. The holes would be ready for firing about ten minutes past one. They had a wheel half way up the rising drift and to this two sets of rails were laid. Three full tubs ran down and pulled up three empty ones. The dilly hand came and asked for assistance to clear the way. At Burn's request witness went to see if things were right. Other men also had gone to see what was wrong. They went down to rectify these runaway tubs. After the firing of the first two shots witness went as close as possible to the face to examine it. Burns was standing close by and put his lamp up to the roof but there was no signs of gas. The battery would then probably be coupled on for the third shot, and Burns went to the battery while witness proceeded down the drift to the dilly wheel. Witness did not then go back, but afterwards heard another report. The next thing was the explosion, and witness never saw any flame. He however, felt a little heat but could see no dust. One of the tubs which were loaded with stones turned over, and another came on top of it. Two other tubs were overturned. The empty tubs always ran on the side next to the air pipes. He was sure they did not strike the air pipes or the door at the bottom as he heard it move after they had got to the bottom. Witness was employed by the contractor as a chargeman and he did not sign any reports for the Company. The air pipes began at fifteen inches, but at the top they were 20 inches. The pipes were slung up by wires, and the air came into them from the main haulage road. When they first inserted pipes they proved satisfactory at fifteen inches, while an inner gallery was formed of canvas. There was a good deal of escaping air. They then tried the fan and a four-inch pipe to blow a little air to the face, but this was used mostly to kill the fumes from the explosives. This little fan was, however, given up. At the time of the explosion the fan then in use was abut 60 yards from the face and Fitzsimons and Rowe were on the fan all the morning. They had to spell each other off, and while the fan was going there was nice air. Between leaving work on Saturday and starting again on Sunday night he believed the fan would be standing, and before going to work on Sunday night they would turn the fan until the air was clear. That was to clear it of gas. The drift was 450 yards from the haulage road with a gradient of 1 in 16. As regards the officials there that day he saw the overman Wilson Graham, in the drift a little after eight. He saw the underground manager, John Rothery, there chock on ten o'clock. Directly after that the manager, Mr. Turner, came with the miners' agent and miners' delegate, Mr. Hanlon and Mr. Smallwood. They were right up to the face. Mr. Turner was within a couple of yards from it. The Inspector: When the fan stopped at the week end was it a regular thing for the gas to collect? — I went once in three weeks at the week end and the foreman told men that it had to be worked before they could get to the face as there was generally a little gas. The Inspector that was that the system of ventilation was not sufficient to keep the place sufficiently clear? -Not without the fan. The Inspector: The fan had not been working. Cross-examined by Mr. Helder: Burns was an experienced man and had been shot firer five or six years as far as he knew. Burns had to examine for gas between the shots, and on this day witness saw him search for gas between the two first shots and the second one. Witness then left. Cross-examined by Mr. Milburn: He understood that Burns had been apprenticed as a mining engineer and had been in the pits all his life. He had not worked as a practical miner to witness's knowledge. The fan was connected with the air pipes, and Fitzsimons was the regular fan man. Witness had to send a man to assist him, and at the time of the explosion Rowe was working the fan. At that time Fitzsimons was coming away from the fan. Witness did not make reports, but he heard that on the day before the overman, Wilson Graham, made a report that the ventilation was not in working order. He had seen the "bosses" trying to better the ventilation two or three times. Witness had worked the fan many a time. Sometimes want of ventilation arose through the smoke from the shots and not clearing away quickly enough, and then the fans were worked quicker. There was a little smoke on Tuesday after the firing of the first two shots. At that time Fitzsimons and Rowe were working the fan together. Fitzsimons was found 440 yards from the scene of the explosion. On his way down witness did not notice any want of ventilation. He accounted for Fitzsimons being sent at that distance because he was not an experienced hand and before the firing of the shot Burns would send him away. Mr. Milburn: How does it come at such a distance from the scene of the explosion he came to be knocked down and injured in that way? — How do you account for the force at that point where it is widening out? — It might be stronger where he was at the bottom. Is it possible that there might be some gas or dust? — I could not say. Witness continuing, said there was dust about in places, and before firing he did not see the floor of the drift sprinkled. It was a "slape" floor and naturally there would be a little dust on it. The depth of coal would be about seven inches, which he took from what had been suggested at the inquest. The Inspector of Mines: I have seen it. Mr. Milburn: Asked if Mr. Smillie could ask some questions. The Coroner said the relatives were represented. Mr. Smillie said the Coal Mines Regulation Act provided for it. The Coroner said the Colliery Company and the relatives were represented and he did not think they could allow anyone else to ask questions. Mr. Smillie said the Mines Act provided for the men to be represented by their fellow workers, provided they were authorised in writing. He had not seen that authorisation. Certainly it had never been objected to before. The Coroner said he was sorry but he could not allow it. Mr. Smillie: It is only a technical objection. I only wish to bring out a few facts and I have not the opportunity. The Coroner said Mr. Smillie had not right to say that. If he allowed Mr. Smillie to cross-examine other people might want to do it. By the Coroner: He had not known of anyone at all being "gassed" in this place. They had been satisfied with the ventilation, but if there had not been sufficient they would have complained to the shot firer who would have brought it to the ears of the Colliery managers. By the Inspector of Mines: He had known men affected by the fumes, and had helped them out. That was when they were lower down in the bottom and before the fan was erected. Everything had been right since it had been put up some months ago. He expected "Saxonite" was a permitted explosive, and by the term permitted he understood to mean safe; that was, would not flash fire. He would not have stopped there, however, if anyone had been using permitted explosives in the presence of gas. The shot firer could stop himself, but witness would not. (Laughter.) He believed they had tried two or three different kinds of explosives, but "Saxonite" was the most satisfactory. Mr. Atter: On behalf of everyone I must congratulate you most heartily on your satisfactory escape, and also thank you for the manner in which you have given you evidence. Mr. Smillie: In case of an adjournment, if I am authorised by the majority of the workers will I be allowed to take part? The Coroner: Certainly. Mr. Smillie: And re-call these witnesses? The Coroner: Yes, certainly that could be done. If I allowed you now I would not really know who had the privilege, and who had not. If you can get any authorisation these witnesses could attend and you could question them as you liked. You should have the right to question them. Mr. Smillie: I am appointed by the Miners' Federation of Great Britain in the first place and Mr. Sharp's Association in the second place, but it may be necessary to hold a meeting of the men for a majority. The Coroner: The relatives are represented you see. There are some men who have been injured and you might appear for them. Mr. Sharp: To put the thing in order I am representing one of the relatives. Can he take my place? The Coroner: I understand Mr. Milburn is representing them all. Mr. Sharp: But we have them separate as well. The Coroner: But we cannot have them represented by two or three different people. Mr. Sharp: For the sake of saving time we put it that way. The Coroner: We cannot take something at the commencement, and then make alterations. Mr. Milburn: If you find any difficulty I will withdraw. Mr. Smillie: On, no, not at all. We are allowed under the clause in this Act, which was specially put in for this purpose, in addition to people appearing for the relatives. We have not got authorization, but it is very singular to be refused when a person is well-known as a representative. The Coroner: If Mr. Milburn says he is not representing any of these Mr. Milburn: I don't go so far as to say that, but Fitzsimons, if you like, can be represented by Mr. Sharp. Mr. Smillie: I don't care to stand in the way. We will hold a meeting of the men, and get authorization from them. Mr. Milburn: Mr. Sharp is representing the men here, and I don't care why he should not appoint Mr. Smillie to act for him. The Coroner: I have got you representing the relatives if the five deceased. If you wish for an alteration I will make it. Mr. Milburn: I am not instructed to withdraw now. Mr. Helder: On behalf of the Colliery Co. I don't suppose they have any objection to anyone appearing. (To the Coroner): I quite see your point, and the difficulty you may have at future inquests if you did not stick to the rules. Robert Roberts, miner, said he had worked for the Colliery Company for seven years. He was shot lighter on the day of the accident. He was appointed by Mr. Rothery and Mr. Turner. He went to work at two a.m.He fired shots in the working about five a.m. He fired seven shots in all - two together and the other five one by one. It was a quarter to six when he finished firing. He was using Saxonite. He left at five minutes past six when the place seemed all right. He had seen gas when the fan was not working. By the Inspector: He had been shot firer in the drift since the commencement of the drift. He was appointed and paid by the Colliery Co., not by the contractor. He charged and stemmed all the holes himself. He had sufficient clay at the face. There was plenty of clay at the dilly top when he left at six o'clock. The auxiliary fan was put in for heat not for gas, to his knowledge. After the interval at the week end he always worked the fan before going to the face because of the gas. Men had felt dizzy because of the gas. He had felt it a little. He liked a good stemming in his holes, and rammed it a little. He always made a careful examination. Once he refused to fire a shot because of gas in that drift. There were fissures in the coal above, and it was possible that gas came through from the old workings above. By Mr. Helder: He had been a shot firer for four year. During the time witness was in the drift a deputy named Penny came in. At this stage, one p.m., the inquiry was adjourned until 1.40 for luncheon. After the adjournment Mr. Milburn commenced his cross-examination of the witness Roberts. The latter stated he refused to fire a shot about three months ago on account of gas. The fan then was not workable, but had only been stopped an hour. It was on the back shift. He did not see any report of the circumstances anywhere, and he only looked at the report book when he was going out. He could not say whether it was his duty to examine the book when he was going in. The Coroner: Oh, you know your duty. Witness: The officials down below tell us everything. Continuing, he said he made a report on the gas being present. The book in which the reports are entered was produced and handed to witness, who, after examining it, said he reported the presence of inflammable gas on October 11. That was the last time he made a report on the presence of gas in the working. He did not make any entry on Nov. 26, after the accident. He made his last entry before the accident on November 25. At a quarter to six on the morning of the accident he was the last man to go out, and reported "Fired 17 shots; safe." He examined the place before he went out. Nine of the shots were fired between nine and ten o'clock on Monday night, and the other eight between five and six o'clock the following (Tuesday) morning. Witness examined the place just before leaving with a locked safety lamp, and there was scarcely any smoke. Burns's shift was the next one to enter. The ventilation was in very good condition, and the fan then in the working had replaced a smaller one. The small one was found to be inefficient, and the large one was put in to give better ventilation and to get the smoke from the face. Witness had never known the ventilation to be bad with the present fan, and he had never heard it was necessary to put a third man on the fan to get rid of the bad air. He did not test the passage from the main road to the working with his lamp for gas, because it was not necessary. He tested some fissures for gas about 150 yards from the face and found no signs of gas, about nine and ten the day before. He had never found gas there. On October 11 he reported No. 6 drift "full of gas." On October 12 he reported, "Fired seven shots; safe." The cause of it was that the fan went out of order for half a shift. It was sent up the shaft for repairs. He could not give an explanation of the explosion. He had thought it over many a time. He thought that as the workings above them had been worked for many years, there might be a "slip," and the gas from the old workings come down at the face and into the holes bored. He had seen no crack or "slip"; it was only his suggestion. On October 11 he reported to James McKenzie, the overman, that the fan was not working properly. The handle came off, and the men were stopped until the fan was repaired. The men did not work at the face, but 300 yards below. It was fenced off by brattice. He had never seen it done in Cumberland. There was more stone dust than coal dust - it was grey, not black in colour. He had never objected to fire a shot. On October 11 it was solely because of the fan. On no other occasion had he hesitated to fire a shot. The material produced by the Inspector had a small proportion of coal in it. Witness used clay for stemming, and his colleague would do the same. Mr. Milburn: Do you call it a small proportion of coal? — Yes, there is some stone in it. What do you call stone? — Metal. You are prohibited by the Act of 1896 from using anything but clay? — We never use anything but clay. You are sure of that? — Perfectly sure. Since that Act of Parliament, where gas is reported as it is here, you are limited to the use of clay stemming? — After and before. Mr. Milburn: Yes, but not coal. Coal is not for stemming? — Yes. Cross-examined by the Inspector: There was a deputy to examine the working under General Rule 4. There was nothing in the rules stating shot firers had to make reports, but he reported only because he had been asked to. He made an examination before and after firing shots in pursuance with the rules. He suggested that the gas might have come from a hole being driven into a crack, but, of course, the person drilling ought to have detected the presence of gas, if there was any. The face was between dryness, and dampness, and water occasionally dripped from the roof. Sometimes the shot holes were rather damp. They always used clay for stemming, and not only after inflammable gas was discovered in a working. Cross-examined by Mr. Helder: The book containing the reports was only as a check for his work, and not necessary according to any rules. By a Juryman: It was a double precaution to help the overman, and the man that was helping witness. By Mr. Milburn: Making these reports was a duty imposed on witness by his contract with the Company. Mr. Helder: I rather object to the word imposed. Mr. Milburn: I rather take it from him than you. Mr. Helder: I don't think he understands the question. Witness: We had orders to sign it. Mr. Milburn: If that is not imposition I don't know what is. By the Coroner: There were two of his entries for October 7th and 11th underlined with blue pencil, but he had never seen them until that day, and did not know who had put them there. George Harker, 9, James Pit, Whitehaven, a shot firer in the employ of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, said he had acted as shot firer between 16 and 17 years. The last day he was at work previous to the accident was on November 23, Saturday afternoon, when he went on duty at two o'clock and left at 4.20 the following (Sunday) morning. He fired eight shots and he had made entries concerning them in the book. It was, however, in the general report book and not the shot firing book. By the Inspector: He had always sufficient clay and it they were likely to run short he reported to the under manager, who would have a supply sent to them. A canvas gallery was erected for improving ventilation, but it did not improve it owing to too much air escaping. He had never had a blown out shot in No. 6 drift. After the place had been standing empty for the week end there was generally some gas present, and it had to be fanned away before anyone entered. The deputy used to go in with them to examine the place. By Mr. Helder: The station where the men should stay while the place was being examined was called "Macadam's Station." By the Inspector: The men would go 200 yards past the station in order to get their clothes off. By the Coroner: He had no idea as to the cause of the accident except it was a blown out shot, weak through stemming or weak explosives. By Mr. Milburn: When he reported safe he meant that the shots had been fired safely, not that the place was safe. By weak stemming he meant six or seven inches with strong walls, and weak stuff something was blown out. Mr. Milburn: A shot missing fire does it not affect the whole system if gas is present elsewhere? It all depends if the charge comes out far enough to ignite gas. If there were any feeders about it would ignite them. By the Inspector: A blow-out shot simply gives flame. There must be something else. John Graham, 9, Bransty Road, who is a deputy at William Pit, said he had occupied the position for about 15 months, and he had been in the employ of the Whitehaven Colliery Company for about 9½ years. On November 26 he went on at six o'clock in the morning, but he did not go into No. 6 drift. The last time he was in No. 6 drift was the previous day, November 25, at about half-past two in the afternoon, and reported in his book "All in safe and working order except as above reported." Except as above reported had to do with Lowca No. 1, which was not in this district. He was there a quarter of an hour after the accident. He was of opinion that it was a blown out shot. By the Inspector: There must have been a crevice holding a little gas, which the flame ignited. Once every shift he examined No. 6 drift. If he was up with a message to the chargeman from the manager he would look round again. He would give the fan a good spin for about an hour, and then if it was safe he would take the men from the station. Clay was always on hand for stemming. He remembered an attempt to improve the ventilation by building an inner gallery of canvas, which was abandoned after five days, because of the leakage. He was in the Lowca district, and felt a cloud of dust come about two o'clock. At first he thought there had been a fall on the road, but when he got to the bottom of the drift he found some confusion and several men injured. By Mr. Milburn: As the result of his report of the drift being full of gas on the 11th October the ventilation was improved. Bratticing was not a success, and a larger fan was put in. The shot firer's report book was in the lamp cabin, and he could examine it if he wished. His book was left in the office. On the Monday morning Jim Bigrigg, his deputy mate, reported on No. 6 drift. Witness did not visit it until three o'clock. He was alone at the time. He examined the roof and the sides, and the drift face, with a safety lamp and found nothing. He had found gas there on Sunday night. But that was simply due to the standing of the fan. He found very little. Mr. Milburn: Where is your report? — Witness pointed to his report of October 11th. That was the only time he reported gas. He had found gas in Lowca district, and he reported it on November 25. That district was about a mile and a quarter from No. 6 drift. He examined No. 6 drift three-quarters of an hour afterwards. He was 25 years of age, and had been a deputy for two years, and had been employed in the colliery since April, 1897. He had been shiftsman in the Delavel and Countess districts. By Mr. Helder: The miners had the right of appointing delegates who made quarterly reports, and on the 24th September James Smallwood and Joseph Drydon reported as regards No. 6 drift "found all safe and in good working order." The limit of age for a manger was 23. By the Inspector: He had not gone to the face before the fan was worked in order to see if there was gas. He had gone to the face just after the fan had started, and found no gas. James Bigrigg, 75, Duke-street, Whitehaven, said he had worked for the Company for 26 years, and nine years in William Pit. He had been a deputy for about 15 months. He had worked at the drift for eleven months, which was since the drift started. They left No. 6 drift at seven a.m. on the 26th November. He went there about a quarter past six, and was engaged there three-quarters of an hour. After his inspection he was talking to the fan man about the working of the fan. He had not much experience among explosives until the last eleven months, and could not give an opinion as to the cause of the explosion. By Mr. Cannell (a juryman): It was not an extra kind of gassy coal that would give off blowers. By Mr. Dyson (a juryman): He did not think gas would come down from the cracks mentioned as gas rose. By the Inspector: When he left the shift that was in the explosion had not come in. He had found gas coming down the six pipes, but did not report it. Gas was lighter than air, but if it could not get out it might come down the cracks. The fact that tubs ran amain might have the effect of checking or reversing the air, and draw gas out of the cracks. By Mr. Helder: There was a heavy fall of the barometer that day. By Mr. Helder: To what extent? — 1.20. Continuing, witness said he had never found gas present in No. 6 drift at all. He did not send in the fan men to work the fan previous to October 11. The drift was then perhaps 100 yards in past the fan. The place was ventilated by the suction or draw fan. On November 26 he was only in the drifts once. The man before witness would make the report on the condition of the drift, and that man, Blaney, would be in before eleven o'clock the previous night. Witness reported in the book "all was in working order." He went in on Sunday night, the 24th, to start the place and after that a fan man would be on the spot continuously, and the fan would never be stopped.When he entered on the 26th he found a fan man there, James Martin. Witness used his lamp at intervals of five or six feet until he got within 40 feet of the face, but could not find no signs of gas. They had been more cautions since October 11, when signs of gas were discovered. The latest signs of gas were found on October 23, and it was recorded. He believed that was the only other occasion on which he found it. Witness wrote in the book on October23 "No. 6 drift fenced off temporarily until ventilation is improved." He found gas on that date, but did not report it because the drift was temporarily stopped. Regarding the cause of the accident, he had had very little experience among explosives, and had not formed any opinion. He had thought it over, and came to the conclusion that he had better leave it to more practical men than himself. Mr. Milburn: But you are a deputy, and you ought to know about explosives and the power of gas, and you mean to tell the jury you have come to no conclusion as to the cause of the accident? — I have come to no conclusion. You can't come to any decision? — No. The Coroner: Do you or do you not know that you should have reported in your book that you found gas? — I don't think my duties lead me to do any more than I have. The Coroner said that under Rule 49 where noxious or inflammable gas was found or there were any defects in the roofs or sides "it shall be recorded without any delay in a book accessible to the workmen," and should be in the handwriting of the person making the inspection? Witness said he did not report it after the report that the main drift had been fenced off. The Coroner: Did you or did you not know that having found gas you should have recorded it as soon as possible in this book where the workmen and others could have seen it? — Yes, I knew. Please give us your reason for not doing it - it may be a good reason? — There was the report that the drift had been fenced off. The Coroner: That does not tell the workmen that gas had been found. — The drift was fenced off, it was stopped. Why did you not report it? — It is reported here. There is no report as far as I understand it? — There is no inspection here because the drift was standing. By the Inspector: He did not go to the end of the pipes on the Sunday night, as his experience told him there would be something. He, however, kept the fan going from half to threequarters of an hour. The Coroner said no more of the injured men were available that day as witnesses, but if any-one wished to call additional witnesses they could do so. Mr. Milburn thought it would be desirable to get the evidence of the injured men before calling the colliery officials. The Coroner said he was going as far as he could that day. Wilson Graham, 32, Bransty Road, Whitehaven, overman for the Colliery Company, said he had occupied the position for about twelve years with a cessation of about six months. He had been in the colliery about 30 years. On November 26 he went down the pit at six o'clock in the morning and first visited No. 6 drift, which on inspection he reported it as "all in safe working order." It was never better. He visited the place at about 7.50 a.m., and left ten minutes later. He wrote in his report about eight o'clock at night, remaining after the accident to render all assistance he could. He passed the drift bottom at 25 minutes past one, and noticed the wreck caused by the runaway tubs. He would then be about 500 yards from where the explosion occurred. It did not reach where he was standing, but a cloud of dust came by and he thought there had been a fall as the air reversed itself. He sent a man named Parkinson to see if there had been a fall and communicated with the engineer on the surface not to remove his ropes until he received communication from Parkinson. The latter said there had been a slight side rush, but that would not cause the dust. Just then a man rushed out, and said some men were lamed in No. 6 drift. He met 50 or 60 men coming out as he entered, and when he got to No. 6 drift, his lamp being lit, he saw there had been an explosion. A lot of officials came within threequarters of an hour. The next day he went down about six o'clock to search for the three missing men, and remained until eight p.m. In his opinion he had no doubt the cause of the accident was a blown out shot, and that the concussion of one of the shots had liberated some gas from the little seam above, and in conjunction with a small quantity of dust in suspension in the air, had ignited by a blown-out shot. He would not call the place a bad one for gas, or they would not have been allowed to work there. By the Inspector: At the time of the explosion the men would be going up for the riding set, coal-hewers and shift hands. There was about a dozen sitting when he went past and others would be coming. The drift men were assisting at the wreck. When they put the large fan in he examined the drift before they began to turn it. There were some cavities in the place, but whenever he found gas he reported. The Inspector thought the coal dust in the air would be very trifling. Witness said they were informed by experts that any little there was mixed with fire damp would make an explosion. The Inspector: Any kind of dust mixed with gaseous mixture will make it more inflammable. There was no coal dust. Witness: There was a little; the shot would make a little. He could not say whether gas would be liberated by the boring of the shot holes. He thought the blown-out shot might dislodge gas from the cavities. He did not attach any importance to the runaway tubs, and could hardly believe they would reverse the current. Even if they did it would re-assert itself before the explosion. It was possible the tubs might have made a vacuum of air that would dislodge gas in cavities in the roof. He was aware the barometer fell three-quarters of an inch that day, which was very unusual. He did not think much fire damp would come from the old workings, as they found more black-damp than fire damp in them. They could get to the face even with the fan standing by keeping their lamps down, but if the fan had been standing they would not expect anyone to go into the workings until it had been going some time. After the explosion there was some smoke down the drift, but when they had extinguished some burning canvas there was no fire. When he saw the injured men they were complaining of injuries not burns. If the fire had been extended to the engine plane it would have been a worse thing. The Inspector: It had only to go another 100 yards, and it would have been much more serious. Witness: Probably. By Mr. Milburn: He made a daily inspection according to the rules. He made an inspection at eight o'clock on the morning of the accident and found 11 men that were in the accident. Burns was making his clay ready for stemming when witness left. Witness used his lamp to ascertain whether gas was present. He would have been surprised to have found gas under those conditions. He would not have been surprised if the fan had been standing. He reported gas on the 11th October, when there were some tubs damaged. They put in a brattice, as it did not act and they put in a larger fan. He would expect to find gas in any part of the pit if the fan was off. At 5.35 the inquiry was adjourned until 6.20. On resuming the Coroner said he had decided to adjourn the inquiry. There were five injured men but only two of these, Thomas Moore and Cannon, were desired on behalf of the workmen, and the inquest would be adjourned for their attendance. There were three others but these were not required. He had seen the doctor who told him Moore would be able to attend in a short time but he thought Cannon would be a fortnight, and even then it would be extremely doubtful. Three weeks would bring them to ‘Xmas, and therefore he had decided to adjourn it until ten o'clock on Tuesday, January 7th. Mr. Milburn then finished his cross-examination of Mr. Graham, who said the barometer was taken in the pit on November 26, and it was at 64½. On this date no place was reported unsafe in the drift. The nearest place reported was a mile and a half away. The inquiry was then adjourned until ten ‘o'clock on January 7. The Funerals. On Friday afternoon the remains of Wm. Vincent Fitzsimons were interred in Whitehaven Cemetery, and the funeral was largely attended, many colliers and other workmen from the pit being present as well as officials. Mr. J. Scott was present as representing the County Federation , while Mr. J. Hanlon (local agent) represented the Whitehaven Miners' Joint Lodges. On Thursday night the body of Fitzsimons who was a member of the chancel choir at St. Begh's Church, was taken to the church, where it was met by the priests and the choir. The first part of the funeral service was then chanted and the body placed in the Sanctuary. The Rev. H. G. Murphy was the celebrant. At half-past eight on Friday morning, solemn Requiem Mass was sung. The choir again attended for the concluding portion of the funeral service in the afternoon, which was conducted by the Rev. H. G. Murphy, who gave the Absolutions, the choir singing the Libera. The Rev. H. G. Murphy afterwards addressed the large congregation, and feelingly referred to the sad calamity, through which the relatives of the deceased young man and others had suffered heavy bereavement. At the close of the service the choir accompanied the cortege to the cemetery, walking in processional order. The procession was headed by cross bearer and acolytes. At the grave-side the choir sand the concluding portion of the burial service, and the Rev. H. G. Murphy again officiated. Hundreds of people gathered at the cemetery, and the scene was a most impressive one. The interment of the remains of the late Alfred Burns took place on Sunday. There was a large gathering of sympathisers. The body was conveyed first of all to the Whitehaven Wesleyan Church, where an impressive service was conducted by the Rev. E. Murphy, who also officiated at the cemetery. The last scenes attending the Whitehaven Colliery disaster took place on Sunday, when three of the unfortunate men were interred at Whitehaven Cemetery. On Sunday, in the presence of thousands of spectators, Joseph Kennedy, William Hanlon, and James Rowe were taken to their last resting place. Rowe was a member of the Whitehaven Borough Band, the members of which attended and played the Dead March to St. James's Church, where the first part of the burial service was read by the Rev. J. W. Hartley, vicar. The bodies of Rowe and Kennedy were taken into the church, which was crowded, and at the close of the service the Borough Band led the way playing the Dead March through the crowded streets. The coffins were taken into and from the church to the hearse by fellow-workmen, who also bore them from the hearse at the cemetery gates to the graves. The coffins were covered with wreaths, that of Rowe's bearing his band hat and tunic. The Whitehaven Hogarth Mission Band also attended and played suitable hymns. Kennedy's body was carried from his home to the church and cemetery by relays of workmen. Mr. T. Cape represented the Cumberland Miner's Association. In the case of Denwood a wreath was sent by the members of the Whitehaven Borough Brass Band.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||