25th July 1905
The Drinking Facilities At The Miners' Demonstration
The Police Object
An Equality Divided Bench
On Monday, Mr. E. Atter applied at the Whitehaven Police-court, for an occasional licence, on behalf of William Shepherd Tinnion, of the Vine Inn, Irish-street, Whitehaven, on the occasion of the miners' demonstration to be held at Cleator Moor, on
Monday next. The presiding magistrates were J. G. Dees (in the chair) and T. Richards, Esq. Wm. McGowan, Esq., arrived too late to adjudicate.
Mr. Atter stated that the application was in respect to the miners' demonstration, to be held at Cleator Moor, on the 31st of this month, and he asked that an occasional licence be granted from eleven o'clock in the morning to eight o'clock at night.
The application was supported by a letter from Mr. Andrew Sharp, secretary of the Miners' Association, and it was pointed out that there was only to be one tent erected in the field, and that the tent was sanctioned by the committee. There would be
about 15,000 present at the field, which would be opened at eleven o'clock, and later in the day there would be sports and other kinds of entertainment. In addition to the letter from Mr. Sharp, Mr. Flynn would tell them that the application was
supported by the whole of the committee. It would be a means, Mr. Atter contended, of keeping the large number who attended in the field, and they would be kept off the streets. That is one of the reasons why the licence should be granted.
William Shepherd Tinnion, landlord of the Vine Inn, Whitehaven, was the first witness called in support of the application.
Mr. Atter: You have the licence of the Vine Inn?
Witness: Yes.
Mr. Atter: You have had that some time?
Witness: Yes, for six years.
Mr. Atter: Have you on previous occasions supplied intoxicating liquor for the miners' demonstration?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Mr. Atter: At Cleator Moor?
Witness: No, but other places.
A letter was then put on from Mr. Andrew Sharp.
Further, witness said that he applied for the licence from eleven o'clock to eight o'clock.
Supt. Hope: Have you ever had this licence at Workington or Maryport?
Witness: No, sir.
Supt. Hope: Do you know Cleator Moor well?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Supt. Hope: Tell their worships how many licensed houses there are within a short distance of this field?
I think there are about two.
Supt. Hope: Don't you know the Derby Arms?
Witness: Yes.
Supt. Hope: How far is that off?
Witness: Well, the Derby Arms to the best of my recollection is about 100 yards off.
Supt. Hope then observed that the Golden Lion and another public-house was not far from Aldby Field, where the demonstration is to be held.
Supt. Hope: Well, there are three pubic-houses within 300 yards.
Witness: Well, I have not measured the distance.
Supt. Hope: You are making this application because you have succeeded with the tender which you have made?
Witness: Yes, sir.
James Flynn was then sworn, he being in favour of the application.
Mr. Atter: Are you on the committee?
Witness: I am treasurer of the demonstration.
Mr. Atter: Have you been connected with it some time?
Witness: For ten years.
Mr. Atter: You are also on the committee?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Mr. Flynn added that the application had the unanimous support of the committee, and that the tent would be the only one upon the field. He pointed out that when they had no licence the men went outside, and returned after they had had some drink.
Nearly one half of the men of the committee were temperance men.
By Mr. Atter: He thought that it was an utter impossibility for the people in the town to cater for the mass. He had never heard of any complaints.
Mr. Atter: Will members of the committee be attending the sports?
Witness: Yes, sir. 9 think it will lesson the evil of drunkenness. The only thing to prevent it will be to close all the public-houses. The other way would cause them to go out of the field - annoyance would be caused.
Supt. Hope: Were you at Maryport two years ago?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Supt. Hope: Is it correct that Mr. Philip Snowden had to make a complaint about the conduct at one of the demonstrations?
Witness: It is not. Mr. Flynn said that in his letter Mr. Snowden complimented them, and said that he had never seen a better conducted demonstration.
Supt. Hope: Do you know that it was in the papers about his complaint?
Witness: Well, we are not responsible for what is in the papers. (Laughter.) When they had no licence, they were running out and causing trouble at the gate.
In reply to Supt. Hope, witness said that when they had pass-out-checks at Whitehaven the men went out, and did not return until they had had six or seven pints. If they had the drink in the field they would take it in moderation.
Supt. Hope: They have always had a tent, and there is not doubt but what this application is simply for drinking facilities.
Witness: Not to increase them at all. They would have 10,000 extra people there and no one to provide for them.
Supt. Hope: There has always been a temperance tent.
Witness: No, not always.
Supt. Hope: So that this application is really for drinking purposes?
Witness: Not at all, it is for feeding as well.
Supt. Hope: I oppose the application as it is for drinking facilities, and I contend that at Cleator Moor there are quite sufficient public-houses to supply the drink required. I can only speak from one experience of demonstrations, and as on that
occasion a licence was granted he would like to see a demonstration without a licence.
Mr. Flynn: Last year, Mr. Hope.
Supt. Hope: Where at?
Mr. Flynn: Last year the demonstration at Workington was without licence.
Supt. Hope said two miners had come to him that morning, and had offered to give evidence against the application.
Walter Joyce, miner, 7, Banks's Lane, Whitehaven, was then called, and he said that he had been in the habit of attending demonstrations.
Supt. Hope: Do you consider it necessary that a licence should be granted?
Witness: No, sir.
Supt. Hope: Will you state to the Bench why you oppose the licence?
In the course of a long statement, which was not very audible, he said that there were examples shown on that day which stood for years, and if there was not such thing as a drinking tent he had found from his own experience - although there was no one
in the wide, wide world who liked drink better than he - that it was a thing which gave men a craving for it. Through it being so near they are led away to it, and there they are to be found drinking to their heart's content. (Laughter.)
By Supt. Hope: He had come to the Court voluntarily to give evidence.
Mr. Atter: You would do away with hotels?
Witness: To a certain extent.
Mr. Atter: You go the whole hog?
Witness: I have no occasion, but to a certain extent.
Mr. Atter: You would do away with it altogether?
Witness: If I thought it would do me good, I would.
Mr. Atter: Do you think that these people would take too much?
Witness: Well the biggest majority of them.
Mr. Atter: When were you there last?
Witness: Four years ago.
Mr. Atter: Oh, you did not go last year?
Witness: No.
Mr. Atter: Where were you four years ago?
Witness: Whitehaven.
Mr. Atter: Did you see anything wrong there?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Mr. Atter: You would shut up all public-houses on that day if you had your way.
Witness: I cannot say, sir.
Mr. Atter: Do you ever take drink yourself?
Witness: Yes, sir.
Mr. Atter asked if that was the reason why he opposed the application?
Witness: I am speaking from experience, sir.
Mr. Atter: You are?
Witness: And other people's.
Mr. Atter: Are they here?
Witness: Yes, sir.
The Rev. C. McGregor Greer, curate of St. John's Church, Cleator Moor, said that he was inclined to oppose the granting of the licence, because it gave very increased facilities to sell liquor. They had, as everyone was aware a good number of
public-houses at Cleator Moor, but he did not stand there and oppose a legitimate number of public-houses. They had no right to put temptation in anyone's way.
In reply to Mr. Atter, he said that surely it was not a great matter to walk a short distance if they wanted a drink. They could not assume that all these 15,000 people were wanting drink.
Mr. Atter: Suppose a thousand want it?
Witness: Well, there is accommodation for 1,000 at Cleator Moor.
Mr. Atter thought that he might as well say that in regard to a railway train.
Witness: Oh, that has nothing to do with a railway train, and he did not think they should assume that it was absolutely necessary that the men wanted drink.
The Rev. E. A. Steen, Primitive Methodist minister, Earl-street, Cleator Moor, said that he was strongly opposed to the grating of the licence for more reasons that one.
The Rev. J. W. Stewart was also in attendance.
After a short consultation, the Chairman said that the Bench were divided, and that they would have to make a fresh application.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atter, E. | | Solicitor | |
| Dees, J. G. | | Magistrate | |
| Flynn, James | | Miners' Agent | |
| Greer, C. McGregor, Rev. | | Curate | |
| Hope, — | | Police Supt. | |
| Joyce, Walter | | Miner | |
| McGowan, William | | Magistrate | |
| Richards, T. | | Magistrate | |
| Sharp, Andrew | | Miners' Agent | |
| Snowden, Philip | | | |
| Steen, E. A., Rev. | | | |
| Stewart, J. W., Rev. | | | |
| Tinnon, William Shepherd | | Innkeeper | |