3rd July 1907
Iron-Ore Miners' Union
Position Of General Secretary
One of the minor sensations of the past week was the news that by a ballot of over four-to-one the Iron Ore Miners Union had resolved to dispense with the services of Mr. J. Flynn, their agent and general secretary.
The Cumberland Iron Ore Miners & Kindred Trades Association is the name of the Union in the West Cumberland mining district of which Mr. James Flynn has been for the last 13 years the general secretary. It has been worked by means of seven branches
with lodges at Egremont, Cleator Moor, Frizington, Kirkland, Moor Row, Whitehaven, and Rowrah. Each branch has been managed by its local secretary and treasurer; each has taken its own subscriptions, kept its own accounts and audited and issued its own
balance sheets; each has contributed to the general common fund of the Association, and elected representatives to the common Council, one for every 100 members belonging to the lodge. The subscription of members has been 6d per week. There are now
about 2,500 members, and at 6d a week this number of subscriptions would yield a total (branch) income of £3,276. For the year ending 31st December, 1906, as shown by the audit balance sheet, the seven branches contributed to the common fund,
£2,012 9s 7d, as follows :—
Egremont, £840; Cleator Moor, £565 1s; Frizington, £315; Moor Row, £145; Kirkland, £95; Whitehaven, £46 8s 7d; Rowrah, £6. The amount of expenditure for that year for strikes was £2,392 17s 6d, and the
total expenditure £3,176 15s 9½d. £531 18s 6d was received from the National Federation, and there was a loan of £200 from the Blastfurnacemen's Federation.
The general balance-sheet and audit does not touch branch expenses, but includes only the amounts paid over by the various branches to the General Treasurer (Mr. J. Redmond).
For some time there has been friction in the working of the Association, and the General Secretary has been endeavouring to re-organise it on a different basis. He sent out a circular to each mine, asking that a vote of the members working at the mine
should be taken on the question of each mine being a lodge to carry on its own business direct, having its own delegate to represent it on the Council and at all joint meetings. This, the circular said, would be a great advantage to the members working
in outside mines, and a saving of time and money to the Association. "This resolution," it proceeded, "is sent in by Cleator Moor and Frizington Lodges. At the present time, only a few members attend the quarterly meetings, and only
about ten per cent of the members know the business of the Association. If the members are in favour of this resolution, kindly let me know on or before the 30th day of May, 1907." The following gave in their adherence to this resolution :—
Iron ore winding enginemen; Postlethwaite's Moor Row; Lindow's; Bigrigg Mining Company; Wyndham & Falcon; Lord Leconfield's; Jacktrees; Town Head Mining Company; Moss Bay Company; Stirling's iron ore mines and coal mines; Ainsworth's Frizington;
Lonsdale; Salter Hall; Pallaflat, Woodend. These have already voted, and voted in favour of the change; and there are one or two mines yet to vote. The representatives of these mines, according to the new constitution form the council.
Some of the members of the old Council, elected by the old branches, have been re-elected under the new constitution of mine lodges taking the place of the branch lodges; others have not been thus re-elected. This is how Mr. Flynn regards the matter.
It is here, in consequence of this revolutionary change of constitution that the friction has burst into flame. The position is something like that of Cromwell and the Rump Parliament. The old Council is the Rump. It claims that it is constitutionally
in the right, but it is shown to the door. Thereupon certain members of the old Council had a circular printed, without any signature, but "By order of the Council," in which they set out that a serious crisis had arisen, and after making
certain statements with regard to Mr. Flynn's conduct as general secretary, submitted a resolution to be balloted, that had been handed in to the old Council by the Egremont Lodge :—
That we members of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners & Kindred Trades Association having lost all confidence in Mr. Flynn as General Secretary, do move that he receive three months' wages, and be dismissed from the service of the Association."
The ballot on this resolution was taken on Wednesday, July 3rd, by this order of the old Council. We call it the old Council not as in any way indicating any opinion on the questions at issue, but simply to distinguish this Council from the body of new
representatives that Mr. Flynn holds is now the Council. Circulars are usually sent out over the signature of the General Secretary, but of course, in this case, that was impossible. The ballot was taken at the several old district lodges, from nine in
the morning till seven at night, and the ballot-boxes were then taken to the Frizington Lodge, and were counted under the superintendence of Mr. Hugh Doyle, Egremont, and Mr. H. Crellin, of Frizington, who were stated to be general auditors. The
counting started at half-past eight, and at ten minutes to ten. Mr. Crellin announced the result as follows :—
| | For. | Against. |
| Kirkland | 49 | 2 |
| Frizington | 119 | 56 |
| Moor Row | 33 | 17 |
| Cleator Moor | 104 | 36 |
| Egremont | 459 | 52 |
| | ___ | ____ |
| | 769 | 163 |
On this vote, Mr. Flynn takes up the position - first, that the old Council was defunct, that its circular was irregular and without authority; but that even if the old Council still had authority and had acted regularly, the ballot was bad, as the rules
require that a vote shall be taken at the pits and that two-thirds of the members must vote. In this case 932 voted out of about 2,500. Again, Mr. Flynn contends that according to the rule the votes must be taken and counted in the presence of the
general secretary; and in the case the general secretary was not present, nor was he represented.
These are some of the leading facts and allegations on both sides in a rather complicated business. And so it results that Mr. Flynn ignores the vote and proceeds to establish and confirm the Association under its new constitution, of each mine a lodge.
The question of joining the Conciliation Board, or the method of representatives on the Conciliation Board is involved in the change of constitution, but it is not necessary to go into this. The Ullcoats Mine, Egremont, is alleged to be against joining
the Conciliation Board, and Egremont not only originated the resolution condemning the general secretary, but cast more than half of the total number of votes.
From interviews obtained with officials at Egremont, the point of view is that the dispute with the Secretary, Mr. Flynn; arose through his attempting to carry through a scheme to make each pit into a separate lodge, and do away with the local lodges,
without ever consulting the Council. At present, it may be explained; there are five lodges, viz: Cleator Moor, Moor Row, Egremont, Frizington, and Kirkland. The Council is a body elected by the men in January of each year, and is expected to serve
until the end of December. It consists of the chairman, secretary, treasurer, trustees, and one member out of every hundred. A meeting was held on June 7th, and adjourned until June 14th. Between June 7th and June 14th, Mr. Flynn called together a
body of delegates from some of the mines only, without consulting the duly elected Council. When the latter body met again on June 14th, Mr. Flynn was not present, but they went into business, and a resolution was given from the Egremont Lodge that the
members of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' & Kindred Trades Association having lost confidence in Mr. Flynn, he receive three months' wages and be dismissed. Although the Council had authority to deal with this case, they thought it better to leave
it to the members, and so called a mass meeting in the Cleator Moor Market Hall on June 27th, when owing to some rowdyism, no decision could be arrived at, and it was decided to take a ballot of the members on the question. The result was a majority of
606 in favour of dismissal. Since the result of the ballot was announced, Mr. Flynn has been going round the mines and is still continuing with his scheme of a lodge for each pit, although the Council hold it is entirely out of order. On the Council
called by Mr. Flynn himself did not include a single delegate from the Egremont Lodge, although it has a membership of between 800 and 900. Egremont miners are not in favour of the Secretary's scheme. At the other mines a good many men have left the
meetings, and the decision of only a few has been taken as granted. The men hold Mr. Flynn's action as entirely out of order, and one of the rules of the Association, dealing with the Secretary, reads: "He shall be under the control of the General
Council and shall obey their directions during the time he is in their services." The scheme for each pit to have a lodge of its own has never been discussed by the duly elected Council. Another rule bearing on the question runs as follows
:— "No new rule shall be made nor any rule be contained or altered, or rescinded, unless three months notice be given of such alteration or amendment, and then only with the consent of a majority of the delegates present at a Council meeting.
A few members of the Council have gone over to Mr. Flynn as delegates. The Council, as elected by the men, proposes to carry out the result of the ballot.
At a meeting last Saturday evening, to deal with the result of the ballot, there were 17 delegates present. The present Council holds office until the end of December, and it holds that Mr. Flynn is attempting to form a Council of his own which he is
not entitled to do.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Crellin, H, | | | |
| Doyle, Hugh | | | |
| Flynn, James | | | |