|
12th May 1905, Page: 8, Column: 7 Gowerton Pit DisasterOwners and Managers Summoned at SwanseaAlleged Defective Ventilation: Case DismissedAt Swansea on Wednesday Messrs. Baldwins, Ltd., Stockport, owners of the Elba Colliery, Gowerton, were summoned for a breach of the first general rule of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1877, which provides that adequate ventilation should be provided. There was a similar summons against Herbert Griffiths, the colliery manager. Mr. Arthur Lewis (instructed by Mr. Talfourd Strick on behalf of the Home Office) prosecuted; Mr. Abel Thomas, K.C., M.P., represented the owners; and Mr. S. T. Evans, K.C., M.P., the manager. Col. J. R. Wright was present in court, and considerable interest was manifested in the hearing, which took place in the Crown Court. It was agreed to take both cases together. Mr. Arthur Lewis said their Worships would probably remember that on January 22nd a disastrous explosion occurred at the Elba Colliery, Gowerton, with the result that eleven people were either killed on the spot or died shortly after, and five were injured. The allegation of the prosecution was that sufficient ventilation had not been provided to "render harmless noxious gases" in the mine. The owner and manager were both liable. They had to do in this case only with the workings in the six-foot seam. Having described the system of ventilation used at the Elba Colliery, he explained there were too many working places for the air which was coming to ventilate these properly, and said it would be shown that the system was a faulty one. This state of things ought to have been known to the owner and manager. Wm. Henry Jones, day foreman, said he had been employed at the colliery for six or seven years. The colliers were working a double shift — began at 7 and left off at 4. Proceeding, witness spoke to throttling up a pipe in No. 5 tophole a day before the explosion so as to get more pressure of air in No. 4 tophole. The ventilation, however, was good. Cross-examined by Mr. Abel Thomas, witness said that the company and the men did their very best to observe the colliery regulations. Answering Mr. S. T. Evans, witness said the withdrawal of men had nothing to do with the condition of No. 5 tophole; it was simply done to push on the work in No. 4, but the men could not have gone on working if the pipe had not been throttled. Re-examined by Mr. Arthur Lewis: There was no natural ventilation, but the place having been idle he thought there was sufficient air there. John Davies, night fireman, said he did nothing to create ventilation in No. 5 tophole, where he had found gas within four feet of the entrance. The men did not go in, but after No. 4 tophole had been got through nothing was done to clear the gas in No. 5, as witness did not believe the gas was accumulating. By Mr. Abel Thomas: The explosion must have been caused by a naked light. Replying to Mr. S. T. Evans, witness added that he took all the precautions possible when striking out No. 4 tophole into No. 6 level. He thought the ventilation so good that he even sent in his own father among other men, and he was killed by the explosion. Re-examined: The cause of the gas in No. 5 tophole was due to the absence of air, but, added the witness, the pipes sometimes choked themselves. Mines Inspector Robson characterised the means of ventilating the level in question (No. 7 west) as an attempt to do too much with the amount of ventilation. "They had too many working places, and too far in for the amount of air ; it was a complete breakdown," witness said. Had there been adequate ventilation there could have been no accumulation of gas and therefore no explosion. The whole district should have been stopped. By Mr. Abel Thomas: Inadequate ventilation was the cause of every accumulation, but it did not follow that colliery managers ought to be fined because of a resulting explosion. Counsel put it that the evidence went to show that the colliery officials wanted to be extra cautious in No. 4 tophole, and consequently withdrew the men from No. 5 to complete it. Witness: Yes, but they made a mistake by sending them back again. Counsel: Are not you like the rest of us — wise after the event? Witness: Of course we are all wise after the event, but I should have been wise before if I had seen that place. I would not have had 20 yards of tophole full of gas. In cross-examination by Mr. S. T. Evans witness said he regarded as a "working place" any tophole that might be crossed off to indicate that it was dangerous for an innocent person to enter it. It still came within the officials' inspection. Mr. S. T. Evans: What authority have you for that? Witness: Common sense. Frederick Grey, mines inspector for the Cardiff district, said the system of ventilation in question was inadequate. This was the case for the prosecution. Case Against Owners Dismissed. Mr. Abel Thomas asked the Bench to say there was, upon the evidence, no case against the owners who had done everything they could to have the colliery carried on properly. Mr. S. T. Evans made the same point for the manager, who could not, any more than the owners, see that everything done was absolutely perfect. Assuming there was an error of judgment in stopping the ventilation in No. 5 tophole in order that No. 4 might be rapidly driven and so shorten the pipes, did not amount to any offence against the manager or the owners. The Bench deliberated in private for ten minutes, when Mr. Powell said: The Bench are of opinion that there is no case against the owners, but with regard to the manager they would like to hear evidence. The case against the owners is dismissed. Mr. S. T. Evans said he would call the manager. Counsel first of all urged that the manager could not be held criminally responsible for an error of judgment on the part of anyone under him. Herbert Griffiths, manager of the Elba Colliery, stated that he left the pit on the morning of January 20th, about twelve hours before the explosion occurred and saw the report of the day fireman to the effect that there was no gas, ventilation good, and the whole place in good working order. The night fireman's report showed presence of gas in No. 5 tophole, but this he did not hear of till after the accident. Apart from the temporary blocking of the ventilation in No. 7 level west — which witness did not know of till after the explosion — the ventilation of the colliery was precisely the same as before and no difficulties had been experienced not even when shot-firing was done. The colliery was ventilated by 8,783 cubic feet of air per minute, and that, in witness's opinion was adequate. By Mr. Arthur Lewis: He did not approve of the partial blocking of the airway by the night fireman, who might, however, be perfectly conscientious in what he did. What do you think brought about the explosion? — The throttling of the pipe. And that you don't approve of? — No. Witness admitted that he did not usually go down the colliery with the night shift, and did not think it necessary in the present instance, because gas had been reported on one or two occasions some days before. If the ventilation had been continued in No. 7 Level the explosion might never have occurred. Answering Mr. W. F. Richards, witness said it was usual in the South Wales collieries to send men into a level even if gas were reported in a particular tophole. John Morris, M.E., colliery manager, John Joseph Noyle, manager of Broad Oak Colliery, and Albert Harding, manager of Cae Duke Colliery, Loughor, gave expert evidence, asserting that if the ventilation had remained as the colliery manager had left it, it would have been adequate. John Austin, one of the workmen who was down in the pit at the time of the explosion, was also called and he said that he was working in No. 6 tophole when he heard a noise as of rushing wind. Looking down, he saw the level full of flame, and crawling on his hands and knees beneath the fire, he got to a place of safety. Case Against The Manager Fails. This was all the evidence, and the Bench, after retirement, held that ventilation up to the time the manager left the pit was adequate after he left the fireman in charge committed an error of judgment in throttling the pipe, which probably prevented adequate ventilation. The summons was dismissed. Mr. Arthur Lewis wanted to know if the Bench meant that the manager was absolved from a duty that was cast upon him. There had been a contravention of the rules on the part of the fireman, and he desired the Bench to state a case. The Bench declined to discuss their decision. The Clerk: You had better apply in writing in the usual course.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||