|
31st October 1907 Important Local Mining ActionMoore v. The Ullcoats Mining Company LtdThis action came on for hearing in the Chancery Division, before Mr. Justice, Warrington, on Tuesday. Counsel for the plaintiff: Mr. Upjohn K.C., Mr. Terrell K.C., and Mr. M. Swinney, instructed by Messrs. Brown, Auld, and Brown, Whitehaven. Counsel for the defendants: Mr. Warmington, K.C., Mr. Cave, K.C., and Mr. J. G. Wood, instructed by Messrs Brockbank, Helder, and Ormrod, Whitehaven. Mr. Upjohn, K.C., in opening the case, said the action is by reversioners, the Exors of the lessor, against the lessees, for two purposes. The first is to recover possession of the devised premises, on the ground of breach of covenant. The other claim is to recover damages for a breach of a totally different kind. The lease in question was granted by the testator, and dated 28th December 1900, and is a lease of all the iron ore lying under the estate of Ullcoats. That body of ore goes to the adjoining property of Lord Leconfield, and is, if not the largest, the second largest field of iron ore in the Whitehaven district, and on the Ullcoats property alone at quite a moderate estimate there are nearer two million tons of ore rather than one million tons. The lease, which expires in 1921, contains amongst other covenants two covenants relating to the working according to the custom of the district, and to keep maps and plans in the usual way, and on request to produce the maps and plans to the lessor or his agent, and also to permit lessor or his agent to descent into the workings and find out anything they desired to know. That was a covenant, the breach of which had been followed by an action of ejectment. They, the plaintiffs, in the month of April last, desired to inspect the work, and on defendants failing to give them access, took this action. In the month of March of this year were two most serious subsidences happened. The workings were flooded by a rush of quicksand, of which there was an enormous body overlying the roof of the iron ore, and the rumours of the district were that the mine was absolutely drowned out, and would never be worked again. Therefore, the Exors, very naturally thought it to be their duty to have some reliable report on the matter, so they authorised two gentlemen, Mr. Thomas, a mining engineer of considerable experience, and Mr. Stout, who was acquainted with the district, to see the working plans and inspect the workings and report. When the application was received, the managing director asked for the authority, but before it was produced, he communicated with a gentleman named Brockbank, a member of the legal profession, who is Chairman of the Company, the fact that the Exors were moving in this way. Thereupon, Mr. Brockbank, by his letters and telegrams, gave most positive orders that the Exors, and their agent were not to be allowed to go down or see the working plans. That excited great suspicion in the plaintiff's minds. On one occasion the defendants did allow a partial inspection, on the same day after Mr. Thomas and Mr. Stout had seen the plans, but the examination of the plans took some little time, and there was very little time left for the inspection of the workings, and it was intimated the gentlemen meant to go again. When they made another appointment by Mr. Brockbank's direction the Company reverted to their old position, and said they should not go and thereupon the plaintiffs brought an action of ejectment. In that action they had had ample inspection since. The result of their inspection since had satisfied the plaintiffs and they hoped to satisfy His Lordship that the defendants had so worked in the mine as to lead to that inrush of quicksand. The mine was most seriously damaged. The workings to the north, which are workings to the rise, are inaccessible, water is still coming in, and generally the mine is most seriously depreciated in value, and it will never be safe from another inrush of quicksand. The ore is somewhat irregular. It descends from the south about 80 feet. They work it in three tiers, which run about north, and then runs up very considerably, and very rapidly becomes only about two feet thick, and then outcrops on the surface, the outcrop being what is locally called pinnel. What happened was that in the early part of 1904 Mr. Thomas, who was acting then as agent and engineer for Lord Leconfield, whose property marches with the plaintiffs' drew their attention to the fact that their working the rise was endangering the mine, and there were several consultations, with the result at a meeting of the defendant Company in the month of March, 1904, they deliberately resolved not to prosecute the workings to the rise. After that the price of iron ore rose very rapidly from something like 11s in 1904 to about 18s per ton in 1907. Now, it so happened that the ore to the rise was more easily worked. The mode of working is by firing shots, and the court would understand that tended to disturb the whole roof. The ore lying to the rise is more friable, and more easily worked, and in order to take advantage of the market and the high prices that were ruling the defendants seemed in 1905 to have deliberately re-started their workings in the rise. There was an enormous quantity of ore, which was from 30 to 40 and 80 feet in thickness, and in 1905 the Company resolved to work in the rise again, and they denuded the ground of pillars, and denuded the roof of its support. The result was that in January the water began to come through, and early in March there was a serious subsidence of surface, at the first about ten feet in diameter and about 25 feet in depth. They worked the ore right up to the outcrop, worked into the pinnel, so that they must have taken away some of the pinnel to get room to walk. The result was the pinnel became insecure, and the plaintiffs claimed that the defendants should have made greater provision for the protection of the roof than they did. They did not timber sufficiently, and enormous damage had been done in the mine. Turning to the lease, counsel described its chief provisions. It was made on the 28th December 1900, and expires in 1921. The dead rent is £200 a year, and the tonnage rents are according to the selling prices of ore. When the price is under 10s it is 8d, and when above 10s and not reaching 20s, it is 8d and 1/6th of the excess, and when over 20s it is 2s 4d and one fifth of the excess under 26s. There were covenants for working in the manner of the district about Whitehaven, and if lost by any unskilful or careless management the ore was to be paid for by the lessees as if actually got, and the plaintiffs asked for monies under that condition. There were also provisions for the lessor to enter the mine in certain contingencies. Mr. Upjohn, then taking the plan, explained upon it to the Judge the position of the ore to which his arguments applied. It varied in thickness from 37 to 47 and 80 feet. At No. 2 borehole it diminished to 25 feet, at No. 1 to 28 feet, and at No.3 had disappeared altogether. An important matter, said counsel, to bear in mind was that these three boreholes were sunk before the shaft was sunk, and the defendants knew therefore what he (counsel) was going to tell the court. The great bulk of the ore lay in the dip, and that was very important, when they came to the question of damages, because of its relation to the future working. The pitch is very steep and the quicksand comes down with a great rush. At No. 2 shaft the roof over the ore is very good, about 200 feet in thickness, but when they got up to No. 1 there was a very different state of things. In No. 1 shaft, after passing through the surface, there was a thickness of quicksand, the same being so fine that it was like that used for hourglasses. Then there was pinnel, and then conglomerate. Stopping at the sole of the pinnel and the top of the conglomerate there was a depth of 89 feet from the surface, and such was the nature of the soil it took them nearly a year to sink 690 feet, they met with such difficulties. In the next place they got some 30 feet of conglomerate and 90 feet of limestone. That made a fairly good roof. And then at a depth of 212 feet they got into a bed of ore, which at No. 1 shaft was 47 feet in thickness. In sinking the borehole No. 2 before No. 2 shaft was put down they got into 39 feet of quicksand, with water, and then pinnel, and then limestone. In borehole No. 1 after passing the surface soil they had 73 feet of quicksand and the limestone below the pinnel had only a thickness of something over 2 feet, so that the roof there was practically a pinnel roof. Counsel proceeded to show by means of plans the course of the workings of the Company, which the plaintiffs objected to, and said that with all the knowledge gained by their sinkings and borings the defendants early in 1904 were working to the rise, and getting near the pinnel. At this time Mr. Watkyn-Thomas was acting for Lord Leconfield as the lessor of the ore adjoining these mines. In 1904 in the course of one of his inspections, Mr. Thomas found the defendants were working to the rise, and had worked very much to the rise, and accordingly be made a representation to Mr. Walker, who is managing director of the Company. Mr. Burnyeat, who is a director of the Company, came in and discussed the matter with Mr. Thomas, and at a subsequent meeting of the directors it was decided to stop three workings in Mr. Moore's royalty, and one in Lord Leconfield's, all of which were going to the rise. There the matter rested for the time. They could not exactly say when the working was resumed, though the working plans afforded more information on that point. In 1905 there was a very large increase in the price of ore, and in October 1905, there was an entry in Mr. Walkers book that he had arranged with Miles Richardson to commence roofing the northeast end of No. 1 pit. And when they did that if they timbered at all they timbered badly. There were a few posts found on inspection, but at all events such as they were they were insufficient to support the roof. The plaintiffs considered this a most absolutely suicidal method of working, because the fact was for the sake of saving expense in working denser and stronger ore and hauling it uphill instead of lifting it downhill the defendants deprived the mode of protection against water. The inevitable result happened. This was in October 1905, and in little more than a year afterwards, in January last, they began to make water. On the 14th of January Mr. Walker recorded the receipt of news of the pit that there had been an in-rush of quicksand in No. 1 pit, and that the men had run and the pumps were standing. Counsel proceeded to quote further from Mr. Walkers notes of his proceedings for the arrest of the in-rush, and by the 21st of January the Company had overcome the difficulty, and the men were at work in No. 1 pit. Some pumping went on until the month of March, and then the subsidence occurred, and following the course of Mr. Walker's observations on that, counsel found that on the 9th of March No. 2 pit was restarted. On the 18th the matter was not being so easily surmounted as they expected, and No. 2 pit was stopped again, and matters went on until the 28th or 26th when they had another in fall and a considerable enlargement resulting in a greater quantity of quicksand. Then it was that Mrs. Moore, widow, and one of the executors of the lessor, living at Ullcoats House, got very much alarmed, and ultimately at the end of the month consulted Mr. Watkyn-Thomas. No. 2 pit had been suspended from time to time. No. 1 pit had never been worked since, and they had been pumping all the time and the surface subsidence had continued to increase. On the 24th of October when Mr. Thomas and another gentleman were inspecting the mine and were going towards the part counsel indicated on the plan, they found a great deal of water coming, and Mr. Richardson, the mine manager, who was with them said "I am not going further; it is dangerous to life, and I am not going to have your lives on my hands. I am not going, and I warn you it is dangerous." Well they did go and they would tell the court what they saw, and a very little more rain such as they might expect in that part of the country at this time of year would cause another larger subsidence. The plaintiffs say the whole mine is endangered. It is a very valuable property, and if they did get possession they got possession of something worth many thousands of pounds less than it ought to be. Counsel then passed on to the other part of the case, the refusal to give the plaintiffs the inspection to which they were entitled. On this they got the history of the proceedings from the correspondence and Mr. Walkers entries in his diary. In April, 1907, Mr. Thomas wrote a letter making an appointment for himself and Mr. Stout to see the mine and plans, and Mr. Walker telegraphed this to Mr. Brockbank and that Mr. Thomas had produced authority. Mr. Brockbank replied that they would require more particulars before assenting. Mr. Walker asked for the authority of the executors authorising Mr. Watkyn-Thomas, and Mr. Thomas was given such authority. Counsel followed the course of the correspondence between the parties in considerable detail, to the inspection of the plans and partial inspection of the mine, which was subsequently refused, and this action commenced. Counsel then called evidence. Mr. W. M. WATKYN-THOMAS, sworn, deposed that he was a mining and civil engineer in practice at Workington, and had a long experience as mining engineer, and in 1882 came to Cumberland as a mining engineer for Lord Leconfield and continued on until the end of 1905. Lord Leconfield had mines in the district he worked himself, and others he leased. Witness had had a large experience of iron mines in Cumberland. Lord Leconfield owned mineral property intermixed with Mr. Moore's and the present defendants were lessees of the minerals under the Ullcoats estate and witness was frequently underground in the mine up to the end of 1905, and knew the workings. The fault was in the S.W. side. The mine lay to the N.E. of the fault and rose the whole way from S.W. to W.E. and rose on the whole one in the three, but in the extreme west there was a very sharp rise. The greatest thickness of the ore is 80 feet. At No. 2 shaft it is 37 feet thick. At No. 1 shaft it is 47 feet thick. At No. 2 borehole 35 feet thick, and at No. 1 borehole 28 feet, and at the nip-out under two feet thick. The working is wholly by blasting. The thickness of the ore as it gets to the roof affects the roof in blasting. Pillars are left to support the roof. The defendants sunk a shaft No. 1 and boreholes 2, 1, and 3. He had examined the defendant's journals of the sinking of the shaft and boreholes. That showed in fortnightly periods what sort they were passing through, and how much they got through in fathoms and feet. Looking at the journal of No. 1 shaft they commenced with quicksand, clay, and pinnel and then conglomerate. They took a year and a fortnight to get through 89 feet. That was slow, but not considering the difficult ground they had to deal with. The experience gained was of great importance showing that above the solid rock they had a body of dangerous material. Quicksand was worse than water to deal with when it got into a mine. The distance from No.3 borehole to No. 1 shaft was 465 feet; from No. 1 to the shaft 280; and from No. 2 to the shaft 230. In No. 1 shaft there was about 41 feet of quicksand only, then the pinnel 33 feet. The water, the sand, and the pinnel were the causes of difficulty in the sinking. At borehole No. 2., top-bed of quicksand, 24 feet thick, there was pinnel again and then about 8 feet of sand and water, and then pinnel, and then 18 feet of limestone. That compared with 9 feet of limestone in the shaft. At borehole No.1, top stratum of quicksand, gravel was 63 feet, pinnel 26 feet, then gravel and sand and water 7 feet, and then pinnel 47 feet. The limestone there was about 2 feet 8 inches thick. It was going out altogether. At No. 3 borehole the thickness of the quicksand stratum was top bed 17 feet, pinnel 19 feet, and then more water strata and then pinnel again for 63 feet. The limestone and the ore are lost here entirely. Limestone is a good roof and so is conglomerate. Down to the dip working from No. 2 shaft there is a very good roof of conglomerate 200 feet thick. Pinnel is a very uncertain roof, and at times dangerous. Pinnel is a mixture of clay, stones, boulders, gravel, and sand. It is dangerous because stones fall with very little warning, and are so concealed that they cannot be perceived. Pinnel breaks, and is so uncertain it cannot be safely relied on as a roof. It is a purely glacial deposit-boulder clay. Quicksand is very dangerous as an overlying stratum, extremely difficult to get rid of when it gets into the working. The borings 1 and 2 were complete in 1897, and No. 3 in 1898. Apart from anything that had been done at the present time to prevent the access of quicksand before the subsidence of March 1907, nothing whatever had been done to provide against it. There were open roads from the rise to the dip. When he inspected after the subsidence at the end of May this year he could trace how far the quicksand had got, and it was shown on the plan. What do you suggest they could have done to make it safe? If they had abstained from working the ore at some point between No. 2 borehole and No. borehole they had some limestone above them, and they might have left there a barrier or wedge of ore between that point and the dip cut. Then the protection you think advisable and proper was to stop between No. 3 and No. 1? — Certainly. Where they had a limestone roof? - Yes Continuing, witness said acting on behalf of Lord Leconfield he saw Mr. Walker on the 18th of February, 1904, and pointed out that they had touched the pinnel, and that owing to the uncertainty of the pinnel witness thought it was dangerous to have the pinnel touched, and he advised them most strongly to keep away from it. Witness also saw Mr. Burnyeat, one of the directors, with reference to the water, and after some consideration the matter was adjourned to a week later. On the 25th they had a meeting, when witness put his views before the directors expressing what he thought was the dangerous position. Mr. Walker, the Company's engineer, opposed witness's views, but after some discussion Mr. Burnyeat said the working must stop. Witness told them if they left a reserve of ore along the line marked it would be useful someday. Working this would have been the last operation. During the time, witness continued, Lord Leconfield's agent the workings to the rise were prosecuted. At the meetings it was decided to stop those particular, but his objection applied to similar workings and in the following October Mr. Walker told him that one working had got the pinnel in Mr. Moore's royalty, and witness told him they should have stopped sooner as arranged. Witness reported this to Lord Leconfield's agent. Witness had examined the present working plan and a previous one. Witness had compared the plans with reference to the workings in question, and referring to the plans witness described what had been done and how certain pillars had been worked. Witness was not underground in the mine between leaving Lord Leconfield in 1905 and April in 1907. The timbering was inadequate, and he gave an instance, a particular working where a single prop was supporting a pinnel roof. When the supports were withdrawn from the roof by working witness considered the timbering done was not a sufficient precaution to support the roof. Witness was further examined at some length on the plans, with regard to various references to pinnel written thereon. Considering in which way that defendants have worked the ore to the rise as far as the pinnel roof I want to ask you whether in your opinion they worked in a proper skilful, mining like manner? — No. Did they work according to the most approved practice in the working of iron ore mines in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven? - No. In your opinion was there any unskilfulness or carelessness of management? - Yes I think getting and taking on the ore along that line they should have put in good and sufficient supports in the way of timber or stone pillars. In your opinion was there any unskilful or careless management in removing the ore as far as shown? - I think so. In your opinion by reason of that has any of the ore been lost, rendered incapable of being worked? - Certainly it has for the time being at least, and with any future possibility of further subsidence there may be much greater loss. Now, tell me in your opinion have they ever by the way they have worked the mine endangered the mine or the working thereof? - Yes, I should say they have. Have they occasioned loss or damage to the mines? - Certainly. Examination continued: The market price of ore in 1904-5-6 rose to 18s to 20s. If a large output was wanted to be made to get the benefit of the market there was an advantage in working the rise ore instead of the dip ore. It was much cheaper to work. Mr. Walker told him a fissure occurred in January 1907, in the top road into which he could put his hand. When he went down on the 12th April he observed that the sand had then got down to No. 1 shaft, and below No. 1 shaft towards No. 2 shaft. They went down No. 2 shaft. No. 1 shaft was blocked. So far as is material now the result of the inspections was shown on the map. In the rise workings to the west the pillars were left extremely thin. What timber there was was broken down and the timbers were altogether inadequate, and if there was a collapse the roof would collapse over a long line. The surface subsidence is now 150 feet across the whole fenced in. Water was constantly coming in now. The sand produced is a fair specimen of the sand in the stratum, and is very fine. With regard to the course of the subsidence. In your opinion what is the cause? — The working of the ore under the pinnel and up to the pinnel. On the occasion of his inspection on the 24th October they went to the west side of No. 1 pit. They went westward, and then from the top road to the road next to the one below, and then went along the west, but before they went down into the working or the top workings the manager said he would tell them they had got water. He (the manager) did not know where it came from but it altered with the weather. He (the manager) did not consider it safe and he told them because he wanted to free himself from the responsibility if they went down into the workings. Witness said they must inspect it and Mr. Richardson and his foreman remained behind. They found that the timber had rushed from the top workings, or upper workings, down to the road, and they went forward and found another rush of timber. Some of the timber was evidently new, and must have been recently put in and there had been falls of earth, which had smashed the timber and rushed it down. They found a little water coming down and as they went west they found the water increasing. When they went to the top road and east and west the water was coming down very freely from the roof running on the floor and running into a hole in the floor. Witness thought it unwise to try it any further. He was satisfied there would be further subsidence along that line. Had you formed any estimate as to the quantity of ore left in the mine, but not beyond the fault? - In Moore's royalty about two million tons. Examination continued: When witness produced his authority to Mr. Walker, Mr. Walker said he might have to wait until the next meeting of the directors at the end of the month, but he also said something about trying to arrange it earlier. The inspection witness had on the 12th was not sufficient for his purpose; he had only begun. He understood when he left that they knew he was going again. Cross-examined by Mr. Warmington, K.C., — The defendants had mined unskilfully by the way in which a road indicated on the map had been driven, to give one instance, and when he had pointed out the danger of working beneath the pinnel they subsequently did work beneath the pinnel. In working along the pinnel he distinctly said in his opinion that was unworkmanlike, having regard to the facts, which were known to the defendants as to the nature of the roof. In mining roofs have a great deal to do with what is proper mining? According to the plan the road to which he had referred was driven subsequent to 1905. He said that that was one thing the defendants had done which was not according to the practise in the mining and working of iron ore mines in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven, and that the substance they had left did not leave sufficient support for the maintenance of the roof for them to remove its natural support. The things he had described were not done in a manner to get and raise the greatest quality of ore that could reasonably be got, when they considered the consequences. They must have regard to the consequences in estimating what the working was. He thought the defendants had endangered the mines by having worked out so much ore along the whole length of the rise, and in not having put in sufficient support, having regard to the fact that they knew perfectly well from their journals of their borings of No. 1 shaft and the general character of the ground. There was no doubt whatever in his opinion that they had taken out too much ore to the rise, to leave it in a safe state. Subsidences were to be expected in the Whitehaven district in iron ore mines. He should say they were inevitable. Witness had inspected the mine whilst acting for Lord Leconfield. He knew the late Mr. Moore; he had met him once. He was a gentleman very largely conversant with mining matters. Witness was succeeded in the mineral agency for Lord Leconfield by the son of Mr. Foster Browne. So far as Mr. Moore was concerned it was an important matter for the lessees to satisfy him and his agent, and to satisfy Lord Leconfield as well. Mr. Warmington said then it came to this that if what was done and known and sanctioned by Mr. Moore and Mr. Moore's agent and by Lord Leconfield and Mr. Foster Browne nobody could complain. Witness was replying that if so, but Mr. Gill agreed with him-when the judge interposed that the question was rather a question for him. Cross-examination continued: Witness had had charge of supervision of iron ore mines of Lord Leconfield's which were managed by mine managers. He had not acted as a practical manager of an iron ore mine. There was no formal working on Lord Leconfield's behalf against the working in 1904. When Mr. Burnyeat said the workings must be stopped witness accepted that. He knew Mr. Burnyeat, and knew he could rely on him. He did not think that it was said that it was for a time, for if so he would have certainly would have wanted to know for what time. The workings were to be stopped absolutely. He had seen Mr. Walker's note of what took place but he was not accepting all Mr. Walker said. Assuming that the words for the time were in the minutes of Mr. Burnyeat's handwriting he thought it was wrong without doubt. There had been working between February and October, and witness consulted Lord Leconfield's solicitor on the matter, and advised a stronger condition in any subsequent case. In reply to the Judge, witness said he should think he certainly inspected after the 26th October, but he did not know what he found; at any rate nothing to lead Lord Leconfield to interfere. The court then adjourned. Yesterday's Hearing The hearing was resumed yesterday (Wednesday) morning, when the cross-examination of Mr. Watkyn-Thomas was continued by Mr. Cave, K.C. Witness said that in February, 1904, when he was acting for Lord Leconfield, his object was to protect the whole mine, both in Lord Leconfield's and Mr. Moore's royalties. Counsel asked whether Mr. Walker's note as to the agreement to stop working in certain workings was accepted as correct by the witness, who said it was, except the proviso for a time. Witness intended the works to be stopped for good until the conditions became safe for work. The effect of the discussion was the workings of which witness complained were stopped. From time to time in 1904 and 1905, witness went down the pit. He went down with Mr. Hartley in the summer of 1905. On that day, witness saw also Mr. Walker, Mr. Richardson, and Mr. Burnyeat. Before going down witness had a little talk with Mr. Burnyeat and Mr. Walker. There was some talk about the pinnel, and as to water coming through the pinnel, and witness asked what they were going to do when they got to the limit of the ore on the northeast side, and Mr. Walker said they would rob it. Witness pointed out again the danger from the overlying surface. That was at the northeastern extremity, where the ore was thinning out. In reply to a question about water if it came, Mr. Burnyeat said they would pump it, and Mr. Walker agreed, but witness did not say that would be all right. Witness dissented from their idea, but certainly did not agree to the robbing - that, is to remove the pillars. Witness could not accept Mr. Walker's note of what passed. There was a limestone roof over only part of the northeast corner. The defendants had robbed in that corner, and underneath the pinnel in some cases. There had been no in-rush of sand or water there yet. Witness saw Mr. Walker again in October 1904, and Mr. Walker had told witness the working had reached the pinnel in Mr. Moor's royalty, and witness said they should have stopped sooner as agreed. As a matter of fact they did touch the pinnel at many points along the outcrop. In April 1907, on the first occasion, witness gave notice of his desire to inspect. Witness thought he saw Mr. Walker on the 3rd April. Mr. Walker asked if witness would produce his instructions or authority. Witness told Mr. Walker he gave the Company notice as a matter of courtesy, and in his view they did not require a notice at all. Witness would not promise to produce his authority, and on Mr. Walker objecting to his going without, witness asked him to put it in writing. Witness saw Mr. Walker again on the 5th, and thought he saw Mr. walker also on the 4th, the day after he visited the mine. On the 5th, witness went to the mine again, On the 3rd, when he went to the mine, and on the 4th, witness was not asked for authority. On the 4th, witness arranged to come on the following day. On the 5th, witness went to the mine again, and Mr. Walker refused to show the plans and section, and said they would consider it at a Board meeting. The Board meeting was at the end of the month and Mr. Walker said he would try to arrange a Board meeting for the 8th, the following Monday, after which he would communicate the decision. On the 12th, witness and Mr. Stout began their inspection. They were accompanied down the mine by Mr. Miles Richardson. Witness pointed out where Mr. Richardson said the subsidence was about 250 to the southeast. It was a typical subsidence. They went into the top working and saw No. 18 working, which was barred off, and went along and saw other workings indicated in the plan. Then they went down on the east side. There was no question put to Mr. Richardson by the witness, which Mr. Richardson declined to answer. Witness wrote a letter subsequently on the 24th April, as to continuing the inspection. He had not then seen Mr. Stout previous to writing the letter. Witness wrote that letter without communicating with anyone, except the Executors, but it was not on Mr. Sherwen's particular instruction that he wrote this letter. Witness wanted to inspect whatever part of the mine that was open, and relevant to the report to be made. He wanted to make the further inspection over the ground he had already seen, and any other that was open for the purpose of making a report to the plaintiffs. On the 24th October, witness was in the northwestern part of the mine, and saw a stream of water coming in No. 11 road. It was not an uncommon thing to see in mines. He would be surprised to hear that it is now abated. Assuming a good roof, the usual practise was starting from the shaft to the drive to the rise from the first level. Having completed his first working to the rise and the level, he would begin at the extremity of the mine to work back. This shaft was sunk near the north end of the mine. It is a long way from the dip of Mr. Moore's royalty, which is only now being bored to see if there is ore in it. No. 1 shaft is contained within Mr. Moore's rise royalty. The usual way is to work to a level course, and from they're to the rise, and from the extremity of the rise towards the shaft. On the second working the pillars were removed which supported the roof. As a rule the pinnel is tough, and apart from a crack it would absorb water freely. The thickness of the pinnel was a good thickness. Pinnel makes a good roof as a rule, but a very unstable one. The pinnel is very heavily fallen in the top working, and in the working eastward and in the third working eastward, first under No. 3 borehole, there was a very heavy fall, and the roof was in a dangerous condition. Witness did not know the period between the cessation of working and the fall. If counsel said it was twelve months, witness would not disagree. Witness, further examined, described other falls of pinnel in the mine, indicated by him on the plan. Supposing a subsidence has taken place, or an indication of subsidence so as to show that the ore might not be got, it would be good mining to get the ore out if it could be done with safety to the men and to the mine. The life of the first timbering was a point to consider in the working. Witness had never known a case, he thought, where the pinnel had given way and let water through. He had never known such an accumulation of water as there was here. The pinnel might have thinned out under the sand and gravel. Pumping is going on at No. 1 shaft, but witness could not speak of the quantity, nor as to whether it is sixty gallons a minute or not. That water came in from the sand-bed. They are constantly pumping from the subsidence, and at another pump, and are putting down another drainage shaft. The first working should have been stopped as soon as they cut the pinnel. That was somewhere between No. 2 and No. 1 borehole say halfway the limestone being practically no support, it was getting so thin towards No. 1 borehole. The distance between the two boreholes named is 62 feet. If they stopped there it would leave a good many thousands of tons unworked. After they had worked out the dip ore, they could have got it. They should have left pillars to get to No. 1 shaft; and westward and eastward, also, and they could have robbed those at any time, working backwards. Mr. Cave: You would have left a road between the pit and the outcrop, and up to that point which you put there within I do not know how many feet of the nip out, your point of stopping, you would have worked the ore on both sides of the road the second time? Witness: I should go to the extremity and work towards this road, leaving artificial support in the way of stone pillars and so on, and then have left support below on the solid rock; and then when it came to the time to get the reserve ore I would work back. Before that you would get all the ore in the dip? — Yes, except No. 1 shaft. Will you point to the particular place on Mr. Moore's royalty where you say the pillars are insufficient? - Yes, the pillars immediately under No. 3 borehole. (Indicating on plan.) In reply to further cross-examination, witness pointed out the position of pillars, which he considered of insufficient strength, and also a measurement of space, which he contravened, having measured the place. He suggested a pillar, which he said had given way, had contributed to the collapse of the roof. Along that west side they found little or no timbering at the first inspection, and heavy falls of roof. Since that time fresh timber had been put in. Since the rush there had been some barriers put up, and it would have been wiser to put them higher up. What had been done would lessen the risk of further trouble. The roads generally were now dry, as dry as was to be expected. The ore originally covered by sand was shown on the plan, and the workings at No. 1 shaft were filled with sand. In places it had been right up to the roof, and it had settled down to a couple of feet, sometimes more from the roof. Sand was, he believed, to be used to fill into one of Lord Leconfield's pits when it was worked out to prevent subsidies of the surface. The ore in this mine could be got, where the inrush of sand had taken place, at an increased expense, and the ore would be less valuable when got. The Hodbarrow mine had many inrushes of sand; and they had the most elaborate precautions there to prevent it getting into the ore. At Longlands witness knew they were working very near the gravel roof, but it was very thin. Witness had not been down that mine, and could not say what the effect of the sand had been in that mine. Re-examined by Mr. Terrel: They might have worked to the rise, and when they touched the pinnel they should have stopped. When they had touched the pinnel they should have left the working altogether. They should have worked right and left on a line short of where they cut the pinnel. When they reached the extremity of the deposit they should have worked away the pillars, and not before they had worked all the ore to the dip. When the whole of the dip ore below had been worked out, they should then have worked the reserve ore. Up to the meeting in February 1901, there had been no suitable working, so far as witness knew. Examined as to a position indicated on the plans witness said there was a break of the surface caused by robbery of pillars below, and witness thought there might be further subsidence. On the 5th of April witness produced his authority and was refused admission to the pit by Mr. Walker, who said he acted on Mr. Brockbank's instructions. The working, which would be proper with a good sound roof, would not apply in the case of a pinnel roof with sand above, like this. In witness's opinion the result of such workings as these at the rise side were likely to lead to future subsidence. Mr. JOHN DIXON KENDALL, sworn, deposed that he was a consulting mining engineer. He had had 43 years experience of iron mining, and for 31 years in the Whitehaven district: and for 20 years of that time had managed large mines. He had since had a large practise as a consulting engineer, both at home and abroad. He had made an inspection of the Ullcoats mine on the 31st May this year. He had perused and considered the defendants journal of shaft No. 1 and boreholes 2, 1, 3, and the section produced: and he agreed that what was shown was the result. In witness's opinion the defendants had not carried on the working in a proper, skilful, and mining like manner, nor according to the approved practise in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven. In his opinion they had neglected to do something, which ought properly to have done. Having regard to the information obtained in sinking shaft No. 1 and the boreholes, that ought to have disclosed to the defendants that there was a large body of dangerous ground overlying the ore. The conditions disclosed as to the overlying strata were, he thought, quite unusual. He knew, he thought, every other mine in the district, and he did not know of any other mine in the district with similar conditions. Pinnel under the conditions shown was not a good roof, with the water, sand, and gravel, over it. A competent engineer would have worked the mine by driving to the rise; and assuming that the pinnel had been cut, the working ought to have been stopped at once, and the pinnel built up; and then he should have tried to avoid the pinnel. The working of the ore, which remained, had been dangered. He did not think it possible to take the ore out now without considerable risk of further subsidences. He thought further subsidences were bound to occur. The working according to the method the defendants had pursued had endangered the mine. Undoubtedly that working was the cause of the subsidence, which occurred in March. He said that along the line on the reduced plan there should have been a body of ore left. Much of the timber had been disturbed by the pressure. There was not ample timber for the condition of working. It was quite inadequate. Witness noticed the pillars in the part of the mine referred to, and they were small: but whether they had been stripped he could not tell. Assuming the correctness of Mr. Thomas's statement that pillars had been stripped, that was not proper and mining-like working. As to pillars indicated to witness on the plan, he said they ought not to have been taken away. They ought to have been allowed to remain until the lower part of the mine had been worked. To remove them before was not proper and skilful mining. His method of working would not involve the loss of any ore, or leaving dry ore in. It secured a lot more ore than would be secured in this case. That which was left for the protection of the whole of the mine would be got last. The conditions of working might have been proper if they were working with a good roof, but they had to work according to the condition of the mine. The time taken to sink the shaft of 89 feet in eleven months through pinnel and water-bearing strata was unusual. One or two other shafts had taken a long time, but it was not by any means a common occurrence; of all the shafts in the district there were probably not more than three or four which had taken that time. The cause was the body of water coming from the strata. There was no doubt about that. The boreholes that were put down had recorded the presence of water in the sand. They would have conveyed that knowledge to the mind of any competent engineer. Cross-examined by Mr. Cave, K.C.: He had known deposits subside over a large area, and had not found a crack on the surface. The removal of the pillars when the mine was worked out might cause a regular or an irregular subsidence. Pinnel is a tough subsidence intermixed with gravel or sand; it is a stiff olayey mixture, and unless there is a fracture or a crack in it, did not allow water through. It was impervious, but it was not apt to flake away; and once it began they did not know where it would go. He did not say it was unsafe to work under pinnel, but it was if it had quicksand above. It was a common thing to work under pinnel. He knew of mines worked directly under pinnel, and mines were sometimes worked under rivers. In those cases the river was either carried through a large trough or diverted into a new course. That had been done. There might be mines worked under rivers where neither of these processes had been carried out, but witness would like to know the exact conditions obtaining under the river. He knew of none himself, and he knew practically all the mines in the district. The circumstances and situation of this mine were quite special. The problems to be solved by the engineer were new, in the sense that points had not occurred in the same shape before; but in Cumberland large bodies of sand were met with. The Hodbarrow mine had a large body of sand, but in that case the sand is nearer the workings. It is lying on the top of the ore, and there is no protection between the ore and the sand. They are worked from the bottom upwards, to leave the ore as a protection. It was the same problem dealt with in a different way. Witness would have worked up the rise in this mine until he got to the pinnel, and then he would have stopped, and by that time he would have had a very good idea of the course to pursue, and would have set out his working from that time so as to leave bodies of ore between the points where he first struck the pinnel, and he would not have gone into that again until this mine was ready to be closed. There were a series of pillars on the slope, but it did not follow there was a tendency for the whole mine to slip downwards. Where could it go? — He had not known such a case. When they took the support away from it, it then sank. He could not give an instance of where a barrier of ore had been left. He did not know of any other mine where the conditions were the same. He thought there was evidence that the body of water and sand were constant. No. 1 shaft had been sunk several years, and they had been pumping water all the time from the sand and gravel bed. That meant a large body of water had been abstracted. But there was a large body of water coming in-rain water. Witness expected to find a large body of sand as they went up the valley. In sinking No. 2 pit they came to no sand at all. Witness did not think from the evidence of the boreholes that this might be a self-contained body of sand. To deal with this inrush of sand, witness would have put in a drain as close as possible to the source of danger. When he went down the roads were fairly clear. They walked down on sand for a considerable distance, and sometimes were in danger of sinking into it. Witness would have left a barrier of ore 60 feet wide. Along the outcrop, generally speaking, he said the pillars were altogether insufficient - the whole right along that nip-out, but especially where he indicated on the plan. At that spot he would not have had pillars left at all. He would have had a barrier of ore left 60 feet wide. He objected to the getting of the ore in this way, and the exposure of the pinnel. Mining engineers were apt to differ very much - even quite experienced engineers. Re-examined by Mr. Upjohn: Witness did not see why there should be any differences of opinion between experienced engineers on this question. He could not find any sufficient data to show what the body of the quicksand is altogether, but there were sufficient data to show a large body of sand and water. There was a deep watershed above the mine; and his inference was that the water came in from this marshy ground to the southeast of the mine. As they had been pumping five years and were pumping still, the reasonable inference was that all the water had not been taken out. The defendants did not make a dam as near the subsidence as they might have done. They were scattered about the mine: and in witness's opinion that was not the proper way to deal with the damage. It was not a difficult engineering problem to deal with these conditions. It might be a novel one. At Hodbarrow they were working from the sole to the roof practically. In a deposit like that there could hardly be said to be any dip or rise. It was not the same problem there was at all. In reply to the Judge, witness described the method of working out a mine by robbing the pillars backwards to the shafts. JOHN McKELLAR MAIN, sworn and examined by Mr. Upjohn, K.C., said he was a mining engineer of 36 years practise in the Whitehaven district. He had been the manager of the Crossfield mine for about 36 years. He had made six or seven inspections of the mine, and had examined the working plans, and in his opinion the mine in Mr. Moore's royalty had not been worked in a proper, skilful, and mining like manner, nor according to the most approved practise in the winning and working of the mines in the Whitehaven district: and they had worked the mines negligently and to the danger of the mine. He thought considering the information the defendants had with regard to boring and the sinking of No. 1 shaft, the presence of a great mass of quicksand, gravel, and water, the working out of that deposit was decidedly bad mining, and even surprisingly bad mining. Witness considered the condition and the character of the overlying strata were unique in the district. It was an unusual deposit, and the peculiarity of was not the presence of the pinnel but of the marshy quicksand. Witness took the specimen of the sand in Court from the floor of the mine, and it was a fair sample. Any engineer should know that he must protect pinnel below a water bearing strata; because although pinnel sometimes made firm, good roofs for a time, it was only of a temporary character. It was acted upon by the atmosphere of the mine and crumbled away, and in a short time came down in large flakes. In this mine the presence of quicksand caused a great danger. Witness thought there was no probability of the supply of water being exhausted, looking to the character of the watershed. With regard to the proper manner of working the pit, witness agreed generally with Mr. Kendall's conclusion. The court then rose until Thursday morning.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||