23rd March 1905
Miners' "Beat Hands"
A Question In Compensation Law
It appeared from a case under the Compensation Act., at Newcastle, last week, that miners suffer occasionally from what they call "Beat Hands" — that is, hands which are injuriously affected by the jarring or friction of the pick, or the
tight pressure of the hands and fingers while using it; and two miners claimed compensation for this injury as an "accident." For the respondents it was contended that "beat hands" are not an accident, but are simply developed in the
ordinary course of employment; while on behalf of the claimants the decision of Lord Naughton was quoted, in which it was held that every physiological injury sustained by a man in the ordinary course of his employment is an accident.
Judge Greenwell, in giving judgment for the respondents, said it was admitted that these "beat hand?" and knees are more likely to occur to men out of condition than others, and he held that they were not accidents. There was no
un-locked for mishap, and the injury arose naturally, though not necessarily, in the course of ordinary employment.
It was stated that both the Miners' Association and the employers desire to obtain a decision of the Court of Appeal on the point.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Greenwell, — | | Judge | |
| Naughton, Lord | | Judge | |