|
28th June 1906 Fraud In A Whitehaven PitAt the Cumberland Quarter Sessions, on Tuesday Alexander Murphy (40), collier; Wm. Devlin (22), collier, and Thomas Duggan (24), collier, were indicted for attempting to defraud the Whitehaven Colliery Company of two sums of 1s 4½d and 1s 6¾d by placing tokens on certain tubs which they had not wrought for or filled, on the 27th March. Devlin and Duggan appeared in the uniform of the Cumberland militia. All the prisoners pleaded not guilty. Prisoners applied for legal aid; and after consideration, the deputy chairman said he did not think having regard to the nature of the defence set out, it was a case for legal aid. Robert Blair, Whitehaven, surveyor to Messrs. Bain, the proprietors of William Pit, produced a plan of the pit. Prisoners' company was No. 86. No. 85 company was the company which worked previously to them. The coal hewn by 85 would be taken to one of the sidings. In the ordinary course of working tubs filled by No. 86 would be behind tubs filled by No. 85. John Joseph McDonald, brakeman employed on the 27th March in the main brake of No. 6 north section, said he left work at one o'clock that day. The last tub he drew up that day had the words on the side in chalk, "rope. Me," which meant that he had to look in the tub for some rope. The tub was produced in Court, and a witness explained how the token was fixed to it. James Rothery, coal hewer, said when he went down the pit with his company he was given token No. 80. The first tub they filled that day had the words "rope. Me," on the sides. It was taken down by Thompson Dixon. Casson put on the token. On leaving the pit that day he noticed some tubs in the siding, which was irregular and he also saw the coal in one of their tubs had been disturbed and a passage made through the coal to the staple on which the token was fastened. Cross-examination by prisoners, witness said he did not see them charge the token. All he saw was that the token had been changed. John Rothery, under-manager at the pit, deposed that prior to March 27th there had been uneasiness amongst the employees owing to tokens on tubs having been changed. To make inquiries he reduced companies working in the section to two. Only brake men would be in the section in addition to the companies, one of which was prisoner's and the other Casson's. He received a report on March 28th, in consequence of which he had five tubs placed in the siding next to the one marked "rope. Me." Prisoner and the rest of the shift were all present. He said "This is Casson's tub and these men (meaning prisoners) have "stuck it." The word "stuck" meant that the token had been changed. Prisoners made no reply to that, but a man named Roney, who was standing by, asked if prisoners were going down the pit. Witness said "Certainly they are not." Roney then said it was a good job, because if the prisoners had gone down the rest would not have done so. There were three men in each company, and the result of the changing of tokens was that each of the three men would share equally in the profit made. Cross-examined by Murphy: Witness cold not swear that he changed the token. At this stage Mr. Cavanagh said he had been instructed to defend prisoners. Isaac Rothery, overman at the colliery, said that on the evening of the 27th March, when on his way to the engine plane, he met the three prisoners. Witness was riding in a train of tubs with Michael Burney. One of the prisoners came to the tub side and said to Burney "You will find your shovel at the bottom of the brake, Mick." Shovels ought not to be at that place, they should be in the working. Witness had heard complaints before from this part of the working. The remark made to Burney made witness suspicious, and he hurried up the place where the shovel was. On his way he saw a tub with No. 86 token on it. Further on he found a number of tubs, one of which had the token 86 and the words "rope. Me." There were also tubs bearing the tokens 80 and 85 and tubs marked "touped," No. 86 should not have been in front of the other numbers. He concluded when he saw 86 in front, that the tub of coal had either been "struck" or "sliped," which meant taken from the pillars which support the roof. This was irregular. Witness marked five of the tubs with the words "side off at pit top" and appended his initials. On the following day John Rothery remarked in front of all the men that one of the tubs belonged to Casson's company, and these men had "struck" it. Prisoners did not deny this at the time, but later Murphy came to witness and said he knew nothing about "sticking" the tub, but would admit filling the tub on the burr (the first tub on the engine plane). Witness said if he knew anything about the matter he ought to say. Murphy then turned to Devlin and said, "Thoo knows thoo struck five tubs last week, and thoo can't deny it." Devlin said nothing, but Duggan said " — the soul, thoo's no man for telling." Prisoners then went away quarrelling. On the following day witness met Murphy near the Bransty Arch, and he offered to tell witness all about it. Witness said he had better tell Mr. James, the manager, all about it, as there might be a police court case of it. No other men but prisoners would be supplied with No. 86 tokens. The only man who would gain would be the one who put the tokens on. By Mr. Cavanagh: The men took as many tokens as they wanted. The tokens were hung in numerical order, and anyone who passed the place where they hung could take them. He could not say why proceedings were not taken until May. He had been employed by the Company for 26 years. He did not know how long prisoners had been working the pit. Thomas Casson also gave evidence as to the filling of the tub marked "rope Me." Thompson Dixon said he was the brakesman who succeeded McDonald on the day in question, and went on duty at one o'clock, at the same time as Casson's and Murphy's companies. In the evening one of the prisoners asked witness to get a shovel and pick. Witness asked why, and was told they were going to fill some loose coal at the bottom. Thomas Kermain, another brakesman, deposed to getting a pick and shovel from Murphy at the request of the other prisoners. He gave the pick and shovel to the last witness, who put them on the set to go to the siding. He saw two of the prisoners filling tubs. James Patterson, watchman at William Pit, deposed that he accompanied the inspector who served the prisoners with the summonses. Duggan said if it had been anybody else's tub but Rothery's there would have been no bother about it. Devlin said " — Murphy's led us into this bother; it was him that 'stuck' the tub, and we knew nothing about it." Cross-examined: A man might make about 5s a shift on an average. Samuel Turner, the manager of the William Pit, deposed that one of the tubs when filled would hold about 11½cwt. of coal. The value of 11½cwt. was 1s 4¼d. The average wage for the last quarter was 7s 2d a shift. At that rate one of the prisoners would make about 35s a week. This was the evidence for the prosecution. Mr. Cavanagh, for the defence, said the case was started with a lack of information, and commented on the case being delayed until May, when all the information was before the officials earlier. It was inconceivable that men would destroy their characters for 1s 4½d when they were earning 35s a week. The jury found prisoners guilty and recommended them to mercy. Mr. Sharpe said there was another indictment of partially filling tubs. If a tub was marked "touped," which meant that it had met with an accident, the men would be allowed full. He would not, however, proceed with the charge. Mr. Cavanagh said prisoners had borne good characters. Two of them had worn H.M. uniform for five years, and he thought justice might be tempered with mercy. The Deputy Chairman said Devlin and Duggan had forfeited their characters; they could make no difference between the prisoners. It was a mean contemptible thing to defraud fellow workmen, and the Bench must pass a sentence which would act as a deterrent. Prisoners must go to gaol for three months with hard labour. Murphy left the dock smiling.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||