Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th July 1906, Page: 5, Column: 5

Caradoc Vale Disaster

Two Men Found Alive

Over Five Days Entombed

A Miraculous Escape

Two men were recovered alive from the inundated drift at the Caradoc Colliery, near Tonyrefail, late on Sunday, and were assisted out of the level amid a scene of indescribable excitement. The rescued men are :—

David John Stephens (32), Gilfach Goch, single.

Richard Richards, Gilfach Goch, single.

It will be recalled that six men were entombed in the colliery slant on Tuesday afternoon, when the drift was flooded by an inrush of water from some workings unused for 18 years. In addition to the two men found alive the following four were also missed :— Thomas Edwards (23), Llewellyn-terrace, Gilfach Goch, single ; Ed. Hathaway (25), Evanstown, Gilfach Goch, single ; John Morris (45), Tonyrefaii, married, four children ; Edward Manley (40), Waunrhyd road, Tonyrefail, married, two children. Rescue work was at once commenced, and on Friday three bodies were recovered, viz., those of Edward Manley, Thomas Edwards, and John Morris. Edward Hathaway, who bravely risked his life by returning to the drift to save his comrades, is now the only man unrecovered, and at the time of writing strong hopes are cherished in the district that even he may be rescued alive, for it is reported that the two colliers brought out alive state that he was with them in the old workings for some time.

It appears that the rescue parties, failing to discover the remainder of the men, either alive or dead, in the drift, extended their exploration work to the old workings, being led by a man who had been engaged in that portion of the pit 20 years ago. The sensational result was received with the wildest exultations of delight by the residents, thousands of whom had gathered round the mouth of the level. Both men, it appears, fleeing from the overwhelming water, found a safe place of waiting in the older portion of the drift, and here, with mingled hope and fear, they waited, praying that succour might reach them ere it was too late.

Stephens when found was in a fairly strong condition, being able to walk unassisted from the mine. Richards, however, was in a weak condition and had to be carried from his living tomb to an improvised hospital at the pit mouth.

The scene of the flooding disaster at the Little Caradoc Level, near Gilfach Goch, was on Sunday visited by crowds of people from the Rhondda, Ogmore, and Garw Valleys, who sat all day round the mouth of the heading awaiting the result of the pumping operations. Mr. W. W. Hood, of Llwynypia, and Mr. Gomer Evans, manager of the Glamorgan Colliery, Gilfach Goch, who had been almost continuously on the scene, rendering every assistance in their power, again visited the colliery and took an active part in the work. Mr. Jacob Kingdom, the manager of the flooded level, was also down in the workings engaged in the operations. Mr. Hood remained until the afternoon, when he returned to Llwynypia and took a short and much needed rest after his exertions, and Mr. Evans subsequently kept him in touch by means of the telephone with the progress of the clearing of the colliery. In the course of the afternoon the water in the new main drift was pumped out, and the whole of the deep was explored, but no bodies were found anywhere. When this became known to those waiting on the surface it caused something in the nature of a sensation, especially when it was heard that the explorers were going to examine the old workings for any signs of the missing men.

The two rescued men, Stephens and Richards, were quickly brought to the surface and placed in the colliery office pending the arrival of medical aid. Dr. McCochie, assistant to Dr. Morgan, of Gilfach Goch, and Dr. Munroe, Tonyrefail, were quickly on the scene. Richards was very much exhausted, but Stephens was in fairly good condition, and wanted to be allowed to walk home, but this of course the doctors would not allow. An ambulance was procured and the men were taken to their homes at Gilfach Goch.

Interview with Stephens.

Our correspondent had a few words with Stephens after he had been made comfortable in his room.

Asked how he had managed to escape the water, Stephens said :—

"We were working 12 yards on the other side from where the water broke in. We heard a cry of 'Water,' and rushed down the 12 yards only to find that the water barred our passage out. We waited for a while until the water subsided somewhat, and then we got through the hole which the water had made into the old workings, and there we have been ever since."

"Hathaway was with us until two shifts ago, or perhaps two nights ago ; I can't remember the time exactly. Probably he is wandering about the old workings now. We missed one another occasionally, but always managed to meet again — except when, two shifts ago, we missed Hathaway."

Stephens at this point closed his eyes wearily, and our reporter refrained from asking any further questions.

Unheard Tappings.

Another curious point is that search parties had previously penetrated into these old workings, and Stephens states that on Wednesday night he heard the explorers tapping, and that he and his companions tapped back, but unfortunately they did not tap loud enough to be heard.

Hathaway's Body Found.

The dead body of Edward Hathaway was found about 3 o'clock on Monday afternoon lying face downwards in the sump of the old workings. To explore the sump the parties had driven through about seven yards of coal in order to drain off the "sludge," which was at least waist deep. This exposed the body, which was lying right down in the sump, to view, and it was first seen by John Parry, who drew his comrades' attention to it. The body was clothed only in a coat and shirt. It was lifted tenderly out of the "sludge," placed upon a stretcher, and hidden under brattice cloth, borne to the top of the drift on the shoulders of six old comrades. Later on in the day the corpse, accompanied by an immense crowd of sorrowful men and weeping women, was carried to the neat little cottage where the aged father and mother awaited their boy, plunged in grief, the news of the tragic discovery having been broken to them. Had young Hathaway only turned slightly to the left instead of going straight on and stumbling into the sump, he would probably have found his way out through the hole which the water-burst had made in his stall. A faint gleam of light, such as a match could afford, would probably have saved his life.

The Old Workings.

During the day there were various speculations as to what had become of Hathaway. These old workings are stated to date back to the time of Caradog, the famous Welsh choir conductor, who is stated to have opened them, and no one seems to know exactly how far they may extend. Some think that they extend some distance through the mountain towards the South Rhondda Colliery at Pencoed, and that there is probably some small means of connection between the working which has now been explored, and those which date back farther than the memory of most of the local inhabitants. If this be so, it was thought that Hathaway, in a delirious state, had squeezed through, and was wandering underground.

Then there is an old drift leading out of the old workings and now used as a watercourse to carry off the overflow of the water-logged portion of the mine. It was said that there is room in this watercourse for a man to crawl out into a field a couple of hundred yards from the colliery, and it was suggested that perhaps one night, unnoticed by the explorers, Hathaway might have crawled out through this watercourse, and wandered over the mountains in a delirious state, not knowing what he was about. Another fear was that he was not alive, but buried in the "sludge" somewhere in the dips or jumps in the old working, and that when these could be properly searched with grappling irons his dead body would be found.

Statement by Mr. F. Gray.

Mr. Gray, chief inspector of mines, accompanied by his assistant. Mr. Trump, went down the colliery on Monday and on returning to the surface he supplied our reporter with the following official report :—

When the deep was pumped dry and the bodies not discovered the next step was to explore the old workings to the rise. This was done about half-past 10 o'clock on Sunday night, and two men were discovered alive in a spot that had been explored before, so that they must have travelled about the workings ; in fact, they must have been within 40 yards of where I was on Friday. Of course we were not looking for them then, because we thought that their bodies had gone down the deep. They were in fairly good condition, and Stephens insisted upon walking out. The other man, Richards, was delirious, and had to be carried. Stephens could give a clear account of what happened. He distinctly says that he left Hathaway alive about 24 hours ago. Before Hathaway left him he said he was going to swim home, so that Hathaway must have been delirious. All the old workings had been explored, and we are now making a second visit to each place. I think I must say a word in praise of the conduct of the men who have helped in the exploration. They have worked remarkably well under very difficult circumstances, generally waist-deep in water and mud, and they have never flinched in anything. The search will be continued until Hathaway has been recovered, dead or alive.

Federationists and the Search.

Mr. Tom Lucas, secretary of the Ogmore District of the Miners' Federation, was largely instrumental in organising the systematic search which led to the finding of Stephens and Richards. The Federationists discussed the question on Sunday evening, with the result that representations were made to those who had taken charge of the rescue operations. A ready agreement by all concerned was made to a suggestion that Mr. Lucas should ask for volunteers to form parties to carry out a systematic and comprehensive exploration of the old workings district by district. Scarcely an hour had passed after the adoption of these methods when Stephens and Richards were recovered alive.

Funerals of Three Victims.

Amidst widespread signs of public sympathy and respect the bodies of three of the victims were buried at Tonyrefail on Monday. They were Thomas Edwards, single, Gilfach Goch ; John Morris, married, Tonyrefail and Edward Manley, married, Tonyrefail. The two first named were buried at Tonyrefail Churchyard, and the last at the Methodist chapel burying ground. An immense number of mourners attended the funerals, most of the men in the local collieries having ceased work to do so. The funeral procession of Thomas Edwards was an exceptionally large one, and the flower-laden coffin was borne to Tonyrefail from Gilfach by road on the shoulders of young miners. At Edwards's funeral the Rev. B. Salmon officiated.

A Mother's Pathetic Wait.

When the news of the finding of Richards and Stephens was brought to Gilfach, it was conveyed to Mrs Hathaway, the aged mother of the missing lad, and hopes were held out to her that her son would soon be brought home. "Thank God," she exclaimed at the joyful news, "to think that I shall have my boy back after all." She at once commenced to make preparations to receive him. But as the minutes lengthened into hours the old lady gradually, began to lose hope, and her grief was pitiful to witness, as she stood on the doorstep of her neat little cottage making tearful inquiries of everyone coming up from the colliery. The aged father of Hathaway and his three brothers hurried down to the colliery with a dry suit of clothes for him, and they waited, hoping against hope, that he would be found alive.

Hathaway's mother contradicts a statement that her son's wedding day had been fixed for Monday.

A Graphic Narrative.

Lost in the Mine.

David John Stephens is progressing as favourably as can be expected after his terrible privation, but as the doctor wishes him to rest and recuperate very few questions were allowed to be put to him. From what he has said, however, in a scrappy conversation with our reporter and his near relatives, we are enabled to piece together the following connected narrative of the terrible experiences through which he and his two companions went while they were entombed :—

When the outburst of water came, Stephens and Richard Richards were in a stall 12 yards further in the heading on the rise side than the stall into which the water burst. When they heard the shout of "water!" they ran down the heading towards the deep, and in the road near the stall of Hathaway and Cox, where the water was deep, they saw Hathaway standing by a tram, which he had been filling when the torrent roared out. There they stood and watched the raging waters rushing down to the main deep. After the rush was over they tried to get down the heading towards the main deep so as to get out, but the depth of the water was so great that they could not manage it. Then they sat down higher up in the heading and waited for several minutes. At last Stephens, who evidently kept wonderfully cool, said to his companions.

"Where the water has come from it is safe for us to go now," so they made their way to the stall into which the water had broken, and with their lights, which they had fortunately retained unextinguished, they saw a gaping hole in the face through which the overwhelming water had come Stephens said they had better go through into the old workings as they might be able to make their way out some way through the old drift, now used as a watercourse to carry away the overflow of the water-logged portion of the old mine. The hole was not more than 3ft. high and about the same in width, and the entombed men crawled through. As they did so a most serious misfortune befel them. They had not proceeded far when their candles were extinguished by foul air, and a box of matches which Hathaway was carrying fell into the wet sludge and became so damp that they would not strike, although the men did their best to dry them by wiping them in their hair.

The three men endeavoured to make their way back to the rise heading from which they had come to get some matches which they believed to be in the pocket of Richards, and also his box of food which they had left behind, but try as they would they could not find their way back through the hole connecting the two portions of the workings, and at last the heart-freezing fact forced itself upon them that they were lost in the workings of the mine with no knowledge of their bearings. They wandered about until they were tired out, and at last they sat down to rest and to think out the situation.

They soon lost all record of time in the darkness, and to add to the awfulness of the situation Richard Richards began to get delirious. "Come on, boys," he said, "let's get to work and get some more coal. It's no use sitting here idle." Hathaway also began to wander somewhat in his speech. Stephens maintained a clear head and aroused his companions, and they sought a way out of their living tomb. They came across two old trams full of rubbish, and they struck off from these as a centre. They repeatedly tried to find some means of egress out to the light of day, but they seemed to walk in a circle, for time after time they came back to these trams, and at last they lay down beside them and slept a terrible sleep, in which Richards now and then broke out into delirious babble. Again the efforts to find away out were renewed, but again they failed, for each time they found their way back to the trams. Several nights — as far as they could decide what was night in their pitchy darkness — they returned to these trams to sleep, and each time they lay down to rest they took off boots and stockings, and ringing the latter, which were soaked through by the puddles of water in the roadway, they slung them on the trams to dry by what they took to be morning.

About 24 hours before the rescue, according to the calculations of Stephens, the three laid down together to sleep again, completely worn out and despairing. When Stephens woke he found to his horror that both his companions had disappeared. Hathaway had left several articles of clothing behind, so that he must have gone almost naked. Stephens went in search of them, and e'er long he found Richards. The poor fellow was very delirious. He was putting on his singlet, which he had evidently taken off. He was quite oblivious of the situation in which he was, and was under the delusion that he had been home to his brothers, and he had washed, and was now putting on a flannel shirt. Stephens roused his comrade again, and they set off to look for Hathaway, but failed to find him, and they did not see him again.

At last Stephens and Richards were found by the exploring party. Richards, when found, was still light-headed, and as the dark forms of the rescuers came trooping along the heading he crouched in terror behind Stephens, who still, however, retained his wonderful nerve and spirits, although terribly exhausted, for he and his companions had had nothing to eat beyond what they had been driven to nibble from their wet candles.

Stephens is a man of fine physique and iron constitution, and the way in which he kept up his courage and put heart into his comrades will rank among the best stories of heroism even in the annals of Welsh colliery disasters. His widowed mother is nearly beside herself with joy for his miraculous escape, and so, too, are the relatives of Richards.

Plans Of The Old Workings.

Home Secretary Interrogated.

Mr. W. Brace, in the House of Commons on Monday, on behalf of Colonel Herbert, asked the Home Secretary, with reference to the recent disaster at the Caradoc Mine, Gilfach Goch, whether, as required by the Mines Act, a plan of the disused workings of that mine was deposited at the Home Office when working was temporarily suspended ; what guarantee the Home Office had of the accuracy of such plans and whether, having regard to the danger of flooding in collieries that had been partially disused, he would direct that special inquiry be made with reference to the working plans of the colliery in question.

Mr. Gladstone said a plan was deposited at the Home Office of the workings in the Ty Du seam at this colliery, which were abandoned in September, 1904. The accuracy of the plan was certified by a surveyor approved by the inspector in the district, as required by the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1896. Inquiry was being made by the inspector as to the accuracy of the working plans of this colliery.

Opening Of The Inquest

At Tonyrefail Institute on Saturday the Coroner (Mr. E. B. Reece) opened an inquiry into the death of two of the victims of the Caradoc Vale Colliery level disaster. Mr. T. Thompson (Messrs Ingledew, Cardiff) appeared for the company, and Mr. A. T James (Messrs Walter Morgan, Bruce, and Nicholas, Pontypridd) represented the Miners' Federation.

Before the inquiry was formally opened the foreman (Councillor William Evans, Tonyrefail) explained that considerable dissatisfaction prevailed at Gilfach Goch because all the jury had been empanelled from Tonyrefail, though the majority of the men who had lost their lives had been resident at Gilfach Goch.

The Coroner remarked that he only proposed to conduct the inquiry on the Tonyrefail men. He did not propose to hold a separate inquest, but the verdict given with regard to the Tonyrefail men would be applicable to the Gilfach Goch men, inasmuch as they had all met their deaths under precisely the same circumstances, and the evidence would be the same in both cases. This was the course he had always pursued in cases of this kind where a number of men had been killed by the same accident.

The body of Edward Manley was identified by George Davies, contractor, Tonyrefail, who said that deceased was his brother-in-law and 30 years of age. He left a widow and four children.

The body of John Morris was identified by his father-in-law, William Evans, of Tonyrefail, who said that deceased was a collier, 47 years of age and left a widow and four children.

Evidence of identification of Thos. Edwards, Gilfach Goch, for the purpose of granting a burial certificate, was given by the father, who said that his son was a single man, 22 years of age, and resided with witness.

Mr. Thompson, on behalf of the colliery company, expressed deep regret for the accident, and sympathy with the bereaved.

After a few words of condolence from the Coroner, the inquiry was adjourned until July 10th.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brace, W.      
Bruce, —    Solicitor  
Cox, —    Miner  
Davies, George    Contractor  
Edwards, Thomas   23 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Evans, Gomer    Colliery Manager  
Evans, William      
Evans, William, Councillor    Jury Foreman  
Gladstone, —    Home Secretary  
Gray, Frederick Augustus    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hathaway, Edward   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hathaway, Mrs      
Herbert, —, Colonel      
Hood, W. W.      
Ingledew, —    Solicitor  
James, A. T    Solicitor  
Kingdom, Jacob    Colliery Manager  
Lucas, Tom    Secretary, Miners Federation  
Manley, Edward   40 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
McCochie, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Morgan, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Morgan, Walter    Solicitor  
Morris, John   45 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Munroe, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Nicholas, —    Solicitor  
Parry, John    Miner  
Reece, E. Bernard    Coroner  
Richards, Richard    Miner  Rescued, Individual Page
Salmon, B., Rev.    Vicar  
Stephens, David John   32 Miner  Rescued, Individual Page
Thompson, T.    Solicitor  
Trump, Frederick Joseph    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
07 Jul 1906  Caradoc Vale Disaster, Two Men Found Alive, Over Five Days Entombed (The Cardiff Times)

Links to related pages

 

Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Mar 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print