|
10th October 1907 The Cage Disaster At Watergate PitResumed Inquest, YeserdayMr. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland resumed the adjourned inquiry at the Police- court, Maryport, on Wednesday afternoon, into the cage disaster at Watergate Colliery (owned by the Flimby and Broughton Moor Coal and Fire Brick Co., Ltd.) near Maryport, on Thursday, October 3rd, which resulted in the death of three workers. Their names are :— Joseph Tindall, 54 years, married Buchanan Terrace, Ellenborough. Wm. Fletcher, 38 years, married 14, Cemetery Road, Flimby. John Fletcher, 14 years, son of the above. Mr. John Newton was chosen foreman of the jury. The others empanelled were :— Messrs. J. Cameron, G. Hannah, A. Robinson, H. Hodgson, A. Clayton, R. Bailiff, M. Cape, J. Atkinson, T. McManus, P. Hunter, J. Hodgson, P. Hurst, and T. Williamson. Mr. E. W. Lightfoot represented the Colliery Company; Mr. T. Cape, assistant miners' agent, the Miners' Union. There were also present: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines; Mr. L. Wilson, a director of the Colliery Company; Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Metalliferous Mines, Mr. Fryer, manager of the colliery; Mr. T. P. Martin, representing the Coalowners' Association; and Supt. Illingworth. Some delay was caused by the non-appearance of Mr. G. Hannah, one of the jurymen. P. C. Singleton said he had warned him on the previous evening. Mr. Hannah told him he would be there. He knew the time. The Coroner said that Mr. Hannah's recognisance of £5 would be forfeited. George Fryer, Broughton Moor, manager of the colliery, said he had been manager since a year gone February, but only since June at Watergate. He produced the special rules under the Coal Mines Regulation Act, of which a copy was exhibited on the pit bank. The model produced that had been made under his supervision represented the pit bottom. Witness explained that model to the jury. The shaft was 84½ fathom. He produced a copy of the code of signalling, in force on the 3rd. The engineman on that date was James Newby, who had been in the employ of the Company some two or three years. He was there when witness went. Tindall he should say had been in the employ for many years. Fletcher, the elder, had been in the employ a considerable number of years. The lad had been there since he started work. Witness was called for on October 3 about 20 minutes past seven in the evening. He found the dead bodies of the two Fletcher's in the joiner's shop at the top. Tindall was missing. Two men named Morley and Routledge were let down to search for the other body by the engineman, Newby. The engineman went on duty at 1-30 in the afternoon and was on until half-past nine. Witness did not speak to him that evening. Witness did not go down the shaft. He sent Moralee and Routledge down, and they found Tindall's body. He heard the signals given during the time he was there, and they worked all right. He saw the cage brought up with the three safety lamps in. They were quite satisfied that they belonged to the deceased. They knew that by the numbers of the lamps. Each man had his own number and they could identify the three lamps found on the bottom deck of the cage as belonging to the deceased men. They were quite satisfied on the point. The lamps were given out before six o'clock in the morning. When the pit was done and the whole of the men were at the bottom they rode on both decks of the cage, but in this case, when only one or two men were in the pit, it was the custom to take the top deck. There was, however, no written rule on that point. The workmen all understood that. These men were accustomed to ride regularly, and would know the custom. Tindall would know better than the other two because he had been stationed at the shaft to get the six o'clock men down. The cage was lowered very slowly at the bottom. He thought that a man could get in when it was in motion, because Newby was a very careful engineman. He would not like to say three men could get in. The sump had four feet of water in it from the flat sheets to the legs on which the cage rested. There was 20 inches of water on the flat sheets making 5ft. 3in. of water from the logs. The water on the flat sheets had been caused by the pumps going wrong, and they were undergoing repair from 1-30 to six o'clock. The cage was eight feet from the roof to the bottom. This was equally divided between the upper and lower decks. For riding either deck would do as regarding convenience. If a man gave the wrong signal and got on the bottom deck he would be dropped into the sump, whereas if he got on the top deck he would be clear. When men below wanted the cage they would give three signals from the bottom, which meant the cage was wanted, and the engineman was supposed to set it in position and give three back, and then the men who were going to ride were supposed to give three signals, when the engineman allowed them sufficient time to get into the cage and drew them up. If there were two or three men they would all get in except one, who would give the signal, and then join the others. The engineman was not supposed to move his engine until he got a proper signal, and there was a rule to that effect. The cage was working right. Witness was down the pit the previous day. Since he had been manager he could say the engineman had been a steady as well as an experienced man. He had been employed since the accident. The Foreman: I suppose the method of signalling has been the same ever since you remember? - Yes. Do you think there is any room for improvement in it? - I don't. Is the telephone not preferable? - I would not like to say that. To my own mind I would rather have a wire signal. If you had any other signal it is liable to go wrong. I have been in collieries where they have electric signals, but they only use them for drawing the coal and not when men are riding, because they were so liable to go wrong. We know that men are subject to irregularities? - Oh yes. A juryman: If there had been keps in the shaft the cage could not have gone down the sump? - It is not customary to have keps at the top and the bottom both, but just in one place. They are either at the top or the bottom. Don't you think it would be very simple to stop the cage from going down, a couple of logs or something? - The two decks are there for that purpose. A juryman said he had seen keps both top and bottom. By the Foreman: They had the option of going in the upper deck if they signalled right. If they had desired to have the top deck and had signalled to the engineman he would have lowered it. The engineman got the signal to give them the upper deck, and got no more signals. By Mr. Bayliff: It might be that with signalling quick they might miss a stroke. By the Inspector: There were two cages, one at the top and one at the bottom. They had fixed lights at this place - safety lights. After the pit was done the onsetter brought the safety lamps away. The signal was three for men to ascend. That signal would go into the engine room. The men would come out, find the cage in the right position, signal three to the surface, wait until they got three back then get in, and give three. The men used both cages for riding. It was the only stopping place in the shaft. The engineman also attended to No. 2 pit about 50 yards away. He could here the gong in one engine-house from the other engine-house. There was no onsetter there at the time. Tindall was authorised by the under-manager. The regular onsetter left when he got his ordinary man away. It would take about eight hours for the water to get over the flat sheets, and about two or three hours to rise above the sump if they were not pumping. His theory was that the men climbed into the bottom deck of the cage when it was about four feet above the flat sheets. Can you account for the men getting into the cage until they got the signal from the engineman? - I can't, sir. Have you ever known it? - Never in my experience. If the engineman did put the cage, into the sump it would make a considerable splash? - Yes, it would swill the water out on to the flat sheets. Mr. Lightfoot: The signals for these men would be about six o'clock? - Yes, sir. And about half an hour before there had been a safe ascent by two other men, Tindall and Brown? - Yes. By Mr. Cape: He was responsible for all notices posted in and about the pit. Fletcher was put in charge of those working and Tindall was left in charge for signalling them out. Mr. Cape: Your theory is that those men got into the bottom deck when it was four feet above the flat sheets? - Yes. Do you think it likely when Tindall was present he would have allowed the Fletchers to do this? - I can't say. Was any notification given to the engineman that the water was likely to be up on the flat sheets? - Yes, he knew. Would the signal wire go wrong if the knocks were given sharp? - I don't think the wire would go wrong. Would an experienced man be likely to knock sharp? - I think he would take his time as there would be no hurry. The Foreman: Would the men be standing in the water that was up? - Yes, they have done so many a time. James Newby, engineman at the Watergate Pit, who resides at Grasslot, said he had been employed there nearly eight years. On October 3rd he went to work about half-past one in the afternoon, and his time to go off was at half-past nine. Just after going he commenced to draw up the men, and finished this about five minutes to two. The signals were regularly used and worked all right, as did the cage. The last men he brought up that afternoon was at half-past five when four were lifted. Two were named Tindall and Brown, and the others were the pumpsman and his partner, who had been repairing the pumps. Coming to the time of the accident he got three knocks that was all. They were distinct - three. He did nothing at that time because he had the top of the cage level with the flat sheets. He did not signal back. He was waiting for Routledge to clear his tools from the top of the cage. As soon as Routledge was clear Routledge shouted to him to let the men up and witness let the cage down. It might be three or four minutes before he lowered the cage. He lowered it about seven foot, about that speed, indicating a slow speed with his hand. He then knocked three times for the men to get into the cage but go no answer. When he received no answer he gave the three knocks five or six times more, two minutes perhaps lapsing between each signal. From the first to the last knockings would take perhaps ten minutes altogether. He then communicated with the pumpsman on the pit top. He thought it was rather curious the men were not knocking and this had never happened before to his knowledge. After they had waited a bit longer, about 20 minutes altogether, they decided that the pumpsman should go down and being the men out. The Coroner: Could you not have done that long before by sending a man down the pumping shaft? - Yes, but I was doing wrong even then. Why? - I am not supposed to lift the cage without a signal. Quite true, but couldn't someone have gone down the pumping shaft? - That was the pumping shaft I was on. Well, the pumpsman did go down, didn't he? - Yes, he went down. Why was this 20 minutes or so allowed to elapse? - Well, I was not supposed to lift that cage until I got the knock. But you sent a man down? - Yes, and I had then to lift the other cage, as when one goes down the other comes up. You remained? - Yes, sir. Did you see the cage brought up? - Yes, sir. Did you see anything found in either the upper or bottom deck? - Yes, I went round to see, and found three lamps and a pit bottle on the bottom deck? Any blood? - I did not notice any, but I saw a little piece of human flesh, which was also on the bottom deck. And were you certain you got no signal back? - I got no signal back. The Foreman: You talk about the men setting the cage themselves. They can't set it without you moving the engine? - No, sir. It is I who does the moving part. By Mr. Hodgson (a juryman): He was in charge of the two winding engines, and on account of a fresh man being charge of the water engine he was in charge of that, too. Do you think you are qualified, you or any man, to mind four jobs at one time, when lives are dependent on you? - That is not a question for me to answer. I expect you are a workman yourself, and you will be expected to do what there is to do, or you would not be there. That is not a question for me to answer. The Coroner: Do you think you have too much work to do? - I can do it comfortably enough. I can manage what I have to do, and I don't think anyone complains. By the Inspector: About 5-30 he got two raps to lower, and lowered it right to the bottom. The bottom deck would be right in the sump. He got three and one which meant bring them right to the top. He then brought Routledge and three others off. Mr. Atkinson: If the men had been ordinarily riding what raps would you have got? - If we got three we would answer three back and wait until they knocked again, and then give them a little time to get on the cage before drawing. But you did not answer back when Tindall and Brown came up? - No. After they got off the cage at the top I suppose Routledge and Wilson would go back to their work? - Yes, directly after. Both cages would be standing half shaft? - No, not half, one would be rather lower than the other. The next rap you got was what? - Three and one. What time was that? - Well, it might be "mebbe" five minutes to six. Three and one means that they were coming up? - Yes. You wouldn't be able to tell exactly where these raps were from? - I had an idea. They might have been from the bottom or from where Routledge and Wilson were working? - They might have been, but it was not likely. What did you do? - I brought the cage nearest the engine house to the surface, and set it level with the flat sheet. It might be a little bit higher or a little bit lower? - It might be a little below the flat sheets. Or it might have been above? - I would see if it was above. You would say it was as near level as you could tell? - Yes. How long after you got the cage to the position did you get three knocks? - It might be a minute. I didn't look at my watch or anything like that. You would know they were from the bottom? - Yes, there was nobody else to knock. After Routledge came up and cleared the gear off the cage did he say anything? - He shouted to me. "Let the men out." Witness had heard him say since that the men below had shouted to him. Witness had no suspicion that the men were in the cage then. When Routledge said that witness lowered the cage to make the top deck available. The Inspector: If the men were in the cage they must have got in when Routledge was taking his gear off the cage? - I don't think it is for me to say. The cage stood four or five minutes while Routledge was taking his gear off the top. The Inspector: Can there be any doubt that they got into the cage at that time? - In my opinion they did, but I am not supposed to know. You will form as good an opinion as anyone else? - I did form that opinion. By Mr. Lightfoot: When he brought Brown and Thompson up he got the shaft signals from Routledge. Routledge was using the shaft and the other men got in with him. When he got the signal from the men at the bottom the top of the cage at the top was nearly on a level with the flat sheets, and therefore the bottom cage would not be in a proper position for men to get in the bottom cage. When Routledge got his tools off he raised the top cage and lowered the bottom one. Mr. Lightfoot: The consequence would be that the lower deck would be lowered into the sump and the men would be drowned? - Yes. You then put it in a proper position for men getting in, gave them an answering signal, but got no reply? - I knocked five or six times expecting to get signals. At that time, according to your theory, these deaths had occurred? - Yes. Therefore whatever delay there was would not affect their deaths? - No. Witness, continuing, said that not getting an answer to his signals he moved the cage a little up and down, which was usual in such cases, as an additional signal. He then sent Routledge down. When Routledge came up he said he had heard something fall. The signalling was in perfect working order. Mr. Lightfoot: Those unfortunate men, assuming your theory is correct should not have entered the cage until it was in a proper position? - No. Something has been said about you doing several jobs but it is only your duty to attend to one job at once? - Yes. Mr. Lightfoot: You work one shaft at a time? - Yes. You have always been able to do your work and have never had any accident? - Not that I know of. Mr. Cape: Were you warned there was any possibility of the water being on the flat sheets? - No. You have to form your own conclusions when men are on the back shift whether they are "knocked" away by a responsible person or whether they knock themselves away? - Yes. Is there any special signal for the men that knock themselves away? - Yes, just the same but slower. Are all the men aware of this? - I don't know whether they are or not. It is, however, only a custom and not a rule. If anybody knocked when you were drawing at No. 1 engine it would have been nearly impossible for you to have heard? - Yes. Did you ever know of any men, after signalling, to get into the cage before knocking themselves away? - No, I never did. It would be a most unusual thing? - It would. The Coroner: Did you know water was on the flat sheets at all? - I did. Did that make any allowance with you as regards the depth you lowered the cage to? - Yes, From the place you lowered the cage could one man get in whilst it was in motion? - Yes, he could, but it is hardly likely that he would. You think three men could? - No, not while it was going down. Is there a man at the bottom to watch when work is going on? - Yes, but he had come up. Wm. Humble, under-manager at the Watergate Pit, and who has been there since last June, said he was at the pit on October 3rd at 5-30 in the morning, and at 2-15 in the afternoon when all was in order. The last witness came on duty before he left. He told deceased to stop back to do some alterations and left Tindall in charge of the "rapper." He was a careful and experienced man. By Mr. Cape: Witness did not order the boy Fletcher to stop over-time, but gave permission when asked by the elder Fletcher. Thompson Brown, rolley wayman at Watergate Pit, said he was working on October 3rd and saw the three deceased men. He was however, not working in the same place. Witness came up the pit at half-past five with Tindall, Routledge, and Wilson. Witness did not signal at all, Wilson letting them up. He could not say what the signal was working like. He had worked at the colliery since Xmas, and during that time the signal had been all right. The men signalled before they entered the cage. He did not see the bodies brought up. Mr. Atkinson: How did you come up? - On the cage top. What height was the water on the flat sheets? - About two foot. Did you say anything to the engineman? - No, sir. Thomas Routledge, — pumpsman at the colliery, said he was working in company with Wilson. They were about 50 fathoms from the bottom of the pit, and after they had just finished work they heard the deceased men shout. It would then, be about six o'clock. By the shouts he understood the men wanted to be up. Witness and Wilson went up immediately afterwards, and got off the cage, when the former told the engineman to bring up the men from the bottom. He had previously told the engineman the water was up. Perhaps half an hour later Newby came and told him he could get no communication from the men, and said he would lower witness to the bottom. When witness was being lowered and was below the other cage he heard something crashing, and signalled to be drawn up again. When he got to the top he told Newby he had caught something in the shaft, and that he had better bring the cage up quietly. They did so, and found three lamps, a tin bottle, and a piece of flesh about the size of his finger. Witness and Mr. Humble were lowered down No. 2 shaft, went to the eye, and by the air course to No. 1 shaft, and found two of the bodies, which were brought up. The other body was found in the shaft. The boy Fletcher's head was almost severed from his body. He did not notice whether any of the legs were broken, as thought they were struggling to get out of the cage. You went down half an hour after you came up. Could you not have gone down earlier? - I could if I had been requested. What do you say about the signalling? - It is all right. By the Inspector: They could not tell what the men said. It was down the shaft, and the sound travelled better down. Do you think it is possible they have shouted something that you did not understand or that you did not hear? - I don't think so. They might not shout any distinct thing. Mr. Atkinson: Would they know the cage top would be stopped level with the flat sheets? — Well, Tindall was an experienced man and would know. So that when the cage came to a standstill it would not be in the sump? - No. Had they been nearer the shaft and it had gone into the sump they would have heard the splash? - Yes. It appears likely that when you were getting your gear off they got into the bottom of the cage? - That is my idea. What do you think made them get in? - I could not say. They should not have gone in. Might they not have thought it was the top deck? - I don't think a mistake like that is possible. Do you think they might have got on to the deck and thought they could have signalled themselves away? - It is an unusual thing. Do you think it is possible that they would climb in to get out of the water, and "rap" themselves away? - They might have done so, but I have never known it done. Could they "rap" themselves away while they were in the cage? - Yes, it could be done, but they would have to stretch out of the cage. Could they reach the wire? - A man would have very little power to pull the wire through the space in the cage side, from which he must put his arm. Would Tindall not expect the cage to be sent into the sump to make the top deck available? - He should have known that, as it is generally done. He would understand that by entering the lower deck there was a risk of being lowered into the sump? - Yes, it is possible. Do you think they shouted something to you that you did not hear, to prevent that being done? - I don't think so, but we cannot tell what they shouted. Exactly, but that makes the possibility they have shouted something to you, you have not understood that has led them to believe it was safe to get into the cage in any position? - Well, it is a thing I have never known to be done before. What signals did you hear after you got off the cage at the top? - Well, I would not like to say because when we threw our gear off the cage top we remained no time. The Coroner: Did you hear any? - I could not say we did. Mr. Atkinson: There might have been signals? - Yes, there might have been. Was there anyone else to hear signals except the engineman, Wilson or yourself? - No, there was no one else to notice any signals. And this crash has been caused by what? - Well, it was from the opposite side cage I could hear. It would have been the body of one of the men? - Yes, I think it would have been from what we afterwards found. Has Newby ever made a mistake with you? - No, he is a very careful man. Mr. Lightfoot: If these men had got into the cage and then attempted to signal themselves off it is a thing the engineman would never have expected? - Yes. You have no means of ascertaining whether the shout you heard was before or after they "rapped" to be brought up? - No, I know nothing about any signals. Mr. Cape: It has been asked how these men go on to the bottom deck. Did you ever know any experienced men to enter the cage prior to knocking themselves away after they had received the signal from the engineman? - Never in my life. The Coroner: Was Newby cool and collected or excited when he came to you? - Oh, he just came in his usual way. Thomas Morley, Broughton Moor, sinker at Watergate Pit, said he commenced work at six o'clock at night. He was one of those who went and searched. He was accompanied by his brother James Routledge, and Mr. Humble, the under-manager. They went down No. 2 shaft, and on getting round to the other shaft they found a tin bottle floating on the water. They also found a book floating. Two bodies were in the sump, and the other body in the shaft. The Coroner: Was the body of Tindall found in such a position that he could have fallen from the cage? - He was found with on part of his head and arm hanging over the brandreth. It could have fallen out of the shaft. By the Inspector: His head was almost torn off. The boy, Fletcher had about half, his head torn off. The right arm was torn. I suppose if the men got into the cage and found they were going to be dropped into the sump they would try to get out? - Do you think the injuries would be caused by the men trying to get out? - We can't say. - How do you account for the body being found in the shaft? They may have fallen some distance? - A jacket was found in the shaft opposite to where Tindall was found. The Inspector: So that Fletcher's body may have been taken up and fallen out. The Coroner said he had other witnesses, but their evidence would be a repetition. Mr. Fryer, recalled by Mr. Lightfoot, and was asked by him. - Do you agree that the men were drowned? That they were in the lower deck of the cage and were lowered by the engineman into that position? - Yes, sir. And having previously got in were drowned in the sump? - Yes, sir. The Coroner: Did the engineman do right in lowering it? - I think so. Do you think he should have lowered it without signalling? - The cage was not in a proper position for anyone to be in, and therefore I think the engineman was within his rights in lowering it. The Inspector: What additional precautions can you suggest to prevent a similar accident in the future? - Only keeping an onsetter for the second shift. By the Coroner: The rules provided against the men getting in the cage in that position. Mr. Lightfoot expressed the sympathy of the Colliery Company with the relatives of the deceased. The Coroner, in summing up, said it had been a lengthy inquiry, but no one moment had been wasted, and probably all the facts available had been elucidated. Notwithstanding that, a great deal must remain a mystery. There were two stories - the top and the bottom, but unfortunately no one was left to tell the bottom one. As regards the top story, it was for them to judge from the way in which the engineman had given his testimony whether it was correct or not. It was only due to him to say that he was a man of long experience, and still retained the confidence of his employers, which was testimony of his steadiness. He believed it was the first accident that had happened to the engineman. Notwithstanding that, there had been a misunderstanding somewhere. It was for them, if they possibly could, to come to the conclusion where that misunderstanding existed, with whom it was, and how it happened. Accidents, even with the most careful of them, would happen, and the question was whether anything had happened by way of a signal being given back to the engineman which he did not hear. He was bound to say the evidence was not at all that way. On the other hand, give all credit as he did, and he hoped they would, to the engineman for his character, and then there was the workmen. Northing had ever happened to suggest that one or other of these workmen were reckless. They had a father, and a son with him. A man might be reckless as regarded himself, but he had his son to study, and therefore he did not think the father would be likely to do something which was either reckless or careless. They also had evidence that Tindall was a man of great experience, who knew signalling well, and thoroughly understood the working of it. Was he likely to have done something reckless? The theory of those who had given their testimony, and he thought one and all had given it in a very satisfactory manner, was that the pumpsman, Routledge, when he was brought up had a message that the men wished to be lifted. The cage was lowered; they had heard there was 20 inches of water on the flat sheets, and while the cage, which had brought Routledge up, was stationary three men had got in on to the lower deck. The engine was then moved and the cage was lowered into the sump, when the engineman gave the signal. That was the theory of those who had given evidence. It seems to be one that was possible, and what did happed. The testimony of the engineman was positively that he got no signal back, and after waiting this length of time a search was made and the bodies found. He (the Coroner) had gone down the pit and seen the place himself on Monday, and he was obliged to those connected with the pit, who had rendered every assistance to him in viewing it. Having seen it, there was no doubt whatever that these men came to their death by drowning, and undoubtedly it happened in this sump. The question for their consideration was if, when in the sump, which contained about four feet of water, the men would be struggling - he thought the condition of the bodies showed that - and two of them were probably washed out of the cage, hence their being found in the sump. The body of Tindall was probably raised, and they must come to the conclusion that the fall the witness Routledge heard was the body of Tindall slipping out of the cage. That was all the evidence available, and if they made any recommendation he was satisfied the Company would comply with it. They entertained the deepest sympathy for the relatives of the deceased men, and they also had feelings of regret for the owners, as it must have caused them a great amount of sorrow. They must remember, however, that whatever decision they came to it had nothing to do with compensation. No matter what they decided it would not affect that. The jury deliberated in private for half-an-hour, and then the Foreman delivered the following verdict :— That the deceased men met their deaths in the pit shaft of Watergate Colliery on October 3rd, but there is not sufficient evidence to show whether they were killed or drowned. We also suggest that a man be appointed by the Company to take charge of the shaft at the time any work is being done. Mr. Hannah, the missing juryman, having put in an appearance early in the course of the inquiry, he now explained that he had mistaken the time for 3-15 for 2-15. Mr. Atter said they had 13 without him. There would be no fine.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||