|
11th October 1906 The Bigrigg FatalityInquest At BigriggThe Jury's VerdictThe adjourned inquest touching the death of John William Southam, who met with his death at the Sir John pit, belonging to the Bigrigg Mining Company, a week ago last Wednesday, was conducted by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, at the Parish Room, Cleator, on Thursday evening. Mr. J. Hope Brown, Whitehaven, represented the Bigrigg Mining Company, and Mr. J. Flynn miners' agent, was present on behalf of the relatives. Mr. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines, and Mr. David Gill, engineer to the Company, were also present. Mr. Matthew Burns was the foreman of the jury. Mr. Gill submitted a plan of the shaft, which he explained to the jury. Samuel Russell Adair, 10, Church-road, Cleator, was the first witness called. He stated that he was an iron ore miner employed at the Sir John Walsh pit belonging to the Bigrigg Mining Company. On Wednesday, the 26th September, he was working with Patrick Sloan, Peter Morgan, and John William Southam. There were just the four of them working on that shift - the night shift. When they reached the level where they were working two stepped to the right and two to the left. Witness and Southam were subsequently working in the north side of the shaft, witness working alone for ten minutes. The method of working was to clear out the south side first and twenty minutes after they had been down witness who had crossed the shaft by the way of the cage, called to the other men to cross. When they had all crossed they buckled in and it was necessary that one man should go across to knock the cage away, a full bogey having been run on by witness and Sloan. Southam went to knock the cage away, though he was not asked to do so, but it was an understood thing that anybody knocked it off. There had been some staging across the shaft and witness did not know but what it was still across on the night the accident occurred. He had, however, been told by Thomas Daley that the cage had been run so far down and stuck in the shaft. From what he was told witness did not gather that the staging had been removed, and he had no idea that it had been. There was no way of reaching the hammer only by crossing the shaft. The Deputy Coroner: Would it have been the proper thing to have gone in front of the bogey to get at this hammer? Witness: They could go either way. Mr. Skerry: If the two cages had been working you would not have been able to go that way; you would have had to go in front as there would have been no other way round? Witness: Just so. Mr. Skerry: When you saw Southam disappear what did you do? Witness: We took the bogey off as quick as we could, and went down to the low bottom by another way. They went down to the 140 fathoms level, but from there they could not see anything of Southam. Mr. Skerry: Was he not floating on the top? Witness: No. Mr. Skerry: Would you have seen him if he had been? Witness: Yes. It was seven to ten minutes before the got down to the bottom owing to them having to get the bogey off. Witness sent for the overman, and after consulting him, got a ladder and rope and the three of them went down and found the body in the next compartment to the one which he had fallen down. Mr. Skerry: How long had you been crossing over this compartment which was boarded over? Witness: It was only in a week. Mr. Skerry: Did you get any notice when it was taken out before? Witness: Well, it was some time ago, and I can't really tell on what ground we worked at that time. Mr. Skerry: If you had been going to use this hammer would you have gone across in the same way? Witness: Yes, I was just about to do it when he did. Mr. Leck: Can you tell how long it is since the stage was put in first? Witness: I cannot tell how long it is since the stage was put in first, but at a rough calculation it will be seven weeks. Mr. Leck: Can you tell us how long the stage was out? Witness: I could not, really. Mr. Leck: How many days? Witness: I have no idea. Mr. Leck: Several days? Witness: I should think several days. Mr. Leck: When the stage was out before for several days, what method did you adopt then in crossing the shaft? Witness: I think it was partly worked by the cage as there were no other means at that time. Mr. Leck: Do you remember at any time having any instructions as to how you were to cross the shaft - any official instructions? Witness: No. Mr. Leck: Had you any impression at any time that you should not go this way? Witness: Never. In reply to further questions, witness said he was the leading hand, and that it was usual for instructions to be given to him for his shift. There was nobody at the 140 fathom level, and in the ordinary course of working they would not be "knocking" the cage to that level. He did not think that under the circumstances they could have got down to the lower level any quicker. Replying to Mr. Skerry, witness said he meant to inquire whether the boarding had been put back, though he never had any suspicion that it had not been. By Mr. Brown: If there had been a hammer across the stage, Southam would not know whether the men on the other shifts used the same method of crossing the shaft as they did. In answer to Mr. Flynn, witness said he had started the cage in the same manner as Southam had done. He did not receive any instructions from the manager of the mine before he went down. That was the first time during that week that the stage had been taken out. There was not stationary light in the working, with the exception of the candles. He did not notice the planks when he went down the pit. In reply to Mr. Skerry, witness said he did not tell Southam that the cage had been down. He did not give him the information he had got from Daley. Peter Morgan, miner, 13, Church-street, Cleator, gave corroborative evidence. Thomas Daley, another shiftsman, deposed that he had worked on the afternoon shift on the day in question, and left the pit at ten o'clock. He was aware that the boarding was off, the shaftsman Pratt having told him. Pratt was not there when witness left at ten o'clock. Witness was told by Pratt that the staging was off and that it had to stay off. The boarding was not put there for the purpose of crossing, and the men on his "shift" did not use it for crossing, but used the cage. Witness had crossed it, but before doing so he used to get a light to see whether there were any boards there or not. It was his opinion that Adair (the first witness) would have understood that the boards were off. By Mr. Leck: He saw the manager that day, but he did not remember him saying anything to him. He did not remember being given any instructions as to whether they should cross the cage or not. No instructions were given as to how they were to get from one side of the shaft to the other. Replying to Mr. Brown, witness said that he remembered seeing Mr. Wilkinson at two o'clock before going down the pit. He did not hear Mr. Wilkinson say anything about the boards being away. By Mr. Flynn: He just said to Adair that the cage had been through, but did not say that the boards were away. Robert Wilkinson, the manager at the pit, was called at the instigation of Mr. Brown. He stated that the boarding was removed on the same day as the accident at about one o'clock, for the purpose of opening up the shaft to commence working. It had been in to act as a temporary prevention for anything that might fall from the engine, which was some sixteen feet above. Witness was at the pit top at two o'clock when the second shiftsmen went down. He saw Daley and the other men on the shift and told them all the wood had been taken off the shaft, and that they had to be particular. He also told them to tell the night men. The boards had not been there the whole time they were working on that level. They were out for nearly a week up to the Friday before. He did not know that any men were making use of that platform for crossing over. Witness had not given any orders about it. By Mr. Skerry: It was not fastened up because they were working, and were obliged to keep it partly opened. In reply to Mr. Leck, witness said he had told the men that they were to cross the shaft by the cage. He knew that according to the rule every shaft should be properly fenced. Under the present circumstances he considered the shaft properly fenced. It was fenced in such a way that no one could fall into it inadvertently. The place, as a rule was fairly well lighted. The shaft was only working temporarily, and it was the intention as soon as it was made into a proper working shaft, to have a handle to the bell on both sides of the shaft. Pratt told witness that he had taken the boards off, and asked him if they had to remain off or not. Witness finished with, and that they were going to put the cage down. Mr. Leck remarked that the hole which the deceased had gone through was 3ft. 6in. Mr. Skerry asked if witness considered when work was getting on like that - sinking - whether the protection round the compartment was sufficient under the circumstances, and added that it evidently enabled a man to creep through, but it did not allow a man to fall down. Mr. Leck said that he might say at once that as the battery covered the compartment right across there was adequate protection for the time. Replying to Mr. Flynn, Mr. Leck said that undoubtedly the thing to have done when the boards were taken off was to have put a fixture across the shaft if the officials knew they were using that method of crossing. Mr. Leck to the Manager: Supposing you had known that the men were using this as a travelling road what would you have done? Witness: I would have let them cover it up at once. Mr. Flynn: Had you ever asked the men whether they were using it? Witness: No. James Pratt, joiner at the pit, said he took the staging from the shaft, and the boards were put into the eye at the right-hand side. He did not see whether Mr. Wilkinson addressed Daley or the lot when he was telling about the boards being off. He heard him say "You must be careful, and tell the night shiftmen that it is off." Witness spoke to Daley and Clements and told them that the stage was off, and they should be particularly careful. Mr. Flynn: You say that Mr. Wilkinson told the whole of the men that the stage was off? Witness: He addressed the lot of us. Mr. Flynn: Did you address the men after Mr. Wilkinson had gone? Witness: Yes; just as I was leaving. Mr. Flynn: Well, if Mr. Wilkinson had told them, why did you tell them? Witness: Just because I had been in the habit of telling them. Mr. Flynn: Did you ever know that the men were crossing by this way? Witness: No. Mr. Flynn: Did you ever see them cross? Witness: No. Mr. Flynn: Did it ever come to you knowledge that they had crossed by this way? Witness: Yes. Questioned further, witness said that he happened to be down one day when a certain party crossed it. Mr. Flynn: Why did you not board it up when you knew that a certain party had crossed it? Witness: Simply because I had if for my own use for putting the boards in. It would have taken some considerable time to have boarded it up if they had had to board it up every time he went down. He could have completed the job in the time it would have taken them. The Deputy Coroner, in reviewing the evidence, said there was no legal duty on the mine manager to fence it any more than he had done. Mr. Leck said he considered a gate the best form of fence at an "eye," but if a gate had been on in this particular case, with the knowledge which the deceased possessed he would just have opened the gate and gone in the same way. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed," and added the following rider: We consider that great carelessness was exercised in giving the necessary message from one shift to another, that the boards had been removed, and that if it had been known that the men were using this road, the way to it should have been fastened up as soon as the boards were removed. They also think there should have been a stationary light at the eye, and a bell wire on either side of the compartment. The hearing occupied over two hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||