|
9th March 1907, Page: 7, Column: 4 Damages Against Seaton Burn MinersFor Refusing To Enter The PitA Question Of CustomAt the Moot Hall Police Court, Newcastle, on Saturday, a claim was made by the Seaton Burn Colliery Company against six miners in respect of Damages sustained by the company through the defendants having refused to go into the pit. The defendants were Matthew Reed, John Patey, Andrew Steel, Peter Hepple, Thomas Brown, and John W. Purvis. Mr. R. S. Holmes prosecuted, and Mr. W. S. Burton defended; and it was agreed to take the case of Reed as a test case. — Mr. Holmes said the the case rested upon a question of custom. There were two shifts at the colliery — the fore shift, which went in very early in the morning, and the back shift, which went in at 9.30 am. On Jan. 31, an accident happened in the mine, and a set of tubs were thrown off the way, in consequence of which the line was impeded. It was a considerable distance in to the face, and the men usually rode in-bye, but owing to the accident in the mine, the back shift were given instructions to walk in. It was the custom at the colliery for the men to walk in-bye if anything happened to the way, and they received a shilling in lien of the ride. On this occasion, the defendants, along with 57 other miners, held a meeting, and decided by a majority that they would not walk in. They accordingly returned to bank, and in consequence the coal brought to bank was 150 tons less than is ought to have been, and the company claimed 3s damages against each of the defendants. — Mr. Burton said the men had adhered to the custom of the colliery, and, in adhering, had refused to go to the face. There was an implied guarantee from the company that if the men went in-bye they would get a fair shift, and earn a fair wage; but the overman who told them to go in on this occasion would not give this guarantee. Even if there was a breach of the custom of the colliery, he joined issue so far as the damage was concerned. Any loss that the company might have sustained on the day in question was due to a breakage of the rope. The men could not have done any work until 3 o'clock in the afternoon. — William John Winter, overman, stated that, in consequence of the accident, he received instructions from the under-manager that the men had to walk in. Witness told the men this, but they held a meeting, and in consequence refused to walk in to the face. He spoke as to the custom of paying the men 1s when they were obliged to walk in-bye owing to accidents, and he denied that he refused to give a guarantee to the men that they would get a fair shift. — J. A. Gilchrist, under-manager at the colliery, said if the men had gone in they could have hewn the coal and "put it back." This was frequently done at the colliery. The tubs were working at 1.45 a.m. on the day in question. — Mr. Thornton, manager of the colliery, said that, if the men had gone in-bye, the amount of coal lost would not have been so much, because the tubs were working at 1.45 p.m. The men would not have been asked to go in to the face if the management did not think that they would get a reasonable shift. — William Dunbar, local secretary at Seaton Burn of the Northumberland Miners' Association, gave evidence on behalf of the defendant in regard to the custom of the colliery, which was that that the men had a guarantee for a fair shift if they walked to the face. — Walter Donkin, hewer at Seaton Burn Colliery, said that when the back shift went into the pit on the morning of Jan. 31. they learnt that there was a block, and they were told to walk in-bye. Winter was asked if he would guarantee a shift, and he replied that he would guarantee nothing. — David Turnbull, hewer, gave similar evidence. — William Brooks, putter at Seaton Burn, said the accident occurred in the mine at 8 o'clock on the morning of Jan. 31, and it was 2.50 p.m. before the empty tubs arrived at the face. — Mr. Burton intimated that he had more corroborative evidence, but he would leave the case as it stood. — After a consultation in private, lasting ten minutes, the Chairman of the magistrates (Sir Riley Lord) said that the Bench had decided that the Colliery Company had proved their case, and damages were assessed against Reed at 1s 6d with costs. — Mr. Burton said he was prepared to accept this decision in the other five cases.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||