|
22nd July 1905, Page: 2, Column: 7 Bebside Pit DisasterThree Men KilledPathetic ScenesIn the early hours of Saturday morning, a disastrous accident, resulting in the loss of the lives of three strong young men. occurred at Bebside Pit. Advantage had been taken of the holidays to extend the haulage system or engine plane, and a number of deputies and others were engaged with the work, which was under the supervision of the manager, Mr. Davis. A "sheave" wheel had been erected at a curve in the road, and several men and two boys were near it when it was being tried. For a few minutes the wheel went all right, and Robt. Bland, a skilled mechanic, who was engaged with the work, expressed his satisfaction with the result, little reckoning that he was on the verge of entering upon a period Of excruciating suffering in a living tomb by the fall of the fatal wheel. The place where the men stood was full of timber recently erected. The roof, which was "blue," was bad, and it was spanned by iron girders. Suddenly the wheel collapsed, bringing down the timber and iron beams, burying up three men, Joseph McLean, a deputy, and Wm. Grand, a deputy, both of whom were killed on the spot, and were mercifully spared the torture which the unfortunate mechanic Bland was fated to endure before death came to him at his home. Another deputy named Davison, who was standing between McLean and Grand when the fall took place, jumped clear of the falling timber and escaped without injury. The alarm was given and a message sent to Mr. Jobling, who arrived on his bicycle, and was soon down the pit directing the operations, and did not hesitate to strip off his clothing and take a hand at the dangerous and heartrending work of rescue. Grand's mangled body was soon recovered, but for over six hours did Bland languish and suffer. He was conscious all the time, though fatally injured. He was on his knees with his head and shoulders bound down by tons of debris. Throughout the long hours he was able to speak to the rescuers. During his incarceration two other falls came away. At the third fall the poor fellow lost heart, and said he felt he was done. He gave a message for his wife asking her to be kind to the bairns, to whom he was deeply attached. Mr. Robert Wilson, an official who had worked ceaselessly at the work of rescue from the first, succeeded in crawling under the debris and giving Bland a mouthful of brandy and afterwards to fix a leather strap around his body, by means of which he was drawn out. Dr. Fairlie, who had descended the pit to minister to the injured, was with the rescuers ready for service. He found Bland terribly injured, suffering from compression of the nerves and shock, as well as other injuries. He administered morphia, and Bland was taken to bank. He recovered so as to speak to his family and was able to talk a pit, and to raise himself up in bed, but about 7 p.m. he took suddenly ill and succumbed. A pathetic scene was witnessed on his arrival home. His little girl toddled up to him and said "Kiss me daddy, you were a long time coming." The Inquest. No Negligence. The inquest on the three victims of the disaster, Grand, Bland, and McLean, was held at the Bebside Inn on Monday. Mr. H. T. Rutherford conducted the inquiry. Mr. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector, was present, also Mr. T. E. Jobling, Mr. Kenneth Davis (manager), Mr. G. Dunn (engineer), Mr. Howe (under manager), Mr. S. Coulthard and Mr. Michael Miller (representatives of the Northumberland Deputies Mutual Aid Society), Mr. Hugh Hills, and Mr. Robert Grand (local miners' inspectors). Thomas Fenwick, brother of Mr. Charles Fenwick, M.P., father-in-law of the deceased man Grand, gave identifying evidence and said that Grand was 31 years of age, and was a deputy. Joseph McLean, overman, identified the deceased, Joseph McLean, as his son. He was 28 years of age, and a deputy. Robert Bland, of Benwell, the father of the deceased Robert Bland, identified the deceased, and said he was a colliery joiner, aged 34. Deceased expired at his house at 8 p.m. on Saturday. Wm. Davison, whose face bore evidence of slight injuries, said that on Saturday morning they were busy making a new road for the engine plane. The three men deceased, and witness, about 2.30 a.m., were sitting near the wheel waiting to see the set tried. They were sitting "cracking" when the accident occurred. When the set started to run they were watching the wheel, and Bland, the mechanic, remarked that he had never seen a new wheel run so well. Witness remarked that they should move back a little for fear the set should get off the way, and they were in the act of moving back when the accident occurred. Witness "fancied" he saw the wheel go wrong, and he heard a cry from the others and the roof came away. The other three men were buried, and witness was buried up to the knees, but managed to get clear. He was between McLean and Grand. He had not a very clear recollection how he managed to escape. H.M. Inspector: The engine is worked by an endless rope ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: Then the tail-rope in-bye begins ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: Was the tail-end haulage being extended a hundred yards or so ? Witness. Yes, two hundred perhaps. H.M. Inspector : And as it was pay week end you had been busy with the work from Friday night ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: There is a rope called the tail rope which goes round the sheave and pulls the empty tubs in-bye and which also takes the main rope in with it ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: When there is a curve it is necessary that there should be a wheel or sheave to take the rope around ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: It is about four feet in diameter ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: How was the sheave secured ? Witness: I cannot say. I did not work there. H.M. Inspector: What happened to cause the sheave to be pulled out of its place ? Witness: It was pulled out by the strain on the rope. H.M. Inspector: You cannot tell us what caused the strain on the rope ? Witness: No, I cannot. H.M. Inspector: How was the roof supported ? Witness: By props and iron girders. H.M. Inspector: And when the wheel fell it would catch the timber and knock them out ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: Can you tell me how many girders fell ? Witness: No, I cannot. H.M. Inspector: Do you know if the engineman who works this rope saw the road beforehand ? Witness: Yes; I saw him down the new road that night. H.M. Inspector: The engine that works this rope in a long distance away ? In the Yard Seam ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector: Was the roof bad where the accident occurred ? Witness: No; it was not supposed to be a bad roof. H.M. Inspector: After the first fall there were more falls; in fact the stone continued to fall. Is that so ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector : How near to you was the set when the accident occurred ? Witness: About thirty yards out-bye. H.M. Inspector : Then the set had hardly got on to the new road ? Witness: No, it had not then reached the new road. H.M. Inspector : Was it going at an ordinary speed or slower than it usually goes ? Witness: It was going slower than usual. H.M. Inspector : Something you might expect with a trial set ? Witness: Yes. H.M. Inspector : What means of signalling to the engineman was there ? Witness: There were electric bells. H.M. Inspector : Were they all in order ? Witness: Yes, the bells were all right so far as I know. James Howe, under manager, was the next witness. He said he came in and heard shouting. That was about 2.30 on Saturday morning. On going in he found the wheel down and the roof down. The deceased men were buried under the fall. Witness and the overman, McLean, and others commenced to set timber, as the root was all on a move and in danger of falling. They then commenced to get out the men. Grand was first got out, and then they set about getting Bland out, who was alive. Bland was got out about 9 a.m. Bland did not say anything as to how the accident occurred, but spoke a little, telling them where he felt injured. Mr. Atkinson: Can yon tell how the wheel was secured ? Witness: It was a horizontal wheel, the axle was vertical. Asked to describe the wheel further. Howe said it was secured by two baulks of timber which were bolted at each end. The wheel was set three inches into the roof and also into the floor of the mine. The frame lay on the floor. Bland superintended the setting of the wheel. Bland was a first-class workman, in whom they had every confidence. From what witness had seen of the work he thought it was a good job. Questioned further by Mr. Atkinson, witness said that when he was in the set he found the rope fly up. That would be after the fall. The tail rope was broken out-bye. He found that the tail rope in the in-bye part if the sheave had got off a hanging sheave and jammed between the hanging sheave and the hanger. The two hangers were bent out-bye, showing there had been considerable force. Mr. Atkinson: At the point where the rope was jammed there was a socket, and although the rope might run between the sheave and the hanger the socket could not run ? Witness said that was so. Mr. Atkinson: And this would cause a very severe strain on the sheave at the curve ? Witness: Yes. Mr. Atkinson: Enough to pull the wheel out ? Witness: Yes. Mr. Atkinson : And that would be the real cause of the accident? Witness: Yes, that is it in my opinion. Mr. Atkinson: Is there any reason why these sheaves could not be erected to prevent this ? Witness said he knew of no other form of rollers. Mr. Atkinson: How many tubs were on the set ? Witness: Thirty three empties. Mr. Atkinson : And is there a dip in-bye ? Witness: Yes. Mr. J. B. Nicholson (a juror) : Do you attribute this as the only cause of the accident ? Witness: Yes. The Inspector said he could not see any difficulty in constructing sheaves so that the rope would not come off. Asked by the Inspector how it came that the rope broke out-bye witness said he thought the sheave gave way first, and as the engine was in motion it would mean the breaking of the rope. In reply to Mr. S. Coulthard, Seghill (Deputies Societies representative), witness said the props set near the wheel were adjuncts of the wheel. The local inspectors were called, Messrs. Robert Grand and Hugh Hills. Grand was called first, but when Mr. Rutherford learned that he was a relative of one of the victims, he chose the evidence of Hills. The Coroner asked for a written report, but there was not one. He told the inspectors that they should have brought a written report and to write one when they got home, which they promised to do. Hills was then sworn, and stated that he and Grand went down the pit and inspected the place after the accident had occurred. They found it was a pure accident, and no one was to blame so far as they were aware. In reply to Mr. Jobling, Hills said that as local inspectors they had examined that part of the pit so late as Thursday. The wheel was then erected, but they had not made any examination of it. The Coroner said what the jury had to consider was whether everything was in order, whether there had been any negligence on the part of the managers. It was a very sad case, and they must all express their sympathy with the relatives of the poor men killed, and likewise with the owners, for it was a very serious thing for them also. The jury did not retire, but deliberated for some time, after which the foreman, Mr. Geo. Rutherford, said there was one thing the jury was in doubt about, and that was whether there had been sufficient care exercised in securing the sheave. Though there might have been an error in judgment, the jury did not think there had been any negligence. The Coroner then recorded the verdict, "that the deceased men were accidentally killed by a fall of roof caused through the tail rope and a wheel frame giving way and displacing the supports of the roof." The Funeral. Not during the half century that Bebside was been a colliery, has there been such a spectacle as was witnessed on Tuesday, when the funerals of the victims took place. Bland was taken to Benwell Cemetery, where he was buried beside his brother, who was also the victim of a pit accident. Mrs. Bland and the children go to reside with deceased's father at Benwell. To enable the workmen to attend the funerals of McLean and Grand the pit was started and closed two hours earlier. Many thousands of people were in the village when Mr. Davies commenced to carry out the funeral arrangements. The remains of the two unfortunate men were taken inside the Primitive Methodist Church, where a memorial service was conducted by the Rev. Thos. Robson, minister of the Primitive Methodist circuit, and the Rev. Mr. Cumberland (Wesleyan.) During a short discourse Mr. Robson referred to the sudden disaster which they had fallen upon the place. The life's work of their departed brothers could be seen by all. Henry Grand, in that little Wesleyan mission, had worked almost alone in God's cause. How much the children of Bebside had lost by his death ! and how sorely that church which he represented would feel his loss ! Brother McLean had revelled in the services of praise in God's house a week ago. Little did they think that before another Sabbath he would be taken from their midst. They could comfort themselves with the thought that the last Sabbath of his earthly life he was at the service ion God's house. Both churches had been stricken by their death. During the solemn delivery of the above there were general manifestations of sorrow. Messrs. Burt And Fenwick's Message The following letter was read from Messrs. Burt and Fenwick, dated from the Library of the House of Commons :— "Fellow workmen, — It is with feelings of deepest sympathy and regret that we learn of the lamentable accident that has resulted in the loss of three valuable lives, and inflicting injuries of a more or less serious character on others. This accident, coming so soon after the great mining calamity in Wales, emphasises the hazardous nature of the miner's occupation. We desire to convey to you our sympathy in the loss of your comrades, and to assure you of our heartfelt sympathy and condolence for the widows and families, and wish the injured may have a speedy recovery. The Dead March. The organ, which had been untouched since played on by the late organist, Mr. McLean, was used by Mr. Henry, South Shields, who played the "Dead March." The dense mass of people formed into a great procession to Horton, where the remains of the deceased were interred. There was a large number of wreaths, amongst which were two beautiful ones from the mechanics, officials, and friends. Mr. Davies, Bedlington, carried out the arrangements for the whole of the funerals with becoming order and facility. Mayor Of Blackpool's Sympathy. The Mayor of Blackpool (Ald. Brodie), who was in his early life a workman at Bebside Colliery, telegraphed :— "Please convey the best sympathy of the Mayoress and myself with the widows and children of the men who lost their lives in the colliery accident." Mr. John Mouter telegraphed the following reply :— "Your sympathetic message has been conveyed to the widows and friends of the three unfortunate men who lost their lives through the accident, and on whose behalf I beg to thank you for your kindly feelings expressed therein."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||