Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

8th August 1907

Leaving Work Without Notice

Claim Against Colliers

At the Maryport Police Court, on Friday, the Gillhead Coal, Firebrick, and Gannister Company Ltd., sued James Robinson, Seaton, coalminer, for breach of contract under the Employer and Workman's Act 1875. The claim was at the rate of 6s 6d per day for twelve working days, amounting to £3 18s. There were also summoned Tom McMillan, coalminer, Flimby; George Irving, Seaton; John Fletcher, Seaton; Ritson Graham, Flimby; William Graham, Flimby; John Campbell, Flimby; John Tyndall, Flimby; Tom Scott, Flimby; Jeremiah Kendall, Camerton; William Robinson, Seaton; Christopher Telford, Flimby; Tom Hornsby, Flimby; Joseph Holliday, Flimby; James Luty, Flimby; John Luty, Flimby; Robert Irving, Seaton; James Smith, Flimby; Joseph Collins, Seaton; William Peele, Seaton; William Irving, Seaton; Joseph Irving (the elder), Seaton; Isaac Nicholson, Flimby.

The Chairman (Mr. Cockton) suggested that the advocates should meet and endeavour to settle the matter in a friendly way by referring it to the Conciliation Board. If the magistrates settled it, it might not be a happy end.

Mr. Atter: The workmen offered to refer it to the Conciliation Board.

Mr. Rigg: It was not an offer they could accept.

The Chairman suggested that the advocates might talk the matter over.

The advocates retired for a short time, but could not arrive at a settlement.

Mr. Rigg, in opening the case, said that on 8th July 31 men left their employment without giving any notice whatever, and they said the men should have given 14 days notice. Not only did they not give any notice but they did not even tell the manager on the morning on which they left. The result was very serious for the company. Two kilns were on full fire and coals had to be at the works by nine o'clock, and the damage was very serious. They must have known that perfectly well. Communication was opened with those associated with the men, but nothing was done. As regards the damages for the fortnight ending 6th July they consumed 195 tons of coal. During the following fortnight the Company bought 140 tons, but only got 110 tons delivered, so that the loss and inconvenience was very great. They estimated the loss at about £150, and the amount of the aggregated claim ran to £117 or £118.

Mr. Thompson, manager of the colliery, said the defendant Robinson was working as a hewer up to the 8th July. 14 days' notice was given and required at the colliery. He received a notice signed by the defendant giving notice that they would cease work on the 22nd May unless their demand for a weekly square-up was granted.

Mr. Atter, interposing, said that the first point to be proved was whether there was a contract. His contention was that there was no contract.

The Chairman asked if any contract was implied when the men were engaged?

The Clerk said he would advise the Bench that there was prima facie evidence of a contract on the notice.

Witness said that on the 8th July he had no notice that the men would leave work. They sent no deputation, nor told him they had no dispute with them. A deputation came to him on the Monday afternoon. An effort was made to settle on the Friday. The men had not been at work since. He estimated the loss at about £150 — £105 for coals, £17 for keeping the pit open, about £10 for labour in the stores, and about £20 loss on 400 tons of fire clay and stone at 1s per ton. There was also the inconvenience. The brickworks had been impeded by the absence of the men. They had to stop four days last week. They had had to give up orders, and had refused to take orders.

By Mr. Atter: They had no rules about the colliery about the men giving notice either written or otherwise. That, however, had been understood for the last eight or nine years. The men understood it. The question of giving notice applied to witness as well as the others. He could be dismissed by receiving 14 days notice. They had a book in which the workmen signed their engagement. Men, however, were not keen on signing, and after August 1905, they did not force the men to sign. The men, however, knew that the understanding existed. James Robinson's name was not in that book, and Robinson had not signed any engagement by which he had to give 14 days notice. They kept the book from 1903 to 1905, because they had a case before the Conciliation Board which went in their favour. After that they made the men sign. It was not because a case was dismissed by the Whitehaven magistrates that they made the men sign. The dispute in May was because the men required weekly wages with no deductions to be carried over to the next week.

The Chairman: Has it not been a generally accepted thing this 14 days notice? — Yes, sir.

Mr. Atter argued that a contract must be mutual. That in the book did not bind the Company.

The Clerk pointed out that in the contract the men had signed previous to 1905 it said that the men agreed "to give and take." The whole of the dispute arose over six men, whom he dismissed without 14 days notice, because they left their work on Saturday morning. The men dismissed themselves by leaving their work. He denied shutting the door in the face of a deputation. He offered to meet a deputation if it did not consist of any of the men dismissed. He refused to restart the six men.

Mr. Rigg said they had been quite willing to go to the Conciliation Board, but not to reinstate the six men.

By Mr. Rigg: One of the men had come back, and they had found work for him. He was not one of those summoned.

Mr. T. P. Martin, secretary of the Cumberland Coalowner's Association, said he was secretary when this question, respecting the giving of notice came before the Conciliation Board, and he agreed with Mr. Thompson as to that. If the men had obeyed Rule 13 of the Conciliation Board the men would not have left their work. The rules were adopted both by the coalowners and men.

Mr. Atter, referring to the dismissal of six men, said that by the Colliery Company acting in that way the men had a grievance.

Mr. Rigg contended that they were rightly dismissed.

The Chairman: My opinion is that the men dismissed themselves. But we are not trying that.

James Wilkinson, under-manager, said that William Peel, one of the workmen summoned, gave a 14 days notice to leave.

Fred Nixon, one of the defendants, said he had worked for them twice. He left them in July last year. No notice was given or required.

By Mr. Rigg: He left because he was not making a wage. (Laughter.) He signed the notice for the weekly pays.

Isaac Nicholson, banksman, said that if the pit was not working there was no duty for them to fulfil.

Mr. Atter then opened the case for the defence. He contended there had been no breach of contract. In a contract there must be mutuality; both parties must be agreed. The contract in the book signed before 1905 was not mutual, as it did not bind the masters, and the contract could not bind the men unless at the same time it also bound the masters. Mr. Atter went on to say there was spite against a man named Musgrave, and he had not had fair play. It had been said the six men had not been dismissed, but left their employment, but they said there had been unfair dealings with these six men as compared with nine others in the old dip. If the employer could dismiss men without notice, the workmen could leave without notice. They had as much right to leave without notice as the masters had to dismiss them without notice.

Thomas Musgrave, workmen's representative and delegate at the Gillhead Colliery, said he had been that for the last twelve months. On the 6th July he was working in the new dip. Six more men were working with him. One of the set riders, Harry Atkinson, told them that he was going to run two sets down the old dip for their one. If they had not got the tubs there was not work for them. They decided to come to the pit bottom. There were nine working in the old dib. Subsequently when they went for their pay they were instantly dismissed. They left an hour before the usual time because they could not get any tubs. On the Monday witness went with Thomas Cape to meet with Mr. Thompson. Mr. Thompson said he would not meet any of them that was sacked, and then shut the door in their faces. Subsequently they proposed that the whole case be referred to the Conciliation Board, but the offer was not accepted.

By Mr. Rigg: On 5th May, five men were dismissed. Witness was not dismissed then, but Mr. Thompson had threatened him afterwards.

Mr. Rigg: What for — Insubordination, disobedience? — No, sir.

Witness, further cross-examined, said he signed the contract in the book in 1903, but had been twice away from the Colliery since then. He went to the Colliery on the Monday morning, but he did not persuade them to resume work. He told them there was two or three ways of doing, but they decided they would stand by him and the others, and not go to work, seeing that no notice existed at that colliery.

Thomas Cape, assistant miners' agent, said that on 8th July, he and the last witness saw Mr. Thompson. The latter said he would grant an interview but not with any of the men that were dismissed on Saturday. There was a general rule at the collieries that 14 days notice should be given. There was no such rule at the Gillhead Colliery. At the collieries where there was an agreement to give 14 days notice, a book was signed which contained the agreement at the top. Another signature was given on behalf of the Colliery Company.

Mr. Andrew Sharp, miners' agent, said about two-thirds of the collieries in West Cumberland had 14 days notice and a third had not. No man was bound at these collieries except he signed. At every colliery where the 14 days notice was signed by the men, an official also signed, as proof of the man's signature. At other collieries there might be a mutual understanding. The notice the men had given had only reference to weekly. The rules of the Conciliation Board were mutual, and were not legally binding. There was nothing in them about a 14 days notice.

Mr. Atter, in addressing the Bench, on the question of damages, assumed the Bench was against him in his contention that there was no contract, and the colliery had no right to keep this place idle for twelve days without any attempt to get other people in their places. He also contended that to claim 6s 6d per day for the whole of these men was unreasonable.

Mr. Rigg thought that Mr. Atter knew more of the conditions of labour at collieries than he appeared to do. He did not think there was a gentleman on the Bench who supposed that they could, during the time these men were out on strike, have obtained anything like the labour to work these collieries. As regards the damages, Mr. Thompson's estimate had not been challenged. The men went out knowing they would inflict severe loss upon the colliery.

Mr. Atter admitted that as regards those who had signed the book he had a weaker case, and he would not ask the Bench to state a case with regard to them. The only question as to them would be whether the six men were rightly or wrongly dismissed.

In answer to the Chairman, Mr. Thompson stated that the colliery would work on an average five days a week.

The Bench retired, and on their return the Chairman said they had very carefully considered the case, and they found that the 14 days notice had been established, and in the cases where the claim had been for £3 18s they mitigated it to £2 15s.

Mr. Rigg said there were two cases at £1 19s.

The Chairman: Other cases in the same proportion.

Mr. Atter: I accept your decision on behalf of the men who signed the book, but as regards the other I shall certainly apply for a case on the question of contract.

In answer to Mr. Atter, the Chairman said they had considered the case of the four men, set riders, banksman, and on-setter. They considered they had never given the managers a chance.

As regards the question of time for payment, Mr. Atter said his friend stated they had £45 in hand for wages.

Mr. Sharp: We'll take action to get that.

Mr. Rigg: Then I'll ask for an immediate order.

Mr. Atter: That would be unreasonable in the case of working men.

The Chairman said they would give them two months. They hoped that no more expense would be incurred, but that they would take the judgement of the Bench. They thought they had dealt exceedingly leniently with them.

Mr. Atter then applied that, as the Bench had found there was a contract existing, it should be annulled.

The Chairman: No.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, Harry    Set Rider  
Atter, —    Solicitor  
Campbell, John    Miner  
Cape, Tom    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Cockton, —    Magistrate  
Collins, Joseph    Miner  
Fletcher, John    Miner  
Graham, Ritson    Miner  
Graham, William    Miner  
Holliday, Joseph    Miner  
Hornsby, Tom    Miner  
Irving, George    Miner  
Irving, Joseph    Miner  
Irving, Robert    Miner  
Irving, William    Miner  
Kendall, Jeremiah    Miner  
Luty, James    Miner  
Luty, John    Miner  
Martin, Thomas Pattinson    Secretary  Whos Who Page
McMillan, Tom    Miner  
Musgrave, Thomas    Miner  
Nicholson, Isaac    Banksman  
Nixon, Fred    Miner  
Peele, William    Miner  
Rigg, —    Solicitor  
Robinson, James    Miner  
Robinson, William    Miner  
Scott, Tom    Miner  
Sharp, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Smith, James    Miner  
Telford, Christopher    Miner  
Thompson, Thomas    Manager  Whos Who Page
Tyndall, John    Miner  
Wilkinson, James    Under Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Gillhead Colliery  Gillhead Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print