|
31st January 1907 The Watergate Colliery DisasterTwo Cwt. Stone Falls 200 FeetThe InquestThe inquest concerning the death of Albert Sheehan, 65 years of age, 14 George Street, Maryport, and Joseph Bell, 33 years of age, 4, Hewson's Yard, Crosby Street, who were killed by a fall of stone in Watergate Pit, Flimby, on Wednesday was held in the Furnace Road Mission Room, on Friday afternoon, by Mr. G. Falcon (coroner for West Cumberland.) Mr. John Newton was chosen foremen. Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines, was present, while Mr. Lightfoot (Messrs Lightfoot and Lightfoot) represented the Flimby Coal and Fire Brick Co., and Mr. A. Sharp appeared for the Cumberland Miners' Association. The deceased were killed on Wednesday afternoon. About 1.40 p.m., they had completed their day's work and had entered the cage at the bottom of the shaft with several other men, when tow large stones, weighing about two cwt., from the side of the shaft fell, from a distance about 200 feet. It crashed through the cage, killing the deceased and injuring five others. John Bell, St Bees, identified the body of his brother, Joseph Bell. Albert John Mossop, Furness Road, Maryport, identified the body of his father-in-law, Albert Sheehan. Robert William Cochrane, surveyor at Watergate Pit, produced a tracing of part of the shaft. The stone came from the blue metal. It fell 201 feet. They had been sinking in the shaft and shot firing. It would finish about six the previous morning. It was 470 feet from the top to the stone. The cavity was 3ft. 6in. by 1ft. 6in. by 2ft. 6in., wedge shaped. The stone broke the woodwork away. By Mr. Sharp: The stone was out of the pit side, not out of an eye. There was an eye, but it was three fathoms below. The shaft was latted and cribbed, and the stone broke the cage. George Henry Pape, Risehow, shaftsman at the pit, said he had been shiftsman for eight months. He started to examine the shaft at twelve noon. He and the other shiftsman went down daily in one cage and came up in the other. They had lights sufficient. Both he and Lowden had been down the shaft that day. On Wednesday, some four or five feet below where the fall came out, and about the eye, he noticed a bad place. He noticed a little piece of latting off and noticed a stone. That was fresh that day. The latting that was off was perhaps ten inches by three feet. It had gone down the shaft. He knew there was no immediate danger, and on getting up he told them to stop the sinking operations, as he attributed it to the concussions. He thought it was safe for him and that it would be safe for the men. The place he saw was still standing yesterday. The actual place where the stone came from showed nothing wrong. The timber was sound. Witness produced a piece of timber from the latting. The latting was not oak, but the cribbing was. It was 12.30 when he came out, and the accident happened about a quarter to two. It was his intention to have the bad place he found repaired after the men came out. After the accident he went right down the pit. Until Wednesday he had seen no signs of movement whatever. By Mr. Atkinson: He thought the shaft was about 130 fathoms. It was an upcast shaft, and the steam from the steam pump sometimes came up it. It would not be affected by the frost. Beginning at the top there was walling down about 12 fathoms, and then came latting and cribs to above where the fall took place. The shaft was being sunk when he was going to school. (Laughter) The only eye in use was at the bottom. He thought it was the concussion from the shots in the sinking pit below that caused the fall. He reported the latting unsafe in No. 2 about the ten quarter eye. On December 19th he reported wood work in poor state in and about the ten quarters eye. That did not mean it was crumpling but that the wood was decaying. Mr. Atkinson: Is it safe to have stone pressing against decaying timber? — I would like to know how we were to know when the stone is pressing. Witness further stated that there was only about two feet between the place he reported and the top of the stone that came down. Mr. Atkinson: On the 23rd, did it never strike you something should be done before the men were allowed to ride? — I did, sir. Although, as a matter of face, within and hour afterwards, there was a fall within two feet of this point? — About this other crib, that is it. By the Coroner: After reporting a piece as having decaying wood on it, how could you consistently afterward report all safe. I did not consider it necessary to report it every day. It was safe with regards to the working operations, and there was no movement. The Coroner: Your idea was that it was not unsafe because the wood was decaying? — Yes. By Mr. Sharp: The wood had not rotted at the nails. No repairs had taken place in the shaft during this time. By Mr. Lightfoot: In reporting the wood to be in a poor condition he did not mean it was unsafe. He would not like to say that good latting would have kept back a stone of this size. He did not think that was the object of latting. When he reported it unsafe he meant as regards the sinkers, as he considered it safe for the ordinary working of the colliery. Mr. Atkinson: What is the object of latting? — Both for water and any kind of small stone, but it would not hold a big stone. Mr. Atkinson: A very little resistance on the part of the latting would have kept it back? — I would not say that — not for a big stone. Mr. Atkinson: If that is your view, the shaft is not safe unless it is walled. Witness further stated that it was the danger to the sinkers he was thinking of. He did not think that the men in the cage were exposed to the same danger, as all was working nice and easy. Alexander Lowden, Broughton Moor, the other shaftsman, gave somewhat similar evidence. By Mr. Atkinson: He had been shaftsman for four or five years, and during that time new batticing had been put in at different places. By a juryman: Had the place been reported been attended to it would not have prevented the accident. John James Pape, Risehow, had got in the cage to come up. There were seven in the cage, which as a one-decker. The cage was waiting for another to getting in. The cage had a wooden roof, and the stone crashed right through. He say no planking coming down with it — he saw nothing after the crash. He was knocked down. They could see nothing for splinters. He had seen no woodwork come down previously. By Mr. Atkinson: Ten men generally rode in the cage. They heard nothing until the stone crashed through the roof of the cage. He had never known anything fall on that cage during the four years he had worked at the pit. William Johnstone, Grasslot, on-setter at the bottom of the shaft, said he was there from six to 2.30. He had sent five cagefuls of men up that day. He had seen nothing come down the shaft before that. He had the cage up and had got the men in the cage, got the signal from the engineman to send the cage up, but had not rapped to away. By the Jury: As far as his knowledge went he considered the shaft safe. Is it not likely that a piece of wood fell down the day before you would see it? — I don't know, sir. Mr. Atkinson: He had been twelve months on-setter. He heard the stone coming. When the men heard the stone they all rushed out. About seven got out before the stone hit the cage. Twelve were in the cage. It was the men in the middle who were left in. He did not see what fell as he ran away from the shaft. By Mr. Lightfoot: He did not know how many were injured. The seven got out of the cage after the stone came down before. Robert Kellet, Manager, examined by Mr. Atkinson, said he had been manager since August 6th 1906. He examined the shaft along with Pape on the Wednesday before the accident. He was inside the cage, but he had it stopped at several places, and made a fairly good examination. His attention was called to the reports of December 19th, and he discussed the matte with Pape. He asked Pape what was the matter with the latticing, and he said nothing particular, except that it was getting old. Witness asked him if there was any danger, and he said "None whatever." Witness asked him if it was unsafe, and he said "Not at all." He did not make an examination himself at that time. He would put the length of life of latticing or cribbing in a shaft like Watergate at ten or fifteen years as there was not much steam coming up: other wise the duration would have been shorter. Sinking began on the 9th of that month, and proceeded after the coal had been drawn. The stone come off the slip. He saw that from looking at the cavity. He had formed rather a high opinion of Pape, who had No. 1 and No. 2 shafts to look after. Mr. Atkinson: It is rather awkward that after he calls attention to this place an accident occurs within two feet. — It is just possible there had been some movement in the measures abut the ten quarter seam. By Mr. Sharp: After the accidents, none of the cribs were broken away, but some of the lattices were. At his first examination of the shaft he found it in fairly good condition. By Mr. Lightfoot: He did not think it necessary to go and examine the place after Pape's statement to him. By the Jury: I understand he also made a repair on the day before? — Yes, he reported the lattices were bad, but I did not see it until the afternoon. By Mr. Sharp: He would not say that if the latticing had been stronger it would
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||