Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th October 1907

The Mining Disaster At Frizington

The Inquest

On Monday evening Mr. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held the adjourned inquest in the Council Chambers, Main-street, Frizington, on the two miners, Joseph Irving (31), single, Winder; and John Hocking (37), single, Main-street, Frizington, who were killed by a fall at No. 5 pit of the Lonsdale mines on Saturday, September 28th. It will be remembered that a man named Alexander Pooley had a leg broken in the same accident.

Mr. J. B. Hodgson was chosen foreman of the jury.

There were also present: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, H. M. chief inspector of mines; Mr. W. Leck, H. M. inspector of Metalliferous mines; Mr. J. Nelson, solicitor, Egremont, representing the Lonsdale Mining Company; and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, secretary of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners and Kindred Trades' Association, representing the deceased's relatives.

Richard Hartley, Beckermet, engineer and manager of the mine, in conjunction with Mr. W. E. Walker, produced plans and photographs of the working place in which the accident occurred and explained the same.

George Dixon, miner, 20, Peter-street, said on the day of the accident he was working with Hocking, Pooley, and a labourer in No. 5 pit. The got into their working about ten minutes past six, when he examined the place most particularly with both a pick and a bar, and it appeared to be very sound and quite safe. It was a "robbery" working and they were taking out "middling." The accident occurred about eight o'clock when witness would be about four feet away. They received no warning at all, and the piece of ore that fell weighed from 10 to 20 tons. They had lights with them but they were all put out with the breeze created by the fall. None of the fall came near him, but Hocking was killed and Pooley injured, he sustaining a broken leg. Pooley would perhaps be working two yards from Hocking. Irving was in a working below and the fall went on to him, but witness could not see what happened down below from where he was. Irving would be working directly underneath, and he would be protected by a row of props. Witness was shovelling metal down at the time to where he could get at it with a bogey, and Pooley was picking metal. Teasdale, the labourer, was below at the time and outside altogether. He would go down about twenty minutes before the fall, and was out of the working altogether when it happened. No blasting had taken place that morning.

The Coroner: Had anything been done to cause this fall? — No. I can't account for anything. We could not find anything wrong and we examined the place the best we knew how.

Do you ever miss examining this? — We all three examined it.

Was there any blasting on the previous day? — No, there had been no blasting in there for three or four days.

How far away had there been any blasting? — Four yards away.

Would the blasting in that place loosen this ore at all? — No, the blasting where we were could never effect it.

After the fall occurred did you know Hocking was underneath? — Yes, we knew Hocking was under and Pooley to.

What did you do? — I got a light and made as fast as I could to where I thought they would beat. Hocking was the highest up, being a good deal higher than the other man.

Was Hocking completely underneath the ore? — Only his head and part of his shoulders were under.

What did you do when you found him there? — I ran down and helped to get the stuff off him.

Did he speak? — No, he never spoke.

How long was it before you got him out? — Perhaps three or four minutes.

Was he alive? — Yes, but unconscious.

What did you do with him out? — Laid him on a plank and an ambulance man examined him.

Could you do anything for him? — No, we could do nothing.

When did he die? — After he was taken home, sir.

Where did you find Irving? — He was between Hocking and Pooley.

Was he covered with ore? — Yes, he was buried over together.

How did you know he was there? — Well, we pulled out some lumps where we thought he was at and found him under twelve inches of stuff.

How long after the fall? — About threequarters of an hour.

Was there more stuff on the top of Irving? — Oh yes, there was scarcely anything on Hocking at all.

Do you think he was killed instantly? — Yes, Irving would be.

Was anything necessary to be done, so far as you know, that could have prevented this accident? — No, nothing, so far as I can say, sir.

Had you any protection up at all? — No, we had no props under this piece. We had it propped all the way except this piece. It was so shaped at the bottom that we could not get a prop against it.

Was it necessary to take protection under these circumstances? — No, we believed it to be quite safe.

Whose duty is it to see that all these bodies of ore are safe? — The deputy goes through every morning.

Had he been through that day? — Yes, and had put a chalk mark on.

He came through before the accident happened? — Yes, about half-past six, perhaps.

Was anyone at all to blame for this accident at all so far as you know? — No, we are all of one opinion about it. There is no blame attached to anybody. Just that morning both Hocking and Pooley said the place looked the best it had ever been since they started.

You think it was an unavoidable accident? — Yes, sir.

Mr. J. B. Atkinson: Was Irving firing any thing that morning? — There was no firing that morning sir.

Have you examined this place since the accident? — Yes, I have been in it every day.

Did you see anything that accounts for the fall? — There is a big block of soft metal goes right across between the two walls. We knew of it in the side, but we did not know of the other as it ran at right angles.

You knew of it at one place, but not at the other? — Yes.

You call them a "slape back," don't you? — Yes, a "slape back."

Crossing the ore? — Yes.

Are these "slape backs" common? — No, they are not common. I have not seen one before.

I suppose this ore that fell was the ore you were really mining? — Yes, we were going to take it down as we wanted it.

Supposing you had been aware of that "slape back" what precautions would you have taken? — We would have shot it down if we had known anything about it.

If you had any suspicion you would have blown it down? — Yes.

Could you not have put some timber under it? — I don't think it would have held this piece, because it had scarcely any bottom part.

It was a really a piece free at the bottom, at one end at the top, and at the back? — Yes.

It was therefore just held by the two sides? — Yes, but it would have come down with a prop, all the same. We could not have stopped it coming at all.

If you had had a prop in it might have held it? — I don't think it would have held it, as it would have to be too near the back before it would have caught.

Were you working in the ordinary way? — We had it propped all the way, but this was the last piece and it was left by itself.

Had you taken props from under it? — No, but we had from under the other roof as we went on.

Were you working in the ordinary way taking this "middling" out? — Yes.

Supposing you were wanting timber where would you have got it? — We have plenty lying on the side, which we had taken out.

You could also have got timber at the surface if you had wanted it? — Yes.

It is the custom to do you own timbering in these workings? — Yes.

Sometimes the deputy gives you help and advice? — Yes, if it is a big job.

Had you ever a fall like this before in working this "middling?" — Never had a fall of any sort, sir.

When the deputy was in at a quarter-past six did he give any directions? — No, only asked how we were getting on.

Did he sound the metal? — I think he did before we came in.

In this "robbery" workings how many shifts do you work? — Just the one, sir.

What is the reason of that? — I don't know, sir; I can't tell that.

There was a brake for running the bogies below. Was it running at the time of the fall? — I can't say, whether it was or not.

It makes some noise, doesn't it? — Sometimes it squeaks a little bit.

Do you think if the brake had been running it might have prevented you hearing the stuff working? — Oh no, it would have made no difference.

You might have heard some slight warning, you know. The man right underneath would have heard it if there had been any warning.

Still, if the brake was running he might not have heard it so readily? -- I don't know whether the brake was running or not, sir.

You would hardly be able to tell much by sounding a piece of metal like this? — It is too thick a piece.

You had sounded it and it seemed good? — Yes, and it fell about an hour and a half later.

It was too big a piece to sound? — Too thick.

Wasn't there a small drift ran from one side of this working to the other? — Yes.

It had been packed up? — Yes.

I suppose it would be packed up with stones? — Yes, sir.

Which of you was the leading man? — There was no leading man. Hocking, Pooley, and I were all alike.

The Coroner: Is there no other means of examination except by sounding? — There are no other means I know; only sounding and looking at it.

Mr. T. Gavan Duffy: If it was partly loose how did you know it was safe? — That was opinion.

The Coroner: What does the chalk mark mean? — Simply that the deputy has been in that working. If there is anything dangerous he will tell us on the top.

John James Crellin, miner, 16, Winder Gate, said he was with Irving in a working perhaps three fathoms below Hocking. They had a labourer named Wm. Howell, and there was another man on their company, Joseph Fisher, but he was working a long way off. Witness was about seven yards distant from Irving, who was raking metal down to the labourer. On a ledge above five or six props were sticking up and there were lumps of Norway poles and large poles lying longways to keep anything from coming over on to them.

The Coroner: Did you see the accident? — I just heard a sudden rush and all the lights went out.

What did you do? — I got a light and ran forward.

What did you find? — I heard a groan near my feet, but I could hardly tell where Irving was.

What steps did you take? — We got Pooley out first; he was on the same level as we were.

He was working above you? — Yes, sir, but he came down with the stuff.

Hocking did not come down? — Yes, sir, Hocking came down as well.

Did you make any examinations of this ore that fell? — No, sir, I had nothing to do with it, not being on that level.

Did you make any examination of the staging above you? — Well, sir, it seemed to be all right as far as I knew.

Can you account for this fall in any way? — No, sir, I can't tell how it happened.

Had Irving any warning? — I never heard anything until the rush came.

Had the deputy been through your working that day? — Yes, sir, for anything I know.

Does he leave chalk marks? — Yes, if there is anything dangerous.

Doe he leave a mark if there is not anything dangerous? — I have never seen him.

Where do they put their mark? — On the stone, or ore, or whatever is had.

Mr. Atkinson: Do you see the deputy generally before you go down? — Yes.

Did you see him that morning? — Well, I really could not tell whether I saw him or not.

You generally see him? — Yes, generally, and he tells you if anything is wanted or if there is any danger.

Do you remember if he mentioned anything to you on September 28? — No, I never remember him mentioning anything.

How long have you worked in that neighbourhood? — About three or four months.

During that time have you had any falls? — No, sir, not that I know of.

Was the brake running at the time of the fall took place? — I could not tell you, sir.

There will be a certain amount of noise when the brake is running? — Yes, there is; but we could hear anything that was going on.

There seems to be a little misunderstanding about this chalking. Does he chalk only because it is dangerous or whether he has been in? — Well, I only know if there is any danger in the place there is a cross put on it. If there is a bad piece of metal or rock he would chalk it.

Would he always tell you about it? — Yes, if he saw anything.

Have you ever seen a cross on a shovel? — I never saw it.

The Coroner: How long have you been a miner? — As near as I can tell 20 years.

Have you ever been instructed what the meaning of a chalk mark is? — I have been told that a chalk mark is a sign that the ground wants looking to.

Are there any different chalk marks made? — I have seen a cross, but never anything else.

You take it to be a sign of danger? — Yes, sir.

Is that what all the miners consider a chalk mark means? — That is what I think it is.

The Foreman: Was there any working higher than where Hocking was? — No, sir. No one was working higher up.

A juryman: When a deputy finds a bad spot he marks it with a cross to show it is dangerous. It is the duty of the men to look for that.

Witness said that was what he always understood.

Thomas Stainton, deputy, Waterloo Terrace, said he had been at the No. 5 mine about 17 years. His duties were to go through the working places to see they were all right, and he went down at four o'clock in the morning. On September 28 the workings appeared to be all right, having a proper sound. He knew the particular body of ore that came away and sounded it this morning. It was a big piece, and was all right as far as he could tell. They could not test a thick piece like that by sound. There were no other means of testing, except by sounding and looking.

The Coroner: Is sounding conclusive that it is quite safe? — Oh, yes. I think it is to the best of our knowledge.

It was not safe in this case? — I think it was.

This was not safe, was it? — It was safe enough when I went through.

Have you had any suggestions to make why it fell? — It came off by an unknown "slape" that had never been since.

Could you ascertain that was there by sounding? — No.

Could you have done so with an inspection? — No. I don't suppose I could.

Had you inspected it? — Yes, I had.

Do you make a report of your soundings every morning? — Yes.

The book containing the daily reports of the deputy was here produced and handed to the Coroner.

The Coroner: What time did you make the entry in your book on the 28th September? — At six o'clock.

Did you then write "all safe and right"? — Yes, sir.

When you go through a working do you make any chalk marks? — Yes, to let the men see I have been in.

Is there any other object? — If there be anything else I report it to the men on the pit top before I go down and to the other deputy.

In what positions do you make these chalk marks? — Oh! on a pick, or a spade, or a hammer.

There are chalk marks all the way through? — Yes, in every working every morning.

Did you make a chalk mark that morning in these particular workings? — Yes.

Where did you make the mark in No. 34 company's working? — On a pick.

You also inspected No. 11 company's working? — Yes, and everything was quite safe. I made a mark.

What do the miners understand if they see a mark? — That I have gone through a working.

What sort of a mark do you make? — A cross I believe it was that morning.

By seeing a mark they don't understand there is any danger? — No, that it is all right. If there is any danger I report on the pit top.

Mr. Atkinson: If you saw a bad place would you put a chalk mark on it? — Yes, I would put a cross on it and that would represent it was bad. That would be addition to putting a cross on a shovel.

What experience have Hocking, Irving, and Pooley had? — I have known Hocking and Irving a good many years but have not known Pooley so long.

Did you find them experienced men? — Yes, I think they were as good as we had in the pit.

Supposing you found this "slape back" what would you have done? — Have ordered them to take it down or prop it.

Could it have been propped? — Yes, for a certain time, until they had got a hole bored in.

The Coroner: What difference is there between a chalk mark for danger and a chalk mark for safety? — If there is chalk mark on a lump or anything it means it wants taking down, and I always chalked on a spade, or a shovel, or a pick for safety.

The Coroner said the nature of the accident seemed to be pretty clear from the witnesses. There had been a good many questions about the chalk marks. He was not quite certain that all the miners rightly understood the meaning of the chalk marks, and certainly the witnesses Dixon and Crellin had not the same idea of the meaning of chalk marks. Stainton, however, seemed to have cleared it up to a certain extent.

The jury returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed."

Mr. Nelson expressed the sympathy of the Lonsdale Mining Company with the relatives of the deceased men.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Crellin, John James    Miner  
Dixon, George    Miner  
Fisher, Joseph    Miner  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Hartley, Richard    Mining Engineer  
Hocking, John   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hodgson, J. B.    Jury Foreman  
Howell, William    Labourer  
Irving, John   36 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nelson, J.    Solictor  
Pooley, Alexander    Miner  Injured
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Stainton, Thomas    Deputy  
Teasdale, —    Labourer  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Lonsdale (Iron Ore)  Lonsdale (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
03 Oct 1907  Miners Buried By A Fall Of Ore At Frizington, Two Killed And One Injured (Whitehaven News)
10 Oct 1907  The Mining Disaster At Frizington, The Inquest (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Lonsdale (Iron Ore)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print