|
25th July 1907 Millom Miner's Lingering DeathNine Months With Fractured SpineOn November 1st last a young Haverigg cricketer named James Hoggarth, brother of the well-known footballers, Sammy and Tommy Hoggarth, of Millom fame, was carried into the Hodbarrow Hospital, Millom, suffering from a fractured spine and other bruises, caused by a fall of metal in the Hodbarrow mines. He had been working with his brother Thomas, who fortunately heard the metal coming, and crouched down by the forebreast, thus escaping very serious injury. James Hoggarth, the deceased, was working in the middle of the drift, and had no time to escape, nearly a ton of lumps of ore falling on his back. His legs were paralysed, and it was generally expected that he would pass away in a few days. The Hodbarrow Company spared no expense in his treatment, two trained nurses being engaged on his behalf. Dr. Stoney was unsparing of himself in his serious case, and it is undoubtedly a tribute to his skill that the poor fellow has lived so long. About a month ago a special invalid carriage was procured by the Hodbarrow Mining Company, and the deceased appeared to enjoy his first outing after so many weeks' confinement. However, he seemed to fall away after this. Losing his speech on Saturday, and, becoming unconscious on Sunday, he expired in the evening at 9.30. Deceased was a playing member of the successful Haverigg team up to the time of the accident, his genial disposition and unassuming ways gaining the respect of all he came in contact with. He was a particularly well developed young man, and his untimely end has caused the greatest sympathy for the bereaved family. The Inquest The inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital on Monday afternoon, before Mr. W. T. Lawrence (deputy coroner), and a jury of which Mr. J. Hoyle was foreman.Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector, was in attendance, and Mr. S. Coade watched the proceedings on behalf of the Hodbarrow Mining Company Ltd. A Juryman Late When the jury was called over, Mr. M. S. Spry was found to be missing. The Coroner decided to make up the compliment by asking one of the reporters to act. Happily, before the jury could be sworn, Mr. Spry put in an appearance, and the incident ended. The Coroner's Explanation The Coroner said though it was very long time since this unfortunate accident occurred, it was necessary that this inquiry should be held. They had the presence of Mr. Leck, H.M. Inspector, and he no doubt would be of assistance and show in detail what was the actual cause of death. Thomas Hoggarth, living at Egremont Street, Millom, said he was a miner, working at Hodbarrow. The deceased, James Hoggarth, was his brother, aged 22 years last March. On the 1st of November last he was working with him in the mines in company with David Jordan. They were breaking metal to put in a head-tree. It was not in a dangerous position. They had started to work in this place on the previous day. They had fired three holes, and then they dressed them down. Jordan commenced to fill, and deceased and witness began to bore. Witness heard a small piece of metal falling and crouched down under the forebreast. Before his brother had time to move from the middle of the drift, a slice came away from the side on top of him. It was composed of big lumps, and would weigh from half a ton to a ton altogether. Witness was just scarred on the left shoulder. He went to the assistance of his brother, who was partly lying on his side and back, but not completely buried up. He said "Chaps, I'm done; my back is broken." He was removed to the hospital as quickly as possible. They had received no warning about this particular part of the mine, or about the possibility of an accident there. The place had been carefully examined and inspected by an official, Mr. J. Yellard, timberman, three or four hours before the accident. The captain visited the place daily, but no one had been in that day. They had done all that was usual in timbering. By Mr. Leck: The place was 10ft high by 10ft wide inside the timber. They were sliping at the time. Captain Coade here produced a plan of the working, which Mr. Leck explained to the jury. By Mr. Leck: There was a considerable difference between driving into the solid and sliping from the open side. The fall of metal did not bring any timber away. The head-tree was close to the forebreast, or about 18 inches. They had forks under the carrier on both sides. After firing the first holes they were not able to get in the head-tree. These holes were in the middle. Witness, and his brother made an examination after the holes were fired. No official had come in after firing. The effect of the firing of the three holes was to undercut the place. One side was shot clean out for the head-tree, but the other side was not. Mr. Leck: Did it occur to you or any of you three that it would have been a good thing to put in a prop? Witness: We thought we had done a good job. Mr. Leck: Sometimes the ore comes away quite suddenly in Hodbarrow? Witness: Yes. Mr. Leck: Did it occur to you after the accident that a prop would have been a good thing? Witness: Yes, it did. He had, however, examined the place with a long bar and a pick, and they did not start again until they thought it was sound. He had worked at Hodbarrow for ten years, and his brother for about six years. Mr. Yellard came into the place and asked if it was all safe, and told them to look after themselves. They had plenty of timber about if they wanted it. They had no leading hand in the drift. Jordan was an older miner than witness. Dr. Stoney deposed that he was first called to see the deceased on 1st November last, about nine or ten o'clock at night, at the Hodbarrow Hospital. He was told he had been crushed under a fall of metal in the mine, and he found the lower part of his body completely paralysed. On examination he also found his spine was fractured above the level of the shoulder blades. There was also certain bruises on his buttocks and the calf's of his legs, caused by metal scraping it. He considered that eventually the accident would end fatally. Nothing was spared for him, a special carriage being bought for him in London. Mr. John Yelland, foreman timberman at the mines, said he knew the deceased and the place he was working at, very well. He examined the working about five o'clock the same day, when the Hoggarth's and Jordan were present. Everything appeared to be secure and safe. It was a new place of working. There had been no shots fired then, and there was plenty of timber at hand, in fact, everything that the men required. Witness did not see the place again until the next day after the accident. Nothing was then brought to his notice. If he had seen the place after the shots had been fired he would have ordered a wedge to have been placed in between the head-tree and the ground. By Mr. Leck: Witness's sole duties consisted of overlooking the timbering and seeing that the work was done properly. Nurse Stephens, caretaker at the Hodbarrow Hospital, testified to the death of deceased. Mr. Leck thought it would not be necessary to call David Jordan as a witness. The Coroner, in summing up, said, as the Inspector of Mines had remarked, it was all very well to be wise after the accident. If they could be wise before an event many of the accidents that happened would probably not occur. In any case it appeared to him that this had been a pure and simple accident. They knew that every provision was made at the mines for the workmen. They were stinted for nothing, and so far as the management was concerned no blame was attached to them, or any other of the firm. They knew that men sometimes would take risks. He was not sufficiently skilled in mining to say that if a prop had been put in the accident would not have occurred. In any case it was an accident. The jury unanimously returned a verdict of "Accidental death."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||