Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th January 1905

The Fatal Accident To A Hodbarrow Miner

Smothered By A Fall Of Wood And Metal

On Saturday afternoon an inquest was held at the Hodborrow Hospital, Millom, touching the death of a miner named William Crellin, who was fatally injured on the previous Thursday night. The inquest was held by Dr. Stoney (coroner), before a jury, consisting of Messrs. Geo. Hill (fore-man), R. A. Mitchell, H. D. Shardlow, A. H. Darvell, W. Jones, Edwin Dixon, G. H. Thompson, Wm. Richardson, Joseph Benn, Alfred Coward, Thomas Huggins, and W. B. Miles.

Samuel Northmore of 13, Cambridge-street, Millom, stated that he was a miner, and had worked along with the deceased and William Cartwright. He identified the body viewed by the jury as that of William Matthew Crellin, aged 39, who resided in Lonsdale-road, Millom. On Thursday evening he was working with the deceased and Cartwright on the afternoon shift. In the evening they were putting in a fork to keep up the headtree. They wore doing this work in the ordinary way about a quarter to nine o'clock. As they were lifting up the fork, the headtree fell out and buried Crellin.

The Coroner: There was something to make it fall out, was there not? — I could not say. I did not see anything to make it fall out

Was there not something else with it? — Yes, there were two poles and some metal.

Did the metal force the fork out? — No. the fork was not in. If it was, the head tree would not come out. The headtree came out, and about 2½ tons of metal.

Was the deceased quite covered up? — Yes, sir.

How long was he covered? — About ten minutes.

Was he dead when he was got out? — Yes, sir.

Did you hear anything of him after the fall? — No sir

Were yourself or Cartwright struck at all? — No, sir.

Can you explain how it was that Crellin was covered, and you and Cartwright were not? — Yes, Crellin was inside the fork, and we were on the outside. He was on the forebreast side, and we were on the outside.

If Crellin had any warning would he be able to get away? — Yes, sir.

There was no warning? — No, sir.

You had not seen the metal move at all? — No, sir.

Was there no noise, nor anything of that kind? — Not till after the fall, but not beforehand.

Do you know if Crellin was deaf? — A little bit.

It would not make any difference to him in this case? — No, sir.

Because you say there was no noise? — No, sir, none whatever.

This completed the Coroner's examination, and Mr. Leck, Government Inspector, then questioned the witness.

Mr. Leck: I would like you, Mr. Northmore, to give us an idea of the character of that work, what kind of working it was, and what you were doing? — At the time, sir?

What kind of work was this you were engaged on? — Slipping'

Slipping a pillar? — Yes, sir.

In that case there would be one side open? — Yes, sir.

Were you driving to meet any other company? — Yes, we were, to meet our mates.

Had you met them? — We had meet them before there was a hole.

The place was holed? — Yes.

This pillar you were sliping or slicing was about what width? — Eleven feet.

And your mates were at the other end coming to meet you? — Yes.

Was there any timbering between your mates and you? — Yes.

What? — The two holes were covered over with poles.

What kind of poles? — Eight foot poles of six inch larch.

So that it was all covered over at the time? — Yes. sir.

This headtree on the open side what had it beneath? — A fork.

What length of fork? — Eight feet.

And on the other side there was? — A six inch hitch.

Had any official been in to your shift? — Yes, sir, Captain Strike.

Anyone else? — Yes, the woodman.

Captain Strike visited you about what time? — Ten minutes to five or five o'clock.

Was this headtree in at the time he visited you? — Yes

And was the fork in on the other side? — Yes.

But at the time he visited you the fork could not be put in? — No.

How many holes did you fire? — Three.

What time? — About a quarter past five.

Before bait time? — Yes.

After the holes were fired did you make an examination? — Cartwright did.

Was anything said about the changed character of the ground? — No, nothing whatever.

You thought that it was all right? — Yes.

Did you notice after you examined the ground after the accident that there was a slide or a break to let the headtree down? — No.

Can you tell us was above the headtree? — Metal on the pillar side.

Right in the centre? — Only wood.

Old wood? — Yea.

Then if this old wood was above the headtree I take it that there would be very little weight? — Very little.

Is that old wood that supports the roof standing yet? — Yes.

Then in that case there would not be a deal of weight on the headtree? — Very little.

Had you any middle fork in at the pillar end? — No.

I suppose, if you had noticed that the headtree was likely to give way you would have done this? — We would have put a middle fork in.

Did the timber man make any suggestion as to what you had to do about the timbering? — No, sir, and when Capt. Strike came he said "I think it is looking all right."

Therefore you did not think that there was any necessity to put in a middle fork? — No, sir.

Did any of the timber or this headtree break? — No, it simply fell.

And at the time of the accident you were actually putting the fork in? — Yes.

After the fall did your lights got blown out? — No.

Was there any more falls after the first? — No.

So you immediately attempted to get deceased out? — Yes.

Was he covered entirely? — Yes.

Was he dead when you got him out? — Yes.

Were there ambulance men about? — Yes, sir.

Did they make an examination at the time? — Yes.

But, of course, they could do nothing? — No.

Mr. Hill asked if the fact of the 2½ ton coming on the headtree did not make it fall away? — I don't think so. The hitch gave way, and this brought the headtree down.

Mr. Leck: There was nothing done with the place from the time they got the man out until I saw it? — No, sir.

William Cartwright, miner, residing at Poolside, Haverigg, and engaged at the Hodbarrow mines, said that on Thursday evening he along with the last witness and the deceased were engaged in cleaning out the ore before the accident happened. At the time of the accident they were lifting up a fork in order to put it in under the headtree. They were just in the act of lifting the fork up when the headtree fell along with poles and four bogies of metal. Crellin was covered up, and would be under the stuff from six to ten minutes. He was dead when they got him out. At the time of the accident Crellin was stooping to fit in the foot of the fork. He was inside the headtree, and was in a stooping position when the stuff came down. There was no sound or warning whatever, and there was no sign of the metal moving.

Examined by Mr. Leck: Did it occur to any of you to put in a middle fork? — We did not think that it needed it.

I suppose that it is a quite common practice to put one in? — Yes, if we think that it is needed.

That is if there is not a good hitch? — Yes.

But you believed that this hitch was a good one? — Yes.

As soon as the accident happened did you notice if there was face or slip back to let this ore away? — No.

Did you notice if it came from a slippery side? — It was just the ordinary character of ore.

How long before the accident was it before you fired the holes? — They would be fired about 20 minutes to six.

After you fired the holes did you make an examination? — Yes, I tried it with the pick, and it seemed to be good then. How long before the accident? — Twenty minutes before that, and then we went to put two forks on the main road outside.

How long would it be before you would have this fork in? — Half a minute would have done it.

And if you thought that there was any danger you would have put it in before you put the two outside? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: What effect would it have if the fork was put in? — It would have kept the headtree and ground up.

So you say in half a minute? — We would have it up.

Mr. Leck: So the accident would not have happened if that was done? — It would have prevented that.

Did you get him out without help? — No, as soon as we heard the fall we called for help.

How far were the others away? — Three or four yards only.

Captain Strike, Steel Green, examined by Mr. Leck, said that he knew the working where the accident happened. It was No. 55 working, and during the day he had been to see it. This would be about five o'clock, and he then considered that the work was thoroughly satisfactory, and that everything was perfectly safe. They could not put another fork in when he saw the place, and he never questioned the soundness of the hitch. The roof above the headtree was old wood, and would be interlaced, there having been five heights previously worked over it. When he saw the place after the accident he only noticed that one piece of timber had come away. The rest of it had formed a firm roof. One of the timber men had been in the same evening, and his duty was to inspect the place, and if they did not consider it safe to see that more timber was put in. Their duty was in that respect precisely the same as his own. Every working place was examined each day. In fact they were always examined some time during a shift.

Mr. Leck: I believe that you have a good many ambulances men at Hodbarrow? — Yes. In this case the poor fellow was killed almost instantaneously so that the ambulance men would not be able to do anything.

I recognise, however, that you have a good staff at Hodbarrow, and I like to encourage it wherever possible.

With respect to what caused death, Mr. Strike said he saw the deceased laid out at the hospital. Someone had said that his shoulder was broken, but he was satisfied this was not so, but he considered that his neck was broken, as his head could not be kept steady.

Mr. Leck: As to the character of the deceased was he a capable workman?

Capt. Strike: Thoroughly.

And had been a long time there? — Yes, over 20 years, and he was a very good, capable workman, and very nice and steady.

The Coroner, in summing up, said he thought the jury would have no difficulty in coming to a conclusion as to the nature of the accident; and they could only give a verdict as regards the accident. They had the advantage of His Majesty's Inspector of Mines, who had very lucidly explained how the accident happened, and had been able to deal with the technical working of the mine. He did not know whether any of them were miners, but he confessed to not knowing much about it. It appeared that this headtree fell out without warning, and as far as could be seen nothing could be done to prevent it. One witness had told them that in half a minute the fork would have been in its place, and this accident could not then have happened. He thought that they would have no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that death was accidental. The man was probably suffocated from being covered up, but if they were satisfied that death was due to accidental causes that was sufficient.

Mr. Mitchell said that the evidence was given in a very straightforward manner.

Mr. Leck: Was there nothing done towards resuscitating him?

Mr. Strike: There was an attempt made.

The Foreman said after the lucid manner in which the evidence was given they could not come to any other conclusion than that death was purely accidental.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Benn, Joseph    Juror  
Cartwright, William    Miner  
Coward, Alfred    Juror  
Crellin, William Matthew   39 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Darvell, A. H.    Juror  
Dixon, Edwin    Juror  
Hill, George    Jury Foreman  
Huggins, Thomas    Juror  
Jones, W.    Juror  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Miles, W. B.    Juror  
Mitchell, —      
Mitchell, R. A.    Juror  
Northmore, Samuel    Miner  
Richardson, William    Juror  
Shardlow, H. D.    Juror  
Stoney, —, Dr.    Coroner  
Strike, —, Captain      
Thompson, G. H.    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
12 Jan 1905  The Fatal Accident To A Hodbarrow Miner, Smothered By A Fall Of Wood And Metal (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print