|
7th November 1907 Important Local Mining ActionMoore v The Ullcoats Mining Company, Ltd.Thursday, October 31st.The hearing was resumed at 10.30 a.m., when the examination of Mr. Main was continued. Witness was examined by Mr. John Upjohn in detail as to the working of the mine, indicating the localities to which he referred on the plans. As to some of these he said the work was not mining-like in character. The timbering along the line indicated was not what it should have been. The life of timber in a mine varied. Under the conditions in this case it would be about twelve months. In reply to the Judge, witness said supposing there had been no over-lying water there would have been no object in keeping the workings open. In reply to Mr. Upjohn, witness said supposing the roof had been as it was down the dip, with conglomerate above it, then the only timbering that would be necessary would be only such as was necessary to keep the workings open. In his early inspection of the topmost working along the line of nip out there was no more timber than witness would have expected to find in the ordinary course. Witness had been in a working indicated to the east and examined pillars and found they were too small. There were worked out pillars at the place indicated. Witness went along the extreme west end of the nip out, and the ground all along there was in a very dangerous state and there was water in the workings. That was at one of the later inspections, in September. That would be about 200 feet further to the west of the borehole No. 6. Mr. Upjohn asked, assuming that about 100 yards from the borehole and to the rise of the borehole, there was a small stream fed by a spring, and that spring had not been known to be dry for years, and within the last two or three weeks it had been dry, as an expert what was his opinion, with his knowledge of the strata there, what had become of the water, and what inference did he make as to any future accident to strata? Mr. Cave, K.C: My lord, is that right? His Lordship: Well, I think it is right; it may not be worth much. Witness: It is just what I expected. The workings, witness continued, along the nip-out and close to this borehole, were in a most dangerous state, and a further crush might be expected from the structure of the ground. The water would stop flowing and get into the mine. Other streams further away had been affected in a similar manner, and the water would get into the mine. Mr. Upjohn: Now, I want you, having regard to what you have told my lord as to the workings along the line of the nip-out and the timbering and the thinning of the pillars, knowing all these things, what do you say was the cause of the subsidence which happened in the month of March of this year? Witness: Undoubtedly the working out of the ore along the nip-out. The pillars, did they have anything to do with it? — The pillars, of course, they, were too small. My learned friend suggested to Mr. Kendall that good mining requires or suggests when you have a crack in the surface you should work out all the ore from the neighbourhood of that crack. Do you agree with that, as a general rule? — As a general rule. As to the case of the general rule in these conditions? — Oh, certainly not, under these conditions. Having this bed of quicksand on the top it is necessary to take every care and precaution in the working. What is the principal thing to be careful about? — To support the roof. Cross-examined by Mr. Cave, K.C: I think you were at one time in partnership with Mr. Kendall? — I was. At that time were you connected with a mine belonging to the Southam Mining Company? — Yes. And were you engaged in sinking a shaft for them? — Yes. I think that shaft collapsed entirely, did not it? — One of them did. Shaft No. 2? — Shaft No. 2. And the mines were closed and the Company wound up? — The Company sunk another shaft, but the ore proved to be a pocket. And the Company went into liquidation? — Yes. The second shaft was sunk under your advice? — Yes, of course. Where are you employed now as engineer? — For the Crossfield Mines and Postlethwaite's Moor Row Mines. That (Postlethwaite's) is a small mine is it not? — Not a large output. It is a good mine. You say that is not a large mine? — Not a large mine; no. And at the Crossfield Mines, have you no such things as subsidence? — Oh, yes. I think there you have pinnel overlying the mines? — We have a little, but very small. Where pinnel does overlie the ore you have been in the habit of working underneath the pinnel? — In places, yes. I think, as a rule, you have no objection to the ground collapsing after working the ore out? — That did not matter materially? — Witness said as a rule it did not. Witness further said they had gravel in places in the Crossfield Mines above the pinnel varying in depth from one to three or four feet. At that mine you have had many subsidences? — Oh, yes. That is what you expect. At one time did you in that mine work under a river; the River Keekle. I think it was? — Yes. I think there you had a rush of water at one time? — Away from the mine. There was no inbreak of the river. It is the general rule, is it not, in this district, to work first to the rise and then work back from the out-crop towards the shaft? — No, that is not the rule. You do not agree with Mr. Kendall in that respect? — Yes, I do. You work along the level to the extreme end of the deposit all the way up to the rise. You would then work the rise? — Quite so. Then having reached the end of the deposit you would work back, removing the pillars as you go, that is the ordinary way? — Yes. As the pillars are removed you expect the soil to subside? Do you take any precaution to prevent it? — It depends on the nature of the roof above. When you have removed the pillars you have done with that part of the mine, and you have no objection to the soil subsiding? — No, I have not. Mr. Upjohn observed that that depended upon the covenants of the lease. Mr. Cave said he knew his learned friend said that. He would refer to the covenants of the lease later on. Now, I want to put to you another general question. I suppose it does happen that when the surface subsides there is some dragging of the ground. Is that the right expression? — Yes. What is the meaning of that expression? — Dragging of the ground, fracture of the surface, the settling down of the surface. Do you mean it is the same thing as subsidence, or is it something different, following on subsidence? — The dragging takes place from the effect of the subsidence. Then what is the process? What is the cause — we have the cause, — which is the result of it? — The result is it draws the surface towards the centre of the subsidence. Assuming a considerable subsidence at one part, would you expect the surface and assuming that part to be what you call the centre of the subsidence, you would expect the surface in the levels to be somewhat drawn towards that? — Naturally it depends on the area affected. That effect might be produced throughout the area affected by the fall of the roof? — Yes. Witness was then cross-examined in some detail as to the relative pressures of a pinnel and limestone roof, and a pinnel and quicksand roof, witness being somewhat imperfectly heard at the press table (as he was more or less in the greater part of his evidence), but he was understood to say that when the former roof was fractured, it supported itself better than the latter, because of the downward pressure of the quicksand in the latter. Subsidence's are found all over this district, you can see them on the surface? — Yes, you can see it on the surface, and you can see it underground where there is no appearance on the surface. That would be the typical appearance caused by that drag? — By such a drag of course fracture and weakening of the ground all around. And some tendency of the ground, where it was undermined towards the centre of the subsidence? — Yes, of course, altogether depending upon the form of the cave-in. I dare say you have known cases where the shaft had been affected by an operation of that kind? — Oh, yes. The shaft is wrecked sometimes by the operation of such a drag, isn't it? — Yes. Would not the whole of the overlying strata sink, including the limestone? — It might not. Well, but in the ordinary course if you remove forty or fifty feet of ore below the limestone, is it not a fact the limestone with whatever there is above it will sink in the ordinary course? — It might. It probably would, wouldn't it? Supposing the workings should have extended right across the width of this ore, which is considerable, would not the limestone then have sunk with the rest of the surface? — Yes. Would not the drag on the neighbouring parts of the mine just above be considerable? — Under those conditions, yes. I understood you adopt the suggestion put forward by Mr. Thomas that the right plan is to leave sixty feet of ore. Mr. Upjohn said it was Mr. Kendall suggested that. Mr. Cave: That the right plan would have been to leave the ore unworked near the outcrop, to work out the whole mine, except that on that line of ore and the road or roads leading to it, and an island I think it is called round the shaft. I put it to you, Mr. Main, bearing in mine, what you have said about the possible effect of a subsidence on the deeper part of the mine, is it not quite possible that the whole of the roofs referred to and the galleries around might have given way, owing to the drag? — It is quite possible, but it would not do to allow that to occur. And if unfortunately that had occurred, the whole of the reserve of ore might have been lost? — If it did occur. In speaking of pillars you are speaking of pillars you saw standing in the mine in some cases, and in some instances of pillars you only know on the plan? — Yes. And the pillars you complain of if I may use the expression, are the pillars which you see on the plan? — Yes. You do not suggest any of these pillars you have pointed out have fallen or given way? — They may or may not be as represented. I cannot say. I put that to you, assuming they have the thickness represented, you do not suggest they have given way? — They may have fallen or crumbled away. You do not suggest that they are not there in the mine, now standing? — I do not suggest that. What about the timber? — Is it not an ordinary rule to put less timber in the first working and then when you are working back removing the pillars, you want more timber in the second working than the first? — Under ordinary conditions. Do you put the life of timber as a rule at twelve months? — It is different in different mines. It is according to the atmosphere of the mine. You get more dry rot in some mines that others, and in other ways the life of timber differs in different mines? — Yes. The timber you saw decayed, to what do you attribute the decay? It was to the age and the effect of the atmosphere on the timber? — Yes. Now, I think you told my learned friend the area of subsidence was spreading. Is it spreading by the falling in of the sides? — Yes. Am I right in saying as it is getting wider so it appears to be getting shallower? — As it appears. of course. I have not measured it. Will you look at this picture, which perhaps I may venture to call a lurid picture, it looks like a volcano — (laughter) — what does it represent? Is it drawn to scale? Have you been down this yellow shaft in the middle, and this is not — call it imaginative — it is your conjecture as to the width of the hole? — Witness was understood to assent. You know, don't you Mr. Main, that no sand or water is now coming into the mine at the bottom of this breakage? — It seems to have stopped in the meantime. Now what does this represent in the middle, this place here, the part which you have given a brighter colour, between these two lines? — That represents sand and pinnel, simply to show the shape. If the sand had got in it must have gone down, that is all it comes to? — Yes. If there were some all the way down through that funnel it would now be running into the mine would it not? — It would. Timber perishes more quickly as a rule in a dry mine than in a wet one, does it not? — Yes. In further cross-examination witness pointed out on the plan the place where he said pillars were fallen or crushed. In re-examination by Mr. Upjohn witness said that his partnership with Mr. Kendall ceased in 1896. The shaft at Southam collapsed owing to the nature of the ground, and the ore proved insufficient. That was not the fault of the engineer. There were 18 shafts at Crossfield altogether. They had had to work under a river, and they dealt with it by troughing the river. With regard to drag any subsidence would not affect the surface so far off as indicated to witness on the plan, nor in the neighbourhood of No. 6 borehole. What was going on there was going on independently of any subsidence in the middle. Witness put the life of the mines at 15 years. The effect of water in the quicksand would have a softening effect on the pinnel. It would penetrate to the stones and weaken the mass of the pinnel. Supposing there was a fault of any kind in the pinnel the water would penetrate it. With regard to a breaking of the roof more damage would be caused under quicksand and pinnel than under quicksand and limestone. The method suggested of leaving a wedge of ore until the whole of the bottom was got was the mining like way of doing and the way to get the greatest quantity of ore. Mr. Upjohn proposed to re-call Mr. Kendall on a point which had arisen in Mr. Main's cross-examination, but Mr. Cave observing that he thought he would put the point to Mr. Kendall, and the Judge agreeing, Mr. Kendall was not re-called. Mr. Joseph James Lace, sworn, deposed that he was manager at Ullcoats Farm, and had been manager for Mr. Moore, altogether having been there some 22 years. He knew where Mr. Richardson got his water supply near No. 6 borehole. The water came boiling out at the surface, and a pipe was laid down to Mr. Richardson's house. The water had yielded well until a week or two ago, when it was quite dry. He knew a small stream fed by a spring. The water ran through a pipe to a grating and into a drain. It had never been dry during the 22 or 23 years he had known it. It had been dry some weeks now. Cross-examination by Mr. Cave, witness said the supply of water had been getting less and less for some time. Mr. Upjohn said that was the plaintiff's case, and the judge suggested that the defendants evidence should be called at once so as to get all the facts before him. This course was agreed to, and Mr. Cave called. Mr. Miles Richardson, who said he is manager of the Ullcoats Mines, and had been manager since the commencement of the mine in January 1898. The Company had a take-note before they got their lease, and there were three boreholes down before he commenced. Before he became manager he was employed in Messers. Lindow's mines for nine years, and before that he was four or five years in the employ of the Lonsdale Mining Company. He carried out the sinking of the pit in this royalty under Mr. Walker's supervision, and also the sinking of the boreholes, except the first three, and he knew the mine very well. He remembered the interview with Mr. Thomas in February, 1904. They had then struck the pinnel in the roof of three workings. Mr. Thomas made some objection to the working of the pinnel at certain points. What was it Mr. Thomas said? — He warned the directors present against the influx of water. What was said then? Was the point discussed? — Yes, the point was discussed, and ultimately it was agreed. The Judge: Did anybody answer him? What was said by the directors? — They objected to the stopping of those workings, and said there was no danger. In reply to Mr. Cave, witness said it was arranged to stop 22, 18, and 24, and a considerable distance away from No. 12. Is that No. 22 which you have just mentioned the same as the 22 in Mr. Walker's notes in Lord Leconfield's royalty? — Yes, that will be in Lord Leconfield's royalty. And are the other three you have mentioned, 18, 24, and 12, as marked with a cross and circle, are those the workings referred to in Mr. Walker's notes as 20, 23, and 12? — Yes. Do you remember the interview at which you were present with Mr. Walker and Mr. Thomas in June, 1905? — Yes, sir. I'll give you the date, it was the 16th June? — Yes, as near as I can tell, sir. Is that the day when Mr. Thomas was going underground with Mr. Hartley? — Yes. Now, did you hear a discussion between Mr. Thomas and Mr. Walker about robbing out? — Yes, I remember the discussion. Will you tell me what was said? — Mr. Thomas asked if he was told we have commenced robbing, I think that was the way of it, and Mr. Thomas said we had done wrong but he wanted to know what we had to do with the water if it got into the mine at that point; and I think it was Mr. Burnyeat replied he would pump it. Mr. Thomas said "That's all right." What was the point you were discussing? What part of the mine? — As near as I can tell this was near the eastern position. When did you begin robbing the north-eastern corner of the mine? — I cannot give the exact date. About when? What year, to begin with? — I think the early part of 1905, I cannot say to a few months. Can you remember the workings stopped in 1904 being re-started? — Yes. How long was it before they were re-started? Take No. 22 with cross and circle. How long was it before that was re-started? — About three months after. That was in Lord Leconfield's royalty? — That was in Lord Leconfield's royalty. As to the others how long was it before they were re-started? — About nine or ten months. As to the other three? — All the other three. Did you consider it safe to re-start the whole of these workings? — Yes. Did you on that incident of re-starting these workings confer with Mr. Walker, the managing director? — Yes, I conferred with the managing director. Besides being managing director he was engineer for the mine? — He was engineer, yes. Did he consent to them being re-started? — He did. In your judgement, as a practical man, was it a right and a wise thing to re-start these workings? — Yes. You considered it? — Yes. The Judge: Do you think so now? — I think so now. Mr. Cave: Can you give my lord your reasons? — Well in the first instance No. 22 company, the working above had been driven across beyond the other workings, so that was the reason, and it only wanted just driving up hill into one of the back roads. We knew at that time that we could not possibly cut the pinnel in that direction by driving on. There had been workings above in the pinnel? — Yes. What do you say about 18 and 24? — Then the other places, seeing that we had cut the pinnel in one or two places besides previous to re-starting these we considered the pinnel was tough enough and strong enough to form the roof of an ordinary working. Therefore we commenced these workings again. I may say further the three places where we had touched the pinnel previously to that are still standing. That proves that the pinnel was of that nature. I see there is a mark "Stopped for good." Did you stop altogether there? — Yes, sir, there was no reason to go on No. 22 and 18 are standing today as good as ever they were, and No. 24 may be for anything I know. Do you mean 18 with a cross or 18 with a cross and circle? — I mean 18 with a cross. You said some robbing had been done in the north-east corner of the mine. You had altogether removed the ore in the part coloured blue on the plans (indicating the place?) — Witness assented. Did you know the late Mr. Moore? — Yes, very well. I dare say you had conversation with him from time to time? — Very often, in fact I may say when he was at home he came to the mine every working day. The mine adjoins his private grounds. He appeared to know something about mining? — Oh yes. Did you have any discussions with him about questions relating to this mine? — Yes, very often. He made inquiries every day. Did he see the working plans? — Yes, he often asked for the working plans to be shown to him. Did any of the plans shown to him indicate the workings on this spot? Mr. Upjohn objected on the ground of irrelevancy. What has this to do with the cause of action? The Judge: No. The suggestion may be that Mr. Moore knew what they were doing. Mr. Cave: Do you know what experience Mr. Moore had in mining matters? — Witness: I understand Mr. Upjohn: I object, my lord. "I understand" means "I don't know." Mr. Cave asked whether witness spoke from this own knowledge or Mr. Moore told him. Witness: I know from what Mr. Moore could talk about the mines for one thing. The Judge intimated that the question could not be admitted. Mr. Cave: Who was Mr. Moore's mineral agent? — David Gill. Did he come to the mine? — Yes. About how often did he come? — About every fortnight or three weeks. He did not come at regular intervals. Did he from time to time see the working plans? — Yes, sir. Did he at times go underground and inspect the mines? — Yes. How long did that continue? From the end of 1904 did he go during 1905? — Yes. And also 1906? — Yes, sir, and parts of this year. On the 25th of February Mr. Gill was there we know. — Yes. When the agreement was come to, to stop Mr. Gill was present? — Mr. Gill was present. At any time after that after you had re-started these workings did Mr. Gill ever make any objecting? — Not in my hearing. Mr. Cave was proceeding to examine as to Mr. Forster Browne, Lord Leconfield's mining agent, inspecting the mine, but Mr. Upjohn objecting Mr. Cave said he would get it first hand. Mr. Cave: As you worked the mine did you put any further timber in? — Oh yes. Did you put in such timber as you thought necessary and proper? — I put in the kind of timber I thought necessary, and where I thought necessary. Do you know of any place where the roof had given way from any defect in the original timber? — Well in a few places, but to my mind it is immaterial. There are slight holes in the roof. There are not any more subsidence than are usual in mines? — No, I do not think so. If we had needed the roofs of course we would have kept them up, but we did not need the roofs. Have you had any accidents to you men owing to the fall of timber? — None whatever. Timber, we know, only has a certain time? — In our mine it does not last very long. The Judge: How long? — Witness: Well, about twelve months. Some parts of the mine it lasts longer than the other. There are different things about it. It very much depends on the kind of timber we put in, whether it is seasoned or not. What causes timber to perish? — Dry rot, and if we cannot put in well seasoned timber, if we can get it will last the longest. The green timber goes the fastest. Do you buy the timber? — Yes, I buy most of it and see most of it before it comes to the place. I see where it is growing and judge it myself. Are you under any restrictions as to price? — Not any restriction whatever. My orders are to get the best of everything. Are you restricted at all as to quantity? — Not at all. Witness was then examined as to the clipping of all pillars, and pointed out on the plan where this had been done. When the gentleman came to inspect the mine witness did not take particular notice of the places they had been in. They made a general inspection of the whole mine. Mr. Cave: Will you say what you first noticed before the first subsidence occurred? — After it had been standing twelve months the overman in going in noticed a sagging of the roof and drew my attention to it, and there being a little bit of ore in the roof I was afraid the sagging of the pinnel would drop, and we proceeded to take it out. Do you think that the right thing to do for the purpose of saving that piece of ore? — Perfectly. Judging from our experience I expected nothing more but that the place would be closed up. When that piece of ore was taken out what happened then? — There was a fissure or crack in the roof through which a certain amount of sand and water came. That was in the pinnel, of course, after the ore had been extracted. Was that the moment you took the ore out, or did anything happen between? — Well, we had got the whole of it. They were working in the place about six weeks. I had just two men working there about six weeks. Was the sand which first came much at all? — Not a big quantity. It certainly slackened our pumps, and I think that was only owing to the pumps being standing at the time. We were not using them. How wide was it? — Just an inch or two. Just something I could shove my hand into; that was all. It was there that originally the sand came and a little water? — Yes. When was the next inrush of sand? — On the 18th of March. And was it then or before that you first knew of the subsidence on the surface? — Well, just before that, a very small depression did make its appearance on the surface. We commenced at once to put in wood pillars all along the outcrop shown on the small plan. Witness proceeded to detail the methods taken to secure the mine by putting in barriers and pumping. There was, he said, no water from the inrush, and the sand was lying in the mine. Will that sand interfere with your working of the remainder of the ore? — Very little. Will you say exactly to what extent it will interfere? — Well, there are one or two of the main roads we will have to clean out, but most of them we will just need to drive through from one pillar to another, that is when the time comes to extract them. Will the result be any considerable expense? — Well no. In some places it will be a benefit. How will it be a benefit? — Because the open space will be already filled up for us, and we will be able to get at the roof so that we will get the roof more even. Is there any water or sand running through the fissure at the present time? — None whatever. None that I know of. Well, we heard something about the feed of water towards the west of the mine. Mr. Main, I think it was, or Mr. Thomas, the day you were said to have warned Mr. Thomas about going further. Do you remember that? — Yes. What was that? — A feed of water coming out of the western extremity of the mine right away at the far end, and seeing that the present subsidence occurred after a small feed of water but I may say there is a difference between that feed of water and the present one. The feed we got previous to the last subsidence was very much charged with sand, but the one which is coming from the west into it had no sand in it, nor had not had, but still it was in rather an awkward position, and we did not think it advisable to go right to where the source was, and knowing, supposing as subsidence did occur, at that place, it was not going to affect the mine in any shape or form, on filling up a few workings we did not think it advisable to go any further, and taking that into consideration I did not feel bound to allow these gentlemen, practical strangers to the mine, to go without a warning. I did not say anything to them till they got to this place and I told them what I knew and that I was pleased to go with them so far and after that they might suit themselves. You thought that a fair thing to do? — Yes. The Judge: The feed is not shown on this plan at all? — No. Mr. Cave: Have you heard Mr. Kendall's suggestion as to the manner in which this mine ought to have been worked? — Yes, I have heard it. Do you agree with him? — Not at all. (Laughter.) Why don't you approve of it? — For many reasons. I think he is going wrongly about it altogether. I would not like to have the mine worked in that fashion. I consider the outcrop is the proper place to commence, irrespective of what the super incumbent earth is. To start working the second working I certainly would not commence with the full length of the outcrop. I would start it at one end, as we have done at the north-east corner, and as we remove the pillars the roofs come down. That was the best way to get all the ore. When you finished your second working right along the outcrop there would be a subsidence right along? — Yes. What would happen to the water? — Judging from experience, the water would very likely be caught or confined to the surface. Would there be any difficulty in dealing with it there? — No, only it would require pumping. Then you are actually robbing, Mr. Richardson. You deal with it at once part of the mine, or at one section. — Do you put any barriers between the part you are actually robbing and the rest of the mine? Yes, we have done so. We have put barriers in to enclose certain places round those places where we have commenced robbing. We have done this so that if anything occurs in the way of an inrush of course I am not anticipating anything; the thing is just working as I expected it, and I think it is very satisfactory so far. The only unexpected thing was the inrush of March. Could you try any exercise of your judgement and foresight have foretold of water and sand? — No, I could not, and when we did get it I dealt with it the best way I could, and I may say it has been a certain experience to men, so it has been useful in that respect. Cross-examined by Mr. Upjohn: Where are you robbing? — At the east end. Now a short time ago you told Mr. Cave in working the outcrop you acted to the best of you judgement. I take it is in your judgement which has determined the mode in which this mine is worked? — Partly. To what extent? — Partly after discussion with Mr. Walker, the engineer. How often did Mr. Walker go underground? — That is a question I cannot say exactly. Perhaps a few months would intervene between his visits. Two or three times a year; perhaps not so often? — Perhaps not so often; perhaps twice a year. How often have you been down lately? — I have been down every fortnight. That is since the subsidence; before that? — Well, I have gone once a fortnight. That is, I suppose, every bargain day? — Every bargain day and also, of course, if required. Cross-examined as to length of time in sinking No. 1 pit, witness said there was trouble from sand and water. The pumps they had were not suitable for the job. They never had proper pumps the whole time. Is that by virtue of your judgement or Mr. Walker's judgement? — Well, it was may be they we short of money. (Laughter.) When you had got your shafts properly lined — were you constant with brickwork or had you a steel tube or what? — We just timbered it. You just timbered it; you were badly off then? (Laughter.) Did you attach any importance to this bed of sand and water as affecting future operations? — There is no doubt I did to a certain extent. I want you to tell me to what extent? — I considered there was not a doubt but what it would be troublesome when we commenced robbing. I anticipated trouble when we commenced robbing, but I did not anticipate much trouble after, because after we got it robbed, I thought, and broken down along the outcrop, I did not expect say trouble. After that I did not attach any importance to it. What trouble was it you anticipated from the sand and water when you had commenced robbing and your roof had come down or partly come down? You told me you anticipated trouble. I asked what trouble? — Well, trouble in so much it was necessary to be careful or otherwise it would get the majesty on us. But with care we did not anticipate any injury from that. Then was your plan of working this mine to work to the side, then when you got to the outcrop to commence working back, removing all the pillars? Is that the usual method of working? — Yes, that is what I consider the right and proper course to adopt. Whatever the roof may be? — In this case. And notwithstanding the roof in this case? — And notwithstanding the roof in this case. When you are working back and robbing the pillars there is no object in timbering, is there? — It is just the very time when timbering is used. You do not mean the working closed beyond? — Oh, no, we expect them to close. That is the time when the ground will come. By the judge: The only timbering required is for the safety of the men who are robbing the pillars. Then we leave it to come down, and we often put dynamite in to bring it down. How did you propose to manage so that notwithstanding the roof coming away as you constantly anticipated it would? When you robbed the pillars what did you propose to do to prevent the quicksand coming through, and mastering you? — Exactly what we have done at the east end. Witness explained, in answer to a further question from Mr. Upjohn, the details of the timbering operations undertaking for protection when the pillars were being taken in the district referred to, from which it appeared that that timber supported a boarded floor upon which the pinnel above was let down a distance of about seven feet so as to form a boarded roof. They proceeded a bit at a time in that way all the way down to the dip, taking usually four pillars at a time within these operations. Witness had advised this plan which was on the lines of something similar which his brother had told him had been done at one of Messrs. Lindow's pits. At this point the Court adjourned. Friday's Hearing. The court resumed at 10.30 a.m., when the cross-examination of Mr. Richardson was continued by Mr. Upjohn. On certain details as to the character of the boreholes at Syke House Mine being put to witness, he said he could neither deny them nor confirm them. Mr. Upjohn put it that witness's sinking at Syke House was something like this. It passed through 73 feet of alluvial strata clay, gravel, sand, and thin pinnel, and then through 283 feet of sandstone and conglomerate and limestone, and then met the ore. I put it to you, said Mr. Upjohn, that that is about the section of your shaft. Are you prepared to deny that is substantially the section of the sinking? — Well, certainly something like it, sir, but the very large proportion of it was sand and gravel, but very little pinnel. Mostly sand and gravel heavily charged with water. Mr. Upjohn then cross-examined witness by reference to the plans with regard to the operations connected with the robbery of the pillars. The roof had fallen when the pillars were removed. It had fallen in completely when the pillars were patched on that plan. In reply to the Judge, witness said that the roof had fallen on to the platform which he had described yesterday. Further cross-examined by Mr. Upjohn, witness said the longitudinal road along the outcrop had not been started prior to October, 1904. The longitudinal road was driven in sections, and there was no date on the plan. Witness could not say when they started to make the road. Witness could not understand what counsel meant, he said counsel spoke of it as one work. Witness considered it as a dozen or twenty works. They commenced the work before they got the pinnel at all, and that would be in 1904, or at the end of 1903. In reply to the Judge, witness said it was a continuous work as the workings progressed. Splitting a pillar was driving a road through the pillar. The pillars were first left large until the extent of ore is found out, and then they were divided into two or perhaps four, leaving them always sufficient. He considered the life of the robbed part of the mine, complete. He did not know what ore there was in the pit. He would say 15 years was too short a time for the ore in sight. The robbery and the splitting of the pillars all went together. The splitting of the pillars had been going on from the end of 1905 to the 2nd of March, 1907. Witness was cross-examined at considerable length as to the piece of ore left in the pinnel roof, and subsequently extracted, as described in his previous evidence, and made a rough sketch showing the position. The 15 feet shown on that was the size of the open space, after the working was enlarged, and witness indicated in the sketch the size of the old working before it was enlarged. Witness went into that working whilst it was going on oftener than once a fortnight. He went because he was anxious about the robbery portion of the mine, about which it was an anxious time, but he was not particularly anxious about this place. The cross-examination was continued at length as to details of working in the neighbourhood of the subsidence elucidated by continuous references to the plan. Witness first noticed signs of the subsidence of the surface between the 13th January and 2nd March. It would be two or three weeks after the 2nd January. He did not make a note of it. That was a thing he very seldom did. Mr. Upjohn observed that was no unwise if one was going into the witness box. (Laughter.) Mr. Cave said Mr. Richardson did not then know he was going into the witness box, and witness was understood to say it was not an easy place. Mr. Upjohn: You're doing very well. (Laughter.) Did you go up the fall at any time? — Before six o'clock on Monday morning I went right up to the place. There was a biggish fall of the roof? — No, there was no fall of roof. I put to you that the pinnel, some pinnel, had fallen? — No pinnel fell. At all events sand and water came through? — Sand and water did come through the pinnel. Was the pinnel fissured? — There was a fissure in the pinnel, a crack. At the end of a week sand and water were still coming through the fissure? — Yes. Well, then in order to deal with the quicksand, that is, the sand and water, I think you constructed a dam some distance from the fall? — Yes, I constructed what we call a catchpit or spoil pond. And you ran the sand and water into your spoil pond, and then you put in water boxes. I suppose that means troughs into the spoil pond so as to lead the water away? — Yes, to lead the water into the catches, there to be settled, and the water to flow to the shaft to be pumped. On the day before the second subsidence witness said there was a party of men who cut through one of the wooden pillars, so that a man could get through and see what was going on. A man cut through the pillars and saw there had been a considerable fall of pinnel from the top of the working and a great quantity of water coming. That is right, is it not? — No, that is not right, or nearly so. There was very little water running immediately before the 2nd of March inrush. At all events, there was a considerable fall of pinnel from the roof? — No, it is not possible, because the timbering had been put in. Have you heard that when this hole was made a man named Murphy got through and a big piece came from the roof and knocked him down? I never heard of that, and I do not think it occurred or I would have heard of it. Further cross-examined, witness said he had not heard anything of a man name Kain warning the men of the quantity or water coming in, and consequently they left the pit 40 minutes earlier than usual, or that Kain told the banksman something would happen before morning. The inrush commenced at 3.30 a.m., and continued till ten a.m., but not continuously. It would come for half-an-hour or an hour at a time. Some of the workings were filled with quicksand up to the roof. Witness was down the mine certainly before six o'clock, after the inrush. He indicated on the map the places he got to. He could see from that position in which direction the sand was coming. Mr. Upjohn suggested that apart from the question of light the witness could not see the workings, which were choked with sand. — I contradict that, sir. Coming to where I stood they certainly were not choked with sand. Mr. Upjohn: To the west I suggest were choked with sand? Well, of course, I was there and I say that it was not choked. (Laughter.) In further cross-examination witness said there was not a split pillar that was crushed. No doubt there were pillars which had ore falling away from them in plenty of places, and he could give the reason for it. The action of the atmosphere caused it certainly, not from any pressure of the roof or the roof would be showing signs of coming down. It could not be pressure of the roof unless the roof moved, and if it moved there would be fracture. In re-examination by Mr. Cave, the witness described in detail the method of working in the rise so as to make the floor of one working the roof of the next, and get the roof of the previous working down, so as to keep the roof always solid. As to the question of the roof pressing on the pillars so as to cause them to break pieces off, the state of the timber round them showed this was not so. The timber would be the first to show any strain from the roof. Mr. William Edward Walker, examined by Mr. Wood, deposed he had had a long experience of iron ore mining. He is consulting engineer for some of the principal iron ore mines in the district, and was consulting engineer to many other concerns. The boreholes at Ullcoats were put down under his supervision, and also the sinking of the shaft. The working of the mine had in witness's opinion been carried out in a proper, skilful, and mining manner. At the meeting of the 25th February, 1904, at his office Mr. Thomas wanted then to stop the workings indicated, lest the pinnel should come down, and they might be prevented getting all the ore they might out of Lord Leconfield's royalty, for whom Mr. Thomas was then acting. The workings were to be stopped for a time to give the pinnel a trial, and they did their best to give it a trial. Witness corroborated Mr. Richardson's account of the subsequent meeting at the mine. Mr. Thomas made no objection to the continuation of the rise working. The working of the rise was continued, and witness approved of it. In his opinion it was proper to get out the ore on the rise before that in the dip. He did not consider it would have been in the ordinary course of mining to leave a barrier of 60 feet of ore along the outcrop. No danger or injury to the mine had resulted from the method of working followed. Witness knew of the piece of ore which was left in the roof being got as described by the last witness, and he approved of it. Its removal did not at all contribute to the subsidence. Not a ton of ore would be lost in consequence of the inrush. The ore would not be depreciated by the sand which had got into the mine. The ore would be brought out as clean as it was done at other places. He gave local instances where sand and gravel were run into the mines purposely in the course of working. He never saw an iron ore mine with so much timber in it for a first working as Ullcoats, where they had in fact spent £7,000 in prop wood. The pillars left were sufficient, and he approved of the splitting of the pillars where it had been done. The suggested stone pillars in a place 30 or 40 feet in height were impracticable. Witness never in his life heard of such a thing in an iron ore mine. Any increase of the cost of getting the ore in the dip by clearing some of the roads of sand would fall on the lessees. Cross-examined by Mr. Cave, witness considered they had an ordinary strata to deal with on account of the thickness of the pinnel. They never took into consideration the possibility of the quicksand coming into the mine, nor nobody else either. It was never mentioned. Witness would not adopt Mr. Kendall's plan. In all probability they would lose the barrier of ore. Mr. Kendall proposed to leave in, and they might lose more. There would be more ore in the proposed reserved barrier than some mines had in them altogether. When the dip ore was got out, and the limestone roof over that came down, there would be a drag which would probably wreck the shaft. The roof over the reserve ore would run down and override the reserve ore if that ore came to be worked. The Court adjourned until Monday. Monday, November 4th. The hearing was resumed this morning, the cross-examination of :— Mr. W. E Walker being resumed by Mr. Upjohn, who, referring to Mr. Kendall's evidence as to his (Mr. Kendall's) view of the way in which the mine should have been worked, read from the transcript of the shorthand notes, passages as to the roads necessary for working reserve ore. Witness said if there were only one or two roads the roof would override the pillars. It would take 15 or 20 roads from shaft No. 1 to the outcrop. If the quicksand and pinnel would override a barrier of 60 feet, what do you say to them breaking where there is no barrier at all? — We have barriers there now, sir. Then how can you justify working all the mine up to the pinnel without leaving even a 60 feet barrier. — By experience and judgment. That won't do for me. I want something much more definite than that. What I want to know is this what thickness of ore — I do not know whether you call it a breadth or width — skirting from the line of outcrop and going to the deep towards No. 1 shaft — it is called breadth or width, or what? — Breadth. Mr. Kendall has said 60 feet. Do you say that would be sufficient? — I would simply leave the ordinary pillars. If you say that a barrier of ore 60 feet in breadth would not be enough to keep back the pinnel and quicksand, I ask you in you experience not what you would do, but what in your opinion would be a sufficient breadth of ore to leave as a barrier to keep back the quicksand? — You would not have a single working on the rise from No. 1 shaft at all You would have to leave the ore there. That is, you would leave a barrier of 450 feet of ore? — Yes, that is practically what it means. Now then, if you do not leave any ore at all up to the pinnel that is a perfectly safe way of working the ground? — Yes, sir, that is my opinion. After some questions on the nature of a drag to be apprehended from the subsidence and from further subsidence's which might be expected, and their dimensions and effects , witness was asked what in his opinion was the cause of the inrush. Witness: Well, my opinion is the pinnel is much thinner at that particular point than in any other portion of the borings. You have not tested or proved that in any way? — No, sir. I suppose you have adopted that theory because you know very well the variable character of the pinnel? — No, it does not vary very much. In fact, I do not know of any other place where I can say it has varied. Then so far as experience goes there is no support to your theory? — We have in the boreholes. We have there about 47 to 60 feet of pinnel, and we expect 40 to 60 feet of pinnel. As far as knowledge goes there is nothing to support your theory that the pinnel is thinner there than elsewhere? — We cannot see through the earth. In reply to further questions, witness said it was contrary to his experience for pinnel to vary much in thickness. It varied more in quality and there was a sandy pinnel about 30 feet down at No. 3, but that was not the pinnel which lay immediately above the ore. Witness liked pinnel for a roof where they had a good thickness of it. Mr. Upjohn: You told me on Friday that you looked upon the infall as a blessing in disguise. In fact, I do not think you think it is disguised, do you? (Laughter.) Further cross-examined, witness said that the timber was such as was usually used when they were working to the rise. He gave Mr. Richardson a free hand, and he went to Scotland and to different places in Cumberland, and it was left to him to buy what timber he required irrespective of price. The ore up in the rise to the outcrop was easier to work than that at the deep, and was of better quality. Ore had been rising in price during 1904-5-6, but it did not go up very much until the latter part of 1906, when it had risen from 14s or 15s to 18s per ton. The Board meetings were usually on the last Thursday in the month, unless it was more convenient for the chairman or directors to have another day. He believed he mentioned to Mr. Thomas that it might be necessary to postpone his inspection until after the Board meeting. The question as to Mr. Thomas producing his authority might be mentioned at such a meeting. You never doubted the authority he said he had? — Certainly not. I knew Mr. Thomas very well. You did not doubt for a moment? — I did not. Then what was the object of having a Board meeting? — I wanted the sanction of my co-directors to allow Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout to go down. I would not do it on my own responsibility. You knew there was a covenant, did you not? — Yes, sir. The covenant does not say after a Board meeting, does it? — No, sir, it says at all reasonable times. I do not consider 24 hours reasonable. In reply to a further question, witness said he had mentioned that view to Mr. Thomas in the train between Moor Row and Whitehaven. Taken to the interview room with Mr. Thomas of the 3rd of April, witness said he went with Mr. Thomas to the mine. They drove together from Egremont station. Mr. Richardson was there, but Mr. Stout was not. He had written Mr. Brockbank on the matter, but did not know his opinion. He had never mentioned it. Counsel said Mr. Brockbank had put some of it in writing, and he read to witness a letter of the 3rd of April, in which he said he had nothing more to say with reference to the inspection by Thomas and Stout, and what he had said applied to the plans as well as to the pit. He (Mr. Brockbank) decidedly objected to the inspection without consideration. The production or no production of an authority, in his opinion, did not affect the question. Has Mr. Brockbank not really explained his attitude to you? — No, he has not. I think Mr. Brockbank is quite capable of taking care of himself. Mr. Upjohn: I have no doubt. He is, I have no doubt. (Laughter.) Further cross-examination, witness said Mr. Stout was manager of the Beckermet mine. Counsel did not say whether Mr. Burnyeat was a director of that Company. He knew Mr. Burnyeat went to the mine, but he did not know who the directors were. At all events, Mr. Stout has a delicacy about acting against Mr. Burnyeat? — Oh, I do not think so at all. Mr. Stout is a man who will speak his mind, it does not matter who it is. Replaying as to question on the inspection of the 12th April, witness said Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout went down the mine about two o'clock. He left and did not know when they came up, but he believed as a matter of fact it was about seven o'clock. As far as he concerned, they could have stayed all night for the matter of that. Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout were not in partnership in any way that he knew, and he did not think they were. Mr. Thomas was in business as a consulting engineer, and Mr. Stout was a mine engineer, and a very good one. Re-examined by Mr. Cave: Have you calculated how much ore there would be in such a reserve of ore as is suggested 60 feet thick? — Yes, Mr. Kendall's 60 feet would mean over 200,000 tons of iron ore. That is more than several iron ore mines have altogether. In reply to a question whether the increased price of ore in 1906 affected the way in which the mine was worked, witness said it did not do so at all. Mr. Justice Warrington, on the witness's examination being concluded, said that finished the evidence of those responsible for the working of the mine, and they might proceed to discuss the breaches of the covenant. Mr. Cave said that an undertaking had been given to call one witness, Mr. Gill, as to a question of fact. It might not go far in His Lordship's mind. Mr. Justice Warrington confessed he did not think it would really affect the question. However, he would leave it to Mr. Cave. Mr. Cave then called :— David Smith Gill, who said he was a mining and civil engineer practising in Whitehaven, and he held a number of appointments. He was appointed mineral agent to the late Mr. Moore for the Ullcoats mine on the 1st October, 1901. He was holding that appointment now, at all events it had not been terminated by any notice, and he was still receiving salary from the Executors of Mr. Moore. He came there on subpoena. From time to time during Mr. Moore's life-time witness visited Ullcoats mine, once every fortnight or three weeks, and went down the pit eight or nine times a year. He remembered the conference in 1904, when it was resolved to stop certain workings, and he knew afterwards that these workings, had been resumed. He learned that on one of his visits of inspection, and he made no objection to the working being resumed. As far as you were concerned with the mine; are you satisfied that the mine has been properly worked? — Quite. Cross-examined by Mr. Upjohn, witness said he served four years articles with Mr. Robert Russell, and was a duly qualified mining and civil engineer, though he held no certificate of either Institute. Witness acted for the Bigrigg Iron Ore Company, the Seascale Exploration Company, and the Winscales Mining Company. Mr. Russell was a consulting mining engineer. He had been in the Geological Survey, but witness thought he had left the service before 1891, when witness went to him. Witness had been paid his salary up to September 30th, 1907. Witness had considered the conditions in this mine and how they might be met, and had talked them over with the manager in the course of conversations with him. He approved of them working under the pinnel roof. This being the conclusion of the evidence, Mr. Justice Warrington said he thought it would be most convenient to hear Mr. Upjohn and then he would hear Mr. Cave if necessary on the whole case if it was necessary to call upon him, and upon the covenants. Mr. Upjohn said if His Lordship had made up his mind he did not desire to protract the proceedings, but His Lordship decline to adopt that suggestion, and Mr. Upjohn proceeded to address himself to the specific breaches of covenant already recited from which the plaintiffs complained. He submitted that the strata above the mine presented great difficulties in the working of the mine which required special treatment. Nobody had said anything to the contrary of that. The evidence of Mr. Richardson and Mr. Walker was that they never took the matter into consideration until they had gone up to the rise and were approaching the nip-out, and were about to work back, and then for the first time it occurred to them that they were going to work the pillars out and deprive the roof of all support. The pinnel would come down and they knew what the strata above was, so they must be very careful. He submitted that they ought to have taken that into consideration long before they did that before they got to that stage, on the evidence of the plaintiffs' witnesses, which was uncontradicted; they ought to have taken that into consideration before they laid out their work there at all. Mr. Richardson, when counsel challenged him on that, said after all it was a similar condition or very like the strata of what he came across at Cleator and Sykehouse. Counsel did not desire to say a word against Mr. Richardson they had a man of ability in the box, but Mr. Richardson, he was sure, did not pretend to any real experience at the time he laid out these workings. The sort of work he had previously done was no the sort of work which enabled a man to appreciate how the mine should be worked. It was quite clear, looking at the evidence that Mr. Richardson — who so far from being contradicted by Mr. Walker was supported in every detail by Mr. Walker — had arranged the working of the mine. Mr. Walker had never appreciated the difficulties. He left it to Mr. Richardson, and counsel submitted Mr. Richardson, although a man of ability, was not a man of the education and experience which enabled him to lay out workings properly and to work on a proper plan, having regard to the proper way. They did not know what would happen, but they contemplated that their method would break the pinnel and would, as Mr. Gill said, hasten the fall of the water and sand, and he said they knew they would have to deal with that. He said that Mr. Walker should have sat down and said to himself that he could see that when he began to work back he would have trouble, that he would have gauged the trouble if he worked back all this ore to the nip-out. Mr. Walker said in the box that in order to make a roof all the ore to the rise of No. 1 shaft ought to have been left. How could Mr. Walker reconcile that of course it was exaggeration, he (counsel) did not accept it and did not ask His Lordship to accept it but Mr. Walker's evidence that morning was that in his opinion to leave a barrier of 60 feet in breadth all along the line of the nip-out, some 1,500 yards, would not be sufficient to preserve this part of the mine. How, in the name of wonder, then did Mr. Walker justify working away even that amount of ore? He stood convicted of having worked right along the line of the nip-out ore, which he now says was insufficient for the safety of the mine. What Mr. Kendall and the other witnesses of experience said was that the defendants worked straight up to the rise. When they got to the rise they prepared to work back and robbing pillars in common form. These witnesses said that common form was wholly inapplicable to the circumstances, and they were confirmed and corroborated by Mr. Richardson and Mr. Walker because both said they pursued the usual plan. They did not conceive there was any reason for pursuing a different plan. The whole question for the Court was whether it was not negligently, unskilfully, and unmining like for Mr. Walker to leave it to Mr. Richardson and for Mr. Richardson to adopt and for Mr. Walker to approve so far as he thought of the matter at all, which he did not seem to have done — to approve the methods which were nothing but the common form. He (counsel) said that was wrong and unmining like, and that they never thought what plans they ought to adopt in order to make the special provision that was needed. They went ahead just as it they had a roof of conglomerate, instead of a roof of quicksand, and they had called no expert on the other side to deal with that state of things, except those actually responsible for it. They said the pinnel roof must have been thinner at this point than elsewhere. That was absolute theory. There was nothing to show. What did they know about pinnel? They knew it was a variable strata, and there might be a considerable variation of thickness within a short distance, and it also varied in quality. They knew also that pinnel contained pockets of boulders and stones. Mr. Walker said he had never seen stones in it bigger than he could lift with two hands. But the pinnel being as described, what right had they to go working ahead in this happy-go-lucky way, because they had a roof of pinnel, which they assumed from bore-holes a couple of hundred feet away to by 47 feet thick. Counsel also submitted that the work of breaking up and removing the body of ore, removed from the pinnel roof would have an effect upon the stability of the roof. When the strata was in that condition, anything that went on might shake it, and they did not know what might happen. Mr. Justice Warrington observed that all they did was to remove the ore which had fallen in consequence of the two shots fired in it in December. Mr. Upjohn said that it was not a mere question of putting the ore into a wheel-barrow and wheeling it away. It was a body of ore about 15 feet long by 40 feet wide, and of varying thickness. When he had proved the working of the nip-out, when he proved the character of the strata, and when the expert evidence showed the danger there was, and that in January that very danger happened, he submitted that there never was a clearer case of people working negligently, because with total disregard of the very special, if not unique conditions which they had to deal with, and with a very imminent danger which they ought to have taken all the means at their disposal to obviate. Mr. Cave said he did not think he need dwell on the alleged refusals on the 3rd and 5th. They were followed by inspection. Not only had the defendants a sufficient reason for more delay, namely, in the first instance no authority had been produced for Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout to inspect, and in the second instance the directors had asked for time to consider the request before granting it. He (counsel) did not think anyone would rely — his friend did not rely in his opening on these two. Mr. Justice Warrington: No. Mr. Upjohn said he did not rely on anything before the 12th. He did not rely on the 3rd. Mr. Cave said then he was afraid he must go on. On the 1st, Mr. Thomas wrote to the Company and asked them for an appointment for him and Mr. Stout to examine the mine on the 3rd. Then on that Mr. Walker wrote to Mr. Brockbank and asked him whether that was right, and pointed out that no authority had been produced. That was on the 2nd. On the same day, Mr. Brockbank wired back, "Requires more particulars before assenting," and subsequently wrote to Mr. Walker repeating that statement, and adding that the decision of the matter might very well stand over until after his return home, saying in a subsequent letter he intended to return on Saturday, the 6th. Then Mr. Walker called on Mr. Brown, the solicitor to the plaintiffs, and Mr. Brown knew nothing about it, and would ask Mr. Sherwen, and let Mr. Walker know. Then there was a telephone conversation between Mr. Walker and Mr. Thomas, which counsel had put to Mr. Thomas. Then Mr. Walker wrote to Mr. Brockbank that if Mr. Thomas did not produce any authority from Mr. Moore's Executors. in the meantime he would certainly not let him go down the pit unless he had a wire from Mr. Brockbank and that perhaps he (Mr. Walker) had better call at Mr. Sherwen's office at Moor Row next day and ask him to put the authority in writing. Then he wrote to Mr. Thomas they would be pleased to see him, and presumed he would bring this authority with him. He was not asked for it, and did not produce it, and was not allowed down the mine. Counsel submitted the managing director was quite justified in not allowing Mr. Thomas down the mine without authority. Otherwise a perfect stranger might come saying he was to be let down the mine as the representative of Mr. Moore's Executors. Mr. Justice Warrington: Especially as at that time Mr. Gill was agent for Mr. Moore, and had been for years. Mr. Cave said that there was a letter from Mr. Brockbank of the 3rd April, in which he raised the point of delay for the Board considering the matter. Mr. Brockbank wrote that he decidedly objected to the inspection of the mine by either the one or the other until the matter had been considered, and said the production of an authority would not in his opinion, affect the question. Then Mr. Walker wrote Mr. Brockbank that Mr. Thomas had arrived at Ullcoats, and he (Mr. Walker) had respectfully refused to let him go down, or to see the plans. On the 4th, Mr. Thomas called on Mr. Walker, and produced his authority. There was nothing said in the authority about plans. And the second point on that was that it was a joint authority to the two. Nothing was said about one of them going down. Than there was a letter from Mr. Walker to Mr. Brockbank, on the 4th, saying that Mr. Thomas showed an authority; and he (Mr. Walker) had told Mr. Thomas he would not be allowed to go down. Then there was a letter from Mr. Thomas to the Company fixing an appointment for inspection the next day. That was less than 24 hours notice of an appointment for noon on the following day. Mr. Thomas had reported that Mr. Brockbank was still most strongly against an inspection, but counsel thought he might have added that Mr. Walker had promised if he could to arrange a Board meeting earlier than the usual date. The instructions given to Mr. Richardson not to allow Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout down the mine were founded on Mr. Brockbank's instructions that the matter must receive consideration. On the 5th they called, and they were refused inspection. He (Mr. Cave) said that was justified because dealing with Companies at times they were entitled to a little time in which the matter may be considered at a Board meeting. It is not enough to make an appointment in the way it was done. Mr. Justice Warrington: You say it was not a reasonable time because not enough notice was given? Mr. Cave: Nor was it a refusal of inspection, because the Board had never met to consider the matter or had the opportunity of doing so. Then (continued counsel) came the solicitors' letter making a formal appointment for the 12th, and on the 12th the inspection was allowed, and although his learned friend made a great point in opening about Mr. Brockbank's instructions not to answer questions, Mr. Richardson in the box said he did answer every question put. Mr. Justice Warrington: I have no evidence of any want of reasonableness in the assistance given. Mr. Cave, continuing, said he did not think the plaintiffs were entitled to have the manager for that purpose. The words were "workmen and agents" and counsel did not think there was any refusal to give the assistance of their workmen and agents. Mr. Upjohn said that he did not put much on that, he put the letter to show the animus. Mr. Cave, continuing, referred to a letter from plaintiffs' solicitors giving notice that Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout would be at the mine on Friday, the 12th, for the purpose of inspecting the mine and working plans. To that letter Mr. Brockbank replied that he had given instructions for Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout to be met at the mine and be allowed to make inspection of the mine and plans. Mr. Brockbank had evidently been under the impression which turned out to be right that the lessors were contemplating some kind of proceedings. No doubt he did say that questions should not be answered, but although he said that it was not acted upon because all the questions were answered. Well, on the 12th the inspection took place. Now, continued counsel, he came to the 24th which was really the point he had to meet and he would like before he did that to remind His Lordship of this, that this was a matter of forfeit, and plaintiffs must make it out fully, and on this he quoted authorities in support. On the 24th April Mr. Thomas writing as he said without any previous communication with Mr. Stout wrote a notice that Mr. Stout would attend on Friday, the 25th inst., at about twelve o'clock to continue their inspection. On that the same observation was made. It only gave the company 24 hours' notice and it asked for inspection not only of the mines but also of the plans, which were not mentioned in their authority, and it asked for the assistance of the manager, which was going, counsel submitted, rather beyond the lessors' rights, because their right was to have assistance of members of the staff who would be chosen in the ordinary course by the leasees. Counsel submitted that they had no more authority to insist on the manager, the busiest man in the whole place, than on the chairman of the Company. They were asking more than they were entitled to. The reply of Mr. Brockbank, "We cannot comply with the terms of your notice" meant, counsel submitted, "We cannot comply with your notice in terms — we cannot accept it as a whole." Counsel considered that the point was that altogether beyond the mere letter the plaintiffs were bound to present themselves personally or by the agent, and tender themselves to make the inspection and only then could refusal happen. The letter taken by itself was not a refusal or a repudiation of the covenant. Mr. Justice Warrington said that the covenant was at reasonable times to permit and offer the lessor or his agents to enter, &c. What Mr. Cave meant was that the actual presentation left a locus penitentiae after the letter if they thought better of it and may withdraw that refusal if the persons came to inspect. Mr. Cave said that was so. Suppose he was to covenant to do something next year and was to say to-day he would not do it that would not be a breach of the covenant. Mr. Justice Warrington said it would not. Mr. Cave said he submitted on that letter there was no breach on which a forfeiture could be founded. Mr. Thomas presented himself at the mine on the next day, and by instructions was refused going down. Well, now, what he said as to that was there had not been reasonable notice, only 24 hours' notice, and, secondly, in order to have default in performing the covenant it was necessary not only for Mr. Thomas alone but for both of the nominees of the lessors to present themselves. Mr. Justice Warrington: You say there is no evidence. Thomas by himself was an agent — Thomas and Stout were. Mr. Cave said that was so. The application was to allow them both down together, if they both came together. His friend might call that technical but in an action of forfeiture he was entitled to be technical. Mr. Justice Warrington: Oh, you're entitled to be technical. Mr. Cave said this was an action by which it was sought to forfeit property of very great value, many thousands of pounds, and he was entitled to be technical and so say there was no breach. Mr. Cave then proceeded to quote authorities for the principle that where an authority was given to more than one person jointly it was no operative for one if the other died or did not act. Mr. Justice Warrington said that apparently Mr. Thomas thought Mr. Stout would come. He was a little vague about it. He had not made an appointment with Mr. Stout but that as a rule he had an arrangement that Mr. Stout would be there when called on. The lessee was entitled to say the plaintiffs should have a report of two but not of one unless they altered their minds. Mr. Cave said it was remarkable in this case that although Mr. Stout was a party to the first inspection counsel's learned friend did not call Mr. Stout. He (Mr. Cave) said no more on that. He only suggested it. Mr. Justice Warrington: That is your point on that. Mr. Cave: Yes, that there is no refusal to perform because we never had the chance to perform the request in the form in which it was made. Mr. Justice Warrington observed that the solicitors' letter carried it a little further because it asked that Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout should inspect. Mr. Cave said there was no question of the law on the point that one of the two had no authority to act alone. Mr. Justice Warrington observed that if only one man had inspected and it turned out he had no authority the lessors might have repudiated him as their agent on that ground. Mr. Cave, resuming after the luncheon adjournment, referred to the occasion of the 26th April. On the 2nd May Mr. Brockbank wrote the solicitors to the plaintiff saying the mines were then and had always been open to the lessors' inspection at all reasonable times. At all events if there were any reluctance at all to allow inspection it did not last over a week. There was no real substance in it. As far as that point went counsel submitted there were no breaches of the covenant. If there had been proper notice and both had come and taken inspection it would have been different but they did not present themselves and there was no breach of covenant at all. Now he came to the second point. Assuming there was a breach of covenant on the 26th April the plaintiff having regard to the pleadings could not claim possession of the mine. This opened a question of legal arguments as to the position of the plaintiffs with regard to re-entry on the premises, and the citation of cases to which counsel addressed himself at considerable length. Mr. Upjohn having replied to this argument with other cases and references to the question as to whether the authority to Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout was joint and several asked that if the two agents differed how was the employment on which they were engaged to be executed. He contended that it was absurd to say that one of them was not to go down without the other. The Executors were not going to be bound by anything at all. It was simply an appointment of two professional men for the purpose of obtaining information. It might as well be said that during the absence of his two learned juniors in this case he (counsel) could not represent the plaintiffs. (Laughter). He submitted that it was not necessary to get a new authority for Mr. Thomas to act alone, and that it was not reasonable. How could they both take copies or extracts from plans together? He submitted this was a separate employment in which each was employed in his separate capacity, one as an engineer the other was a mine manager. On the question of the requirement of delay to give the company time to consider the notice and request he argued that this could not be maintained and also the refusal the plaintiffs had met with was a point blank refusal which they were entitled to accept. The refusal of the 26th meant that they should neither see the plans nor go down the mine. The plaintiffs so understood it and until Mr. Cave was in a somewhat difficult position in finding an answer to this action he (counsel) did not think anybody ever suggested it meant anything but a complete refusal. Mr. Upjohn also argued on the question of the proposed qualification of reasonable time that this might have been a case where the delay of a month or a fortnight or a week might have led to a change in the conditions which would have been most injurious to the plaintiffs, and though he made no imputations against anyone in that respect in this case, it could not be shown that there might be good cause for immediate access. The court adjourned until Tuesday morning. The Ullcoats Mining Action. Judgment For The Defendants. (Continued From Page 3.) Tuesday, November 5th. On the Court resuming this morning. Mr. Justice Warrington intimated to Mr. Upjohn that he relieved him of the question of the construction of the authority. The construction of the authority must be the true construction, and it must be taken as authorising either or both of the agents to inspect the mine and plans. It really came to the question whether there had been sufficient re-entry. Mr. Upjohn then addressed himself to the question of the position in which the issue of the writ placed the plaintiffs with regard to re-entry, and also contending that the injunction claimed in the writ was an inter-locutory injunction only, and that the Court would not issue an injunction for the regulation of the specific working of the inline during a length of time. The arguments the adduced in support of his view were of a legal and technical character; such as he said only a Chancery lawyer could properly appreciate, and he supported his position by numerous references to precedents and cases. On the conclusion of Mr. Upjohn's argument, which occupied the Court until shortly before twelve o'clock, His Lordship, without calling on Mr. Cave, delivered. Judgment. Mr. Justice WARRINGTON, in delivering judgment, said this an action brought by the representatives of the lessor against the lessees, first to recover possession on the footing that the lease had been determined under a proviso for re-entry, and secondly for damages in respect of alleged breaches of the working covenant, and an injunction as regards some of those covenants, the subject matter of the lease being an iron ore mine in Cumberland.His Lordship said he would deal first with the claim for damages for breach of the working covenant. No injunction was asked for on that part, and all he had to deal with was whether the covenant had been broken and the defendants were therefore liable to pay damages. Now the covenants relied on in this part of the case were these? The covenant by the lessees was that they should and would at all times during the term carry on the work of the mine vigorously, uninterruptedly, and in a proper, skilful, and mining-like manner, and according to the most approved practice in the winning and working of iron ore mines in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven, and in such manner as to get and raise the greatest quantity of ore which could be reasonably got from the same. Then there was a provision that the lessees should not, and would not, during the continuation of the term granted by the lessee, do, or suffer to be done, any wilful or negligent act, which might endanger, the works and the mine. The body of iron ore, His Lordships continued, in this mine, was on of great thickness in some parts of it, and it lay on the rise roughly from south to north, a little bit east of north, but that was immaterial to the purpose. It came to an end at the extreme rise in a stratum of pinnel or boulder clay, and for some 30 or 40 feet or thereabouts the pinnel lay immediately upon the ore, which was there only a few feet thick, gradually diminishing to a point where it disappeared, that point technically called the nip-out. Above the pinnel were strata of quicksand and gravel and water. The pinnel itself above that part of the bed of ore which lay between the actual nip-out and the termination of the limestone which formed the roof of covering of the bed of ore before it joined the pinnel varied from some 50 to 60 feet or thereabout, so far as could be ascertained by considering the depth of the pinnel at the two boreholes which he would presently mention. The facts as to the nature and position of the overlying strata were ascertained by the construction of three bore holes and a shaft, and allowing for any variation in the strata which might occur at intervals not actually decided were known to the officials of the defendant Company at all material points. The usual and proper practice in winning and working iron ore mines in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven is this: to sink at a pit some where near the dip of the ore, from thence to work the ore to the rise, leaving, of course, sufficient pillars to sustain the roof until the second working, which he was about to mention, had been completed. The ore is worked from the dip by driving roads in this case to the north and from these roads driving east and west. When the ore has in this way been worked to the rise the miner proceeds, as it is technically called, to rob, that is, to work and get the pillars, beginning this process from the extreme eastern extremity of the mine, and working backwards, letting down the roof over the place that is worked out. That practice is the usual practice, the usual and approved practice in this district, and by the description of it substantially from the plaintiffs' own witnesses. His Lordship thought as to that there was no dispute. The course he had described had been pursued by the defendants in the present case. In February, 1904, their first workings were approaching the extreme rise, and some of them had actually struck the pinnel, that is to say, the working had reached the point where the pinnel lay immediately over the bed of ore. The attention of their mining engineer, Mr. Walker, and their manager, Mr. Richardson, was called to the fact by Mr. Thomas, who was agent of Lord Leconfield, the lessor of the adjoining part of the bed of ore. Mr. Thomas, in calling their attention to this fact, expressed his apprehension that if they went onto work the ore under the pinnel, they would be liable to an inrush of water from the overlying strata which he thought they would run some risk of incurring . Mr. Richardson and Mr. Walker had told him (Mr. Justice Warrington) that they personally did not apprehend, any danger from the working, and it was the first working north that was then in progress, but that they did realise that when it came to robbing the pillars, that is to say, when they came to start their second working, special care in this would have to be taken, owning to the fact that there was a water bearing strata overlying the pinnel. They, however, notwithstanding their view as to the risk apprehended by Mr. Thomas, so far acceded to his suggestion as to decide to stop certain of the workings for the time. That the decision, that their decision, was to be unlimited, I find, said his Lordship, to be a fact, by the balance of evidence on the point. Mr. Richardson explained the suspension was in order that they might see how far the pinnel in this position would stand, and how far they might, therefore, trust to it as a roof, in their first working. He (Mr. Justice Warrington) might say that pinnel is a tough clay with stones in it, sometimes small, sometimes of considerable size, and is regarded in ordinary cases as a good roof in this district and for these iron ore mines, always speaking of the first working. The danger that is suggested arises not from the nature of the pinnel, by itself, but from the existence of the water-bearing strata, overlying the pinnel. Having stopped these workings in pursuance of the decision to which he had alluded, the defendant resumed these workings some nine or ten months later, namely, towards the autumn of 1904. The working plans of the mine were open to Mr. Gill, the mining agent of the lessor, and no objection was made by either of them to the resumption of work at the point at which the working had been temporarily stopped. Early in the month of December, 1906, after the first workings had been completed, and after the robbing of the pillars in the eastern extremity of the mine had been commenced, it was reported to Mr. Richardson that a piece of roof in one of the workings close to the extreme rise, close to the nip-out, showed signs of sagging. The first working had left in that particular place a small residue of ore in the roof, which had not been previously removed. That ore was of no use as a support to the roof, and if the pinnel had fallen there was a risk that that quantity of ore would have been buried and would have been lost, or could only have been got with great expense and trouble. Accordingly, Mr. Richardson directed that small residue of ore to be got and early in December, His Lordship thought, two shoots at the outside, two shots were fired, with the result that the whole of the ore which he (Mr. Richardson) desired thus to get was detached from the pinnel roof, and all they had to do was to remove the ore so detached from the ground. The men were engaged in removing this ore, when on the 14th of January in the present year, a crack appeared in the pinnel roof, and water and sand came through. Mr. Richardson immediately proceeded to deal with this, state of things by timbering the whole length of the road in that part of the mine to prevent as far as might be the inrush of water and sand to the lower part. Unfortunately a further subsidence took place, extending to the surface, and the pinnel had allowed from time to time further inrushes of sand and water into the mine, and in particular one happened on the 2nd of March in this year. It is alleged by the plaintiff's that the result of that has been to materially injure the mine, to render it more difficult to get the remaining ore, and to render the remaining ore of smaller marketable value. His Lordship said he would assume for the present purpose that that contention was correct, and that the result of the accident had been to cause damage. The question is whether that damage has resulted in any breach by the tenant of any of the covenants of the lease. Now this must be borne in mind, that since the last inrush of water and sand which he had mentioned there had been no further inrush under the subsidence that has already taken place. To use a technical term the pinnel appears to have sealed itself, to have resumed its previous position, and to have formed now an effectual barrier to the water and sand above. Moreover, no inrush of water and sand has taken place where the pillars have been robbed in the north-east corner of the mine. He would now go back, His Lordship continued, and give them the covenants in order and consider whether there was any breach in any of them. The first to which he desired to refer was the last of them, the last in position in the lease. It was that the lessee would not do, or suffer to be done, any wilful or negligent act, matter, or thing, which might hazard, endanger, or cause loss to the mine. Now, as to that, His Lordship found that there was no evidence at all of any wilfully negligent act, matter, or thing, hazarding or endangering the mine. His Lordship thought that covenant had reference not to general process of working. To make out a breach of that covenant it would be necessary to prove some specific act of negligence or of wilful wrong-doing.Of that there is, said His Lordship, no evidence at all. With regard to the covenant that they will carry on the mine according to the most approved practice in the winning and working with regard to the covenant that they will carry on the mine according to the most approved practice in the winning and working of iron ore mines in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven, not only, said His Lordship, is there no evidence they have failed to do so, but he thought it was common ground that the mode in which they are working the mine is the one of approved practice of working iron ore mines in the district of Whitehaven. The real gravamen of the charge brought by the plaintiffs is they ought to have departed from the practice and adopted a special method, having regard to what they say is the special nature of the strata overlying the ore. That left His Lordship to deal with the allegation that the Company were guilty of improper, unskilful, and unmining-like conduct in the general policy which they pursued. The manager, Mr. Richardson, and the mining engineer, Mr. Walker, had both been called before him, and they say that they saw no reason for departing from the usual course, but they knew when they came to rob out, special care would have to be taken. This was done, special care was taken, when they came to rob out, and as His Lordship had said with success so far, in that in the places where the pillars had been robbed there has been no inrush of water. Both Mr. Walker and Mr. Richardson, said His Lordship, struck me as exceptionally able and competent persons and I am satisfied that they were both perfectly honest witnesses. I have no hesitation in accepting the statements they make, that is to say as to matters of fact, and I have no hesitation in giving weight to the opinions they express. His Lordship continued that the charge of improper and unskilful working was supported only by gentlemen eminent in their profession, no doubt, but who have the advantage of being instructed by the event, and being so instructed they expressed the opinion that no working at all at the extreme rise should have been undertaken, but that a wedge or barrier of ore 60 feet in depth or width should have been left un-worked until the whole of the dip had been worked out, for that purpose, of course leaving sufficient pillars to support the road requisite for the purpose of ultimately getting that wedge of ore and for protecting the shaft. This opinion had been adversely criticised by Mr. Richardson and by Mr. Walker, and His Lordship must say that it is a matter about which competent persons experienced in the matter which they had to consider may well hold different views. Now such words as proper, skilful, and mining-like, and particularly the word skilful, must have a relative meaning. There is no abstract criterion of skilful. It must be read in connection with the facts and circumstances in reference to which it is used, and he thought in construing this covenant it would be wrong to set up any higher standard of skill to be required from the lessees than that they should do this work with reasonable skill and diligence, and if it is found that they had done that then he thought there was no breach of covenant. In his opinion, Mr. Walker and Mr. Richardson, who directed the working of this mine, were justified in supposing that the pinnel would form a sufficient barrier against the quicksand, and proper at all events for the first, working. As he had already said, they realised that care was necessary when the robbing began. Now the inrush of water had happened , not where there has been robbing, and it had happened at a place where in His Lordship's opinion, on the evidence before him, pillars had been left which any ordinary mining engineer or mine manager would consider sufficient for the purpose. Under those circumstances, His Lordship thought that the inrush of water might properly be treated as an accident which might happen although reasonable skill and diligence were shown in conducting the working. It is impossible, continued His Lordship, to hold that there has been improper, unskilful, and unmining-like working, because, after the accident, the mode in which the mine is worked is adversely criticised by eminent engineers, however eminent they may be. It seems to me that there the claim for damages has failed. His Lordship continued that he now came to another part of the case, and one which he confessed had given him a great deal of difficulty. That was the claim for re-entry. The claim for re-entry was based upon the alleged breach of certain covenants in the lease, which was excepted from the provisions of Section 14 of the Conveyancing Act of 1841. These covenants were first to make and keep plans and from time to time produce these for the inspection of the lessor or his agent or any of them, with leave to take extracts and also, as to the clause of the lease which His Lordship read with regard to permitting inspection of the mine, and the provision for re-entry. The point was, His Lordship said, that the breach of covenant conferred on the lessor the right of re-entry, and it is on his exercising his right of re-entry that the lease determines. Now what happened was this. On the 1st of April in this year Mr. Thomas, who had been previously known to the lessees as the agent for Lord Leconfield, wrote to say that he was instructed, accompanied by Mr. Stout, mine manager, to make an inspection of the mine on behalf of the lessors — the representatives of Mr. Moore, the original lessor. The authority on which he purported to act was not immediately produced. It was subsequently produced and was in these terms; "We hereby authorise and appoint Mr. Watkyn Thomas, mining engineer, and Mr. James Stout, mine manager, to inspect and report on the Ullcoats mine on our behalf." The inspection which was there asked for was ultimately refused by the defendants, but having regard to what subsequently took place such refusal was not, His Lordship thought, material to the present question he had to determine. On the 12th of April, however, a week later, the inspection was permitted, Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout were allowed to examine the plans, they were allowed to inspect the mine and His Lordship said he had it in evidence that Mr. Richardson went down with them and answered every question that was put to him. There was no complaint with reference to that inspection. Now on the 24th of April Mr. Thomas wrote to the defendant company this letter: "I beg to give you notice that Mr. James Stout and I shall attend on Friday, the 26th inst., at about twelve noon to continue our inspection of the plans and mine when we shall be glad to have the assistance of the manager." That was answered on the 25th, by a letter in these terms: "We have yours of the 24th inst., and have to say that we cannot comply with the terms of your notice." On the 26th, Mr. Thomas alone presented himself at the mine and was refused inspection. Now it was said by the defendants that there was no breach. In the first place His Lordship did not think that there was any breach by the notice of the 25th. He thought that that notice being only in general terms was not necessarily a refusal. The notice of the 24th, asked for something more than they were entitled to in observance of the covenant, namely the assistance of a particular man. It seemed to His Lordship therefore there was no actual breach, on the 25th, and that attendance on the 26th was necessary that there should be a complete refusal. Now there were two points made by the defendants with regard to this attendance on the 26th. The first point was this, it was said that there was no breach of covenant to permit the agent of the letter to inspect the mine because Mr. Thomas was not the agent for that purpose. The agents for that purpose appointed by the authority of the 2nd, of April were Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout. Mr. Thomas alone was not the agent and reference was made in support of the contention that if two people were appointed to a thing one of these even if the other was dead, was not competent to do the thing. His Lordship thought that contention, however well founded it might be in law, was ousted by the true construction of this notice. His Lordship thought that, must be construed, having regard to the circumstances under which it was given, and so construed he thought it must amount to authority to these two persons or either of them, if the circumstances should so require, to act by himself. The second point made in regards to it was that Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout were not agents to inspect the plans. His Lordship thought it impossible a proper inspection and report on the mine could be made without the inspection of the working plan. He thought, therefore the authority must be taken to imply an authority to inspect plans. In his opinion the refusal on the 26th, was a breach of the covenant to which he had referred. But the question remained were the plaintiffs now entitled to recover possession in consequence of that breach. On the 29th April the plaintiffs gave a notice which His Lordship read that the lease had been determined by the breach of covenant by this refusal, and that they intended to re-enter upon the premises devised by the lease. On the 4th of May they issued a writ in an action which was discontinued two days later. This writ claimed first recovery of the possession of the mine, mesne profits, and injunction to restrain the defendants or their servants or agents from further working the said mine, so as to hazard, endanger, or cause loss or damage to the said mine or the works therein. Fourth an order to the defendants from time to time and at all reasonable times to permit and suffer the plaintiff s and their servants and agents to enter, following the exact words of the covenant which he had just read, and asking therefore for an order in terms according to that covenant. Now two questions arose. The first is, was the writ on the 4th of May a re-entry, within the words of the proviso — re-entry or equivalent to re-entry? His Lordship thought it was now settled that under a proviso for re-entry such as the present a writ claiming possession simpliciter and any further relief which is incident to the claim of possession would be equivalent to a re-entry, and if this writ was regarded as a writ of this nature there would be sufficient re-entry within the meaning of the covenant and the lease is determined. The question he had to decide on this part of case was, was this writ an unequivocal claim for possession? It was answered on behalf of the plaintiff that these two claims 3 and 4 must be read as claims for interlocutory relief only and that not only was the opposite construction a wrong construction to be put upon it but that it is absolutely absurd to suppose that it could have any such meaning. Now, His Lordship thought that the real question he had to consider was, was this writ in such a form that it would not have been open to the plaintiff to offer — if they should consider that their most convenient course — to ask for relief on the footing of their lease being in existence and to abandon their claim for ejectment for possession, and he thought he was bound to come to the conclusion that this writ was equivocal, that this was a writ to which the plaintiffs might if they had been so minded have given a meaning contrary to that which they now contended for as the only meaning. Now it was said that these two claims, one for injunction and one for an order of inspection could only be treated as claims for interlocutory relief. With regard to an injunction he thought that the plaintiff could have obtained protection against improper working by means of an injunction in the terms in which this writ was expressed. It had been said on the authorities cited that it was perfectly well recognised that the Court would not endeavour by means of an injunction to enforce a specific performance of the working of a mine. His Lordship quite agreed, yet he could equally well see that if there was a covenant against any, improper working sufficient to be expressed in an order in that case an injunction might be made and he could grant such an injunction. He thought, therefore, the relief might have been obtained if an injunction had been asked for at the trial. But that really was not the question. The question was, had they by their writ asked for or did they mean to ask for relief of that nature. He thought with regard to 3 they had. With regard to 4 the case was still stronger. They had followed verbatim the words of the covenant and he could not conceive any meaning except that they intended applying for an order. He thought the writ was so framed that it might have been possible if the plaintiffs had been so minded to say they would go for either relief expressed on the writ and they would not go for possession. In other words that the claim of possession and the claim for an injunction under paragraph 4 were inconsistent, and therefore the plaintiffs could not obtain forfeiture, could not obtain possession in this present action. According to the authorities that had been cited he must come to the conclusion that the writ issued by the plaintiffs was not unequivocable. It was, therefore, not entirely a writ for possession. But the plaintiffs contended that if the writ was not in itself a writ of ejectment there was a previous expression of their election to take possession in the two notices of the 29th of April and the 3rd of May. He thought however, that that was not sufficient. The notices were based upon a statement of fact that had not happened, and the only thing that could be relied upon was the actual issue of the writ. The issue of the writ was for the reasons he had said and not unequivocable, and therefore the plaintiffs were not entitled in the present action to re-entry. The result was that the action failed altogether, and there must be a judgment for the defendants with costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||