Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th September 1903

Mineral Train Wrecked At Egremont

Goods Agent Fatally Injured

The news of the serious accident to the mineral train and its sad sequel in the death of Henry Pattinson formed the principal topic of conversation in Egremont, and cast quite a gloom over the place. The circumstances surrounding the unfortunate affair are extremely sad. From pretty authoritative information our reporter was able to gather, it appears that at about a quarter to five on Tuesday evening a mineral train consisting of 18 laden waggons of iron ore were being drawn by an engine from the Gillfoot yard, up the branch line towards the main line. A man named John Paul (engine-driver), Whitehaven, and the fireman, Wear, of Moor Row, were in charge of the engine and accompanying them on the footplates were Isaac Mossop (the guard) and the deceased Henry Pattinson. The train had hardly proceeded three hundred yards, when the engine became derailed, through it is said a defect in the rail. Two waggons immediately behind were also thrown off and in attempting to jump clear Pattinson was caught by rails of the tender of the engine and crushed. He was extricated by John Southam to whom he expressed himself that "he was done." Medical assistance was immediately procured and Dr. E. Braithwaite, Egremont, immediately answered the call. From the first however the case appeared hopeless as deceased apparently was injured seriously internally. The doctor ordered his immediate removal to the Whitehaven Infirmary but he died before his arrival at that institution and at about quarter to seven, two hours after the accident. In the meantime, the news of the accident spread rapidly and there was considerable anxiety as to the other three concerned in the accident. They appeared to have effected a remarkable escape and sustained nothing more than a severe shock. Their escape from serious injury and in fact, instant, death may be considered miraculous for in the accident the steam valve was blown off. Visiting the scene of the accident, the engine was thrown completely across the rails and the tender crushed in by the force of the compact. There is considerable damage to the two mineral waggons. After becoming derailed the engine seems to have run a distance of nearly thirty yards. Gangs of workmen were immediately summoned and are now busily engaged. The deceased Pattinson was about forty-six years of age and has been employed as goods agent at the Gillfoot Mineral Office for upwards of twenty-three years. He was held in high esteem by his many friends. He resided at Beckermet and was a single man.

Out Beckermet correspondent writes: The fatal railway accident, by which Mr. Henry Pattinson lost his life, has cost the village of Beckermet, one of its most useful and energetic members. In the prime of life, aged 44 years, he took an active part in all social and intellectual matters brought forward for the advantage and advancement of the village community. As one of the members of the first Parish Council he strongly advocated the widening of the then narrow and dangerous bridge crossing the Ker, and it is largely owing to this advocacy that the district is indebted for the spacious bridge now standing; he was also a strong supporter of the movement to get a plentiful supply of water otherwise than by pumps. The Reading and Recreation Room, though as yet an unpretentious building, had in him a firm and generous friend, and he always contended that a good fire, a smoke room, and amusement without gambling or rowdyism would attract youths and young men from the street corners and idle loafing. It was with this idea in his mind that he became one of the six guarantors for the expenditure. As an Oddfellow, he took a keen interest in the working of the Widow's Defender Lodge, and its present financial stability is much indebted to his critical survey of the management and expenditure. He will be greatly missed in the Lodge Rooms councils, where his keenly just and well balanced judgement was greatly appreciated. Mr. Pattinson's sad death will be great blow to a wide circle of friends and acquaintances, for with a keen sense of the ridiculous, and a merry humour he endeared himself to many; of an argumentative and assertive character he was always careful to avoid unnecessary offence, and his sturdy intellect will be missed by many. Unless other arrangements may become necessary it is purposed to inter the body in St. John's Church-yard on Sunday next, when a large gathering if his friends and others may be expected.

An inquest was held at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon, on view of the body of Mr. Henry Pattinson, stationmaster at Gillfoot station, near Egremont, on a branch of the London and North Western and Furness Joint Railway. Mr. Pattinson met with injuries that proved fatal, on the previous evening. He was on an engine with a train of loaded iron ore waggons behind it; and at a curve in the line, one of the rails was fractured, the engine was derailed, and the nearest loaded waggons telescoping into the tender of the engine crushed him. The fracture of the rail was said to be quite new, without any indication of previous flaw, and there was nothing to account for the accident, which was a somewhat unusual one.

Mr. Gordon Falcon was the coroner.

Mr. W. H. Chapman appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased, and the deceased's brother was present.

Mr. Postlethwaite, Mr. E. Rose, Mr. Butler, Mr. Fewkes, and Mr. Jones, officials of the Joint Companies were all present.

John Paul, Michael-street, Whitehaven, engine driver, said he was in charge of the engine. It was about 200 yards from Gillfoot Junction. He had a train of 18 waggons, loaded with iron ore. On the engine besides himself, were the deceased, the fireman (Wear), and the guard (Isaac Mossop). They were running engine first, at about twelve miles an hour; and this was their first journey down, about 4.50 p.m. There was a curve in the line. He felt something on the engine, the effect of which was that the engine left the rails. It afterwards appeared that one of the rails had given way. He shut off steam, and the engine went about 27 or 23 yards before it stopped. He was standing on the right side of the footplate, on the opposite side to where the rail broke, and the deceased was standing just behind him. Witness could not see how deceased got hurt. He did not know anything about deceased, till the engine came to a standstill, and then he saw him upon the ground in a doubled up position. The coal bunker had been caught by the waggons, and torn right away. The Coupling had not given way, but the engine had travelled in one direction and the waggons in another, and so the tender had been caught by the waggons. The weather board was off, too, it had gone with the top completely. Himself and the others on the engine were no worse excepting the shock. He went back to see the rail that had broken. He did not examine it carefully. He saw the break in the rail, and he did not bother any more. He could not say that there was any flaw in it. It looked bright at the top, where it was broken, but he could not see further down. Witness just begun to work that branch on Monday. So far as his evidence was concerned he could only say that it was the breaking of the rail that caused the accident.

Alexander Wear, 5, John-street, Moor Row, the fireman, gave similar evidence. He was standing on the left had side of the engine, and Mossop, the guard, was standing in front of him. The other two were on the right hand side, the deceased behind the driver. He saw the rail was broken, but did not see any flaw; he just saw that it was cracked through.

Richard Butler, permanent way inspector, said the Gillfoot branch was in his district. He was there about a fortnight ago, and it was daily patrolled by platelayers. He had examined the rail, since the accident. It would be 70lbs. to the yard, and was double-headed. He would say it would have been down about 20 years, from inquiries he had made, but he could not say particularly. He had only had the inspection of this branch for 3½ years.

Did you form any opinion as to what caused it to break? — Well I could not. The road was in good repair.

But the rail itself, was the rail itself in good condition? — Yes, sir, it is in good condition.

There won't be a deal of traffic on this line? — No, only a couple of trains a day.

What should be the life of a rail at a place like that? — It should last for 50 years I should say.

Was the road good? — The road was in good repair, well ballasted up.

Do you think the rail was tight; were all the keys in? — Oh yes, everything was right.

Everything was in its place? — Yes sir.

What part did it break in? — 10ft. from the joint, in a 27ft. rail.

Then did you examine the place in the rail where the fracture was? — Yes.

What was the fracture like? — It is a clean break.

Perfectly new? — Perfectly new.

No flaw, top or bottom? — Not that I can say.

No signs of any flaw at all? — Not the slightest.

It isn't a rail that has been turned, is it? — No, sir.

Who was it made by? — It was made at Barrow, but I could not just see the date on it.

Would, there be any stress on the rail at this particular place from the curve.

Well, it was just coming off the curve; it would be in the curve just before it came to the straight. Oh, yes, there would be a bit of stress in the outside rail. It was the outside rail that give way. The other was the lowest rail.

It was not a rail, so far as you could see from any inspection, this you would condemn in any shape or form? — No, the rail was perfect in every way.

Can you form any theory, when it has stood so long, what would make it give way as it did? — No.

Was there anything to make the engine jump? — Not that I could find in any way.

Then beyond saying it is one of those things that will happen you can give no explanation? — No, I should say the line was in perfect order.

Twelve miles an hour is not an excessive speed? — No, that is not very fast.

What will the weight of one of those engines be? — Witness said he did not know; and Mr. B. Rose replied that it would be about 46 tons.

It has no special stress this engine? — I should not like to say it has more than the other.

In reply to the Coroner, Mr. Postlethwaite said he thought the rail would have been down about 22 years. Mr. E. Rose added that the whole line was laid not more than 23 years since, by Mr. Boyd, the late engineer, all at the same time, and all of the new material.

Dr. Edward Braithwaite, deposed that he was called to see Pattinson yesterday afternoon about two minutes to five. He saw him on the railway side at Gillfoot. He was injured right over the pelvis. He thought the best thing was to remove him down to the infirmary here, and he came with him. Pattinson died on the way, from the effects of his injuries. He was conscious when witness went to him. He told him where he was injured, right at his lower part of his bowels. He asked him how it happened, but he did not seem to have a very vivid idea of what had occurred. Witness had examined the body since, and there was no evidence of the bones having been crushed in; it was internal injury.

Mr. Chapman: Quite consistent, of course, with a crush on an engine, happening in the way we have heard it did? — Yes sir, quite consistent.

The Coroner: There can be no suggestion that the inquiry could have been got elsewhere than on the engine?

Mr. Postlethwaite: None whatever. The waggons caught the tender and telescoped it forward, and that caught him.

The Coroner: Well if an expert cannot explain the breaking of the rail we cannot, and the death of Pattinson has been caused by the accidental breaking of the rail and the derailing of the train. I think that is as far as we can put it.

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased met with his death by accident.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Boyd, —    Engineer  
Braithwaite, Edward, Dr.    Doctor  
Butler, —      
Butler, Richard    Way Inspector  
Chapman, W. H.    Solicitor  
Falcon, Gordon    Coroner  
Fewkes, —      
Jones, —      
Mossop, Isaac    Guard  
Pattinson, Henry   44 Station Master  Deceased, Individual Page
Paul, John    Engine Driver  
Postlethwaite, —      
Rose, E.      
Southam, John      
Wear, Alexander    Fireman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Gillfoot Park (Iron Ore)  Gillfoot Park (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print