|
17th August 1905 The Beckermet RobberyAccused Before The MagistratesA Lengthy HearingThe Prisoner Discharged. At the Whitehaven Police-court, on Monday, before J. Gibson Dees (in the chair), W. McGowan, G. C. Bennett (Mayor), and R. Jefferson, Esq., Alfred Wm. Going (35), electrician, Egremont, was charged on remand with stealing from an office at the Beckermet Mines, the sum of £152 11s 1d. Great interest was manifested in this case, but the Court was not crowded. Mr. Chapman, who appeared for the accused, asked that all witnesses in the case leave the Court. The request was acceded to. Mr. Chapman then asked that Supt. Hope leave the Court as he was a most important witness, he having given evidence when the accused was remanded. The Clerk said that if the matter was pressed Supt. Hope would have to go out. Mr. Chapman said that he could only deal with him as a witness, and the magistrates' order was that all the witnesses in the case should leave the Court. Hope was an important witness, and he (Mr. Chapman) would not be discharging his duty to the accused if he relaxed his claim one iota. He then asked that Supt. Hope should leave the Court. The Clerk: Well, we can hear the superintendent's evidence first. Mr. Chapman observed that if the superintendent was in Court conducting the case for the prosecution he would have the opportunity of hearing their evidence. He (Mr. Chapman) was placed at a great disadvantaged in that respect. Further Mr. Chapman said the superintendent could make his questions accordingly, and he contended that other arrangements should be made. After a short consultation the Chairman said: Mr. Hope must leave the court, and Mr. Helder will conduct the prosecution. Mr. Chapman said that he was very sorry to cause inconvenience to the Bench, but he maintained that other arrangements should be made under the circumstances. Jacob Stephenson Stout was first called, and said that he resided at Whitehaven, and was a surveyor. He had prepared the plan (produced) from a survey of the locus. Mr. Chapman after examining the plan, said that he objected to it because there were indications on it which were for the purpose of the prosecution. There were several indications in red. The Clerk: We had better had a plan had we not? Mr. Chapman: You see my objection? The Clerk: Yes. Mr. Chapman: It is a good one. There are several indications on this plan which would help the witnesses. He was not aware of what evidence was going to be given. The Chairman: We will adjourn the Court for half an hour in order to have the plan altered. The Court then adjourned. After the adjournment the plan was again produced and accepted. David Tyson Satterthwaite, Beckermet, said that he was employed as storekeeper at the Beckermet Mines. He remembered the day in question when he accompanied Mr. Stout, the manager, from Yeorton Hall with the money bag (produced). There was £150 in the bag, which was intended for wages to be paid at one o'clock that day. It was about 9.30 when they reached the mines. He knew the money was in the bag, because he assisted to put it in. Here witness said the amount was £152. When they reached the mines the bag was taken into the storehouse and locked in the desk. Afterwards he put the key in his pocket. He went down into the joiners' shop, and at 11.15 he again visited the store, and he opened the outer door and went to the desk. In the meantime, however, he had given the key to Charles Booth, the one belonging to the outer door. Booth, who is the under-manager, gave it to him in less than five minutes as he was on his way from the boilers to the engine-house, on the joiners' shop side. He saw the prisoner once or twice, and spoke to him whilst he was at the boilers, but he could not give them an exact idea of the time. The accused asked for an half-inch coupling, and it would then be between ten and 10.30. Witness said he could not tell him where there was one. Upon visiting the store at 11.15 he found the lock of the desk broken. He put the key into the lock and opened it, as he expected, with it. Witness took out the store book and entered the stores up, and placed the book back into the desk. Upon trying to lock the desk he found that it would not latch, and he lifted the lid again to examine the lock, whereupon he found the catch of the lock broken. For some little time he examined the broken part, and then all at once he was struck about the bag, and looking at the place where it had been put he found it had gone. Information was given to Mr. Stout immediately. Witness was at the boilers prior to this, but he could not see the storehouse from that place. The top half of the storehouse window opened, but it was fastened inside when he examined it on Saturday. The centre pane in the bottom half had springs at the bottom, and one at the top, and this could be taken out from the outside. The pane would be about twenty inches, but he could not say that it had been taken out that morning. There was something like finger marks on the glass near the top sprig, which was made of iron. There were also finger end marks on the middle of the pane. By Mr. Chapman: He only saw the prisoner once between 9.30 and 11.15. The store stood upon a considerable elevation, and it was a very conspicuous object if a man happened to be looking in that direction. From most parts of the mine it could be seen, but not from the boilers. They could see it from the winding engine-house. Only one man was employed in the engine-house. It could also be seen from the pit shaft. There were two men working at the smithy, and if the persons in the smithy were looking out of the windows they could see anyone approaching the store. There were three big windows coming low down at the joiner's shop, and on the morning in question two men were working there. The men in there would have a very excellent view if they looked out. Witness had been an employee at the mines since May, 1904. Mr. Chapman: Were all the top men searched that day? Witness: I could not tell how many there were searched. Mr. Chapman: Were you searched? Witness: No. Further he said it was slightly raining at the time. James Stout, the manager at the mines, was next sworn. He lived at Yeorton Hall, and was employed by the Beckermet Mining Company. The prisoner was employed as an electrician at the mines, and had been in their employ about seven months. On Saturday, July 29th, he left his house in company with Daniel Satterthwaite, at about nine o'clock. They proceeded up to the mines with the bag containing the money. The money was in gold, silver, and copper, and each man's money was in a separate envelope. He locked the bag before he handed it to Satterthwaite, and put the key into his pocket. Witness left Satterthwaite between the store and the joiner's shop and left him with the bag. He knew nothing more until about eleven o'clock, when from information received he went to the storehouse and searched the place through to see if they could find the bag, but they did not find it. When he examined the desk he found that the lock was broken, and he immediately sent for a police officer at Beckermet, and gave instructions that none of the men must leave the place. P.C. Morrison arrived at about half-past eleven, and witness proceeded to Egremont in order to inform Sergt. Batey, and he also got more money from the bank to pay the wages. He returned to the mines at five minutes past one, and found the police there, and also all the men waiting for their wages. There were about 50 men at the mines. At eleven o'clock it was raining very fast, and through the thunderstorm men would shelter. He did not know whether they did that or not. In the afternoon Supt. Hope arrived, and they had been having a search to see if they could find this lost treasure. (Laughter.) Prisoner was there when they were told not to go home. At about five o'clock in the prisoner's presence, Supt. Hope, who had been assisting in the search which had been continued, proposed that a search be made in the hot water tank, which measured 20ft. by 5ft. 10in. from the electric works door, where prisoner worked. Immediately Mr. Hope proposed that it should be searched three or four of them went towards the tank, an the prisoner took a long coal rake and put it into the tank, and instead of trying to find anything it appeared to witness very forcibly that he was trying to push something away from him. That was if there was something in. Witness saw him do that, and said, "Hold on Going. Let me have that." Witness then took the coal rake from prisoner, and tried the rake, but he could not lift anything. In the meantime he had given instructions for a small hook to be made, and P.C. Morrison brought it to them. It was a long rod with a sharp pointed hook at the end of it. Supt. Hope used it, and subsequently brought the bag (produced) up by the handle. Witness took the bag off the hook, and at the time he thought the money was in and he took out his key as he found that it was locked. Upon turning it round he saw that it had been cur with a knife and that the money had been taken out and stones put in. The bag was opened in the presence of Supt. Hope and at the time the prisoner was standing by, but he did not say anything. If any one was going from the store-house to the electric engine-house they would have to pass alongside of the tank from where the bag was recovered. The tank was an old boiler, and the only opening was the manhole which was 16 inches in diameter. On the Monday or Tuesday before he had given instructions about a blast pipe, and Going had been instructed to fix a blast pipe and ½ in pipe for the purpose of blowing dirt out of the armatures. He was engaged at that on the Saturday, and had not finished, but there was nothing for him to go to the store for as far as that was concerned. The prisoner had occasionally to go down the pit, but his principal work was in the engine-house. £98 14s 6d was found early on the Sunday morning, but he was not present when it was found. Witness had seen the piece of brown paper produced, and he believed that it was paper which had been used for electric goods. He could not swear to it, however — Mr. Chapman observed that there was plenty of paper similar — Continuing, witness said that it was like paper used for wrapping shellac. The glass window at the store was in two halves, but only the top one opened. He did not think that the store window had been opened that day. They could not find any foot-prints. Cross examined by Mr. Chapman: There would be fifteen men about. The Clerk: We had it 25 before. Witness: That is day and night shift. Between leaving Satterthwaite and 11.15 he was about the surface attending to his duties. There were four or five men building and the enginemen, joiners, &c. After adding then together witness said there would be 15 persons there, including the prisoner. He could not say whether he saw the prisoner or not, but he believed that he did. Witness thought that he saw him, but he could not say whether he was in the electric engine-house during the morning. The store-house could be seen from the smith's shop, the joiner's shop, and the engine-house, and generally from the surface premises unless there was a building intervening. In passing from one place to another he would have a clear view of the store-house if he looked at it. Mr. Chapman: Now, Mr. Stout, will you tell me how it came about that this store-house was in such a dangerous condition in regard to the windows? Witness: I don't suppose I can. Mr. Chapman: Now don't suppose, Mr. Stout. I want an answer. No definite reply. Mr. Chapman: I want an answer. Do you know that that pane could easily have been removed? In reply he said that a pane was taken out a month or two before in a case of emergency. The distance from the electrical engine-house to the store was 147 feet, and the shaft was 115 feet from the store, the winding engine 185 feet, and the boiler 120 feet. There were men working at all those points during that morning. He did not know whether Going was down the pit that morning or not, or if he did go down at what time. Witness believed that all the men were searched at about two o'clock, that was some time during the afternoon before the tank was tried. He was not sure about it. Mr. Chapman: Except Satterthwaite? Witness: I don't know. The prisoner he stated, in reply to further questions, joined them when the search party reached the tank. Prisoner was not ordered by anybody to get the rake. Mr. Chapman: Who told him to put this rake into the manhole? Witness: There was nobody who told him. Mr. Chapman: Was it proposed in his hearing that the tank be searched? Witness: He would hear it. Witness was close to him when he put the rake in the manhole, and was watching him. Supt. Hope was just behind a foot or two. Mr. Chapman: A foot or two he says, make it a yard. (Laughter.) The manhole was two or three feet off the end of the tank. Mr. Chapman: Now, Mr. Stout, I am going to put before you a common sense question. The rake would have to be pushed forward before it could be drawn towards the person holding it. Witness: No. Mr. Chapman: How suspicious you must have been, Mr. Stout. How would you have done it if you had been in Going's place and had to rake how would you have felt it? Witness: I would have taken it all round. Mr. Chapman: Now be fair, Mr. Stout. At about half-past one the court adjourned for lunch, and the hearing was resumed at a quarter past two. Mr. Chapman, after adjournment, said that he wanted to ask Mr. Stout one or two more questions. Mr. Chapman: Do I understand you right when you say that you do not identify that piece of paper in any way. Mr. Stout: No, I don't. Mr. Chapman: In reference to the answer you made about the paper, I take it that gum and shellac are used in other parts of the works. Witness: No, sir, they aren't. Mr. Chapman: Joiners never use gum and shellac? Witness: No. Supt. John Hope said that on Saturday, the 29th July last, he arrived at the Beckermet mines, about three o'clock. After making certain inquiries at about five o'clock he proposed to have a search made in a hot water tank for the bag and money. The prisoner was near by when they got to the tank, and he procured a long boiler coal rake from near the boilers, went up to the tank, pushed it into the hole at the top of the tank, and witness saw him push it away from him as if he was endeavouring to push something to the other end of the tank. At that time witness was standing down below the hot water tank and upon observing the prisoner doing what he had stated he hurried up to the top where prisoner was. He hear Mr. Stout say "Hold on, let me have hold of that." Witness saw him take the rake from the prisoner, and Mr. Stout used the rake but did not get anything. There was nothing but mud adhering to it. A hook which had been prepared was brought and given to witness, which, he put into the tank and pulled up to the surface the bag (produced.) Mr. Stout leaned forward and unhooked the bag, and carried it away a few yards. Witness followed him and saw him take out the key of the bag, and unlock it. He then for the first time noticed that the bag had been ripped open as it now appears. On making further examination he found that it had been filled with pieces of stone. Witness took possession of it and had held it since. By Mr. Chapman: It was a heavy rake, probably eight feet long. Anyone who wanted to grope in the tank would have to put in on the edge of the manhole and push it. Further he said they would have to rest it on the side and push. He could not say whether it was resting on the side when prisoner had hold of it. Witness was looking in from down below, and Mr. Stout was watching the prisoner also. They were both close to the prisoner. Whatever the prisoner was doing he was doing it without concealment. If witness had been going with the rake he would have put it down perpendicularly, but it was open to doubt whether six different people would have used it the same way. Had they been using it to look for the bag they would have probably put it down perpendicularly. Continuing, witness said that he was not positive who told the prisoner to get the rake. Nearly all the other men were assisting, but he did not know anyone who was not. He was positive that the prisoner was never requested to use the coal rake. By the Chairman: The bag was almost underneath the manhole. He did not see that the bag was ripped when it was brought up, because the other side of the bag was towards him. Charles Booth was then called, and he stated that he was the under-manager for the Beckermet Mining Co., and resided at Beckermet. On Saturday, the 29th of July, he had occasion to go to the store-house at about quarter past eleven in the morning for some fuse. He got the key about the same time from Mr. Satterthwaite — the key for the door, and when he got there he found the door locked. Witness opened it and went inside and got the fuse. Afterwards he gave the key to Mr. Satterthwaite. He was only in the stores a few minutes. Witness did not notice anything unusual inside. George Higham, an electric engineman at the Beckermet mines, living at Beckermet, said that he was in charge of the electric engine on Saturday, the 29th of July, between six a.m. and one p.m. Witness saw the prisoner several times that morning, the first time at half-past eight, coming to his work, and the next time was at a quarter past ten, when he saw him going in and out of the engine-house, but he did not see where he went. He went out at a door which led up some steps past the tank,, and into the smithy. A minute afterwards when witness looked through the window he saw prisoner going under the window, and just as he got round the corner he seemed to look round. The Clerk: In what way? Witness: Just took a glance round as I thought, and seemed to be looking as could he see somebody. He then went a few yards further, and then got through a wire fence. Witness lost sight of him at the engine-house. Witness sat down and prisoner came back in two or three minutes and went up to the engine-room and put his leggings on, and away out again. He then went towards the pit top, and in about three-quarters of an hour he returned and entered the engine-house. Prisoner said, "Have you heard the latest," and witness said "No." Prisoner then said, "Somebody has gone with the money," and witness replied, "Get away man," or something like that, and asked him (the prisoner) who had told him. Prisoner said, "I heard them talking in the smithy." Witness asked where they had taken it from, and he said, "They have stolen it, I expect." Prisoner then went away. Witness thought that he (the prisoner) was in and out of his place pretty often during the morning — more often than usual, he thought at the time. Mr. Chapman: You were in charge of the engine-house? Witness: Yes. Mr. Chapman: Is he under you or you are under him? Witness: I should rather think that he is over me. Prisoner's movements became peculiar when he heard that the money was gone. Mr. Chapman: Just so, exactly what I thought. Wm. Walker Douglas, Egremont, a winding engineman at the Beckermet mines, said that shortly after ten o'clock he saw the prisoner standing over against the store. Witness was in the window, and saw the prisoner looking towards the joiner's shop. He saw him standing at the place for about five or ten seconds, and when he (witness) left the window he was still standing there. Cross examined by Mr. Chapman: He saw nothing to excite his interest. Benjamin Simpson, Beckermet, a fireman at the mines, said that he remembered the 29th of July, on which day he was on duty from 6.30 in the morning to one o'clock. He saw the prisoner between nine and ten, when he was going backwards and forwards either from the joiner's or blacksmith's shop. Witness saw him many a time. In going to and fro he had to pass the hot water tank, and between eleven and half-past prisoner went to first fire hole in the electric engine-house. He opened the door with his right hand, and threw something in, after which he walked away. Before doing so he shut the door. Witness could not say what it was he threw in. It was similar to a piece of paper, but he would not swear that it was a piece of paper. Prisoner had no business at the fire hole as far as he knew. By Mr. Chapman: He did not attach anything suspicious to the act, nor did he do at present. Isaac Cooke, a fireman for the Beckermet Mining Co., residing at Egremont, said that he was with Constable Morrison searching for the missing money. On Sunday morning at a quarter past six he found twenty-one packages similar to those produced. He found them at the back of the water tank lying partly in a heap, and they seemed quite bare. Witness just placed his hand on them at the back of the wall, but they were out of sight as he had to get at the back of the tank and stretch his hand over. Mr. Chapman had no questions to ask Cooke, and he stood down. Edward Fogg, Parkhead, Egremont, a banker in the employ of the Beckermet Mining Company, said that he was searching with P.C. Morrison on Sunday, July 30th, and at about 6.45 in the morning he found thirteen packages like the ones produced. They were in a rubbish tank near to the electric engine-house, whence the water comes from the engine. The witness was not cross-examined. P.C. Morrison, stationed at Beckermet, stated that from information received he went to the mines, and when he reached there he examined several places. He found the nail produced lying beneath the desk, the lock of which was broken. There were marks on the desk such as would be made by a nail like the one found. He remained at the pit all night, and at 6.15 his attention was drawn to a tank by Isaac Cooke. Twenty-one packets were then removed from underneath. Witness then continued the search with Fogg, who recovered more packages, which were wrapped in brown paper. The parcel was found at the north-end of the electrical engine-house. About 1.15 on Saturday witness had a conversation with the prisoner whom he called from the pit top. He asked him if he had heard of anything being lost about the put that day, and he replied "Yes, I heard that a bag of money has been stolen." He asked prisoner who told him, and he said "I overheard Mr. Stout talking about it in the smithy." Witness then asked him if he had been near the store, and he replied "I have not." Witness said, "Are you sure," and prisoner answered "Yes." Cross-examined, he saw five men searched, and one man named Hodgson was searched three times. Mr. Chapman: You pumped Hodgson pretty dry about the prisoner? Witness: I did not, sir. Mr. Chapman: Didn't you ask him what his connection was with the prisoner? Witness: I did not, sir. Mr. Chapman: Did you say this "Well, you are helping him, because I saw you with Mr. Chapman at the mine?" Witness: I did not. Sergt. Batey, Egremont, said that from information received he apprehended the prisoner at 9.30 a.m. on July 30th, at his lodgings, which are in Egremont. He conveyed him to the police station, where he cautioned and charged him with breaking and stealing therefrom a leather bag, containing £152 in gold and silver, the property if the Beckermet Mining Company between 9.30 and 11.30 a.m. on the 29th July. Prisoner replied "I understand. I have nothing more to say at present." During the day while attending to the prisoner in his cell he (prisoner) asked a question, and said, "Have you any more information against me?" Witness replied, "Part of the money has been found." Prisoner said "Oh." In reply to Mr. Chapman, he assisted in the searching of the men. He thought that under a dozen were searched, but he did not know how many. Mr. Chapman: Do you know the names of the men who were searched? Witness: Yes. At Mr. Chapman's request the names were given from his notebook. In reply to further questions, witness said that Morrison would search those he did not search. At this stage the magistrates and Clerk retired. Upon their return the Chairman said: The Bench are of the opinion from the evidence which has been submitted to them that it is not such as would induce a jury to convict, and the prisoner is discharged. When the accused was acquitted news was at once sent to Egremont, and a crowd who gathered at the station to meet the 5.45 train were some what disappointed when they found that he had not travelled by that train. At half-past eight the station was again invaded by people interested in the case, and the vicinity of the station presented an animated appearance. Directly the train steamed in the immense crowd gave vent to cheering, and when Going left the station he was followed down the Main-street by an enthusiastic crowd. The decision of the magistrates was a popular one, and Egremont people generally appeared to be pleased with the result of the case, which they have followed so closely.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||