Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th May 1906

Serious Charge Against Colliers

Committed For Trial On Two Charges

At the Whitehaven Police-court, on Monday, a rather peculiar case, of interest to miners, occupied a considerable time, the magistrates being H. Fox (in the chair), G. C. Bennett (Mayor), W. McGowan, J. A. Jackson, and R. Jefferson, Esq.

There were a good many colliers present in the body of the court.

The defendants were Alexander Murphy (40), collier, Whitehaven; Wm. Devlin (22), and Thomas Duggan (24), colliers, Asby.

Firstly, the defendants were charged with conspiring together by a certain false pretence, namely, by placing a token upon a certain tub of coal for which they had no right, and filled in William Pit, to fraudulently obtain from the Whitehaven Colliery Co., the sum of 1s 4½ d on the 27th March.

Secondly, they were charged with conspiring together by certain false pretences, namely, by marking the word "toup" on three tubs of coal in William Pit, fraudulently to obtain from the Whitehaven Colliery Co., the sum of 1s 11½ d on March 27th.

The last charge was being employed in a coal mine at Whitehaven, known as William Pit, did contravene one of the special rules in force in the said mine by slipping certain coal when they were not authorised to do so, on the 27th March.

Mr. W. H. Chapman prosecuted.

Mr. Chapman gave a detailed account of the charges and evidence. He would first of all take the first charge, which he (Mr. Chapman) did not think that they would be able to deal with summarily. For some time past there had been complaints about tubs being missing, and these complaints had developed into suspicion, which led them into a certain part of the pit to go in for a certain course of action, in the hope of detecting the culprit. There were five working places at the place where the complaints were made, and the officials reduced them to two. It was customary for the man to obtain tokens previous to going down the pit, the tokens being to fasten to the tubs as they filled them. On the day in question, the prosecution token number was 80, and the token for the defendant was number 86. A tub which had the words "Rope me" chalked upon it was in a certain place in the pit, and later in the day it was found that that tub was the first to be ready for sending up, and that it had one of the defendant's tokens upon it. Having given full particulars of the case, which were afterwards given in evidence, Mr. Chapman said the facts that should be relied upon to commit the defendants for trial were that the prosecutors laid a trap for somebody, who they thought were in the habit of practising this dishonesty, and from the facts of the case, it could not have been done by anyone but the three defendants, as they were the only men who could derive any benefit through doing this act. It was not an act that could easily be done; and it must be done determinedly. In conclusion, Mr. Chapman said he would call the evidence, and then he would ask them to commit the men for trial.

Robert Blair, surveyor for the Whitehaven Colliery Co., said the duplicate plans before him were correct plans of the north district, No. 6 left hand section. Witness then explained the system of working. In the natural course of the running of the tubs No. 86 would come after No. 85.

Only Duggan wished to ask witness any questions, and he asked what the number was of the first tub.

Witness: 86.

Duggan: You said 85 a minute since.

Witness: When?

Duggan replied that witness said 85 at the time he was referring to the plan, and concluded by saying "It is no good me talking." (Laughter.)

James Rothery, coal-hewer, Parton, said that on March 27th, he was working with John Martin, and Thomas Casson, and on that day he was working in No. 6 north left hand section. The shift commenced at one o'clock mid-day, and their token number for the shift was 80. On going to the pit top, witness got the token, taking about a dozen down with him. He examined them carefully, and found they were all 80's. It was the practice to examine them carefully, because if one happened to be another number they would not get paid for the tubs filled bearing that number. The first tub they filled that day was marked "Rope me" in large letters, the words being a certain sign to the man at the top of the pit. This tub was the first one sent down the "dilly." On their way home that day they stopped at the siding where the tubs were standing before going to the engine plane. At the front of the tubs was the one witness and his mates had filled, which bore the words "Rope me." Witness examined the token on that marked tub, and found that the number of it was 86. He also noticed that the coal had been disturbed in the tub and a passage made down to the token staple. They had been losing tubs and had suspicion that there was some pilfering, and they examined the tubs that night and that particular tub, which was marked "Rope me" was found to have had the token changed.

Mr. McGowan: Had any of your tubs gone up the pit before you came up?

Witness: No, sir; they were all there.

The Clerk: Did you put the token on "Rope me?"

Witness: No, sir.

John Rothery, under-manager, said he had had several complaints from men about losing tubs, and in consequence he decided to reduce the number of working places in the north district to two. He stopped all the workings but two a fortnight before the 27th March. These consisted of James Rothery, John Martin, Thomas Casson, and the accused. In consequence of a report on March 28th, he had five tubs sided at the top of the pit. One was marked "Rope me," and had a token No. 86 on it. At one o'clock that day he was at the pit top when defendants and others were going down. Witness was standing close to the tub marked "Rope me," and defendants were standing by. A number of hewers were also there. Witness, turning to the men standing about said, "This is Martin and Casson's tubs, and these men (referring to the defendants) stuck it. "Stuck," he added, was the best term he could apply in order to make the men understand. The defendants did not speak. A hewer named John Rooney stepped up to where witness and defendants were standing, and asked if they (defendants) were going down. Witness replied "No, indeed, they aren't," and Rooney said, "No, I think not. If they go we shouldn't go," or words to that effect. The token number of Casson and Co. was 80, and that of the defendants 86. If the preceding shift on the day in question had left any tubs numbered 85 standing on the siding, no tubs numbered 85 could have been found in front of them in the ordinary course of working.

Isaac Rothery, overman at William Pit, said that on the 27th March there had been an arrangement to restrict the working places to two in the working in question, owing to the complaints about tubs being missed. Witness was on the main working at nine p.m. when he heard Duggan say, "You will find our shovel at the bottom of the brake." That was said to a man named Birnie. In consequence of this he hurried in and found a No. 86 tub on a siding near the engine plane by itself. Witness then looked at the next one, which was fifteen yards further in, and noticed that it was marked "Rope me," and also that it was a No.86. The next tubs in order were numbered 80, 85, 80, 80, 85, 80, 80, 85, 86, 86, 86. The last three were half full, and marked in chalk with the date and the word "touped." Further up the siding were two more tubs numbered 80, and two with 80 marked on. The defendants' token number was 86, and the number preceding them in the same working was 85. Martin, Casson, and Co. had token 80. Eighty-five ought to have been in front in the ordinary course of working. There was no reason whatever, except foul play, why number 85 should be behind the 86's. Witness had the five tubs marked "Side at pit top." He was at the pit top when John Rothery spoke to the men ready to go down the pit. Subsequently, Rothery went over to the weigh cabin and three or four minutes afterwards Murphy came to witness, who was standing with the other defendants, and said, "I'll admit fulling that tub on the bur (that was the first tub of all on the siding adjoining the engine plane) but I know nothing about the other tub." The latter was the one that was "stuck." Witness said to Murphy, "If you are innocent and know who did it, say so and clear yourself." Murphy turned round and pointed to Devlin saying "He struck five tubs last week, and can't deny it."

Mr. Chapman: An expert, apparently. (Laugher.)

Witness: Devlin never spoke. Defendant Duggan said to Murphy, "D thee soul; thoo's no man for telling." (Laughter.) The three defendants went away quarrelling and arguing. On the following Saturday he met Murphy near Bransty Arch, and the latter said, "I'll tell thee all about it, Isaac." Witness told him he had better tell Mr. Turner, the manager, and added, "It will likely be a court case." Murphy said that if it was a court case he would clear himself.

In answer to Duggan, witness said there were places for five companies to work, but they had only had four working. When this matter came up they decided to have only two.

The Chairman: Could any other men have tampered with the tokens?

Witness: No sir, there was no one on that section.

Mr. McGowan: Could any one of the three men do it without the knowledge of the others?

Witness: If they went down by himself he might. If they were all at the place at the time it would be impossible.

Mr. Chapman said that he could show that the men were together committing an illegal act.

Joseph McDonald, brakesman on the flat sheets above the siding, said he left the tubs on the brake close to the engine plane. On the 27th March he went off duty at the time when Duggan and Co. came on. The last tub witness had hauled up previous to going off work was marked, in chalk, "Rope Me." There was no other tub marked the same way.

Thomas Casson, of Union terrace, Whitehaven, stated that he went to work with Martin and Rothery in the No. 6 working, left hand section. There was only one other company working in that section. His token number was 80 and Duggan's 86. The first tub filled was marked "Rope Me." Witness put the token No. 80 on this tub. As they went by the sidings that day they noticed three tubs had been "sliped," and in consequence they examined the rest,. "Sliped" meant taken off the face. They found the tub marked "Rope Me," with a No. 86 token on it. He saw that the coal in the corner of the tub had been disturbed. It was not possible that anyone but the defendants could change the token and no one could benefit by it.

At this stage the hearing was adjourned until two o'clock.

The first witness called afterwards was S. B. Turner, manager at William Pit, who said the tub produced was an exact duplicate of the tub marked "Rope Me." The pay for the tubs "stuck" was equally divided between the men in the company. One shilling and fourpence farthing was the amount the company filling a tub would receive. The tubs had eleven and a half cwts. of coal, and the pay was at the rate of two shillings and four-pence farthing per ton.

By the Chairman: One man could change the token without the others knowing. The wages were paid so much a ton and taken as a whole at the week-end the men shared alike.

Thompson Dixon, of 6, Bell's Lane, Whitehaven, brakesman at William Pit, said he took McDonald's place, when he left off duty. There were two tubs standing at top of the brake on March 27th, when he commenced work at one o'clock. One of the two bore the words, "Rope Me." Witness rang the bell for Casson to run them up the "dilly," and they were sent up into Casson's working. He remembered the marked tub coming down again about half an hour later and he sent it on to the siding near to the engine plane. At about 7 o'clock witness saw Duggan and Devlin come out of their working on to the place where he was working at the brake. They were going to go down the brake, and one of them asked witness to go for a pick and shovel, but he replied, "Wait till I get time." The shift was not then finished. After this the men went on towards the siding, and witness who stopped at the brake until the end of the shift (8.30 p.m.) did not see the men come back to go into their working again. When witness reached the siding near to the engine plane there were some tubs standing, one of them being about fifteen yards away from the others. The three defendants were standing near to that tub. Murphy, added witness, had followed Devlin and Duggan some ten minutes after they had passed him. Devlin and Duggan had told him that they were going to fill some loose coal at the bottom. He saw Duggan lift some pieces of coal and put them in the tub. The other two defendants were standing beside him. He got the coal from beside the pillar corner just beside the tub.

John Kermean, 3, James Pit, Whitehaven, said that Devlin and Duggan sent him to Murphy for a pick and shovel and to tell Murphy he was to come down. Witness went to Murphy, who gave him the pick and the shovel, and he carried them down to Thompson Dixon, who put them on a sett which went down the siding. Five minutes later witness followed the sett into the siding, where he saw Duggan and Devlin lift a tub on to the road, and start filling it from between the roads. It is just dirt and coal they were filling. They half filled one tub and wrote "touped" on it. (Laughter.) He saw defendants half fill two more and then write "touped" on them. Murphy then came and they sent him to fill on the bur.

James Patterson, Strand-street, Whitehaven, a watchman at William Pit, said that he accompanied P.C. Seesford when the officer was serving the summonses. They saw Duggan at his house, China Terrace, Asby, and after the summonses had been read over defendant said, if it had been anybody's tub but Rothery's these would have been no more bother about it.

A woman in the rear of the court called out, "It wasn't him that said it. It was me." (Laughter.)

Duggan denied having made any such reply.

Continuing, witness said, Devlin replied, "It's that Murphy that's led us into this bother. It was him that ‘stuck' the tub and we known nothing about it."

This concluded the evidence for the first case, and Murphy said he "was innocent of the crime, but guilty of filling the tub."

Devlin said, "I don't know anything of the tub. I am innocent of it."

Duggan said, "I admit sliping the tub, but I don't know anything of the tub that was stuck."

The Chairman: All three defendants are committed to take their trial on this charge at the next Quarter Sessions.

They were bound over in the sum of £10 and each of them to find a surety of £10.

The second charge was then proceeded with.

The first witness called was Isaac Rothery, who said that if a tub got spilled in transit from the working places to the pit top the officials of the company marked in chalk the word "touped," the date, and their initials. For tubs so marked the men were given credit for a full tub. On March 27th, at about nine p.m. in the evening he met the prisoners coming out of the working. He heard Duggan say to a man named Michael Burney, who was going into his working place, "You will find our shovel at the bottom of the brake. Mind you take it in with you." A hewer could not have a lawful purpose for a shovel at the bottom of the brake. In consequence of this he made an examination of the tubs standing on the siding and found three tubs standing together. They were about half filled with rubbish and coal and had chalked on each side "27.3.06. Touped," but no officials initials. Each tub had a token numbered 86 attached. Witness wrote on each tub, "slide off at the pit top," and put his initials on.

Thompson Dixon, a brakesman, and John Kermean, assistant-brakesman, gave evidence similar to that given by them in the first case. Murphy saw Duggan write "trouped" on the third tub.

Samuel Turner, manager at the pit, gave evidence as to the benefit prisoners would have derived from payment by the company for the tubs.

The defendants, who were now in the dock, did not wish to saw anything, and they were committed to take their trial on this charge at the Quarter Sessions.

The Chairman stated to the defendants that if they could find bail in the previous case they (the magistrates) would only insist upon them entering into their own recognisances of £10 each in this case.

Mr. Chapman said with permission of the Bench he would withdraw the remaining charge, and the proceedings then terminated, the case having occupied several hours.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bennett, G. C.    Magistrate  
Birnie, —    Miner  
Blair, Robert    Surveyor  
Casson, Thomas    Miner  
Chapman, W. H.    Solicitor  
Devlin, William   22 Collier  
Dixon, Thompson    Brakesman  
Duggan, Thomas   24 Collier  
Fox, H.    Magistrate  
Jackson, J. A.    Magistrate  
Jefferson, R.    Magistrate  
Kermean, John    Miner  
Martin, John    Miner  
McDonald, Joseph    Brakesman  
McGowan, W.    Magistrate  
Murphy, Alexander   40 Collier  
Patterson, James    Watchman  
Rooney, James    Hewer  
Rothery, Isaac    Overman  
Rothery, James    Hewer  
Rothery, John    Under Manager  
Turner, Samuel    Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print