Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

21st January 1904

The Explosion At St. Helens Pit

Adjourned Inquest

Heroic Action By Mining Engineers And Men

Mr. Ball's Thrilling Evidence

Appreciation Of Bravery By Coroner, Jury, & Company

Yesterday afternoon at the Workington Police Station, the adjourned inquest to inquire into the death of Joseph Atkinson, who was killed at the St. Helens explosion on the night of the 7th inst., was told by Mr. G. Falcon, coroner for West Cumberland, and a jury of which Mr. R. Reid was foreman. Mr. A. Sharp, miners' agent was present, and also Mr. J. B. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, and Mr. A. D. Nicholson, mines inspector.

Mr. L. T. Helder, solicitor, Whitehaven, said he appeared for the Company. Mr. G. Scoular was, he regretted to say, not able to be present as the doctor had forbidden him to leave the house. His son, however, was here and would be able to assist.

The Coroner said the mine would not be able to opened for some months and he had not been down the mine. They must proceed today as far as possible.

Alexander Carlow Scoular, St. Bees, who held a full manager's certificate, said he was surveyor to the Colliery Company. He produced a plan of the workings made from the survey where the explosion occurred, which was shown to the jury and inspected by them. The shot was fired in the north-west end of the working. In the first instance canvass was put up to stop the air in the intake of the air course. At the time of the eight o'clock explosion, Atkinson was putting up a stopping along with others in the return air course. That was also a canvass stopping: after the explosion. The stopping's were inserted quite close to the shaft. It was considered unsafe to do anything more. The stopping's would have to remain in the mine for some time. The working was in the cannel band. The metal band was above it. There was a division between the two seams of about four feet of metal, The accident in 1888 was in the same seam on the land side. Both bands were "gassy." Explosives were used for shot firing by recognised shot firers. When a shot was fired the men were withdrawn to a safe distance. The explosive used was stowite. It was the only one used by them. It was about the safest which could be used. The fire was the result of the releasing of a blast of air, which became ignited by the gas. The gas was ordinary fire damp. It was non-explosive until it became mixed, with gas to an extent of eight per cent. The workings had always, he thought, been worked with explosives. The shot was fired about 1.30 p.m. The men, six of them, had withdrawn of their own accord. He was not present when the first explosion occurred. At eight o'clock all were working to isolate the air and cut off the fire. They had experts and officers from other pits, there at that time to advise as to the best course to pursue. At eight o'clock the experts had come to the conclusion that the fire was out. Nobody could get to see if it were really out on account of the fire-damp. Afterwards some of the experts got fairly close up to the road on the left marked on the plan where the air was better. It was the first road having doors to it. The stopping's had to be made simultaneously. He thought the explosion came down the first road on the left and down the return course. Hoodless was on the intake side and deceased was on the return.

By the Foreman: Deceased held a certificate as a shot firer.

The Coroner: This was a rescue party to save the Mine.

Inspector of Mines: The shot was fired to assist the miners? — Yes.

How was the shot fired? — By electricity, by battery. The mine is well ventilated. There were 20,000 cubic feet of air passing through the working. He described the course of the air in two splits.

How much air went round the long wall on the left side where deceased was working? — More than half. They had had difficulty with the air on the left side quite near to the fault from gas, and had had to strengthen their ventilation. It had not spread to where the shot was fired. A new airway was in contemplation to overcome the difficulty where the bad gas existed, but it had not been completed. The intake way was used for ponies to the north-west point. The return airway .to a place marked, was as a haulage road. He was aware that in 1900 they had a fire in the district where the shot was fired on the 7th inst. It was overcome by building two brick stopping's the drift. There were then, no explosions.

The Inspector: What is the character of the workings as regards dust inside the trouble? — They are rather damp. At 5-30 that night Mr. Morrison (after the first explosion, when he was injured) was able to give no advice. His father took charge of the subsequent operations. He arrived at the Colliery at five o'clock — the same time as himself. He (his father) went down to examine the state of the air along with the other managers. They were Mr. Gilchrist, Mr. Ball, Mr. Steel, Mr. T. P. Martin, Mr. Underwood (under manager), his father and himself. They thought as the result of the examination of the return air that the smoke was lessening very mush indeed. They next decided to build brick stopping's in about the same position as in 1900. They went down to make a further examination. They got up to the beginning of the long wall — the road leading in to where the shot had been fired. The doors and stopping's leading in for the most part standing good. There was a little gas just at the entrance of the long wall. There was also gas in the return, where they putting in the stopping's, and also at the place where deceased was killed. It led them to the conclusion that the fire was out as they thought there could not be gas on both sides and the fire still be in existence. Mr. Moore and Mr. Cowie from Whitehaven were then present.

Was it generally agreed that the fire was out? — Yes. They couldn't get nearer to the fire owing to the damp. They couldn't carry lights. It was then decided to cut all the fresh air off, so as to prevent a fire being fanned into existence. There might, they thought, have been sufficient heat to fan a fire into life by air. The stopping's were to be canvass, &c. The time would then be about 6-30. It might have been a little later. The work was begun at on until the explosion. He had been sent up for more men and lights when the explosion, occurred. He left the operations about seven o'clock.

Was the discussion of the experts unanimous? — He heard no discussion. He was in the district after the explosion. They could only get in to the first road beyond the air crossing. The rest was full of damp. They got to where Atkinson was lying. As they entered they met some of the party coming out, more or less injured. He wasn't able to see the effect of the second explosion as to whether it had injured the doors and stopping's. After the second explosion the return was very thick. There was white smoke in. There was a little smoke hanging in the intake. The lights wouldn't burn on account of the afterdamp, but it was nothing like that in the return. After the explosion five went in with him to bring out the injured men. Men were told off to help them. Ball, the two Horrigans, and Peel were able to assist. Mr. Cowie and Mr. Williams were the first to meet the injured men. They were on-their way to the seat of the fire at the time by the return. They, of course, assisted.

How was it that Hoodless came to be left? — We couldn't find him.

Was search made for him? — Not for him alone, for anyone.

Was it known then that he was missing? — Not definitely.

Where was he when you left? — I don't know, sir.

Had either of the explosions caused fall of roof? — Yes.

Where the falls in a position to cover a man up? — In the return that was certainly the case. In the intake I don't think so.

Has it been ascertained where Hoodless was working? — It has now.

Where? — In the second place on the left.

That was further in than you were able to get on account of afterdamp? — Yes.

I think Mr. Ball was further away. How did he get through? — He and the others would have to come through the afterdamp.

You would all be aware there was a danger in putting in the stopping's? — Yes.

That it was risky work? — Yes.

If it had been successful it would have meant isolating a small portion of the pit instead of a large portion? — Yes.

Do you think the coal dust had anything to do with either of the explosions? — I think not.

You will be aware of the rules relating to shot firing? — Yes.

Considering you have had three explosions by shots igniting gas at the face, doesn't it suggest that some extra precaution requires to be taken? — We thought they were perfectly right, sir.

Do you know of any other shots igniting gas in the pit beside those mentioned? — No, sir.

By the Coroner: His father had a mining certificate.

By Mr. Sharp: They fired the shots during the whole of the day. There was one shot fired for that district. The lengths of the faces in the long wall were twelve yards. There were eighteen roads.

Was there any report respecting this long wall showing gas? — No.

You have never seen one? — No.

By Mr. Helder: Mr. Gilchrist was manager of Clifton Pit. He was at one time manager of St. Helens. The rest were men of experience.

By the Foreman: At the time of firing the working was free of gas. The result of the fire ignited the gas.

John Clark, Derwent-street, Workington, shot firer, said he worked in the No. 3 pit, and was a shot firer. He held a certificate as shot firer from the manager. On the date in question at 1.30 he went into the working to fire a shot for John Fell, Witness charged it. Fell drilled the hole. He charged it with stowite. He believed he put three cartridges and stemmed the hole with soft clay. It was fired with an electric battery. He examined the hole before firing and found a little gas in it, behind a piece of coal. He removed the coal and diverted the air by means of a piece of canvas. He broke it up and afterwards examined the place from end to end with his lamp, receiving then no sign of gas from it. Hunter and Fell were both in the working He then fixed his cable on to it and shouted to the men to leave. They did so. He next connected the battery to the cable and fired the shot. As the explosion occurred he saw a flash of fire. It struck above where he was. He stayed for a minute. Then he examined the place and found it was on fire. He got a heavy canvas and tried to put it out, but it was too strong for him and too smoky. He went in search of the deputy Lawson Clapperton, who returned with him. They, both tried two or three times to subdue it. They partly arranged to limit the effect of the shot, but they failed. He next sent for the back overman and managers who quickly arrived. The name of the back overman was Fallas Morrison. Mr. Morrison, the manager, also came. They couldn't, however, get at the fire for the smoke. Mr. Morrison gave orders for doors to be closed up, which he thought was done. They then erected stopping's in the return course. After being at work for an hour the first explosion occurred. He was working with Mr. Morrison when he was injured and also John Underwood had his face cut. Everybody came out of the pit. He didn't go down with the second party. What was lighted must have been a blower. He was certain of it. He had been 40 years with the Company and thought stowite was safe. He had never seen a flash from it.

By the Inspector: It was the high side of Fell's place where the shot was fired-and the low side of Hunter's.

What thickness of the coal there? — About six feet. It was a machine hole that was drilled and about four inches deep. The place was properly curved. The three cartridges would take up a foot of the hole. His battery was down Hunter's place on the right-hand side. He couldn't tell whether the shot had its work until he went back to it. The gas was blowing out of the solid into the loose coal, and the flame was coming up. They called a "blower" a feeder of gas. It was more than an ordinary giving off of gas.

Where do you suppose that came from? — It might be making out of the coal. I couldn't say. The roof was a good smooth one.

Have you got your shot firers certificate with you? :— No.

Have you got one? — Yes.

Evidently the ventilation was not keeping the place clear? — The piece of coal behind was sheltering it. The air was sufficient to carry away any gas that was making.

Is this place wet or dry? — Dry.

Dusty? — No. There is no coal dust at the bottom. It is metal dust. When the first explosion occurred they were nearly choked with stowite. There was no water where the shot was fired. When last he saw the place the gas was observable, but he couldn't tell whether the coal was on fire. He pulled the Hurdle screen down to try to put the fire out.

What was the likelihood of the fire extending? — Unless it went in the solid face there was nothing else on either side of the workings

Have you had a fire after a shot within the last four or five years like this? — No.

By Mr. Sharp: He didn't see the flame immediately after the shot was fired. It was a top end shot.

You think there must have been a feeder in the hole? — I couldn't see it. They could put a foot of the fire out, but it spread too rapidly to get it out.

How long would you be away after the shot was fired? — About two minutes.

Isn't that long? — I don't think so. I am quick to get back, but I am not calculated to run. I was ten minutes by myself. The men knew the place was on fire and went away. He never saw them go. He never heard the gas singing that day. When a shot was fired the men working near left, but those further away got behind their tubs.

The Inspector: Why did the men leave? — Because the place was on fire!

By the Coroner: The time of the shot firing was about 2-30. The shift of the men terminated at two o'clock, and they left ten minutes before usual to get to the surface.

Mr. Wm. Henry Ball, manager of the Flimby and Broughton Moor Collieries, said he was certificated. He got a telephone message asking him to go to St. Helens. It was 4-25 when he got in the yard. He saw Mr. Gilchrist and Mr. Martin there, and they went to the office. They had just come out of the pit from the first explosion. A consultation was held amongst them after Mr. Scoular arrived. They agreed first to ascertain if the fire was still burning. They went and got to the main level bottom on the return side.

The Inspector. You went up the haulage road? -Yes. We got to the end and consulted there. They thought they were too small a party and returned to the surface. If the fire was on they determined to put these two stopping's in along the line of fault. On going down again they got to a point where if there had been a fire they expected to see its reflection. They got to 40 yards from the fire and found gas. It was first damp and hot fire damp. They then decided to put two more stoppings in. Three were in. They were canvas stopping's that were being put in. When the explosion took place he was at the top place of all along the in-by stopping. That was the farthest of all. He was superintending the carrying out of the work He passed the place within 10 yards of where Hoodless was supposed to be working. Everything was in darkness after the explosion. Their lights were gone. The two men with him like himself had never been in the pit before. It was impossible to see anything. They came back to a point named, where there was fresh air, and got two men out in the dark — Mr. Martin and Mr. Muncaster. They got a light afterwards and fetched Peacock and Atkinson out. The latter breathed slightly. Deceased was getting good intake air at the time. Both men had been blown there by the force of the explosion. They travelled the whole course where parties had been working and thought everybody was out. After Peacock was got out.

A Third Explosion. Occurred.

They felt the suction on the air, and they dropped on the floor. He thought it was a severe explosion. They had three lamps which they covered and these did not go out. Afterwards they raised Captain Scoular and his party coming for the deceased. If Mr. Martin and his companion had not been discovered by them they would have died from the effects of the afterdamp. Mr. Martin was quite insensible. They (Mr. Ball and the other two men) could not have got out excepting by recourse to artificial breathing. Afterwards it was not deemed safe to enter the workings to try and find Hoodless. If they had tried they would have gone to the wrong place. They supposed he was buried under a fall. The time of the last explosion occurred was about ten minutes to ten. His watch stopped at that time. Mr. Martin's watch stopped at 8-30, the time of the second explosion.

By the Inspector: On the second examination, finding gas at certain points, they thought the fire was extinguished. When the explosion occurred he saw no flame. His mouth was hot. In making their way out he counselled the men to put their shirts in their mouth. He first put his tie in it. That was insufficient. He next put his shirt in his mouth to escape the effects of the afterdamp. Their lives were in great peril, and he knew it whilst trying to make his way out.

Lawson Clapperton, Siddick, deputy at the pit, said on the 7th the working was clear of gas. The hole he entered there was a lot of gas burning in coal. The place itself had not taken fire. Witness and Clark tried to put the fire out. They didn't succeed, and they went for further assistance. The two Morrison's came.

By the Inspector: It appeared to be a safe for the firing of shots.

When had you last seen gas in the place? — a long time since. I couldn't say.

Mr. Sharp: Had you not heard feeders in this place? — No.

Had you no idea it was giving off gas? — No.

The Inspector of Mines said it was a pity they had not the evidence of Mr. Scoular, the manager, but it couldn't be helped.

The Coroner said the inquest could be adjourned, but they have had the impartial evidence of Mr. Ball, who was a mine expert and manager.

The Coroner, in summing up said Clark had shown care in the firing of the shot and he found no gas. It was one or more blowers of gas that led to the explosion, and not the firing of the shot. Whether they should use explosives was a question not for him to express an opinion upon, or the jury, because, as he had said, the explosion was not caused by the firing of the shot. There seemed to be a strong brotherhood amongst the mining engineers, for they all gave their services, and were present when the explosion occurred. It was a case of so many grinding at the mill, some being taken and others left, according to the position they were in. The conduct of Mr. Ball and the men, as described by him seemed very little short of heroic. They were in the dark when they rescued Mr. Martin and his companions. bringing them out, and then, at the imminent peril of their lives, returning to the workings to look for more. (Hear, hear.) He thought the jury would have little doubt but that the deceased was killed by an explosion of gas, whilst engaged along with others in endeavouring to wall off the fire.

The jury returned a verdict to this effect, and complimented Mr. Ball and his party, on the bravery they had exhibited at the risk of their lives. (Applause.)

Mr. Helder said he should like to express, on behalf of the Company, how much they appreciated the services of these gentlemen, who involuntarily rendered them so great a service, going down into the pit at the imminent risk of their own lives.

Their efforts were, indeed, fully appreciated and he was sure the evidence given by Mr. Ball must have impressed them all. (Applause.)

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Atkinson, Joseph   55 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ball, —      
Ball, William Henry    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Clapperton, Lawson    Deputy  
Clark, John    Shot Firer  
Cowie, —      
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Fell, John    Miner  
Gilchrist, James, jnr.    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Helder, L. T.    Solicitor  
Hoodless, William   50 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Horrigan, —    Miner  
Hunter, —    Miner  
Martin, Thomas Pattinson    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Moore, —      
Morrison, Fallas    Overman  
Morrison, Joseph    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Mulcaster, Joshua      Whos Who Page
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Peacock, —    Miner  
Peel, —      
Reid, R.    Jury Foreman  
Scoular, Alexander Carlaw      Whos Who Page
Scoular, George      Whos Who Page
Sharp, A.    Miners' Agent  
Steel, Robert    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Underwood, John    Under Manager  Whos Who Page
Williams, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

St. Helen's Colliery (CUL)  St. Helen's Colliery (CUL)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
08 Jan 1904  Fatal Colliery Explosion (The Times)
14 Jan 1904  Workington Explosion, Heroic Act (Whitehaven News)
21 Jan 1904  The Explosion At St. Helens Pit, Adjourned Inquest, Heroic Action By Mining Engineers And Men (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for St. Helen's No.3, Workington
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print