28th April 1904
Labour Problems
Need Of Organisation
Address By Mr. Flynn
A meeting of the Moor Row Branch of the Cumberland Iron Ore Mining and Kindred Trades Association was held in the Lodge Room on Thursday last. Mr. Jas. Dobie was in the chair. Councillor Thomas (branch secretary) read the balance-sheet for the quarter,
which showed an increase of members. The sick balance-sheet was considered satisfactory, but showed a large sick expenditure owing to so much sickness in the district. After a few remarks by the Chairman on the working of the branch, and the need of
members taking more interest in the Association, Councillor Thomas thanked the members for returning him as a member of the Egremont Urban District Council, and said that he would at all times try to carry out the wishes of the ratepayers and work for
the good of the district.
Mr. Flynn, the general secretary of the Association, in his address to the members, referred to the good that labour members might do if they as workers would only send representatives to all public Boards. They should take an active interest in all
public work for their own good, and the good of their children. Dealing with the education question he gave his experience on the Cumberland County Council Education Committee.
Education Could Be Improved,
and the children of the poorer classes would reap the benefits if only their fathers, brothers, and all classes of workers would send representatives that would do their duty. With regard to the question of labour candidates for the Cumberland
divisions, and the need of a labour member for the Egremont division, he said they had working in and about mines and quarries, 5,500 workmen; other trades, 2,000, making about 7,000 workers. They had no representation in the House of Commons, but about
one hundred employers could have their member. That was a very important matter to iron ore miners if they could only see. They should be represented by one of their own, and if this was only carried out they might then expect some interest to be taken
in their working condition, when they considered that for the last 30 years nothing in the way of any Act of Parliament had been introduced for the iron ore mines an quarries, whereas at the same time they had every year some new Act for the protection
of the coalminer, it behoved them to stir themselves; they had no power to appoint a representative to see that their workmen received their just weight. At a meeting held at Cleator Moor, in December, 1887, representation was made to the Home Secretary
on the compulsory weighing in the iron ore mines, steel trades, and other industries, and a resolution was passed :— "That this meeting of representatives of the Cumberland iron ore mines and quarrymen is of opinion that some provision should
be made for the weighing of iron and steel similar to that existing in the coal trade and requests that the Compulsory Weighing Regulation Act for the weighing of the material to workmen in collieries be extended to workmen in the iron and steel
industries." Copies of this resolution were sent to the Home Secretary and local Members of Parliament. This was six years ago, and nothing was done in any way to bring about this needed reform and would they get it by sending to the House of
Commons men who owned the mines, quarries, blastfurnaces, and steel works. He thought not. Then they had the Trades Dispute Bill, and the position in which trade unions had been placed by recent judgments. Every Member of Parliament was acquainted
with the position in which trades unions stood and although it was generally admitted that the law, as interpreted was unjust, a majority of the House declined to do anything to remedy that injustice. And every day they saw other judgments given against
trade unions. If they wished to protect their unions, and remedy the present state of the law, the only way was to return members that would vote to put them on the same footing as the employers. They could dismiss them for being a member of a trade
union, and the workman could not get damages against them, but the workmen must pay damages if they asked Union men not to work with non-Union men. Then again take the action of the House of Commons on the Royal Commission appointed to inquire into the
Trades Dispute Bill. Not that it would do any good. It was only an expense to the country for nothing, and an excuse to get out of the matter. They were afraid to tell the workers - that the Bill would not be pass into law, and they handed it over to
a commission of capitalists to deal with. It was like asking a fox to bring up a nest of spring chickens. The workers
Must Depend On The Labour Movement,
if they want reforms. Judges like Mr. Justice Grantham are as incapable of judging in labour cares as a brewer is of giving an impartial decision if allowed to sit on brewster sessions. But the blind prejudices of Mr. Justice Grantham must not be taken
to indicate the mind of the English bench. The fact was that English Society had recently been stirred up in opposition to organised labour. It had heard of the tyranny of trade unionism. They had been told that combinations amongst workpeople were
driving trade from the country. It had been taught to regard their combinations as a means by which lazy and dishonest men had adopted to make laziness and dishonesty the general rule of work. Unfortunately, their judges live, and move, and have their
being in the atmosphere of that society. They know nothing of trade unionism from the wage-earner's point of view. They know nothing of the industrial and economic pressure which justifies its action. They know nothing of the internal government which
has a very important bearing upon its legal relations. Not half-a-dozen of them know enough about trade unionism to enable them to answer the absurdities of the "Times" attacks. Thirty years ago that was not the case. The Parliament at one
time was bombarded by trade unions demands. Liberals and Tories alike resisted these demands and alike showed some willingness to accept them. Outside a strong Labour movement was gathering like a threatening storm. A Commission had been appointed to
inquire into the grievances of the unions, and the result was that the whole country was in possession of a great amount of accurate information regarding the theory and practice of trade unionism. The Act of 1871, deliberately declining to make trade
union funds liable for attachment in consequence of the acts of agents, was passed. The Bench and the Bar were in touch with the prevailing spirit, and the protection of the funds was accepted as being not only equitable but legal. After this the
Labour movement quietened down. They split over Liberalism and Toryism, and ceased to be an independent and active factor in politics. Within the space of six years three Labour members had been elected to Parliament. The Labour Representation League
ceased to exist. Trade union officials began to associate themselves with ordinary capitalist parties. They fought a man all day over a trade dispute, and spoke for him all evening in a political contest. Meanwhile trade unionism failed to keep in
touch with public opinion. Capital seized opportunity after opportunity to gain fresh ground. The Bench gradually drifted away from its knowledge of and sympathy with the spirit of 1870. Peaceful picketing was declared to be legal only under such
conditions as made it impossible. Conspiracy became such a dangerous factor in trade union action, that the planning of a concerted movement against employers was beset by a maze of pitfalls. Finally, to crown all the other judgments, the law lords
decided that
A Union Could Be Sued,
with its agents, and its funds made liable for damages. What was the real explanation of these decisions? They were the reading by society minded men of laws passed when the democratic spirit was prevalent. They indicated that the source from which
public opinion sprang had changed since 1870. The wage-earners made the laws, the capitalist administering them. The present condition of trade union law showed the practical importance of trade unionism in the public mind at the present moment. It
was not enough for the people to make laws. They must continue to make the public opinion which controls administration. They must press more earnestly upon all workers, and everyone who was interested in this vital subject, the importance of having a
Labour body in Parliament, and to work for a Labour member if they decided to have one, and in no way help any other party. It was an insult to the organised workers of the country - the composition of the Commission to inquire into trade unionism. It
was partial in its composition, one sided in its representative character, and would fail to give satisfaction in the work it had undertaken. The fiscal proposals now before the country should make the workers think of their position, and to resist in
every way any kind of Protection. The cry of more wages might seem good but when they considered the high cost of living Protection would bring, they should not be misled. The United Kingdom owed its pre-eminence to and could only be maintained by, the
policy of Free Trade. They should oppose to the utmost of their power any proposals which, by imposing taxes on food or raw materials, and as raising the cost of production and living, would cripple the country in its already severe struggle to uphold,
its position in foreign markets. Eight per cent of their productions were absorbed by the foreign markets. They must be prepared to support the candidate who would vote for Free Trade, the Trades Dispute Bill, to legalise the peaceful conduct of trade
disputes, amendment of the Education Act, housing of the people, old age pensions, and other Acts for the benefit of the workers, and who would vote and work against the system of Chinese labour in South Africa. He was glad to say the Association had
come through the few months of bad trade with an increased membership, had prevented reductions in wages that could not have been done without the help of the Association, had paid large amounts in strikes, sickness, and other benefits, and with the
improvement in the iron ore trade would still continue to work for higher wages and better conditions for the members. He hoped every miner outside would become a member, and help them to carry on this work. (Applause.)
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dobie, James | | | |
| Flynn, James | | | |
| Grantham, — | | Justice | |
| Thomas, —, Councillor | | | |