|
19th September 1907 The Inquest On A Miner At EgremontThe adjourned inquest on the body of Thomas Bell (54), shiftsman, of Smithfield, Egremont, who died from injuries received in the No. 4 Gillfoot Mine, was conducted by Mr. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, in the Police Station, Egremont, on Thursday evening. Mr. T. Gilbertson was foreman of the jury, and there were also present: Mr. J. Adair, Wyndham Mining Co.; Mr. Ormrod, of Messrs. Brockbank, Helder, & Ormrod (representing the Wyndham Mining Co.); Mr. W. Leck, Government Inspector of Mines; and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, the Secretary of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners & Kindred Trades Association. Thomas Rigg, shiftsman labourer, said on Tuesday, September 3rd, he went down No. 4 Gillfoot Mine in company with Bell between half-past five and six o'clock. They went to alter a brake of the drop shaft first, and when they were going along to a brake road at which they were working it would be about twenty minutes to seven. Deceased went up the brake road to a drum at the top, and told witness to bring up the tackle from a bogey at the bottom. He came up with two rolls of tackle and some wood, and put the ropes down on the flat sheets. At this time deceased was standing looking at the drum. Witness went back for more tackle, and when he got to the bogey, heard a shout, and ran up the road to see what was the matter. He turned a corner and went on past the drum, being guided by the shout, and found the deceased lying face downwards with what appeared to be a lump of stone on his shoulders. Bell said, "Get it off," and the witness tried to do so, but his light went out, and he had to proceed to the brake for a light, and then ran for assistance. Two other men came and helped to take off the stone. Replying to the Coroner, witness said he thought Bell would be under the stone about a couple of minutes. The other two men would be working 18 or 20 yards away. He did not know whether Bell's duties took him to the point when he was found or not. Witness did no know what he was doing. He did not know if there was any reason why he should not have gone there. Deceased was found in a roadway about 40 feet from the drum. Witness had never previously been in that part of the mine where they found Bell. He had only been in the mine a fortnight. Mr. Leck: How long have you been working at this brake? — A week. But you had not been in the workings? — No, sir. Had you got to the bottom when you heard a shout? — Yes, I was at the bogey. Do you know the distance from the drum to the bogey? — Somewhere about 50 or 60 feet. What time elapsed from when you left him until you heard the shout? — I should say about five minutes. Had he a light? — There was no light when I arrived. You would be acting under Bell's instructions? — Yes, sir. Mr. T. Gavan Duffy: You both were engaged in putting up a brake, and it would be necessary for him to get some packing for that work? — I could not say. Was there anything in the working to indicate it was a dangerous place? — I could not say. Any signboard, or plank, or anything? — I did not see anything. Mr. Ormrod: I suppose there would be plenty of packing to be got from the top if you wanted it? — There was packing in the bogey. Mr. Duffy: If slag was wanted you would not have gone to the top, would you? — Probably a man would take it from where he could? I could not say Isaac Thomlinson, who was in an adjacent working to deceased, said Rigg came running up and asked for assistance, saying Bell had been lamed. Witness went and found deceased lying face downwards with a piece of metal (ore) on his shoulder and arm, and he helped to get the metal off. The Coroner: Would there be a couple of cwts.? — No, I don't think so. Mr. Leck suggested about half a bogey of metal, and witness agreed with this. The Coroner: Where did it come from? — I should think out of the roof. Were you working near this place? Seventy or eighty yards away. Had anyone been working there recently to your knowledge? — I don't know exactly at that same spot. Did you speak to Bell? — No, sir. You don't know how it happened? — No, sir. He was alive then, I suppose? — Yes. Have you ever been employed in putting up a brake? — No, sir. You don't know what a man would have to do in putting up a brake? — No, sir. When you went there, there was nothing to indicate it was a dangerous spot? — I did not see anything. George Edward Brown, deputy of the mine, said he was going to the brake when he heard someone shout for assistance. He found the man to be Rigg, and went with him to the working where Bell was lying. He raised the latter off the ground, and found a leg and an arm to be badly crushed. By the Coroner: There was then nothing on the deceased, and witness did not help to get off a stone. Witness, continuing, said when he moved the man, he complained a good deal about his back. He was badly injured, and not able to move alone. He was taken up the shaft, and died about an hour afterwards. The Coroner: Did you do anything by way of giving him attention? — Yes, we moved him a few yards and then applied first aid and put splints on his leg and arm. We had to get a temporary stretcher made, and a doctor was waiting on arrival at the surface. How long had you found him before the doctor was in attendance? — Close on an hour, I should think. What was Bell doing at this place at the time? — He had been putting a brake up, and should have been fixing the ropes on. Do you know what he would be doing at the place where he was found? — He told me he was looking for a piece of slab for the brake. I suppose he required this for the work he was doing? — I expect so. Was there any supplied? — There were pieces up to four feet long lying about the brake, but what length he would require I can't say. To your knowledge, was there any danger in this place? — Oh, yes. Why? — Because it was a "robbery," and as a rule the workmen in a "robbery" fire at the end of the shift. So that in order if anything falls they will not be there? — Yes. Had there been firing there previously? — I suppose so. How long before? — I expect they would be firing between one and two o'clock in the afternoon, four or five hours before. If there was any firing, do you prevent men going about a place? — As a rule there is a barrier put across to keep men out of dangerous places. If there us no barrier there is nothing to prevent men walking through? — No, sir. Was there any barrier on this occasion? — I did not notice one, but it is possible it might have been there and me not notice it. Whose duty was it to see it was put up? — The men who were working in the place. Would Bell have any knowledge that there had been firing there? — As a rule an experienced man in the mines would know it was the usual thing to fire when leaving a "robbery." Did he know this part of the mine? — Oh, yes. Was he bound to know this place was not safe? — Well, he knew it was a "robbery," and there is always a certain amount of danger for a stranger to go into a "robbery." Are men allowed to walk over the mine? — They are not supposed to go into these "robberies." There are, however, no orders that they are not to go in? — No, sir. Would you have expected Bell to go into this place if he was working at the brake? — No, sir. Is there anything, to you knowledge, that ought to have been done after a shot was fired that was not done? — No, sir. You don't know whether it was protected with a barrier? — No, sir. Mr. Leck: Is it your idea that the roof happened to fall just as Bell went in? — Yes. In the ordinary course they would be nobody in this working until the same men came back next morning? — No, with the exception of the deputy. If when walking through a mine you come across a slab at the entrance to a working, what would you understand? — That there was danger. Deceased was a very experienced man? — Yes. Would he know as well as you it was a regular practice to fire before going out of a "robbery" working? — Oh, yes. Mr. Ormrod: Would he know this was a "robbery" working? — Yes. He would know the danger of going in? — Yes. John Briggs, a miner, who works in the "robbery" where deceased was found, said they were there until close on two o'clock this particular day. They fired just before two o'clock. The Coroner: Is that to bring down some ore ready to start with the next shift? — Yes. Had anyone any ordinary business in these workings except those workings there? — No. It was not a thoroughfare? — No. Did you put up any obstruction after firing this shot on Tuesday? — Yes, one of my mates named Irving, said a ladder was put across. It would be a sort of notice or warning? — Yes. Would it be a likely thing for a man to wander into those workings if he was looking for a piece of wood? — Oh, yes, it would be a likely thing, but all miners know if anything is put across there is danger. Mr. Leck: How many holes did you fire at this place? — Two. One in the roof, and the other at the side of a pillar. In summing up, the Coroner said the jury could make a recommendation if they wished. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed by a fall of stone, but made no recommendation. Mr. Ormrod said the officials would consider the matter to the best of their ability. Mr. Duffy: I quite agree, but I would possibly carry more weight outside this district if the jury made a recommendation. The Coroner: You see there are no special rules. Mr. Duffy: It is an unfortunate thing; almost a cruel thing. The Coroner: You are not making any recommendation, Mr. Foreman? The Foreman: If any of the jury wish to. Mr. Ormrod said the officials would consider if anything could possibly be done, and he thought that was as much as they could do.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||