|
17th February 1905, Page: 7, Column: 1 Gowerton DisasterDisquieting Revelations at the InquestMatches and Cigarette Boxes Found in the MineAnd Contrivances for Opening Safety Lamps The adjourned inquest on the eleven victims of the colliery explosion that took place on the night of January 20th, at the Elba Colliery, near Gowerton, was opened on Friday morning at the Gowerton Rechabites Hall, before Mr. F. H. Glynn Price, District Coroner, and a jury. The names of the deceased men, it will be remembered, were as follows :— William Davies (60), Penclawdd. Edward Rees (26), Penclawdd. Alec Ogilvey (19), Gowerton. William Bowen (16), Three Crosses. D. J. Rees (24), Three Crosses. George Rees (23), Penclawdd. W. H. Morgan (18), Penclawdd. Thomas Pratt (18), Penclawdd. Dan Davies (26), Penclawdd. John Long, Three Crosses. George Williams (14), Penclawdd. H.M. inspector of Mines (Mr. Robson) and Mr. Talfourd Strick (representing the Home Office) sat at the same table as the Coroner, and there were also present: Mr. J. C. Woods (Messrs. Collins and Wood), who appeared for the owners of the colliery; Messrs. Baldwins, Ltd., of whom Col. J. R. Wright, the chairman, was present in person; the Western Miners' Association, by Mr. John Williams; Mr. Denman Benson appeared for Mr. David Randell (Messrs. Randell and Saunders), who is acting for the workmen; and Mr. W. P. Smith watched the interests of the Provident Clerks' Insurance Company. Police-inspector Edwards, of Gowerton, had the arrangements in hand, and Mr. David Thomas was foreman of the Jury. The Coroner intimated that it would be sufficient to take all the details in reference to the deceased man Alec Ogilvey, as that evidence would be found to apply, with slight variations, to all the other cases. Plan Of The Workings. Mr. G. E. Gordon, mining engineer, Swansea, explained an independent survey plan of the underground workings of the Elba Colliery he made subsequent to the accident, and said that eight of the deceased men were fouud in No. 7 level (west) and the other three at No. 3 tophole. By Mr. Benson: Whilst he was there on the 24th January, the body of Edward Rees was found under a large fall that had taken place in the tophole of No. 3 stall. The extent of the fall was about 20 yards. A fall indicates disturbed ground? — The ground is generally weaker where there is a fall. And apt to contain gas? — I do not say it is always the case. Further questioned, witness said there was a very slight fall in No. 7 level, and that certain of the doors and air pipes had been blown away. Mine Manager's Story. Herbert Griffiths, of Gowerton, for nearly twelve months past the manager of Elba Colliery, for five years the under-manager of the Foxhole Collieries, Bonymaen, and having served as overman and fireman at the Glamorgan Collieries, Llwynypia, was next sworn. He obtained his mine manager's certificate in 1900. The slant of the Elba Colliery was 700 yards, and the average dip 16in. to the yard. The output of the colliery was aoout 120 tons per day, and the average number of men employed 47 for each of two shifts. On the 20th, it being pay-day, the night shift practically followed the day shift, this being the custom, and the men went down about 4.30 and were to come up at one o'clock on the morning of the 21st. So far as he knew, the explosion occurred at about 12.45 a.m. The colliery was ventilated by means of a fan, and the Bonnetted Clany locked lamp — one of the best in the market — was used. The lamps were kept in the lamproom, and were regularly cleaned and examined by the lampman. They were given to colliers as they went down screwed up but not locked. The locking was done at No. 6 east drift station. You could not tell whether on the night in question the lamps were given out in order? I suppose the lampman will tell us that as you were not there perhaps? - He is supposed do it. Witness added that there was a separate lamp for each person employed at the colliery, and a register was kept of its number. On the morning of the 20th he examined both No. 6 and 7 levels west and found everything in good working order. No. 5 tophole was stopped as efforts were being made to get more ventilation into No. 4. Was there much coal-dust floating about on the levels? — Nothing much ; a little in the face. Except when you were driving a hard heading or drift explosives were not used? — No. And had there been any shot firing going on during that night? — Yes, sir. Where was that? — In the face of No. 7 east. Was it more than one shot? — I could not tell you ; I daresay there were two or three. At that spot? — Yes, sir. What was the nature of the work? — Driving on the level. What explosive was used? — Saxonite. Who fired the shot? — The fireman ; there is only one night fireman, and he has charge of those operations. How many yards would those shots have been fired from No. 7 level west, where the explosion had the greatest effect.? — About 250 yards. Witness proceeded to say that he was at the colliery about half-an-hour after the explosion, and that at that time two dead bodies and all the injured had been removed. He immediately went down into the mine. The bottom of the slant was not affected by the explosion, and the first thing he noticed was a tram off the road near No. 3 tophole. Men were then working at a fall, and at a spot where the boy Bowen was expected to be, as he attended the trammers, the body was afterwards found. He could not say if there was any gas in No. 5 or No. 6 topholes. He found nothing wrong in No. 6 level, and the air was coming up through Nos. 3 and 4 topholes, but did not go through the pipes in No 6 because the brattice door was down as a result of the explosion. The roof, bottom, and sides of the main drift were very wet and it was his belief that this checked the advance of the explosion. The coal dust helped the explosion. It is rather an interesting point, but do you think the explosion was caused — of course there are many theories — by coal dust or firedamp, or a mixture of both dust and firedamp? — I should say it was an explosion of gas, but I rather think that the coal dust helped it. Continuing, witness expressed the belief that the force of the explosion was greatest just inside No. 4 tophole, because the dust on the timber was more caked than elsewhere. Where do you think the gas came from? — I could not tell you unless it came from No. 5 tophole. Why from there more than any of the other topholes or the level? — Gas was reported there that night, and when I went round the second time on the day of the accident I found gas in No. 5 and 6 topholes and a little in No. 7 level. Do you think the fall occurred before or after the explosion? — After, because there were evidences of two of the deceased having been killed as they were coming down. After you recovered the bodies, you searched for the lamps? — Yes, sir. Did you find all of them — No sir. The exceptions? — The lamps of Thos. Pratt and Edward Rees. Two of the three men under the fall? — Yes, sir. Did you get the third man's lamp? — We had Daniel Davies's lamp. And what condition were they in? — In good order, sir. All locked? — Yes, sir ; to do justice to myself, I should say I did not examine them except two. The inspector examined them. You say you did not find two of the lamps? Did you find any parts of them? — No, sir. Matches, Pipes And A Cigarette Case. Previous to the explosion you did not find any matches, but after the explosion you found what? — I found a pipe (briar produced) in a coat pocket. In a coat hanging up somewhere? — Yes, sir, just between No 5 and No. 6 topholes. On the on the lower side of the level. And did you find any matches? — Yes, sir ; just about two yards from there, about No. 4 tophole on the lower side of the level, we found a waistcoat with six matches in it. In a box or loose? — Loose. Do you know whose waistcoat that was of your own knowledge? — I cannot say whose waistcoat it is. Do you know who owned the pipe? — Yes, sir. Who? — William Davies. One of the deceased men? — Yes. Did you find any more pipes or matches. — Yes, sir ; I found two more matches and an empty cigarette box in another waistcoat. I got the clothes here. This waistcoat was hanging up in the office on the surface of the colliery and had been taken off one of the deceased men. I do not know whose waist coat it is. Contrivance For Opening Safety Lamps. Did you find anything else — any more matches or cigarettes? — Yes, sir ; we went down to the joiner's shop to examine the bodies and we searched the clothing, and in the pocket of a coat that was on the body of Wm. Davies, but not Wm. Davies' coat, was this contrivance (a spiral sort of implement produced.) Who were the "We?" You and the firemen? — No, me, John Jones, the clerk, Inspector White, and several others were present. The coat did not belong to Wm. Davies ; do you know whom it did belong to? — Yes, sir, it belonged to Alec Ogilvey. Do you know what the implement would be likely to be used for? — Opening a lamp. Did you find anything else? — Yes, sir, in another coat that was amongst the clothing in the office. Can you identify that coat? — No, sir ; I found in it this implement. (Here witness produced a piece of wire bent in the shape of a hair pin). And what do vou think this instrument is used for? — As a key for opening and locking a lamp. Have you tried them to see whether they will? — Yes, sir. Did you find anything else? — No, sir. At this stage Inspector White and the foreman of the jury demonstrated how a locked lamp could be easily opened by means of the tools found on the clothing. An adjournment for luncheon followed. Witness was cross-examined by Mr. Benson, and he said that Wm. Davies' lamp was found locked, as were all the others that were found save one, and that could have been wrenched open because it was not properly locked. The two lamps not found were probably under the big fall. He repeated that he believed the fall took place after the explosion, but it was possible for the fall to occur just before, and for a lamp to have then got broken and thus caused the explosion. There was nowadays no danger with locked lamps, as where firedamp existed the light went out of its own accord. When gas was reported on the 19th in No. 4 tophole the men were drawn out. By Mr. Woods: The last report in the fireman's book that he (witness) saw stated that there was no gas at that time. A later report showing the presence of gas he did not see till the Tuesday following the accident. Assuming the explosion to have been caused by a broken lamp as a result of a fall in No. 3 tophole, he should have expected the doors to have been blown inwards, and not outwards, as was the case. In answer to Mr. Strick, witness said that Wm. Davies' body, when he saw it, had no waistcoat, and that the remains were found near to the spot at which the waistcoat containing the six matches was found. There was no overman nor under-manager, and in witness's absence the fireman was responsible for the proper working of the mnne. In addition to the fireman the hitcher kept a lamp-key so that he might give a light at the entrances to No. 6 or No. 7 levels if a lamp went out. Is it a right thing to give a light except at the lamp station? — Yes, sir. Is that in accordance with the rules of the Act? — Yes, it is on the down cast, sir. Do you know whether there was any smoking going on in the pit? — No, sir, I didn't. Never had any complaints made about it? — Nothing whatever. Witness, further questioned, said that two lamps, belonging to Preston and Rees Harries, who were down the mine on the day of the accident, were subsequently found in the office unlocked, but he could explain that. Mr. Robson interposed that witness had better not say anything on that point. Replying to the foreman, witness admitted that the men in the western district were not so willing to have their lamps examined as in the eastern part of the county. Day Fireman Called. Wm. Hy. Jones, of Penclawdd, the day fireman at the colliery, said that everything was in perfect order in the workings on the morning of the 20th. By Mr. Robson: He examined No. 5 tophole that morning (Jan. 20th) and it was quite clear right up to the face. The Coroner: Have you ever had any occasion to think that anybody ever took matches into the mine or anything by which they could open a lamp underground? Witness: No, sir, and no complaint was ever made. Witness further stated that in order to increase the ventilation in No. 4 tophole, he, acting from instructions by the manager, drew the men from No. 5 tophole and throttled the air pipes. When the night shift came on duty he told the night fireman of what he had done. By Mr. Benson: An entry of the night fireman's made on the night of the explosion which read "except a little gas in No. 3 tophole," must have referred to No. 5 tophole, which would be examined, even though it was closed. Mr. Strick put it to the witness that it would have been a proper thing to have examined No. 5 tophole, especially as the men had been drawn out, just before leaving the colliery. — Witness answered that he simply cautioned the men not to go there. The Coroner: Don't you think now that it would have been a good thing if you had gone in? Witness replied that the night fireman was coming in, and it was his duty to make the examination of the tophole. The foreman: Do you really say, Mr. Jones, that you never had trouble about the men taking down pipes and matches? Witness: Nothing whatever. Is it true or not that some of the men are known to be most reckless regarding matches? — Unawares to me entirely ; I never had any cause to be suspicious. You are sure of that? — I am certain of that. The Man In Charge At The Time. John Davies, for 2½ years the night fireman at the colliery, said that the night shift went down about 5 o'clock on the 20th January, witness going down with the men after he had locked and inspected the men's lamps on the surface. When below he inspected No. 6 level first and found everything all right. No. 7 level contained gas in No. 5 tophole. Was there much gas there? — Yes, pretty full, to within four feet of the level. Witness considered that it would take four or five hours for this quantity of gas to accumulate. He found no presence of gas anywhere else. Whilst making his inspection the men were left at the lamp station. He superintended operations for improving the ventilation, and then went to the eastward of the workings, where he was when the explosion took place. He would be about 100 yards away. He heard no report, but felt a heavy rush of air. He at once proceeded to the west levels, taking men with him. He called out, but got no reply, but on going further he received an answer from Thomas Bevan to a call. He then went to the rest of the men, and recognised all he saw except his father (Wm. Davies) who was among the killed. Have you formed any idea, as to why the explosion occurred? — No, sir; quite strange to me. I was satisfied with how I had left the place, except No. 5 tophole. Have you ever had occasion to think that matches were taken underground, or keys with which to open the lamps, or that smoking was done? — No, sir. Never? — No. And did you ever make any search of the men or take any steps to find out whether they took any of those things down? — No, sir. Then you must have been rather surprised to find from the investigation of these poor fellows' clothes that these things were taken down? — Yes, sir. Further questioned, the witness expressed the opinion that at the time he left to go to the eastwards the increased ventilation had not had a disturbing influence upon the gas in No. 5 tophole. But you never saw what was happening there after the new door was up? — No, sir. Cross-examined by Mr. Benson, witness said he warned all the night men of the danger because of gas in No. 5 tophole. Whilst he was there he smelt no smoke nor saw any sign, of an open lamp or a match struck. By Mr. Woods: His last inspection of the west level face was between the erection of the new door to the pulling down of the old door. Replying to Mr. Strick, witness said he did not remember whether he fired any shots that night in the east. He did not think he did. At this stage it was decided to adjourn the inquiry for six weeks, in order that all the injured men might attend.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 12 Mar 2023
|
Search |
|
|||