|
17th May 1906 Serious Charge Against ColliersAlleged Tub StickingThe Court for the greater part of the day was occupied in hearing charges preferred by Mr. H. M. James, general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, against three colliers named Alexander Murphy, 40, Whitehaven, and William Devlin, 22, and Thomas Duggan, 24, both of Asby. The first charge was that of conspiring together by a certain false pretence, namely by placing a token upon a certain tub of coal for which they had no right and filled in William Pit to fraudulently obtain from the Whitehaven Colliery Company the sum of 1s 4½d on the 27th of March 1906. The second charge was conspiring together by a certain false pretence, namely by marking the word "toup" on three tubs of coal in William Pit fraudulently to obtain from the Whitehaven Colliery Company the sum of 1s 11½ d at Whitehaven on the 27th March, 1906. The third charge was being employed in a coal mine at Whitehaven known as William pit did contravene one of the Special Rules in force in the said mine by sliping certain coal where they were not authorised to do so on the 27th March 1906. Mr. W. H. Chapman prosecuted for the Company. Defendants were not legally represented. Mr. Chapman, in stating the case for the prosecution, said he thought none of the charges was such as could be dealt with by the Bench summarily. For some time past there had been complaints which developed into suspicion, and led the officials in the part of the Pit in question to go in for a certain course of action in the hope of detecting the offenders of the offences which were suspected of being committed. The section of the Pit in question was known as No. 6 North Left Hand Section. In this there were five working places and in the hope of detecting what they had reason to believe was going on the officials stopped three of the workings leaving only two, which were nearly side by side. The workings were worked by companies, each of three men and before going down the shaft each party were given a token or working number. The token was something like a button, which was suspended to a string and fastened to a staple inside of the tub, so that the checkweighman could see to which company the particular load of coal belonged. On this particular shift the two companies commenced worked at one o'clock p.m., and the fixed tub sent out by the prosecutors was specially marked in chalk "Rope Mc" and which beyond all doubt was the tub in respect of which the first offence with which defendants were charged was committed. The mark was an indication to the engineman has there was a piece of rope in the tub which he had to take out. This tub was afterwards found with defendants token in. As to the second charge he should call evidence to prove that defendants were seen before their shift was finished at the engine plane cutting off pillars, or what was called "sliping" and filling tubs with this coal. Mr. Chapman here had a tub of the kind used in the Colliery produced in Court, and explained how the token was fixed, pointing out it was impossible for the tubs to be in the position it was on the road to belong to the defendants, quite apart from the special marking with chalk as to the charge of "sliping." He explained that tubs some times were spilled in transit from the working place to the shaft, and it was the case in such instances for the officials to mark such tubs "touped" with that date, month and the year and the individual initials. The tubs in question were clearly marked "touped," and bore the defendants token. A more miserable and despicable thing than for one, set of pals to rob another in such a manner was, he thought, impossible for anyone to imagine. Robert Blair, Surveyor to the Whitehaven Colliery Company produced plans of No, 6 North District of the pit. Witness explained the system of working. In the natural course of the running of the tubs No. 86 would come after No. 85 at the sidings. It could not be otherwise, because the road was a single road. James Rothery, hewer, Parton, said on March 27th he was working with John Martin and Thomas Casson in No. 6 North Left Hand Section. They went to work at one o'clock. Their token No. 80. Witness got the tokens, about a dozen, from the pit top. He examined them to see if they were all No. 80 and he found they were. It was the practice to examine them carefully, because in a mistake they would lose a tub. The first tub they filled that day had "Rope Me" written on it. This was the first tub sent down the "Dilly." Going home that day they stopped at the siding where the tubs were standing before coming to the engine plane. Among the tubs he recognised the tub marked "Rope Me" which was the second tub from the front. The foremost tub of all was about fourteen yards away. He examined the token on the tub marked "Rope Me" and found it to be No. 86. He noticed that the coal had been disturbed and a passage made down into the token staple. The Chairman: What made you examine the tubs. Witness said they had been losing tubs. Duggan: There was never any bother until we lost tubs? (Laughter). John Rothery, under manager, said he had had several complaints from men about, losing tubs, and in consequence he decided to reduce the number of working places in the North District to two. He stopped all the workings but two a fortnight before the 27th March. These were those of James Rothery, John Martin, and Thomas Casson, and the accused. In consequence of a report on March 28th he had five tubs "sided" at the top of the pit. One was "Rope Me" and a token, No. 86, on it. On the 28th ult. one p.m., he was at the pit top when defendants and other men were going down. Witness was standing close to the tub marked "Rope Me" and the defendants were standing by. A number of hewers were also close to. Witness said to the whole shift, "This is Martin and Casson's tub and those men (meaning defendants) "stuck" it. "Stuck" was a common term for changing a token. Defendants didn't reply. A hewer named John Roney stepped up to where witness and defendants were standing and said, "Is these men going down," referring to the defendants. Witness said, "No, indeed, they aren't." Roney said. "No; I think not. If they gah doon we shouldn't gah," or words to that effect. Casson's party token number was 80, and defendants 86. If the preceding shift on that day had left any tubs numbered 85 standing on the siding no tubs numbered 86 could have been found in front, of them in the ordinary course of working. Isaac Rothery, overman, said on March 27th about nine p.m., he was on the main road when he heard Duggan come to a tub side and say to Michael Burney. "Thoo'l find our shovel at the bottom of the brake." Witness thought there was something wrong, and he then hurried to the siding where he found a tub with a 86 token on it. That was full of coal and rubbish. He went fifteen yards further in and found a number of tubs the first of which had a 86 token on it and was marked "Rope Me" The next in order were numbers 80, 85, 80, 80, 85, 80, 80, 85, 86, 86, and 86. The last three were half filled and marked "touped" with the date. Further up the siding were two more numbered 80 and two more 85, two 86's, and two 80's. The defendants' token number for that shift was 86 and the number of the working immediately before their's was 85. There was nothing conceivable except foul play why the 85 tubs should be behind 86's. He had the five tubs marked "side at the pit top." Witness was at the pit top when John Rothery spoke to the men about the tubs. Three or four minutes after Murphy came to witness, who was standing by the other defendants, and said, "I'll admit filling that tub on the Bur [that was the first tub of all on the siding adjoining the engine plane] but I know nothing about the other tub. The latter was the one that was "stuck." Witness said to him, "If thoo is innocent and know's who's done it say so and clear yourself. "Murphy turned round and pointed to Devlin and said, "He stuck five tubs last week and he can't. deny it." (Laughter). Mr. Chapman: An expert apparently. (Laughter). Witness: Devlin never spoke. Defendant said to Duggan, "D — — — thee soul thoo's no man for telling." The three defendants went away quarrelling and arguing. On the following Saturday he met Murphy near Bransty Arch. Murphy said, "I'll tell thee all about it, Isaac. Witness stopped him and told him he had better tell Mr. Turner, the manager. He said to Murphy, "It will likely be a Court Case," and Murphy said if it was a Court case he would clear himself. By Duggan: Five companies of men could be put in the Section of the pit in question. The Chairman: Could any other men have tampered with them? Witness: No, sir; there was no one else in that section. Mr. McGowan: Could any one of the three do that without the knowledge of the others? Witness: Well, if he came down by himself he could. You hear from the evidence two came down. Mr. Chapman: I shall show they were together on the spot, doing an illegal action. Joseph McDonald, Brakesman, said he let the tubs down the siding to the engine plane. On March 27th he went off duty as defendants came in. The last tub he hauled up to the flat sheets that day was marked "Rope Me." Thomas Casson, Union Terrace, Whitehaven, said he worked with Martin and Rothery. The first tub they filled that day had "Rope Me" chalked on it. Witness put the token No. 80 on this tub. As they went by the siding that day they noticed three tubs had been slipped and in consequence they examined the rest. "Slipped" meant taken off the face. They found the tub marked "Rope Me" with a No. 86 token on it. He saw that the coals in the corner of the tub had been disturbed. It was not possible that anyone but the defendants could change the token and no one else could benefit by it. Samuel Turner, manager of William Pit, said the tub produced was an exact duplicate of the tub marked "Rope Me." If defendants had stuck the tub the money would be divided equally amongst them. Whatever was made by a company of hewers in a working was divided equally. By the Chairman: It might be possible for one of the men to tamper with a token without the knowledge of the others, but the other men would get their share of the money. Thompson Dixon, of 6, Belle Lane, Whitehaven, said he was a brakesman at William Pit. He succeeded John Joseph McDonald at the brake on March 27th. When he came on duty at one o'clock on the latter date there were two tubs standing, one of which had "Rope Me" chalked on it. He rang the bell to send the tubs into Casson and Martin's working. When he started working there were some tubs left on Duggan's company's siding from the previous shift. About half-an-hour after the tub marked "Rope Me" had been sent into Casson's working, he saw it come back again and he sent it to the siding. About 7 p.m., that night he saw Duggan and Devlin coming out of their working by the brake to go towards the siding. They asked witness to go for a pick and shovel and he replied "Wait till I get time." The shift was not then finished. They then went towards the siding. Witness stopped at the brake till the end of the shift. At half-past eight the shift was over and witness went towards the siding on his way home. Duggan and Devlin did not come back to their working place. They must have passed witness to return to the working. When he got to the siding near the engine plane there were some tubs standing. One of the tubs was standing about fifteen yards in front of the other tubs and the whole of the defendants were there. Murphy followed Devlin and Duggan past the brake ten minutes. Murphy did not speak to witness as he passed. Devlin and Duggan said they were going to use the shovel to fill some loose coal at the bottom. They told him this in answer to witness's question. He could not say which of the two Duggan or Devlin told him this. He saw Duggan lift some bits of coal and put them on the tub. The other two defendants were standing beside him. He got the coal from beside the pillar corner just beside the Bur. By Murphy: It was ten minutes past seven when Murphy passed his at the brake. By Devlin: He didn't assist him and Duggan to fill the three tubs. Devlin: If we didn't come back we went home without our clothes then? (Laughter). Witness: You had your clothes with you when you went past. (Laughter). John Kermean, 3, James Pit, Assistant Brakesman, said Devlin and Duggan sent him to Murphy to get a pick and shovel and to tell Murphy to come Down. He would nip to the working and said to Murphy "Duggan has sent me for a pick and shovel and you have to come down." Murphy gave him the pick and shovel and witness carried them to the witness Dixon, who put them on to the sett which went, down to the siding. Five minutes later witness followed the sett into the siding where he saw Duggan and Devlin lift an empty tub on to the road and start filling it from between the roads. It was just dirt and coal they were filling. They half filled one tub and wrote "touped" on it. (Laughter.) He saw them half fill two more and write "touped" on them. Then Murphy came and they sent him to fill one on the Bur. James Patterson, Strand Street, Whitehaven, said he was a watchman at William Pit. He accompanied P.C. Sessford in serving the summonses on Duggan and Devlin at Asby. They went to Duggan's house first at China Terrace. Duggan said "If it had been anybody else's tub but Rothery's there would have been no bother about it." A female from the back of the Court: It wasn't him that said that; it was me. (Laughter). Duggan denied using the words. Witness, continuing, said Devlin "It's that — — — — Murphy that's led us into this bother. It was him that stuck the tub and we knew nothing about it." This was the evidence for the prosecution in the first case. Murphy said he "was innocent of the crime but guilty of filling the tub." Devlin said, "I don't know anything of the tub; I innocent of it." Duggan said, "I admit sliping the tubs but I don't know anything of the tub that was stuck." The defendants were then committed to take their trial at the next Quarter Sessions. The Clerk (Mr. L. T. Helder) said the Bench thought defendants were entitled to bail. Mr. Chapman said he had no objection if the amount was made substantial. It was an offence that was regarded by a large section of the population as very serious. Two of the defendants had already left the town The Bench granted bail of £10 each, and one security of £10 each. The second charge was then proceeded with. Isaac Rothery, overman, said when tubs were spilled or partly spilled in transit from the working places to the pit top the officials had power to chalk on it the word "touped" with the date and the official's, initials, and the men were credited with it as a full tub. On March 27th about 7 p.m., he met the prisoners coming out of the working. He heard Duggan say to a man named Michael Burney, who was going into his working place, "You will find our shovel at the bottom of the brake. Mind and take it in with you." A hewer could not have a lawful purpose for a shovel at the bottom of the brake. In consequence of this he made an examination of the tubs standing on the siding and found three tubs standing together. They were about half filled with rubbish and each had "touped" "27, 3, '06." written on it in chalk, but no official's initials. Each tub had a token No. 86 attached. Witness wrote on each tub, "side off at the pit top" and put his initials on. Thompson Dixon, brakesman, and John Kermean, assistant brakesman, repeated the evidence they gave in the first case. Murphy saw Duggan write "touped" on the third tub. Samuel Turner, manager of the pit, gave evidence as to the benefit prisoners would have derived from payment by the Company for the tubs. This closed the evidence for the prosecution, and the prisoners who had nothing to say, were also committed for trial on the charge. The Chairman informed the prisoners that if they could find bail in the previous case, they would only insist upon their entering into their own recognisance's of £10 each in this case. In reply to the Clerk, Mr. Chapman said with the permission of the Bench, the third charge would be withdrawn. The Bench agreed to this course, and the Court rose at 4-25.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||