Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

West Cumberland Times

Article from the West Cumberland Times, 25th March 1903


The Accident at William Pit, Whitehaven

Yesterday (Tuesday) afternoon the adjourned inquest with respect to the death of Thomas Horrocks, Strand Street, and John Mossop, Woodville Terrace, Whitehaven, bricklayers labourers, who were killed by a fall of roof in William Pit last Thursday, was held at the Whitehaven Police Court by Mr. Gordon Falcon, coroner for West Cumberland. There were present : Mr. Atkinson, chief inspector of mines, Newcastle ; Mr. A. D. Nicholson, assistant inspector of mines ; Mr. L. T. Helder, representing the Colliery Company ; Mr. T. P. Martin, secretary of the Coalowners Association ; Mr. A. Sharp, miners agent ; and Mr. S. Turner, manager of William Pit.

George Harker, shot firer at William Pit, said they were driving a drift, known as No. 5 Stone Drift. It was a new engine plane through sandstone and blue metal. The length of the drift where the accident happened would be about 180 yards. Horrocks and Mossop were the masons labourers, and were engaged in putting side walls in. The place where the accident happened was about 9ft wide and between 9 and 10ft high. The roof was sandstone. Horrocks and Mossop were working for the company. Before the brickwork was put in the roof was supported by timber — just roughly timbered to make everything safe. There was no timber in where the accident happened for a matter of 10 or 11 yards. The contractor would set the timber.

The accident happened about four o'clock, and the men were working a second shift. The side wall was finished and the masons had gone further down. Horrocks was a practical miner, but the other man had only just entered the employ of the company. Witness, as a shot firer, had charge of this lot. The under-manager came into the place, also the deputy when there was a change of shift. No shots had been fired on that shift. When the accident took place they had been lifting tubs of metal. Three tubs had been taken from the forehead, and Horrocks had left one of his buckets lying on the road with the result that it knocked the first tub off. Witness and three more hands went to the forehead to put the tubs right, and while they were doing this the stone fell, just striking the end of the last tub. It fell at the place where Horrocks was mixing lime. He had been helping them with the tubs, and had just gone back to the lime. It would be about 33 yards from the forehead.

At the place where the fall occurred the work had been completed, and the roof was considered to be good. Witness did not examine the roof that day. The Coroner suggested that it would be necessary to examine the roof if men were working there. Witness said the job was finished, and there was only Horrocks mixing lime.

The Coroner : Well, that is someone, and there were other men under the forehead.

Witness, continuing his evidence, said the flag which fell and struck Horrocks and Mossop was 8ft by 5ft, and the thickest part would be about six inches. The stone had not shown any signs of slipping. There was a little bit of slate parting on the right hand side. He could not say how Mossop came to be there. He was working with the masons, and he thought he must have come up for some lime just at that time. There was no warning before the fall. The drift had been stopped for a certain time. This was the first fall of roof in this drift. The roof was hard sandstone. Steel girders were put in when felt necessary, but this was an extra good strong roof. The Company would ask the contractors to put in girders if they thought they were requisite.

The Foreman (Mr. Waugh) : Don't you think it would have been better if the roof had been supported all along?

Witness : The roof where the accident happened was supposed to be safe.

By the Inspector : It was not within his province to examine the roof where the bricklayers were working. The under-manager, overman, and deputy were responsible for that portion. He did not see any of those officials examine the roof. Witness examined the roof at the face of the drift.

How long was it since that portion of roof where the fall took place at the face? — Six or seven weeks.

Has your attention ever been directed by anybody to any unsafe roof? — No, sir.

And you had no suspicion of anything of the kind? — No, sir.

This drift is a portion of a long new drift that extends right from the shaft so as to make a better road to the seam coal? — Yes, sir.

There is an old road also? — Yes.

Replying to further question, witness said the old road was very near the new drift, and there might be a bit of friction on the roof. The haulage was going on the old road at the time of the accident, and the setts were constantly passing along. Probably three or four hundred would pass along during the day. Each sett contained 18 tubs. The running of the setts in the old road might prevent anyone hearing the roof working. The walls were being put in to support the sides, which were of soft metal. If it had been thought necessary to support the roof, girders or timber would have been put up. In his opinion it was a very unlikely place for a stone to fall.

By Mr. Sharp : He had authority to order girders to be put in if he thought it necessary. There was an 18in. wall put in on the right and 16in. on the left side. They were put in as a sort of barrier to hold the sides. The thickness between this drift and the old way would be seven or eight feet. There were no middle props where the accident happened.

Did you think it safe with this thickness with the trolley tubs running over it? — It was considered safe.

By Mr. Helder : If any timber had been wanted there was plenty down the pit. The under-manager (Mr. Rothery) would be down that morning. Witness did not go down until two o'clock.

Robert Blair, surveyor at William Pit, produced a plan of the drift where the accident occurred.

John Rothery, under-manager at William Pit, said this drift came under his supervision.

Mr. Rothery was in the place at two o'clock that day of the accident. He made an inspection of the face and back. He examined the roof all along. He did not sound the stone because he had concluded and felt satisfied that it was perfectly safe. If he had thought it was necessary to put girders in he would simply have asked the contractors to do it. It would have cost the Company nothing. He examined the engine plane every day with a stick. The night overman coming out at six o'clock in the morning would also examine the roof. He could not swear that he did not jowl the stone that day.

The Coroner : But unfortunately you cannot swear that you did.

Witness repeated that he considered the place quite safe.

The Coroner : Yes, but if you are to take for granted that a place is safe there would be an end to inspections, I should think. — Oh, no, sir.

Then why not inspect this place? — I considered it perfectly safe.

The Coroner said that if they could consider a place safe, and therefore need not inspect, there would be no necessity for an Act of Parliament with regard to these matters.

The Foreman asked witness what he considered brought the stone away.

Witness said he thought there had been a little pressure from above.

By a Juror (Mr. F. McKee) : He could not see any vibration.

Replying to the Inspector, witness said the contract included the putting in of girders when necessary. It would be impossible to jowl every yard of the engine plane every day. If he considered a place unsafe he would examine it.

Don't you think it would be better, when men are working under a stone for some time, to have it arranged that the stone be jowled every day? — Where men are working under sandstone we take it for granted that that is good.

The Inspector said that was not an answer to his question. Did witness not think that where men were working at a fixed point, even on an old road, it would be better, especially in the case of bricklayers and that sort of men, it would be better to have the roof jowled and sounded every day, and to make proper provision for that to be done. If this stone had been sounded it might have been found to be bad.

Witness : Well, perhaps it might.

By Mr. Sharp : There were many places of the same width without a support.

The Coroner said the two witnesses had given their evidence extremely frankly and fairly, and so intelligently that there could be no difficulty in understanding how the accident happened. One was always rather afraid in colliery accidents, where a contractor was doing the work, that perhaps there was more haste than care, and one always looked into these cases more closely than usual, but in this case the contractor had absolutely nothing to do with the accident. He had finished his work in this particular place, and it was not for him to say whether the girders should have been put in. If the contractor had been asked by the Company to put in girders, it would have been done, but he was not asked. He thought it would have been better in a new place like this if the roof had been sounded daily. It was in close proximity to another road, and probably the vibration had caused the fall of stone.

The jury retired to consider their verdict, and returned after a short absence.

The Foreman : The jury have come to the conclusion that it was a pure accident, but they think it might have been averted if girders had been put in, or if the roof had been sounded.

The Coroner said the colliery officials would no doubt consider the question with regard to girders.

Mr. Turner, in reply to the Coroner, said when the new road was put into use the old plane would be done away with, and there would be no vibration from that source.

Interment of Pit Death Victims

The remains of Thomas Horrocks and John Mossop, who were killed in William Pit on Thursday, were interred in Whitehaven Cemetery on Sunday and Monday respectively. Each funeral was very largely attended, the sad occurrence having created widespread sympathy. The members of the Mount Pleasant Mission Choir and Men's Bible Class, to which Mossop belonged, were present at his funeral. Mossop was also a worker in the Band of Hope, and this organisation was represented by Mr. Woodnorth (superintendent). Before the cortege left the deceased home the Choir and Bible Class sang his favourite hymn, "Sun of my soul," and at the graveside another hymn was rendered. The service was conducted by Mr. Davidson (missioner at Mount Pleasant) and Mr. Dutson (Hogarth Church missioner).


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —      
Blair, Robert      
Davidson, —      
Dutson, —      
Falcon, Gordon      
Harker, George      
Helder, L. T.      
Horrocks, Thomas      
Martin, Thomas Pattinson      Whos Who Page
McKee, F.      
Mossop, John      
Nicholson, Arthur Darling      Whos Who Page
Rothery, John      
Sharp, A.      
Turner, S.      
Waugh, —      
Woodnorth, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
25 Mar 1903  The Accident at William Pit, Whitehaven (West Cumberland Times)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Whitehaven
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print