|
13th December 1902 A Miner's Claim: A Question Of Medical EvidenceAskew v. The Bullgill Coal CompanyWorkington County Court. William Askew, engineman, Town Hill, Crosby, brought an action against the Bullgill Coal Company under on agreement on the part of the Company to pay plaintiff 14s per week during the time he was incapacitated from following his employment as the result of an accident while in the defendants' employ, the amount of the allowance being one-half of the plaintiff's weekly wage, at the time of the accident. Mr. A. Henry, barrister-at-law (instructed by Mr. Tom Milburn) was for the plaintiff, and Mr. W. H. Chapman, of Whitehaven, for the defendants. Plaintiff stated that he had charge of the engine at the coal washer. On March 15th, 1901, he was injured by falling nine feet on his back from a scaffold which he had to ascend to attend to the engine. He was still suffering from an injury to his spine. Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman :— Defendants offered him three doctors, whom he refused to see. The defendants refused his three doctors. He had not dropped his claim against the Miners' Relief Fund. Re-examined :— He could not climb the scaffold now and do the work he was accustomed to perform before the accident. He had been examined by Dr. Lediard, of Carlisle, whose certificate stated that as the result of his examination he was enabled to say that in his opinion the plaintiff was totally and possibly permanently disabled from work by reason of the accident he sustained on March 5th, 1901. Dr. McKay, of Newcastle, referee for the Miners' Relief Fund, stated that he examined the man at Maryport on May 29th. He found no injury to the spinal cord, and as a result of the examination he stopped plaintiff's money. Plaintiff refused to see leading doctors in the North of England who were chosen as final referees in such cases. Witness held to his own opinion against that of Dr. Lediard. Dr. Dickson, of Whitehaven, stated that he examined the plaintiff on September 15th, and that he found nothing consistent with spinal injury. His Honour adjourned the case to the January Court so that both parties may call further medical evidence.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||