|
6th April 1905 Socialist Labour Candidate[To The Editor Of The Whitehaven News.] Sir, Might I state as briefly as possible in reply to your correspondent, Mr. Hoskin, that if he had given Mr. Duffy the advice he freely offers me, there would have been no necessity for advising me to be gentlemanly, to an opponent. But is Mr. Hoskin free from this malady? With one great stroke of his pen, myself, with parsons, laymen, brewers, and slum poverty owners, are victims of his wild language. It is evident Mr. Hoskin is suffering from the contagion of that Socialistic meeting. It is a case of evil communications corrupting good manners, and in future both of us will have to abstain from all appearance of evil, especially if it is a meeting to be addressed by Gavan Duffy. It is true Mr. Duffy said he wished to avoid personalities, and yet in the next breath he denounced with all his power men of wealth and did not hesitate to say that Mr. Helder belonged to that class. Then again he made sneering remarks about the Liberal candidate's university career. I think it is a case of what I have said, I have not said. No, sir, I have no objection whatever to a stranger candidate, providing he treats his opponents (in Mr. Hoskin's language) in a gentlemanly fashion, and this is a general opinion of a good many people who were present at the meeting - that he overstepped the limits of fair criticism is beyond question. Mr. Hoskin has got terribly mixed up about my views of politics and social evils. If Mr. Hoskin will kindly read my first letter again he will find that I am not referring to all the social evils as is evidenced by the illustration I gave of the men to whom I alluded. I am free to admit that environment is a powerful factor, and there is no doubt about it, that people who have to live in slum poverty (called houses for decency's sake) has a demoralising effect. But on the other hand, you have men who are living under the very best surroundings, with wealth to support them, doing exactly the same kind of misdeeds as those to whom you refer who are living in slum poverty, so that it is evident if we want to reform men's lives, both rich and poor, we must begin with the inward man and it will follow as a natural consequence, it will soon manifest outwardly. Let men live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world, as they are instructed to do so by the Greatest Socialist that ever lived, and you will have put an end to a good many of the social evils to which we are subject at present. This principal, if acted upon, is far before any of the latter day quack nostrums, and no honoured position he occupies, which is second to none in responsibility, would do well to impress this fact upon the minds of men, and steer clear of questionable surroundings. He would do well to examine his chart, and take his bearings, as it is possible that he might be out of his course. Verbum Sat Sapienti. Now, Sir, I come more to the political aspect of the case. Mr. Hoskin gives a quotation from a Liberal newspaper about the attitude of Liberals to the crying evils of poverty, &c. Does this very fact not prove that it is all nonsense for Socialists to say that there is no difference between the two parties (Liberal and Tory)? Does this very fact not prove that the Liberal party are fully alive to these grievances, and that they are pledged to carry out measures which will remove a great many of these evils, and is it not a fact that you, sir, have been emphasising this in your columns time and again, that the Liberal candidate goes every inch so far as Mr. Duffy upon these matters? That being the case there is no need for Mr. Duffy's candidature. I notice that a public appeal is being made for the Labour Parliamentary Fund. Working men will be wise if they spend their money on bread and clothes, instead of wasting it upon a forlorn hope. And the Labour party would be acting wisely if they withdrew Mr. Duffy in favour of the Liberal candidate. Anything short of this is a political suicide. Sir, on reading through the columns of another newspaper I found there was another correspondent replying to my first letter which appeared in your valuable journal. That he must be ignorant of the rules of correspondence is evident to all. However, Mr. Editor, as there is some very important items which require the light of day upon them, you will be doing a public service if you will kindly insert my reply to him. It is evident that he has the bump of imagination very large, by the rash statements he makes. Surely he must also have been affected by that meeting. There is no knowing to what extent the evil that has been wrought, through the effects of that meeting. May we venture to hope there will be no more for some considerable time? No, I am in way connected with the Liberal Association, so that to use Mr. Hoskin's words there was no need for his ungentlemanly remarks. With regard to the vast proportions of the Labour League that he would have us believe it has, this is very questionable. Why do the heathen rage and men imagine a vain thing?" Now, sir, he refers to the miners' representative and his representation, which is also very questionable as I will show. I am informed by members of the Miners' Union that half of the miners are not now in the Union and having a knowledge of their meetings, there would not be more than a third of the other half present at the branch meeting when this matter was brought before the meeting. Then again, take again, the Engineers' Society; they probably have a membership of about 40, mostly single young men, and men from the outlying districts, such as Frizington, Cleator Moor, Distington, and Parton, who have no voice in the borough, and in this case as in the other there probably would be 12 or 15 present when this action was presented to them. Then what about the musicians with its membership of one, and that one hails from Workington, and the postmen with its membership of two, and then I think we have arrived at the total of this great army? Now if this is not assuming power I should like to know what is. Now I challenge the labour representatives to take a vote by ballot of their members, and then forward to the press for public inspection, and then we will be able to judge whether they have the right to assume such a power. I question this right for the reason that I have been informed by various trade unionists that they do not agree with their programme. It does seem, Mr. Editor, such rank audacity for these men to try and get a trump card on the question of Home Rule, and yet want to deprive Whitehaven electors of the right to manage their own Parliamentary affairs, by bringing men from the above places, and others to dictate to us who we are to have as our representative at Westminster. He makes a comparison with former and present candidates. Why there is no comparison. But it just shows how men can he led astray with words coming from a man on the same principal as words come from a gramophone. He does not consider with what labour and trouble Mr. Duffy would have, in committing to memory his half-dozen so called lectures, which he will handle better with so much repetition. In concluding, I may state there are many things to which he refers, that have my sympathy and, approval. Let men of all classes put into daily life and practice what the greatest of all Socialists teaches, love to God as the Father of all and men as brethren, and you have the key of the situation. — Thanking you again, sir. Verbum Sat Sapienti.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||