|
25th June 1903 The Mining Fatality At Croft Pit, WhitehavenThe Adjourned InquestYesterday (Wednesday) afternoon Mr. Gordon Falcon (coroner for West Cumberland) held the adjourned inquest at the Magistrates' Court House, Scotch Street, Whitehaven, to make inquiries into the death of James Atkinson, miner, who was killed on Wednesday, the 17th inst., by a fall of stone at Croft Pit. There were present: Mr. T. H. Brockbank, for the Whitehaven Colliery Company; Mr. A. D. Nicholson, H.M. Inspector of Mines; and Mr. A. Sharpe, miners' agent. The plan of the scene of the accident was produced by Mr. Blair. William Robinson, brother-in-law of deceased, said they worked together in the Jubilee district, at Croft Pit. They had two "marrows" — James McMullen and McAlone. Witness went down the mine on Wednesday last, about 5.30 in the morning, and the others followed them on. There had been nobody working in the shift previous to witness. He saw the deputy (Mr. Benson) sitting on the brake top, and he told them that the place was right. They did not set their own timber down the pit. The Coroner: How far is it timbered up at this place? — About four feet. What is the roof there? Is it a stone roof, sandstone, or what? — Stone roof. Is it a sound roof or -? — Yes, the roof was good. Did you know of any slips in it at that place? — Yes, I knew there were slips in, but the sound was very good. Could you see these slips with the naked eye? — Yes, sir. You would begin work at six? — 6.30. All went well until something after nine? — 9.30. Had you been visited by anyone between 6.30 and 9.30 or not? — No, sir. Had there been any shots fired after you had been in that morning or not? — No, sir. I think you had been hagging at the face? — Yes What is about the width of the working place? About five yards. It is fast at both sides, the old system? — Yes, sir. Had you heard anything in the roof at all? — No, sir. Never heard anything? — No. Did you or deceased sound it after going on? — Yes, twice or three times. From time to time? — Yes. Knowing this slip did you sound it under this particular stone? — Yes. And all seemed very good? — Yes, sir. Do you admit any bad sound at all? No, sir. At the time the fall took place you were in the working? — Yes, in the right side. Deceased would be on the left? — Yes, sir. The fall was rather from behind him. It did not come off the face? — About two or three inches off the face. Within two or three inches off the face? — Yes. I understand there is a rise there? — Yes. It was the thin end up the hill and the thick end down the hill? — Yes. Did it all come in one piece, Robinson? — Yes. I believe it did. What weight would it be? Could you form any idea? — About one ton in weight. The heavy part would strike deceased on the back? — I could not tell you, sir. I never heard the stone at all till it dropped. There was nothing to attract attention till the stone fell? — No, sir. The heavy end was how far off the timber? It fell about six inches from the timber. Two or three inches from the face? — Yes. The slips were running lengthways? — Yes. If you suspected anything bad have you any timber? — We would have to send for the joiner, and he would put the timber in. You have timber left handy if you want anything? — We have nothing to do with timbering. Could you have worked with more timber in? No, we couldn't have worked if there had been any more in. You had as much timber set as you cared for, but not suspecting anything? — Yes, sir. I suppose directly the fall came you went for assistance. You got him out alive? — Yes, sir. Did he die in the pit, or you got him out? — He died in the pit. Was the stone broken by its fall? It was all in one piece. The Foreman (Mr. J. Waugh): Had you timber at hand if you wanted it? — Yes, sir. We have plenty of timber at hand. By the Inspector: The timber was about fifteen yards away. Deceased was an experienced miner, and he had worked with him for some 18 years altogether. They timbered about four feet off the face. They could not get much coal out as it was a bad place. He was quite aware of the slips in the roof. There was a slip in the middle of the place, and they could trace it to the roof. Knowing that these slips were there he did not think they were going too far without putting timber in, as the sound was good. By a juror: They had timber to put in if necessary for their protection, but they would not have been able to work if they had put more timber in. By Mr. Sharp: The place was recognised as a bad place on account of the roof. The deputy visited them about ten or eleven o'clock, and his usual visit would have been about half an hour after the accident. Robert Ellwood, deputy at Croft Pit, deposed that he examined the place where the men Atkinson and Robinson worked in the Jubilee district, last Wednesday morning about four o'clock. He made an examination of the place with an iron rod, and a pick shaft, and it seemed to be very good. He could see the slips, but considered the place quite safe with respect to being timbered. There were a couple of props about 40 yards away, which they would travel past as they proceeded to their work. The joiner was in the district, and set timber if asked to do so, and he also went round to see if any timber required setting. There was nothing unusual to indicate the slip of the stone. By the Inspector: They set more timber in this district on account of these slips. The men would take more than a foot of coal out, from 6.30 to 9.30. Everyone who worked in the place knew about the slips. He was not in the place when the men were working. He did not caution them about these slips as he did not think it necessary. He saw the place the following day, and there was a prop knocked out. By Mr. Sharp: He never saw any danger in the slips in the morning. The joiner visited the place once a day, and paid more attention to this particular place where the fatality occurred on account of the slips. William Brown, miner, said he was working in another part of the mine, but being sent for he went to the place in question, and at that time the stone had not been removed. Deceased was underneath it. The stone was in one piece with the exception of a few little pieces off it. He assisted to lift the stone from off deceased. He agreed with the witness (Robinson) that the stone would be a ton in weight. The Coroner, in reviewing the case, said it was rather peculiar that the stone had come out. If the next prop had been put in at the equal distance it would just have been under the thin end of the stone. Deceased and Robinson were two experienced miners, and the latter said they had worked there for 18 years together, and the place had been inspected by the deputy, who saw no danger. If the place had been bad the joiner would have been there. At the same time the men did not anticipate. The stone seemed to be a very heavy one, a ton weight. The Foreman said the jury were unanimously of the opinion that it was a "Pure accident."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||